Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher and student hit

160 replies

Sixpencefaux · 16/07/2022 21:00

Has anybody seen the footage from a Leeds secondary school where a student attacks another student. When the teacher steps in, the student then repeatedly punched the teacher in the face. It really is shocking.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SquirrelSoShiny · 14/11/2022 10:21

FFS Idiot trolls 🙄

SquirrelSoShiny · 14/11/2022 10:20

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 12/11/2022 20:23

Have a look at any thread on here where a parent is posting about their child being violent at school. It’s full of posters telling them how to force the school to keep them in the classroom whilst alternative provision is looked into. Any suggestion that the needs of the other kids not to be attacked is met with outrage - this is disablist. Any suggestion that the parents should home educate their child is met with outrage - it’s not their job, they shouldn’t have to compromise their jobs, the school should be better at stopping the violence. Any suggestion that it traumatises other children who may themselves have disabilities is met with outrage - the other kids should have to learn to be more tolerant.

There are no easy answers but the outcome is that at present we don’t accept, as a society, the fundamental premise that nobody should have to endure an environment where they are physically attacked. And that is deeply wrong.

I see this a lot too. I agree with you.

The thing I dislike is the endless personal victimhood trend I see online. It's giving people a wholescale sense of entitlement that the world has to revolve around them / their child. Instead of the truth:we will make some adaptations as best we can, then you and your child need to get on with living as best you can.

We are not helping anyone by ramming 35 kids into a classroom including 10-15 who need additional support. We need more support units in schools and we need more special school places.

Valeriekat · 14/11/2022 08:52

When the TES had its forums it was apparent that the SLT really didn't care about the classroom teachers at all.
The TES seem to have become cheerleaders for teacher training colleges and government education policies and you are not allowed to criticise either and you can't now so job done I guess. I wonder if anyone still subscribes.

Redkettle · 14/11/2022 08:39

BellaLab · 17/07/2022 00:38

I haven’t seen it nor would want to. I left teaching last August after bending down to welcome a 5 year old into P1 and they spat in my face. That was the icing on the cake for me and I walked out that day.

Far too many teachers are subjected to awful behaviour from pupils and expected to put up with it.

Oh my god!

Valeriekat · 14/11/2022 08:36

ParsleySageRosemary · 17/07/2022 22:11

im sorry you got hassle, being pregnant this doesn’t apply to you specifically: but do you not get intervention or restraint training in mainstream at all?

Adults absolutely should be intervening if kids are fighting and even more so if one is violent on another. Women can restrain primary age kids without the need for male adults.

There needs to be extra staff around to help too, although I agree about the increase in poor behaviour.

And your experience of this is?

Morph22010 · 14/11/2022 07:13

cocktailclub · 14/11/2022 07:02

A lot of this sits squarely with parents. Not saying it's intentional.
And if funding supported early intervention to support better parenting then teachers could basically teach. And not have to be social workers, psychologists and even security guards. The minority who continue to be violent and disruptive should be segregated in a specialist provision. Not to punish them but to protect others and allow everyone else to learn.
All students would get better education because more time would be spent teaching and teachers wouldn't leave because they were unsafe.
Society would benefit.

Then you need to give feedback on the send review to your mp rather than thinking it is a problem that doesn’t effect you. Funding doesn’t even support early intervention with children properly in school anymore never mind working with parents, that’s why things escalate. Lots of people want special school but it’s not a choice you get, it’s very very difficult to fight for. My own child is in an asd specialist school and I had to go to tribunal to even get an ehcp as the la said he could manage in mainstream school with no support. He couldn’t manage and used to lash out a lot, no amount of parenting courses would have fixed this as we didn’t have the same issues at home he was in the wrong school environment for him and couldn’t manage. It was a 3 month wait when we went to tribunal a few years ago, now there are so many people going to tribunal to try and get the right support/ specialist placement for their child that the wait time for the send tribunal is a year

JobSeekingMissile · 14/11/2022 07:05

THREAD RESURRECTED BY TROLL

cocktailclub · 14/11/2022 07:02

A lot of this sits squarely with parents. Not saying it's intentional.
And if funding supported early intervention to support better parenting then teachers could basically teach. And not have to be social workers, psychologists and even security guards. The minority who continue to be violent and disruptive should be segregated in a specialist provision. Not to punish them but to protect others and allow everyone else to learn.
All students would get better education because more time would be spent teaching and teachers wouldn't leave because they were unsafe.
Society would benefit.

NandorsFamilar · 12/11/2022 21:14

A friend of mine is a secondary school teacher and has been for 2 decades.
A yr 7 pupil threw a chair at her head (no reason, just because) and teacher had to evacuate the classroom and let the kid get through the anger- while my mate was bleeding from the head.
The school SLT was very much of the view "these things happen'. So my mate left that day , signed off sick (whilst having stitches) and never went back.
it was the last occurrence in a long line of 'well these things happen' as regards pupil violence and using weapons.

Some schools just really don't care

woodhill · 12/11/2022 20:40

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 12/11/2022 20:23

Have a look at any thread on here where a parent is posting about their child being violent at school. It’s full of posters telling them how to force the school to keep them in the classroom whilst alternative provision is looked into. Any suggestion that the needs of the other kids not to be attacked is met with outrage - this is disablist. Any suggestion that the parents should home educate their child is met with outrage - it’s not their job, they shouldn’t have to compromise their jobs, the school should be better at stopping the violence. Any suggestion that it traumatises other children who may themselves have disabilities is met with outrage - the other kids should have to learn to be more tolerant.

There are no easy answers but the outcome is that at present we don’t accept, as a society, the fundamental premise that nobody should have to endure an environment where they are physically attacked. And that is deeply wrong.

Yes

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 12/11/2022 20:23

Have a look at any thread on here where a parent is posting about their child being violent at school. It’s full of posters telling them how to force the school to keep them in the classroom whilst alternative provision is looked into. Any suggestion that the needs of the other kids not to be attacked is met with outrage - this is disablist. Any suggestion that the parents should home educate their child is met with outrage - it’s not their job, they shouldn’t have to compromise their jobs, the school should be better at stopping the violence. Any suggestion that it traumatises other children who may themselves have disabilities is met with outrage - the other kids should have to learn to be more tolerant.

There are no easy answers but the outcome is that at present we don’t accept, as a society, the fundamental premise that nobody should have to endure an environment where they are physically attacked. And that is deeply wrong.

IncessantNameChanger · 12/11/2022 19:34

rongon · 17/07/2022 09:18

. In nicer schools it doesn't happen often at all, but in many it happens often and in a hefty chunk it'll happen weekly or so.

I teach in a nice, outstanding primary school in a very middle class area with a supportive SLT. It is a weekly occurrence in our school. Mostly children with additional needs attacking staff. Apparently it is the staffs fault for not de-escalating situations.

I personally think blames with the funding cuts, huge battles to get support from camhs, the LA SEN teams OT, speech therapy, socail care and SEN school places. Sure there's some shitty parents and shitty kids out there. But funding cuts fobbed off as inclusion doesn't help anyone.

Parents can't really push back on that but HT can. Just think how kids sre failed by camhs daily. It's not acceptable to bash an adult with mh issues but if your kid? Your a tosser and your parents are scum. That's a lazy oversimplification of the problems faced by education.

If you only allowed exemplary parents places at school do think all the issues would stop? I dint believe that.

Michaelmonstera · 12/11/2022 19:23

Early intervention would also help. I once taught a very disturbed 4 year old who would walk across a room and randomly punch a child in the face. The other children were terrified of him. In Year 1, he was caught throwing stones at pet rabbits. It was clear he needed specialist help but none was forthcoming and he moved through primary school bullying numerous children and having “chats” with the headteacher. He would be an adult now and I suspect will be repeating the DV he witnessed as a child and I would not be surprised to read about him in the papers.

MichelleScarn · 12/11/2022 18:56

@Dotjones would you be as so 'oh well violent shit happens in schools' if a member of your family was assaulted whether teacher or pupil?

Tywin · 12/11/2022 18:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Dotjones · 19/07/2022 08:46

I voted YABU, not because I support violence in schools, but because of the idea that anyone could be shocked that this sort of thing happens.

Schools are violent places, they always have been. They are much like prisons in that there are people attending against their will, and a smaller group of people who are paid to look after them. As in prisons, crime against the attendees is rife, yet rarely treated seriously, and resources are lacking.

Attacks on pupils, attacks on teachers, which occasionally result in serious injury or death, are just part of the schooling institution. It's not good, but it's inevitable when crowding people together, not on interest or skill, but on something arbitrary like age.

Jellycatspyjamas · 19/07/2022 08:43

Children who do have that level of disability are rare.

And it’s not that rare - in my DDs year there are 4 other kids with her level of additional support needs, they present differently as you would expect but 5 kids in a year group of 50 isn’t rare.

Jellycatspyjamas · 19/07/2022 08:41

If I were any of those things then I expect my parents would send me to a specialist school, not try to include me in mainstream education. Children who do have that level of disability are rare.

That would be lovely but specialist provision is very hard to come by. My DD is able to speak but can’t communicate her needs - she has complex processing difficulties due to early trauma. She can’t tell when she’s hungry, thirsty or tired, she experiences most bodily sensations as anxiety, She has sensory processing issues and has significant hearing loss. She gets very overwhelmed in a normal classroom setting which, so far, shows itself in her hiding in the classroom or taking herself off to the toilets, which are quiet and she can gather her thoughts. She’s also significantly learning delayed.

All of this still doesn’t mean she’ll automatically get a place in a specialist provision - at the moment her primary school are able to make enough adjustments for her that it’s just about manageable, but there are still difficulties. In mainstream high school I can absolutely see her lashing out when she’s not able to cope with constantly changing classroom, changing expectations of different teachers, remembering what she needs for what class, busy corridors and the noise levels. At that point she’ll no doubt be labelled as a difficult or violent kid, which she isn’t.

The lack of decent specialist provision for children like my DD is appalling, she has the right to an education but mainstream school would be disastrous for her. It’s not simply a matter of requesting she be placed elsewhere though.

Morph22010 · 19/07/2022 07:51

Legrandsophie · 19/07/2022 07:43

@TheMoth

Yes, it is shit for everyone. But some parents see Special School as a judgement on them and refuse it on principle. He needs to be in a secure unit that can meet his needs where staff are trained to deal with his outbursts and he can have specialist intervention.

And the other students in his year group need to be able to go to school without the fear of being violently attacked. But somehow parents of kids like this never understand that.

in real life I’ve never known anyone not to want special school for their child if they thought it was needed, I’m sure there must be a few people but they are very much the minority. The reality is that it’s virtually impossible to get special school or the sort of secure school that you are referring to, it’s not simply a matter of parents not wanting it. My son is in asd special school but I had to appeal to tribunal to even get an ehcp as the la said he could be supported in mainstream school without an ehcp! He was already not managing and becoming violent and lashing out. Without sounding like I’m bragging I am quite an intelligent person and work in a professional capacity so was able to navigate the law and form an appeal and the la conceded before we even got to appeal, but the fact is lots of parents don’t have the capacity to do themselves or the funds to pay a solicitor/ advocate to do for them, so the reality of getting into special school is virtually zero yet there’s always parent bashing

Legrandsophie · 19/07/2022 07:43

@TheMoth

Yes, it is shit for everyone. But some parents see Special School as a judgement on them and refuse it on principle. He needs to be in a secure unit that can meet his needs where staff are trained to deal with his outbursts and he can have specialist intervention.

And the other students in his year group need to be able to go to school without the fear of being violently attacked. But somehow parents of kids like this never understand that.

MichelleScarn · 18/07/2022 23:04

Aria999 · 18/07/2022 22:47

This is appalling.

As a short woman you have basically zero chance of coming off well against someone bigger and stronger than you without risking serious injury to them.

Then you would get into trouble for hurting the students.

Teachers should not be put in this position, if a school has problems of this kind they should employ security staff.

As to the poster saying a pregnant teacher should be expected to risk the life of her unborn child, wtf?

Absolutely @Aria999 scary to think the entitlement from someone to think that a pregnant woman is awful for not thinking of the fighting pupil before her unborn child.

Threetulips · 18/07/2022 23:02

Staff should be team teach trained.

Without that they should walk away.

Aria999 · 18/07/2022 22:47

This is appalling.

As a short woman you have basically zero chance of coming off well against someone bigger and stronger than you without risking serious injury to them.

Then you would get into trouble for hurting the students.

Teachers should not be put in this position, if a school has problems of this kind they should employ security staff.

As to the poster saying a pregnant teacher should be expected to risk the life of her unborn child, wtf?

Morph22010 · 18/07/2022 22:34

ParsleySageRosemary · 18/07/2022 19:52

The big difficulty with that is whether the TA has the knowledge, via experience and training to do this, on their own in a mainstream. The teacher will leave them to it, and possibly won’t know themselves: and TAs are increasingly fed up of what they are expected to know and do for the paltry wages. I hope your dd is valued.

Tbh most of my Ds’s “1-1s” we’re amazing and really good with him it just that they were expected to look after other kids at same time, worse time was when I arrived slightly early and his 1-1 was in sole charge of 2 classes ie. 60 kids and Ds was having a meltdown and chucking as they couldn’t do his end of day routine. If I’d not had arrived early I’m sure I’d of been told he was having a meltdown for no reason and would have been excluded

ParsleySageRosemary · 18/07/2022 19:52

Mumofsend · 18/07/2022 11:28

That is what they should have been doing in the mainstream too. You don't need a specialist setting when a child has 1-1 to recognise for them when they need a break and gradually teach them to recognise it themselves. That is a school not wanting to, not being unable to. My daughter's mainstream with 1-1 and this is literally what their job is.

The big difficulty with that is whether the TA has the knowledge, via experience and training to do this, on their own in a mainstream. The teacher will leave them to it, and possibly won’t know themselves: and TAs are increasingly fed up of what they are expected to know and do for the paltry wages. I hope your dd is valued.

Swipe left for the next trending thread