Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Don’t want to “make friends” with neighbour’s dog…

636 replies

randomdogfriend · 16/07/2022 18:58

NC for this. Sorry it's long!

Small backstory: Neighbour has a yappy dog that never stops, it comes right up to the fence in our back garden and barks incessantly whenever any of us go into the garden. It also barks at passers by on the street - it literally follows them along the fence yapping incessantly as they walk down the street. Neighbour does very little to address this - the occasion half hearted “stop that (name of dog)”, but it doesn’t listen to her and she doesn’t physically remove it. Last year I had a word with the neighbour about this through the fence - the barking was so bad it was upsetting my then newborn aged baby as we sat in the garden. She argued back with me and was generally unpleasant, so I threatened to report her if it didn’t stop. This was around 12 months ago and I’ve had no interactions with her since. The dog has done its usual nuisance barking at the fence when we’ve been out in the garden but I’ve largely tried to ignore it, and now that DD is a bit older she isn’t as startled or bothered by it. So we just largely ignore now.

Today I took DD (now 15 months) out in the garden to play. I sat on the grass relaxing whilst she played. Yappy dog approached the fence as per usual, but we were far enough away from the fence that I could mostly tune it out and just focus on playing with DD. DD didn’t seem remotely bothered by it either. I was then aware of neighbour approaching the fence and heard her say “oh are you saying hello (dogs name)?” Dog continued to incessantly yap. I ignored and continued to play with DD.

Next thing I heard “excuse me can I talk to you?“ through the fence. The fence is too high to see over it, and you can just about make out a person through the slats but I couldn’t really see her. I said “sorry, do you mean me?” (Not really able to see anyone at this point, just a shadow through the fence, and I was also sat a good few feet away from the fence. She said “yes”. I said “erm, yeah I suppose, I can’t see you but I can hear you”. She said “I’m sorry my dog barks and annoys you”. I replied “that’s ok” and then continued to engage with DD who was toddling around (so my attention was more focussed on her and I honestly didn’t want to have any interaction with anyone else at that point). I was hoping this would end the conversation. She continued: “if you made friends with her, she wouldn’t bark at you”. I just again decided to give a one word answer in the hope she would disengage from me as all I wanted to do was relax and play with DD. I replied again “right, ok”. She then continued… “if you made friends with her she wouldn’t bark and then you wouldn’t complain, would you”.

At this point I got irritated as she was pushing an unwanted conversation and also implying I had “complained” when I’d had one interaction with her about this a whole year ago where I’d threatened to complain but not followed that through, and also not mentioned the dog to her since.

I replied: “I just want to enjoy my garden with my DD. I don’t want to have to make friends with a dog through the fence. If your dog is barking constantly it’s because you aren’t training her properly, and that’s up to you to address. It’s not down to other people to make friends with your dog”.

It was more than I wanted to invest in the interaction but to be honest she had annoyed me by that point.

She then said, randomly, “how old is your daughter now?” I replied with her age. In between I was playing with DD and interacting with her, hoping neighbour would get the hint that I didn’t want to engage with her. She then said “what’s her name?” I replied with her name. Just one word answers to try to end it. She then said “ok. I just thought we could be friends that’s all”. Then she (presumably) walked off back to her house (like I say, limited visibility through the fence).

The whole interaction was just so random. Firstly I hadn’t commented on her dog, I was minding my own business and playing with DD. Also a whole year has passed since our last interaction so why approach me now? It would have made sense if I’d complained there and then about the dog, but I’d said nothing. I was just ignoring it as I usually do.

If it’s relevant this isn’t a next door neighbour as such. It’s hard to explain but we are a detached house and her back garden and mine back share a boundary fence. Our houses are nowhere near each other and are actually on separate streets. I am friends with my next door neighbour, by choice, who is lovely. I have no desire to be friends with this other neighbour or her dog.

Was I mean or unreasonable to not want to be friends with either her or her dog? When I'm in my garden I just want to relax and enjoy my garden and my daughter. Is this reasonable? Also, should random people be expected to befriend dogs, or is the onus on the owners to stop the barking regardless?

Any thoughts welcomed.

OP posts:
TJakes5 · 18/07/2022 14:45

Lalosalamanca · 18/07/2022 14:37

Op has repeatedly demonstrated her inability to be civil though @TJakes5

It's funny she's started a thread asking for opinions but if you give her an opinion she doesn't like she jumps on you.

I'm sensing the op will never be able to get over the fact the dog dared to bark when she had a newborn and is holding a grudge. Sounds to me like she really struggled with the world continuing whilst she had a newborn baby.

Exactly!
We have neighbours Dogs that yap occasionally. Just part of residential Life. No point getting all stressed about it or holding petty grudges. TBH the neighbour sounds reasonable enough.

Lalosalamanca · 18/07/2022 14:37

Op has repeatedly demonstrated her inability to be civil though @TJakes5

It's funny she's started a thread asking for opinions but if you give her an opinion she doesn't like she jumps on you.

I'm sensing the op will never be able to get over the fact the dog dared to bark when she had a newborn and is holding a grudge. Sounds to me like she really struggled with the world continuing whilst she had a newborn baby.

TJakes5 · 18/07/2022 14:25

Yes you are approaching this all wrong. You don't have to be best friends with her or Dog. Sometimes Dog's just want to smell you so they know you're not a threat, then they stop barking.

It would make interactions and your time in garden more pleasant by being civil. Maybe you could just say the odd hello or something. Not a big deal is it?

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 14:23

@Treacletoots

And, I've asked repeatedly for examples of this alleged "rudeness" I am supposed to have engaged in. Nothing concrete or convincing thus far. Just unfounded comments and judgements. Hence why I am more aligned with IANBU, because those posters have presented more convincing and logical arguments.

OP posts:
randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 14:20

@Treacletoots

Hmm. That sounds a bit like you're telling me what I should take from my own thread. 🤔

Doesn't work like that, sorry. We are free to engage with our own threads how we like and we can take from them whatever we like. That's sort of how it works.

OP posts:
Treacletoots · 18/07/2022 14:12

"You do realise there are a mixture of responses? Can you explain why I should be aligning myself with the yabus over the yanbus? Is that a requirement of this forum? Or is it allowed that an OP comes to realise she was not unreasonable based on the mixture of responses"

Where did I say you had to align with either side, although you clearly have aligned with the YANBU ironically, despite there being a mixture of both.

The whole point of AIBU is asking a ton of strangers to hopefully get a balanced viewpoint, not, as you have done, to use to back up your own opinion that you were of course NBU. 🤔

If you were genuinely trying to understand if you were being unreasonable you'd take from the mix of responses that in fact you were perhaps on the fence, if you'll excuse the irony, and that you may have been rude but so was your neighbour.

rightonthyme · 18/07/2022 11:38

YANBU. We are having a similar issue. The advice was "oh make friends with the three dogs and they won't bark! Speak to the neighbours!" It hasn't worked anyway. I got physically threatened for my trouble (police did fuck all as there wasn't enough evidence). Dogs still bark at the fucking wind.

We are currently at the stage of physically recording the noise (after filling out noise diary) for the council.

Go the council route OP, it may be that your neighbour has received a complaint already, thinks it's you, and is buttering you up. Fuck her - go all the way and complain complain complain. If she can't be bothered to train her animal she can take the consequences!

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 11:11

@Sceptre86

My DD was 8 weeks old when the yapping caused her to startle and cry. Using explanations like "don't worry sweetheart it's just a dog" aren't going to help me with a frightened newborn. Hence why I addressed it with the dog owner instead. Like I say, now at 15 months she's much more chilled and barely notices the barking tbh, which is good. If she were to be scared again at this age, explanations like that would be useful, I agree.

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 18/07/2022 10:41

She was trying to make ammends albeit clumsily. Our garden backs onto several gardens and two of the neighbours have dogs that bark once they see our kids. When we first moved in my son was 8 months and dd1 was 2 and would cry and get scared. One of the neighbours would take the dog in when we were out, the others put a screen up. No arguments, no issues. I didn't raise it with either of them but rather would say to my kids things along the lines of the dialogue just being a dog as I don't want them growing up to be scared. They are now nearly 5 and 6 and aren't bothered by the dogs anymore, one of the neighbours has kept the screen up as we have dd2 now and they openly admit their dog isn't a fan of children in general.

You aren't being unreasonable for not wanting to make friends with her dog, I wouldn't either but you shut her down rudely.

SpartacusNotEsther · 18/07/2022 10:14

maddy68 · 18/07/2022 09:46

Your reaction was really rude and unfriendly. She was trying to address a problem for you in a nice neighbourly way and you were rude

She's right too. The dog is defending its territory. If he knows you and you speak to him it'll shut up. And know you are friend not fo.

Your reaction was truly weird

It's not 'nice and neighbourly' to talk to someone that can't see you because you are behind a fence. It's not 'nice and neighbourly' to wait a year to address an issue. Both of those things are weird.

milkyaqua · 18/07/2022 09:58

Londonrach1 · 18/07/2022 06:36

You were rude. She was trying to make peace with you. Yabu in this case no matter how to look at this. Rude!

If she was trying to "make peace" with the OP, why did she wait an entire year to do this?

Blaming the OP for her untrained dog's behaviour, for not being friendly enough towards it, is not "making peace".

Gnomechange · 18/07/2022 09:57

Not the point but how would one make friends with a dog, gifts, invitation over? 😃

I don’t think you were being unreasonable at all, if she wanted to make amends she should have come to your door not creepily through a fence while you are busy. That is weird!

Maybe consider planting a quick growing bush. If the dog see you it might bark less.

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 09:51

SpartacusNotEsther · 18/07/2022 08:50

I'm trying to imagine a) the neighbour having the conversation with op, if op was the baby's father rather than the mother.

b) people thinking that the man of the house was rude for not wanting to engage with the neighbour and befriend the yappy dog.

I do realise this is a bit of a tangent, and I'm sure that the people that have said op was rude will defend their position and say it wouldn't make a difference. And it certainly shouldn't. But I have a strong suspicion that, in reality, it would.

I suspect so, too. Different standards applied because I'm female, no doubt.

OP posts:
randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 09:51

@maddy68

She was trying to address a problem for whom, though? I have no problem. I just wanted to enjoy my afternoon in the garden. I'm not going to start engaging with solving problems that don't exist for me, nor engaging with people or animals whom I have no interest in. I just wanted to enjoy my day.

OP posts:
maddy68 · 18/07/2022 09:46

Your reaction was really rude and unfriendly. She was trying to address a problem for you in a nice neighbourly way and you were rude

She's right too. The dog is defending its territory. If he knows you and you speak to him it'll shut up. And know you are friend not fo.

Your reaction was truly weird

ApplesandBunions · 18/07/2022 09:36

SpartacusNotEsther · 18/07/2022 08:50

I'm trying to imagine a) the neighbour having the conversation with op, if op was the baby's father rather than the mother.

b) people thinking that the man of the house was rude for not wanting to engage with the neighbour and befriend the yappy dog.

I do realise this is a bit of a tangent, and I'm sure that the people that have said op was rude will defend their position and say it wouldn't make a difference. And it certainly shouldn't. But I have a strong suspicion that, in reality, it would.

Likewise.

JauntyJinty · 18/07/2022 09:02

Jangle7381 · 18/07/2022 08:38

This!

She was only "making peace" becasue she wanted to pass the responsility of training her dog onto OP

Mumsnet usually

"Have boundaries, don't let CF take advantage - they rely on people being polite, "no" is a complete sentence"

Mumsnet on this thread

"She shouted over the fence to you using nice words? You're in charge of training her dog now"

SpartacusNotEsther · 18/07/2022 08:50

I'm trying to imagine a) the neighbour having the conversation with op, if op was the baby's father rather than the mother.

b) people thinking that the man of the house was rude for not wanting to engage with the neighbour and befriend the yappy dog.

I do realise this is a bit of a tangent, and I'm sure that the people that have said op was rude will defend their position and say it wouldn't make a difference. And it certainly shouldn't. But I have a strong suspicion that, in reality, it would.

Jangle7381 · 18/07/2022 08:38

Londonrach1 · 18/07/2022 06:36

You were rude. She was trying to make peace with you. Yabu in this case no matter how to look at this. Rude!

This!

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 07:10

@SpartacusNotEsther

You have understood my perspective 100%!

OP posts:
SpartacusNotEsther · 18/07/2022 06:48

Londonrach1 · 18/07/2022 06:36

You were rude. She was trying to make peace with you. Yabu in this case no matter how to look at this. Rude!

a) why was there a need to make peace? Op hadn't interacted with the neighbour for a year?

b) how was op rude? The neighbour decided to have a conversation when op couldn't even see her (who does that when they are trying to 'make peace' with someone?). The neighbour decided the best way to resolve there issue was to pass the buck into op. Op started out by acknowledging what the neighbour was saying, but the neighbour didn't take the hint and repeated herself. What was op supposed to say in order to stop getting talked at through a garden fence? Should she have agreed to try and befriend a dog she couldn't see and has no interest in?

Londonrach1 · 18/07/2022 06:36

You were rude. She was trying to make peace with you. Yabu in this case no matter how to look at this. Rude!

QuebecBagnet · 18/07/2022 06:25

I agree you shouldn’t have to and yes it absolutely should be your neighbour sorting the dog out but she’s either unwilling or incapable. So if I had a choice between spending a short amount of time befriending the dog meaning long term peace and quiet or having to put up with the dog for ever I’d give it a go.

the dog needs positive reinforcement and to associate you with nice things, with the owners permission I’d be giving it treats for a bit so it soon sees you as a friend. Maybe a quick chat with the neighbour about positive reinforcement training methods from her to get the dog to stop doing stuff. She firmly tells the dog to stop barking, if necessary removing the dog and when it stops she gives it a treat. And repeat. It might be hard work for a few days but dogs learn quickly and hopefully it wouldn’t take longer than that.

Aubree17 · 18/07/2022 06:08

OnaBegonia · 16/07/2022 19:01

YABU, she's trying to make peace with you.

This.

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 06:05

@Rattles1

Ah its hard for the lockdown babies isn't it.

Exactly - with a baby / very young toddler, who the hell has the energy to be making friends with a bloody random dog?! It was such a rare moment of chill sat on the grass for the 10/15 minutes with her... seriously not spending that exchanging pleasantries with Fido and his inconsiderate owner 🙄

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread