Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband thinks my family should be more involved and that I need to speak with them? AIBU to tell him his expectations are off

266 replies

Tetetete · 16/07/2022 17:28

My husband has an older child from his previous relationship and we share Dc too.

I met DSC when they were 5 and they are now 11. Our DC is a toddler.

Basically my family has never hugely been involved with DSC. They are nice when they see them but they don't go out of their way to see / talk about them etc... They get a token gift for Christmas from a couple of members of my family and my parents chuck a tenner in a card for their birthdays that sort of thing. I've always thought this was fine, they aren't their grandkids / nephew at the end of the day. Admittedly our son is spoilt a lot by my family but again, always thought that was fine and fair enough.

Anyway, he's made little comments in the past but basically my sister has asked if she can take our toddler with her and her husband and their DC to their holiday home during the summer as they also have a young child and our DC gets on well with them. We can't afford a holiday this year so thought it was great for our DC and was very grateful.

Anyway, my husband has now let all of this out that he thinks my family should make more effort with their 'stepgrandchild/nephew' and it's been bugging him for a while and I should speak to them about it. He seems pissed that I'm not pissed about it. I think they are entirely reasonable and it's their right and choice how involved they wish to be.

My sister does also have another DC similar age to DSC so he thinks why couldn't DSS go too and has said he'll pay if that's the issue. But his wider issue just seems to be around the fact the DC aren't treated the same.

AIBU to think he's being ridiculous and to say there's no way I'm bringing this up with my family and making out like they are doing something wrong.

OP posts:
Meraas · 16/07/2022 23:01

alphapie · 16/07/2022 17:46

Well yes, as a child's feelings are involved.

Do you honestly not understand how upsetting this would be as a child?

To know some adults who are your family, or so you're often told, don't really give a shit about you?

🙄

TiddleyWink · 16/07/2022 22:59

Youseethethingis1 · 16/07/2022 22:54

I actually think it's pretty shallow to assume that meaningful family relationships can just be manufactured to suit according to who is married to who at any given time.

Absolutely this. Anyone who can apparently form such a meaningful bond instantly because of who their relative gets together with can break it just as quickly (see earlier posts about the grandparents disinheriting ex step grandchildren).

Family means different things to different people and this thread shows that what works for one situation won’t work for another. But what will absolutely NEVER work is dictating to extended family that they should magic up a closer relationship overnight with your step child because you’ve decided that’s what you want. If it’s going to happen it will be because it’s natural, not because you’ve been told LOVE THIS CHILD! NOW!

Youseethethingis1 · 16/07/2022 22:54

I actually think it's pretty shallow to assume that meaningful family relationships can just be manufactured to suit according to who is married to who at any given time.

safclass · 16/07/2022 22:52

Totally agree, our family is the same. Everyone accepted from anywhere 🤣

Nearly all our families are blended ones, several generations as well, and there's no difference between the grandkids and the step GC.

Ontomatopea · 16/07/2022 22:50

Supersimkin2 · 16/07/2022 21:57

The decider is usually whether DSC has the full complement of both parents, DGP, etc..

If all the roles are filled, a lighter touch SC ‘bonus’ treatment it is from the extra adults. Otherwise DSC gets too much of everything - parenting, presents, inheritance, you name it. Holidays, even, OP.

If DSC is missing key adults in their life, birth child rights apply to them - the adults are substitute and replacements for their missing father, grandparents, and so on. Equal treatment with the bio kids, ruthlessly.

Nah this wouldn't wash with my DSC either. They've lost grandparents early on and my parents aren't replacements, substitutes etc. The loss of their grandparents is important enough to them to be part of their life story and I'm pretty sure they'd feel insulted if my parents tried to "replace" their grandparent.

aSofaNearYou · 16/07/2022 22:48

To be frank, if a family doesn't then I wouldn't want to be part of it. Family is a lot more than presumed genetics. Unless you're pretty shallow.

Or you just don't have that relationship with them, but whatever judgmental statement suits you better.

TiddleyWink · 16/07/2022 22:46

Somethingneedstochange · 16/07/2022 21:53

That's the way it should be. A friend of mine got in a relationship when her oldest son was about 2. They treat him just like any other grandchild. Even helped with childcare so my friend could work.

They got married and had a child together when he was 5. They had a second child when her oldest was 8.

He worked away so they drifted apart They split up a few years after they're second bio child. His parents told her ex husband they had cut her oldest child out of they're will. Not her husband's biological children they had just the step child. 😪😪😪

A very good example of why pretending your entire extended family feel exactly the same about your step child as their biological grandchildren, and trying to force an artificial relationship, is a very risky approach. I wonder how many of these grandparents are going along with the pretence of an exactly equal relationship in order to appease the demands of their adult children and ensure access to biological grandchildren continues. We’ve already had posters on this thread saying they would cut off their parents if they didn’t treat step children exactly the same in every way as their grandchildren, so it’s not much of a stretch. And this is exactly the kind of thing that’s a risk if it all comes tumbling down. You would have to be staggeringly naive to think grandparents will divide their estate equally with their offsprings ex step child, in 99% of cases this would never happen. By living in la la land and trying to push everyone else into the same pretence of a step family being no different to a nuclear family, you open up far, far more chances of long term hurt and confusion for the children involved.

Onlyforcake · 16/07/2022 22:42

In my husband's family his mum is totally brilliant with her step granddaughters but his dad terrible. We did see it coming though as my husbands dad doesn't refer to my husbands siblings (half sisters) unless forced to. My own family has always taken steps and adopted children into the family on equal terms. To be frank, if a family doesn't then I wouldn't want to be part of it. Family is a lot more than presumed genetics. Unless you're pretty shallow.

aSofaNearYou · 16/07/2022 22:40

*How is it? Step-child's mum won't have anything to do with her Ex's new children.

Totally different,*

And my family has hardly anything to do with my DP's older child. So actually it's not that different.

RocketsMagnificent7 · 16/07/2022 22:38

Somethingneedstochange · 16/07/2022 21:35

No it's not she made a choice to be in a relationship with someone who already had a dsc. He was here before they're shared child. Her family should have made the effort.

I'm sure she would look at it differently if her DH was stepdad to her DC.

Jesus Christ. No. Her family make an effort they just don't put the stepchild at the forefront. They're kind, they buy him gifts. He has a mother and a maternal family, trust me he doesn't want another. He'd probably be extremely uncomfortable if they started treating him like he was their own. And his mum would quite rightly have something to say about it too.

whumpthereitis · 16/07/2022 22:36

Nanny0gg · 16/07/2022 22:34

My father left his step-grandchildren the same as his actual DGC when he died.

Okay, and? That doesn’t mean that people who choose to do differently are wrong.

Nanny0gg · 16/07/2022 22:34

lickenchugget · 16/07/2022 22:24

But not many GP’s would leave anything to ex-step GC in their wills? Might be uncomfortable but they are not related if their son is no longer married to ex. This is what happens when everyone pretends everyone is the same to everyone. It’s not true.

My father left his step-grandchildren the same as his actual DGC when he died.

Nanny0gg · 16/07/2022 22:33

Tetetete · 16/07/2022 17:39

I understand there are lots of families that are super involved and may treat DSC just like DC but does that really mean it's wrong to do it a different way?

DSS has never seemed bothered. He has his own grandparents / aunties and uncles.

I get he has his 'other' family.

But I still couldn't treat him differently when he is with my family (GP here)

whumpthereitis · 16/07/2022 22:26

Supersimkin2 · 16/07/2022 21:57

The decider is usually whether DSC has the full complement of both parents, DGP, etc..

If all the roles are filled, a lighter touch SC ‘bonus’ treatment it is from the extra adults. Otherwise DSC gets too much of everything - parenting, presents, inheritance, you name it. Holidays, even, OP.

If DSC is missing key adults in their life, birth child rights apply to them - the adults are substitute and replacements for their missing father, grandparents, and so on. Equal treatment with the bio kids, ruthlessly.

A more important decider is surely whether unrelated adults want to fulfil that roles/those roles or not.

Nanny0gg · 16/07/2022 22:26

quietnightmare · 16/07/2022 17:35

Does steps child's mum and family buy lots of gifts/holidays for your shared DC? Because it's the exact same situation

How is it? Step-child's mum won't have anything to do with her Ex's new children.

Totally different,

And OP - I think your family's attitude is wrong

lickenchugget · 16/07/2022 22:24

Somethingneedstochange · 16/07/2022 21:53

That's the way it should be. A friend of mine got in a relationship when her oldest son was about 2. They treat him just like any other grandchild. Even helped with childcare so my friend could work.

They got married and had a child together when he was 5. They had a second child when her oldest was 8.

He worked away so they drifted apart They split up a few years after they're second bio child. His parents told her ex husband they had cut her oldest child out of they're will. Not her husband's biological children they had just the step child. 😪😪😪

But not many GP’s would leave anything to ex-step GC in their wills? Might be uncomfortable but they are not related if their son is no longer married to ex. This is what happens when everyone pretends everyone is the same to everyone. It’s not true.

whumpthereitis · 16/07/2022 22:24

Somethingneedstochange · 16/07/2022 21:35

No it's not she made a choice to be in a relationship with someone who already had a dsc. He was here before they're shared child. Her family should have made the effort.

I'm sure she would look at it differently if her DH was stepdad to her DC.

Um, no. Her choosing to be with a man who has a child in no way obliges her family to extend anything other than basic kindness when they interact.

My brother is a stepfather. My parents are kind to the kid on the occasions they see him, but do they act as grandparents? No. I don’t act as an aunt either, and I’d find it weird if that was the expectation.

aSofaNearYou · 16/07/2022 22:22

YANBU at all OP, there are lot of people commenting here that simply do not understand that this kind of dynamic is common and normal.

My DSS is not upset by lack of relationship to my family because this has never been an expectation of his at all. There is no drama needed.

People here just haven't experienced it so they don't get it.

Supersimkin2 · 16/07/2022 21:57

The decider is usually whether DSC has the full complement of both parents, DGP, etc..

If all the roles are filled, a lighter touch SC ‘bonus’ treatment it is from the extra adults. Otherwise DSC gets too much of everything - parenting, presents, inheritance, you name it. Holidays, even, OP.

If DSC is missing key adults in their life, birth child rights apply to them - the adults are substitute and replacements for their missing father, grandparents, and so on. Equal treatment with the bio kids, ruthlessly.

Somethingneedstochange · 16/07/2022 21:53

That's the way it should be. A friend of mine got in a relationship when her oldest son was about 2. They treat him just like any other grandchild. Even helped with childcare so my friend could work.

They got married and had a child together when he was 5. They had a second child when her oldest was 8.

He worked away so they drifted apart They split up a few years after they're second bio child. His parents told her ex husband they had cut her oldest child out of they're will. Not her husband's biological children they had just the step child. 😪😪😪

toomuchlaundry · 16/07/2022 21:48

Is it just your toddler going or are you going with them too?

Ontomatopea · 16/07/2022 21:43

Somethingneedstochange · 16/07/2022 21:35

No it's not she made a choice to be in a relationship with someone who already had a dsc. He was here before they're shared child. Her family should have made the effort.

I'm sure she would look at it differently if her DH was stepdad to her DC.

Her relatives didn't have any say in the matter though

lickenchugget · 16/07/2022 21:41

yanbu in the slightest

Somethingneedstochange · 16/07/2022 21:35

No it's not she made a choice to be in a relationship with someone who already had a dsc. He was here before they're shared child. Her family should have made the effort.

I'm sure she would look at it differently if her DH was stepdad to her DC.

Tetetete · 16/07/2022 21:17

DSS lives here 50:50. Yes he has grandparents on his mum's side.

if my parents and brother treated my DSC any differently to their bio grandkids then none of us would have a relationship with them.

No I have absolutely zero intention of ceasing a relationship with my family because of this, what an insanely over the top thing to do. Quite honestly I'd end my marriage before my relationship with my family over this.

OP, do you have a distant relationship with your step-child?

No but the thread isn't about my relationship with him.

OP posts: