Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Don’t want to “make friends” with neighbour’s dog…

636 replies

randomdogfriend · 16/07/2022 18:58

NC for this. Sorry it's long!

Small backstory: Neighbour has a yappy dog that never stops, it comes right up to the fence in our back garden and barks incessantly whenever any of us go into the garden. It also barks at passers by on the street - it literally follows them along the fence yapping incessantly as they walk down the street. Neighbour does very little to address this - the occasion half hearted “stop that (name of dog)”, but it doesn’t listen to her and she doesn’t physically remove it. Last year I had a word with the neighbour about this through the fence - the barking was so bad it was upsetting my then newborn aged baby as we sat in the garden. She argued back with me and was generally unpleasant, so I threatened to report her if it didn’t stop. This was around 12 months ago and I’ve had no interactions with her since. The dog has done its usual nuisance barking at the fence when we’ve been out in the garden but I’ve largely tried to ignore it, and now that DD is a bit older she isn’t as startled or bothered by it. So we just largely ignore now.

Today I took DD (now 15 months) out in the garden to play. I sat on the grass relaxing whilst she played. Yappy dog approached the fence as per usual, but we were far enough away from the fence that I could mostly tune it out and just focus on playing with DD. DD didn’t seem remotely bothered by it either. I was then aware of neighbour approaching the fence and heard her say “oh are you saying hello (dogs name)?” Dog continued to incessantly yap. I ignored and continued to play with DD.

Next thing I heard “excuse me can I talk to you?“ through the fence. The fence is too high to see over it, and you can just about make out a person through the slats but I couldn’t really see her. I said “sorry, do you mean me?” (Not really able to see anyone at this point, just a shadow through the fence, and I was also sat a good few feet away from the fence. She said “yes”. I said “erm, yeah I suppose, I can’t see you but I can hear you”. She said “I’m sorry my dog barks and annoys you”. I replied “that’s ok” and then continued to engage with DD who was toddling around (so my attention was more focussed on her and I honestly didn’t want to have any interaction with anyone else at that point). I was hoping this would end the conversation. She continued: “if you made friends with her, she wouldn’t bark at you”. I just again decided to give a one word answer in the hope she would disengage from me as all I wanted to do was relax and play with DD. I replied again “right, ok”. She then continued… “if you made friends with her she wouldn’t bark and then you wouldn’t complain, would you”.

At this point I got irritated as she was pushing an unwanted conversation and also implying I had “complained” when I’d had one interaction with her about this a whole year ago where I’d threatened to complain but not followed that through, and also not mentioned the dog to her since.

I replied: “I just want to enjoy my garden with my DD. I don’t want to have to make friends with a dog through the fence. If your dog is barking constantly it’s because you aren’t training her properly, and that’s up to you to address. It’s not down to other people to make friends with your dog”.

It was more than I wanted to invest in the interaction but to be honest she had annoyed me by that point.

She then said, randomly, “how old is your daughter now?” I replied with her age. In between I was playing with DD and interacting with her, hoping neighbour would get the hint that I didn’t want to engage with her. She then said “what’s her name?” I replied with her name. Just one word answers to try to end it. She then said “ok. I just thought we could be friends that’s all”. Then she (presumably) walked off back to her house (like I say, limited visibility through the fence).

The whole interaction was just so random. Firstly I hadn’t commented on her dog, I was minding my own business and playing with DD. Also a whole year has passed since our last interaction so why approach me now? It would have made sense if I’d complained there and then about the dog, but I’d said nothing. I was just ignoring it as I usually do.

If it’s relevant this isn’t a next door neighbour as such. It’s hard to explain but we are a detached house and her back garden and mine back share a boundary fence. Our houses are nowhere near each other and are actually on separate streets. I am friends with my next door neighbour, by choice, who is lovely. I have no desire to be friends with this other neighbour or her dog.

Was I mean or unreasonable to not want to be friends with either her or her dog? When I'm in my garden I just want to relax and enjoy my garden and my daughter. Is this reasonable? Also, should random people be expected to befriend dogs, or is the onus on the owners to stop the barking regardless?

Any thoughts welcomed.

OP posts:
randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 22:03

In nearly 20 years on Mumsnet I have never seen someone defend herself so vociferously and that’s what IMHO got peoples backs up.

That says far more about the people who are getting annoyed than it does me. People who are attacked will defend themselves, that's normal and perfectly acceptable.

OP posts:
randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 22:01

I admire your ability to remain calm and polite in this thread, OP.

Thank you

OP posts:
Chardonnay73 · 18/07/2022 20:42

Lord, Is this still going on?!
I could type a long post out about the inconsistencies in your posts, ‘the dog doesn’t bother me’ in later posts you have admitted it does.
Requesting the thread to be deleted, then saying ‘why should I lose my thread?’
But quite frankly it’s too hot and I can’t be arsed.
OP I’m genuinely sorry that you’ve been upset by some of the vile responses and personal attacks on here. That’s not acceptable.
But in your later posts you’ve been so less aggressive and defensive in your tone and I can’t help think that that is why things kicked off so much initially.

Perhaps if you’d been like that from the start then maybe this wouldn’t have turned into such a bun fight.
In nearly 20 years on Mumsnet I have never seen someone defend herself so vociferously and that’s what IMHO got peoples backs up.
I dont think you ‘making friends with the dog ‘ was actually going to resolve the situation, but you, know, it may have helped somewhat, you’ll never know as you never tried, and put what happened previously aside, and was the bigger person.
I’m fairly old and a good maxim I’ve lived my life by is ‘you get more with honey than with vinegar’. Try it. It might surprise you.
If I were you I’d hide this thread and move on.

zoeFromCity · 18/07/2022 19:40

I admire your ability to remain calm and polite in this thread, OP.

The point with dog yapping at everyone is something not many YABU posters even noticed.

The more I think about this case, if the yapping would be annoying you, there might be actually a good time to complain now- if she acted on other complaint as seems probable here, having 2 at once from different sides might show more about the extent of the yapping annoyance.

Only you know whether it still brings you some value, other than keeping record of how far some dog people can go if someone doesn't love their furries.

Huntswomanonthemove · 18/07/2022 19:39

Lalosalamanca · 18/07/2022 18:51

It is on the owner to train but she hasn't and there's no sign she will. The dog may be barking as he perceives neighbour to be a threat. Its not only for attention so the op wouldn't be rewarding "bad behavioir" she would be showing the dog she isn't a threat and he would likely stop yapping

If she gives the dog attention for barking, chances are it will bark even more every time she goes out there. It isn’t up to @randomdogfriend to do anything. She’s under zero obligation to make friends with either the dog or it’s owner.

WhackingPhoenix · 18/07/2022 19:22

🎻

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 19:17

vodkaredbullgirl · 18/07/2022 19:11

Suprised this is still going with all the deleted posts.

Presumably MNHQ recognise that it's unfair to delete an OP's thread when it's others who are unable to engage in civil debate without resorting to personal insults. I'm not responsible for the behaviour of others, so why should I lose my thread?

OP posts:
vodkaredbullgirl · 18/07/2022 19:11

Suprised this is still going with all the deleted posts.

Mangogogogo · 18/07/2022 18:59

Offit this. Why post on aibu if you’re adamant you’re not?

Lalosalamanca · 18/07/2022 18:51

It is on the owner to train but she hasn't and there's no sign she will. The dog may be barking as he perceives neighbour to be a threat. Its not only for attention so the op wouldn't be rewarding "bad behavioir" she would be showing the dog she isn't a threat and he would likely stop yapping

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 18:49

I've said a few times that the yapping is pretty much continuous, though. It yaps at any Tom Dick or Harry who passes by on the street, literally runs along the fence yapping. So even if I bought into the concept that befriending a dog through a fence that can barely be seen through would solve the problem of it yapping at me, it doesn't solve the overall issue of the incessant yapping at everyone else, which I would still hear. I could befriend the entire street and the dog would still yap constantly. So the whole exercise is just pointless.

OP posts:
Huntswomanonthemove · 18/07/2022 18:47

It’s entirely up to the owner to train her dog properly. If the dog is barking for attention from the neighbour and it gets attention, then bad behaviour is being rewarded.

Lalosalamanca · 18/07/2022 18:19

@randomdogfriend
I think for me I saw an opportunity in that by acknowledging the dog you may will put a stop to the yapping which benefits you when you are in the garden. I'm not suggesting you need to become friends with the neighbour or dog but a simple small act could change the situation you find yourself in and would benefit you. Obviously if you don't mind the yapping then I'm wrong there's no missed opportunity

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 18:17

SpartacusNotEsther · 18/07/2022 18:16

I'm utterly astonished by the sheer number of posts someone can have deleted, yet are still permitted to post.

I'm pretty sure that one person is taking up more time than the entire rest of the membership combined.

I'm astonished too.

OP posts:
SpartacusNotEsther · 18/07/2022 18:16

I'm utterly astonished by the sheer number of posts someone can have deleted, yet are still permitted to post.

I'm pretty sure that one person is taking up more time than the entire rest of the membership combined.

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 18:13

Not everyone knows their neighbours. I know a few of mine - but there are some in the street who keep themselves to themselves (absolutely fine) so how else would I describe them? I don't know them. So strangers surely?

Exactly. This.

OP posts:
Lalosalamanca · 18/07/2022 18:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 18:11

I'm absolutely confident when you are in a better place mentally and aren't feeling so sensitive you will see the opportunity you have missed with you neighbour

Genuine question. You say "Opportunity". But for what? That word implies there's something in it for me. But I don't see that there is. I have no interest in forming a friendship with this person - not necessarily because of a "grudge", btw - I currently don't even feel angry towards her. I just feel, well - indifferent and disinterested, I guess. Therefore, what exactly is this opportunity for me?

OP posts:
Lalosalamanca · 18/07/2022 18:09

Lol@ApplesandBunions

tigger1001 · 18/07/2022 18:08

"People that don't like animals and see neighbours as strangers. Weird."

Why? On either count? Genuine question.

Why is is weird to not want to friend a dog? Why is it weird to expect the owner to have responsibility of the dog? And train the dog not to bark?

Not everyone knows their neighbours. I know a few of mine - but there are some in the street who keep themselves to themselves (absolutely fine) so how else would I describe them? I don't know them. So strangers surely?

ApplesandBunions · 18/07/2022 18:01

Dunning Kruger, ladies and gentlemen.

Lalosalamanca · 18/07/2022 17:58

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 17:48

I'm sensing the op will never be able to get over the fact the dog dared to bark when she had a newborn and is holding a grudge. Sounds to me like she really struggled with the world continuing whilst she had a newborn baby.

I know this comment wasn't posted in good faith and was yet another an attempt to bully and belittle me, however, ironically it's partly correct.

I struggled with a lot after DD was born thanks to quite severe postnatal depression. My baby crying reduced me to an anxious ball of stress, because all I wanted to do was make it stop and make my baby happy. I told myself if my baby was crying it was because I was failing as a mum. It took months of therapy to address that.

So yes, a dog barking incessantly and startling my newborn baby to tears was a huge trigger for my anxiety at that time. I panicked when she was distressed. I still do, to some extent. I'm not ashamed to admit that. Despite feeling that way, however, I was not an arsehole to the neighbour at the time. I asked her nicely (I was actually fighting back tears at the time I remember it well) to please stop her dog from barking right up at the fence. She was unpleasant in return. It's not something I can easily forget because my mental health was so low at the time and in that moment I needed kindness. It wasn't there. Now I'm supposed to be kind to her? With no real apology - just a half hearted shouting over the fence attempt to engage with me, when I have no interest in engaging with her or her dog and I'm playing with DD?

No. I don't think so.

Nope, was not an attempt to bully you. That's your interpretation though and I have no control over that. Simply told you what I intuitively believed, which you confirmed was indeed correct.

I also believe that because of this you are in fact holding a grudge and because of this you can't and won't act reasonably with your neighbour.

Of course I doubt youll agree with this point, yet in time I'm absolutely confident when you are in a better place mentally and aren't feeling so sensitive you will see the opportunity you have missed with you neighbour by allowing your emotions and grudge to take over resulting in your unreasonable response to her attempt at an olive branch

Americano75 · 18/07/2022 17:56

I'm sensing the op will never be able to get over the fact the dog dared to bark when she had a newborn and is holding a grudge. Sounds to me like she really struggled with the world continuing whilst she had a newborn baby.

Bet you feel really good about this one now, don't you?

Seriously, so many people on here should be ashamed of themselves, how bloody nasty.

SaySomethingMan · 18/07/2022 17:50

Loveisnotloving · 18/07/2022 16:09

And in all the time the OP has spent arguing with every single individual on this thread. Perfect Little One has toddled out the back garden and has made friends with yap dog from the other side of fence while neighbour tells her stories about Lassie.

Problem solved.

You know she hasn’t. What do you get for making things up?

randomdogfriend · 18/07/2022 17:48

I'm sensing the op will never be able to get over the fact the dog dared to bark when she had a newborn and is holding a grudge. Sounds to me like she really struggled with the world continuing whilst she had a newborn baby.

I know this comment wasn't posted in good faith and was yet another an attempt to bully and belittle me, however, ironically it's partly correct.

I struggled with a lot after DD was born thanks to quite severe postnatal depression. My baby crying reduced me to an anxious ball of stress, because all I wanted to do was make it stop and make my baby happy. I told myself if my baby was crying it was because I was failing as a mum. It took months of therapy to address that.

So yes, a dog barking incessantly and startling my newborn baby to tears was a huge trigger for my anxiety at that time. I panicked when she was distressed. I still do, to some extent. I'm not ashamed to admit that. Despite feeling that way, however, I was not an arsehole to the neighbour at the time. I asked her nicely (I was actually fighting back tears at the time I remember it well) to please stop her dog from barking right up at the fence. She was unpleasant in return. It's not something I can easily forget because my mental health was so low at the time and in that moment I needed kindness. It wasn't there. Now I'm supposed to be kind to her? With no real apology - just a half hearted shouting over the fence attempt to engage with me, when I have no interest in engaging with her or her dog and I'm playing with DD?

No. I don't think so.

OP posts: