Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband thinks my family should be more involved and that I need to speak with them? AIBU to tell him his expectations are off

266 replies

Tetetete · 16/07/2022 17:28

My husband has an older child from his previous relationship and we share Dc too.

I met DSC when they were 5 and they are now 11. Our DC is a toddler.

Basically my family has never hugely been involved with DSC. They are nice when they see them but they don't go out of their way to see / talk about them etc... They get a token gift for Christmas from a couple of members of my family and my parents chuck a tenner in a card for their birthdays that sort of thing. I've always thought this was fine, they aren't their grandkids / nephew at the end of the day. Admittedly our son is spoilt a lot by my family but again, always thought that was fine and fair enough.

Anyway, he's made little comments in the past but basically my sister has asked if she can take our toddler with her and her husband and their DC to their holiday home during the summer as they also have a young child and our DC gets on well with them. We can't afford a holiday this year so thought it was great for our DC and was very grateful.

Anyway, my husband has now let all of this out that he thinks my family should make more effort with their 'stepgrandchild/nephew' and it's been bugging him for a while and I should speak to them about it. He seems pissed that I'm not pissed about it. I think they are entirely reasonable and it's their right and choice how involved they wish to be.

My sister does also have another DC similar age to DSC so he thinks why couldn't DSS go too and has said he'll pay if that's the issue. But his wider issue just seems to be around the fact the DC aren't treated the same.

AIBU to think he's being ridiculous and to say there's no way I'm bringing this up with my family and making out like they are doing something wrong.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 17/07/2022 17:25

alphapie · 17/07/2022 13:00

To not consider them family is being awful.

It doesn't matter if they're not actively mean to them, they're not treating them the same, children pick up on that.

Thankfully I don't know anyone irl who does this, step children are treated and included as family. They're children ffs.

Tbh, considering how the level of melodrama, venom, rigid thinking and frankly, delusion, the apparently non-awful contingent have been displaying all over the thread, I can’t say it’s being sold as a particularly attractive proposition.

hard pass.

billy1966 · 17/07/2022 16:15

It is interesting how people view others through marriage.

I commented on another thread how my friend was appalled to see how her SIL was treated when her BIL had an affair and the marriage broke up some years ago.

Suddenly her inlaws completely abandoned them and within months welcomed in the new partner.

So awful, but really shocking for my friend.
She couldn't believe that they would do this to a woman who had been in their family for 15 years.

She pulled back massively from the family, absolutely no longer prepared to invest big effort in a relationship with people who would behave like that.

Effectively they lost two lovely DIL's and close contact with their grandchildren with it, as he hasn't had a second family.
They very infrequently see their GP's as their father really isn't hugely involved.

So shortsighted of a woman with three sons, all of whom suit themselves, including my friends husband!

Meraas · 17/07/2022 16:05

KettrickenSmiled · 17/07/2022 15:44

Straw Man argument @CatherinedeBourgh - as you clearly were not cohabiting with 20 'siblings', whereas OP's DSS lives with her & has been part of her nuclear family set-up for 6 years.

Your family needn't subscribe to my "philiosophy", because you've totally invented it. Where have I suggested that adults & children who have never met should be treated as full family?

DSS only lives with his dad 50% of the time.

If he lived with him 100% and he didn’t have a loving mum and her parents then it would be different.

KettrickenSmiled · 17/07/2022 15:44

CatherinedeBourgh · 17/07/2022 14:03

@KettrickenSmiled

By your logic, I have over 20 siblings, roughly half of which I have never met (my step siblings' half siblings from the other side).

Actually there may be some more, as one of my half sibling's mother was married 7 times, and I lost track of the mother of another one.

Thank goodness my family doesn't subscribe to your philosophy, life would be very complicated! On the plus side, I might have inherited a fortune if all those grandparents had felt an obligation to include me in their wills...

Straw Man argument @CatherinedeBourgh - as you clearly were not cohabiting with 20 'siblings', whereas OP's DSS lives with her & has been part of her nuclear family set-up for 6 years.

Your family needn't subscribe to my "philiosophy", because you've totally invented it. Where have I suggested that adults & children who have never met should be treated as full family?

Happyher · 17/07/2022 15:43

I don’t think it’s fair to judge OPs parents when we don’t know their side of this. Maybe they can’t afford to be as generous with SGC, maybe their age makes it difficult to take 2 GC on holiday. All families are different and deal with this issue in different ways so we can’t apply our own standards in judgement.

My kids have a SGF whom they are fond of - they also have half siblings and they know they don’t get the same monetary value gifts or same amount of attention but they’ve never given two hoots about it. They thought it was great that they got an extra tenner at Christmas. Blended families adapt in many different ways

CatherinedeBourgh · 17/07/2022 14:03

@KettrickenSmiled

By your logic, I have over 20 siblings, roughly half of which I have never met (my step siblings' half siblings from the other side).

Actually there may be some more, as one of my half sibling's mother was married 7 times, and I lost track of the mother of another one.

Thank goodness my family doesn't subscribe to your philosophy, life would be very complicated! On the plus side, I might have inherited a fortune if all those grandparents had felt an obligation to include me in their wills...

WimpoleHat · 17/07/2022 14:01

It's really horrible for anyone to treat siblings differently from each other. If one child is been taken away on fancy holidays and the other child isn't, how do you think that makes the other child feel?

But they are half siblings. And half siblings often (usually?) have different experiences. The stepson here will probably go on holiday with his mum, with no thought to how the OP’s son (the child’s half sibling) will feel about it. And fair enough. He may do something with his mum’s family - and why not? They are his family and they are not the family of OP’s son. So why is it such a big deal for OP’s son to go away with his auntie? I’m sure DSS will understand that his half brother has relatives not shared by him - as he himself will have other relatives who don’t know his half brother.

The “when you marry you become family” thing isn’t really true for a lot of people. Or they pay lip service to it at most. I was hugely close to my aunt; spent loads of time with her as a child and an adult. So when I got married, she was very welcoming to my DH. But she was most perturbed when her little grandson (who was very taken with DH) said to someone else about me, “You know Wimpole. She’s the one who comes with DH.” Apparently she corrected him immediately - “No, DGS. DH comes with Wimpole.” And that’s the reality for most people. My DH is welcomed into the family as an extension of me - if we were to split up, he’d no longer be thought of as such. So it’s often the same with step kids. Absolutely it behoves people to be pleasant and
kind and welcoming. Yes - it’s nice to remember them at Christmas and treat them as part of the wider family;
no child wants to be present in a situation where they feel “lesser”. But DSS presumably understands perfectly that his Mum’s family is “his” and not his half brother’s - so equally he will get that his stepmother’s family is not “his” and without any harm or upset being caused to anyone.

aSofaNearYou · 17/07/2022 13:53

Comments like this make no sense it really isn't the same! The step child is part of OPs family and presumably spends some time living with them. The shared DC has no relationship with the ex wife, won't spend any time with them or live with them.

The time they spend living with OP doesn’t automatically include her family. OP has confirmed they have met her sister 3/4 times. They are acquaintances.

And this is very common.

Ponoka7 · 17/07/2022 13:44

That should have said that the split wasn't acrimonious.

Suedomin · 17/07/2022 13:44

Well if that's how it works then your husband's ex should also buy presents for your shared DC!
Comments like this make no sense it really isn't the same! The step child is part of OPs family and presumably spends some time living with them. The shared DC has no relationship with the ex wife, won't spend any time with them or live with them.

RocketsMagnificent7 · 17/07/2022 13:43

spirit20 · 17/07/2022 13:20

Your husband is right. It's really horrible for anyone to treat siblings differently from each other. If one child is been taken away on fancy holidays and the other child isn't, how do you think that makes the other child feel? That can easily build resentment between the two children. If your parents aren't willing to pay for the other child, then you could offer to pay, otherwise you could say that you don't want one going without the other. Ultimately if you let that behaviour happen, then you're condoning it, and yes, that does make you not a very nice step-mother.

What if the child doesn't want to go? What about whether his mum would be okay with her child being taken on holiday by virtual strangers?

You're being absolutely ridiculous. Each child has two sets of extended family, one of which they share, one of which they are entitled to do things and be a part of independently of one another.

I mean, by your logic, the stepchild's mum or her family can never take the stepchild anywhere as that's not fair on OP's child. Right?

Ponoka7 · 17/07/2022 13:43

After 'losing' thee children, because of splits who I'd attached to as I would a GC, I wouldn't treat a SC as a blood related child, ever again. In one case the Mother has got with another partner and has emigrated. The others I see photos of and when I see stuff in shops that I would have been picking up for them, it hurts. If my DD was to gain a SC, I'd get the matching PJ's etc, but I wouldn't invest the same as I do my GC. It's hurtful for any children involved, especially if you've done holidays etc together. My GC used to game with one of the SC and has struggled to understand why they've been blocked. The split was acrimonious. Children need the investment of key adults, first and secondary carers. People only have so much to give. Very unfair that one child could end up with six+ grandparents and the bio child with only two, which have to be shared. I say that as someone who loves children and if I take a few out for the day etc, they all get treated the same.

Viviennemary · 17/07/2022 13:41

I didnt vote because there isnt an answer to this. They are not treated the same because your parents dont see them as the same. It is all very sad when families split up and there are these very complicated situations.

RocketsMagnificent7 · 17/07/2022 13:40

*What a silly equivalence, that child wouldn't be part of that posters family.

Your SDC are part of yours, or at least they bloody should be*

They are part of the OP's family, along with her husband and their child. Where has OP said otherwise?

As you seem so determined for this child to be fully included in his stepmum's family, I'll ask you, which other relationship(s) should he sacrifice for this to happen? Because it will take some time, it's not something that can occur instantly and to make the time needed time with someone else is going to be lost.

billy1966 · 17/07/2022 13:38

spirit20 · 17/07/2022 13:20

Your husband is right. It's really horrible for anyone to treat siblings differently from each other. If one child is been taken away on fancy holidays and the other child isn't, how do you think that makes the other child feel? That can easily build resentment between the two children. If your parents aren't willing to pay for the other child, then you could offer to pay, otherwise you could say that you don't want one going without the other. Ultimately if you let that behaviour happen, then you're condoning it, and yes, that does make you not a very nice step-mother.

So the OP's parents should pay for her husbands child to have a holiday with them?

A relationship that they have no choice in?

The OP's parents are under no obligation to pay for a holiday for the OP's husband, much less his child.

I read threads like these and wonder why anyone would bother with someone with children from an earlier relationship.

I feel sorry for the families of people who get involved with people with children already, such are the sudden expectations foisted on them.

I don't think many women would have the expectations that the OP's husband has.

If he was a decent parent he would embrace this time as a lovely opportunity to spend time with his child rather than thinking his SIL has an obligation to take his child by another woman on holiday with her family.

I wonder would he have the same expectations from a BIL?

If you can go at all, take off for the week.

aSofaNearYou · 17/07/2022 13:38

People shouldn’t get into step families if they’re not emotionally mature enough to navigate the fact that the children involved will not always have exactly the same stuff/experiences at exactly the same time. And that’s ok. Because many aspects of their lives, including their mother’s extended families, will be different. You can pretend you’re a typical nuclear family until the cows come home - that won’t make it true.

100%

Ontomatopea · 17/07/2022 13:33

You can pretend you’re a typical nuclear family until the cows come home - that won’t make it true. 100% agree. It's damaging to pretend otherwise.

RocketsMagnificent7 · 17/07/2022 13:30

KettrickenSmiled · 17/07/2022 11:09

AIBU to think he's being ridiculous and to say there's no way I'm bringing this up with my family and making out like they are doing something wrong.

But they ARE doing something wrong.
When you married your husband, he & his DC became family.
Your sister offering to take one child, but not the other, is beyond unpleasant. Especially as she has 2 children of matched ages to DC & DSS.

I could not exclude one child like this, purely for reasons of blood.
You say DSS does stuff with his own extended family - I'd say the same goes for them - each child has a half-sibling now, & each child should be included by both sets of extended family.

They really aren't.

I'll ask you which relationship(s) should OP's stepson sacrifice in order to become a part of her family of origin. That of his paternal family? That of his immediate family (dad, stepmum, little sibling)? Should he have to attend the events of his stepmum's family over those of his own maternal family as he now has to be treated exactly the same as his little brother?

The chances of this child wanting to go on holiday with his stepmum's sister and none of his own family is slim to none. The chances of his mum thinking this is acceptable even less.

TiddleyWink · 17/07/2022 13:28

spirit20 · 17/07/2022 13:20

Your husband is right. It's really horrible for anyone to treat siblings differently from each other. If one child is been taken away on fancy holidays and the other child isn't, how do you think that makes the other child feel? That can easily build resentment between the two children. If your parents aren't willing to pay for the other child, then you could offer to pay, otherwise you could say that you don't want one going without the other. Ultimately if you let that behaviour happen, then you're condoning it, and yes, that does make you not a very nice step-mother.

But what about when the step child goes on holiday with their mum or her relatives? Their step sibling will ‘miss out’ then and that’s ok? Or does absolute equality only work one way?

People shouldn’t get into step families if they’re not emotionally mature enough to navigate the fact that the children involved will not always have exactly the same stuff/experiences at exactly the same time. And that’s ok. Because many aspects of their lives, including their mother’s extended families, will be different. You can pretend you’re a typical nuclear family until the cows come home - that won’t make it true.

aSofaNearYou · 17/07/2022 13:27

spirit20 · 17/07/2022 13:20

Your husband is right. It's really horrible for anyone to treat siblings differently from each other. If one child is been taken away on fancy holidays and the other child isn't, how do you think that makes the other child feel? That can easily build resentment between the two children. If your parents aren't willing to pay for the other child, then you could offer to pay, otherwise you could say that you don't want one going without the other. Ultimately if you let that behaviour happen, then you're condoning it, and yes, that does make you not a very nice step-mother.

My DD has been on loads of holidays without DSS with my family. He doesn't think anything of it, some of the time he doesn't even know. He's been on holiday several times with his mum's family, too. None of this is confusing or upsetting to any of them.

Tetetete · 17/07/2022 13:27

spirit20 · 17/07/2022 13:20

Your husband is right. It's really horrible for anyone to treat siblings differently from each other. If one child is been taken away on fancy holidays and the other child isn't, how do you think that makes the other child feel? That can easily build resentment between the two children. If your parents aren't willing to pay for the other child, then you could offer to pay, otherwise you could say that you don't want one going without the other. Ultimately if you let that behaviour happen, then you're condoning it, and yes, that does make you not a very nice step-mother.

And yet most people on here agree that it's fine for siblings to be treated differently if it's DSCs maternal family doing it.

If DSC got to go on holiday with his maternal family and my child didn't that would be fine because siblings being treated the same only goes one way. Only ever when it's in favour of DSC on here in seems.

For what it's worth DSS would look at us like we'd grown a second head if we said he was going on holiday with my sister who he's met around 3 /4 times in his life.

OP posts:
Tetetete · 17/07/2022 13:23

alphapie · 17/07/2022 13:01

What a silly equivalence, that child wouldn't be part of that posters family.

Your SDC are part of yours, or at least they bloody should be

I'm asking for clarification because it seems very much that this is what that poster is saying if you bother to read their posts.

OP posts:
spirit20 · 17/07/2022 13:20

Your husband is right. It's really horrible for anyone to treat siblings differently from each other. If one child is been taken away on fancy holidays and the other child isn't, how do you think that makes the other child feel? That can easily build resentment between the two children. If your parents aren't willing to pay for the other child, then you could offer to pay, otherwise you could say that you don't want one going without the other. Ultimately if you let that behaviour happen, then you're condoning it, and yes, that does make you not a very nice step-mother.

Ontomatopea · 17/07/2022 13:15

billy1966 · 17/07/2022 13:13

" I could not exclude one child like this, purely for reasons of blood.
You say DSS does stuff with his own extended family - I'd say the same goes for them - each child has a half-sibling now, & each child should be included by both sets of extended family."

@KettrickenSmiled

The above statement is what I queried.

I asked are you actually saying that the OP should be handing over her child to her husbands Ex wife's family? because she has a step child?

That is so bizarre.
Why would she want her child included in the family of her husbands Ex wife?

I have never heard of this ever happening and would find it very weird that anyone would want that.

Many people barely know their husbands ex wife, not to mind their family.
How exactly does one insist when the Ex wife is doing things with her family, that she take her ex husbands new child, with his new wife?

I have genuinely never heard of this and would wonder at it even bein suggested.

Hell would freeze before I allowed my child anywhere near the ex

Ontomatopea · 17/07/2022 13:14

I find it really difficult when people criticise our family set up and the dynamic. It works really well for us and no one is feeling like a 2nd best or anything like that. I think maybe the actual reality and nuances of the situation are difficult to convey in message form.