Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband thinks my family should be more involved and that I need to speak with them? AIBU to tell him his expectations are off

266 replies

Tetetete · 16/07/2022 17:28

My husband has an older child from his previous relationship and we share Dc too.

I met DSC when they were 5 and they are now 11. Our DC is a toddler.

Basically my family has never hugely been involved with DSC. They are nice when they see them but they don't go out of their way to see / talk about them etc... They get a token gift for Christmas from a couple of members of my family and my parents chuck a tenner in a card for their birthdays that sort of thing. I've always thought this was fine, they aren't their grandkids / nephew at the end of the day. Admittedly our son is spoilt a lot by my family but again, always thought that was fine and fair enough.

Anyway, he's made little comments in the past but basically my sister has asked if she can take our toddler with her and her husband and their DC to their holiday home during the summer as they also have a young child and our DC gets on well with them. We can't afford a holiday this year so thought it was great for our DC and was very grateful.

Anyway, my husband has now let all of this out that he thinks my family should make more effort with their 'stepgrandchild/nephew' and it's been bugging him for a while and I should speak to them about it. He seems pissed that I'm not pissed about it. I think they are entirely reasonable and it's their right and choice how involved they wish to be.

My sister does also have another DC similar age to DSC so he thinks why couldn't DSS go too and has said he'll pay if that's the issue. But his wider issue just seems to be around the fact the DC aren't treated the same.

AIBU to think he's being ridiculous and to say there's no way I'm bringing this up with my family and making out like they are doing something wrong.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SmurfysLaw · 19/07/2022 16:40

Tetetete · 17/07/2022 11:16

You say DSS does stuff with his own extended family - I'd say the same goes for them - each child has a half-sibling now, & each child should be included by both sets of extended family

You think my husband's exes family should treat my child like their grandchild? Confused how utterly bizarre.

Tetetete please please suggest this to your husband! Would love to know his response to that ridiculous request 😆

Both children have two sets of extended family, yet he wants his old DC to have a third family as well? That’s not very equal.

billy1966 · 19/07/2022 16:34

aSofaNearYou · 19/07/2022 15:50

Nothing wrong with asking but your OH needs to be careful about rocking the boat before they say neither goes.

Well that's what's wrong with asking, isn't it. They may think it's CFuckery and resent the implication that this is something they should be doing. I would never ask my family members to do this!

This is what I agree with.

OP's sister has asked for her nephew to come with them, very kind in my view.

She might well think the OP is a CF to ask and simply not extend another invitation because of it.

It comes back to my question, would the OP's husband have the same expectation of a man or is it childcare for women.

Minding someone else's toddler is a very generous offer.

I think the OP shouldn't say a word.
She has every right to hope that her and her sisters children will be close, and holidaying together is a lovely part of that.

whumpthereitis · 19/07/2022 16:23

‘Just asking’ isn’t an inherently benign act, either in regards to what is being asked, or in how a request is received. ‘Just asking’ can rock an otherwise steady boat, and result in bad feeling.

OP knows her family best, and she doesn’t want to ‘just ask’. Nor should she have to.

aSofaNearYou · 19/07/2022 15:50

Nothing wrong with asking but your OH needs to be careful about rocking the boat before they say neither goes.

Well that's what's wrong with asking, isn't it. They may think it's CFuckery and resent the implication that this is something they should be doing. I would never ask my family members to do this!

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 19/07/2022 15:39

Personally I can see both sides as i treated my step nieces and nephews same as my nephew however other family members didnt. It used to bug the step dad but not the mum of the step kids as they got things from their bio dad side which my bio nephew didnt and just token as you do. it would be nice if they took SD if they have one their age more just to give you both a nice break. Nothing wrong with asking but your OH needs to be careful about rocking the boat before they say neither goes.

whumpthereitis · 19/07/2022 15:01

ImustLearn2Cook · 19/07/2022 10:53

@Tetetete While I agree that expecting DSS being invited to stay on holiday with your family considering that they don’t know him very well to be inappropriate, I do think that this part of your OP is a bit sad and I get why it bothers your husband after all these years:

I met DSC when they were 5 and they are now 11. Our DC is a toddler.

Basically my family has never hugely been involved with DSC. They are nice when they see them but they don't go out of their way to see / talk about them etc...

It comes across as a form of segregation and a mere tolerance. A bit like he is viewed as an inconsequential add on to your life with your husband.

So what if he’s not a blood relation. Do they not have people they get to know well who are also not related? Do they show an interest in these non related people?

He’s a person too. Why can’t they make an effort to get to know him? It’s not about gifts or token gifts or holidays. Just show an interest and get to know him because he is part of your family. It’s about being inclusive.

They’re treating him like a person though? They’re not ignoring his existence, they treat him kindly when they see him.

They ‘could’ do more than that, but they clearly don’t want to and that’s fine.

The main reason it invariably turns into a big debate is because of the complete failure of one ‘side’ to recognize that different things work for different families, and there’s no one prescribed way to manage blending.

aSofaNearYou · 19/07/2022 11:33

ImustLearn2Cook · 19/07/2022 11:28

@aSofaNearYouOf course I am being subjective, I can only go by what the Op has written. None of us are there to make an objective observation. I can also offer an opinion based on the limited information posted by the Op along with my own perspectives, life experiences and values.

And yes, I have given my personal opinion. The Op can take it or leave it based on her own assessment, perspective, experience and values.

But what have you based that on, the fact that she says they don't go out of their way to see or speak about him? I'm a step parent and I don't do either of those things myself. That's quite a specific thing to take as "segregation". The fact that they are nice to him and buy him gifts is already making an effort.

ImustLearn2Cook · 19/07/2022 11:28

@aSofaNearYouOf course I am being subjective, I can only go by what the Op has written. None of us are there to make an objective observation. I can also offer an opinion based on the limited information posted by the Op along with my own perspectives, life experiences and values.

And yes, I have given my personal opinion. The Op can take it or leave it based on her own assessment, perspective, experience and values.

aSofaNearYou · 19/07/2022 11:10

@ImustLearn2Cook All that is very subjective, though. For all you know they are already making an effort more than they are actually bothered to do. Just because he doesn't think it's enough doesn't mean they aren't already doing it.

ImustLearn2Cook · 19/07/2022 10:53

@Tetetete While I agree that expecting DSS being invited to stay on holiday with your family considering that they don’t know him very well to be inappropriate, I do think that this part of your OP is a bit sad and I get why it bothers your husband after all these years:

I met DSC when they were 5 and they are now 11. Our DC is a toddler.

Basically my family has never hugely been involved with DSC. They are nice when they see them but they don't go out of their way to see / talk about them etc...

It comes across as a form of segregation and a mere tolerance. A bit like he is viewed as an inconsequential add on to your life with your husband.

So what if he’s not a blood relation. Do they not have people they get to know well who are also not related? Do they show an interest in these non related people?

He’s a person too. Why can’t they make an effort to get to know him? It’s not about gifts or token gifts or holidays. Just show an interest and get to know him because he is part of your family. It’s about being inclusive.

billy1966 · 19/07/2022 09:11

Tetetete · 19/07/2022 06:21

And really how hard would it be to say to your husband that you understand his feelings and you’ll talk to your family about being more involved but you can’t promise anything.

Because I don't wish to bring this up with my family at all. I don't want to make them feel guilty which bringing it up would do, for something I don't believe they are doing wrong.

Agree.

I think your family sound both welcoming and kind.

Your husband sounds like one of those presumptuous men that thinks childcare is so easy for women🙄.

Taking another child on holiday is work.
It certainly is not something done lightly.
Why should your sister be imposed upon by your husband for his child, while she is on holiday?

Has he ever offered to take HER children out anywhere or done anything kind for her?

Or is it just that she is a woman and of course taking his child on holiday should just happen because it suits him?

OP, I hope this episode has been and eye opener for.

If you do a lot of the parenting you might want to pull back a bit.

I think if he doesn't make the time with HIS son special doing one on one stuff......you'll have your answer......he's a lazy arse avoidant parent wanting a break provided by your sister.

You should definitely use this time as free time for you to catch up with friends and leave him to it.

lickenchugget · 19/07/2022 06:44

Tetetete · 19/07/2022 06:21

And really how hard would it be to say to your husband that you understand his feelings and you’ll talk to your family about being more involved but you can’t promise anything.

Because I don't wish to bring this up with my family at all. I don't want to make them feel guilty which bringing it up would do, for something I don't believe they are doing wrong.

Quite right.

Tetetete · 19/07/2022 06:21

And really how hard would it be to say to your husband that you understand his feelings and you’ll talk to your family about being more involved but you can’t promise anything.

Because I don't wish to bring this up with my family at all. I don't want to make them feel guilty which bringing it up would do, for something I don't believe they are doing wrong.

OP posts:
ImustLearn2Cook · 19/07/2022 02:27

@Tetetete Is your husband (as suggested by pp) trying to blackmail or coerce you and your family into being more involved in his son’s life?

Because that is not what comes across in your Op. He’s your husband, you know him better then anyone here.

Maybe you should be having this conversation with your husband where you both actually listen to one another.

And really how hard would it be to say to your husband that you understand his feelings and you’ll talk to your family about being more involved but you can’t promise anything.

Why does it have to become some stupid debate on Mumsnet about the status of step children.

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2022 09:57

ImustLearn2Cook · 18/07/2022 08:45

@whumpthereitis The proposed compromise is only reasonable if OP‘s family are willing to provide that type of relationship, which they may not want to do.

Ok, well this is obviously fair enough. You can’t dictate relationships. I’m not trying to. It’s just that he really is part of the family. He is the Op’s DS’s brother even if it it is only through the dad. It really does mean something. He also doesn’t stay on every other weekend. He stays/lives with the Op and her husband for 50% of the time that he lives with his Mum. That means something too.

I just think that out of consideration for her husband and her DSS it would not be too much to advocate for DSS to be acknowledged as a significant and important member of her immediate family by her parents and siblings.

If friends (who are no relation) can be close and loved then I can’t see why a step child can’t be also.

Sure it means ‘something’, but said ‘something’ it vaguely defined, and invariably has different meanings dependent on who is interpreting it. The ‘something’ that he means to them is kindness when they see him, and it doesn’t need to be any more than that.

I doubt said ‘advocating’ would have the desired impact you’re imagining. If my brother started telling me I had to consider his stepson my nephew and act accordingly I’d be quick to disabuse him of the notion. Again, the husband’s feelings are his to deal with, he can’t expect to be accommodated on this. His son is not their daughter’s child, he is not their grandchild.

If people love their stepchildren/ their child’s/sibling’s stepchild? Fine. If they don’t but are kind when their paths cross? Also fine. Friends are freely chosen and relationships willingly pursued, which is quite different to being emotionally blackmailed or coerced into having a close relationship with someone because someone else thinks you should.

Newestname002 · 18/07/2022 09:33

@Tetetete

So what's the situation now with your husband? Has he seen your viewpoint, or is he still angry? 🌹

Tetetete · 18/07/2022 08:59

And he can be an important member of my immediate family without being their grandchild/nephew.

OP posts:
Tetetete · 18/07/2022 08:58

The point is if it's all to do with 'siblings can't possibly be treated differently how unfair' as some PPs have suggested then how does that work with DSCs mother's side?

The fact is half siblings will often be treated differently in some circumstances because they have different parents, in this case different mothers. I don't disagree that it's not entirely comparable because DSCs mother doesn't live with DC which is why it's reasonable that my family treat DSC with kindness when they see him, get him gifts for Christmas ect... Whereas DSCs mother's family obviously don't do any of that for our DC.

However, DSC will also be treated to different things than my DC by virtue of the fact he has a different mother, he will also go on holidays my child doesn't, he will also receive different gifts, different experiences, it's not possible for half siblings to receive the exact same things all of the time (certain circumstances aside) because they have different family and relationships. I don't think that aspect of it is so hugely different as to not at all be comparable. If it really is about the fact that siblings shouldn't possibly receive different things to each other then why is it only unfair one way but not in reverse? My child is still DSS's sibling even when he's at his mum's so how does this siblings shouldn't get anything the other doesn't work? If my step son would be oh so terribly scarred that my sister who he barely knows is taking DC on holiday, why would my child not also be upset that DSS is going on holiday with his mum's family for example?

OP posts:
ImustLearn2Cook · 18/07/2022 08:45

@whumpthereitis The proposed compromise is only reasonable if OP‘s family are willing to provide that type of relationship, which they may not want to do.

Ok, well this is obviously fair enough. You can’t dictate relationships. I’m not trying to. It’s just that he really is part of the family. He is the Op’s DS’s brother even if it it is only through the dad. It really does mean something. He also doesn’t stay on every other weekend. He stays/lives with the Op and her husband for 50% of the time that he lives with his Mum. That means something too.

I just think that out of consideration for her husband and her DSS it would not be too much to advocate for DSS to be acknowledged as a significant and important member of her immediate family by her parents and siblings.

If friends (who are no relation) can be close and loved then I can’t see why a step child can’t be also.

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2022 03:48

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/07/2022 23:27

@Tetetete If DSC got to go on holiday with his maternal family and my child didn't that would be fine because siblings being treated the same only goes one way. Only ever when it's in favour of DSC on here in seems.

Does your DS live at DSS’s maternal family 50% of the time? No! Then it isn’t comparable at all.

Sure, your DSS doesn’t know your family very well (his brother’s maternal family). After 6 years that is a bit weird. Your husband is equally a resident parent as his ex. Your DSS is part of your family.

While at this stage going away on holiday with your family might not be a great idea as he doesn’t know them very well; a compromise where your DSS gets to know his brother’s maternal extended family would be good.

I don’t think it unreasonable to take your husband’s feelings into consideration and included his son more. It doesn’t require you or your family to have the same feelings towards him as you have for your son. It just requires viewing him a member of your family because he is.

it’s not particularly weird at all. I’ve seen my brother’s stepchild a couple of times in a few years, and my parents about the same 🤷🏻‍♀️ Well, maybe it’s weird for you, but it’s perfectly normal for a lot of other people.

The proposed compromise is only reasonable if OP‘s family are willing to provide that type of relationship, which they may not want to do. He’s the child of their daughter’s husband, that’s it. He’s got his own grandparents and maternal family. Beyond being kind to him when they see him (which they are!) they have no need to do anything else, and the husband is being unreasonable to expect them to. His annoyance is something he has to deal with, no one else is obliged to accommodate him.

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/07/2022 23:27

@Tetetete If DSC got to go on holiday with his maternal family and my child didn't that would be fine because siblings being treated the same only goes one way. Only ever when it's in favour of DSC on here in seems.

Does your DS live at DSS’s maternal family 50% of the time? No! Then it isn’t comparable at all.

Sure, your DSS doesn’t know your family very well (his brother’s maternal family). After 6 years that is a bit weird. Your husband is equally a resident parent as his ex. Your DSS is part of your family.

While at this stage going away on holiday with your family might not be a great idea as he doesn’t know them very well; a compromise where your DSS gets to know his brother’s maternal extended family would be good.

I don’t think it unreasonable to take your husband’s feelings into consideration and included his son more. It doesn’t require you or your family to have the same feelings towards him as you have for your son. It just requires viewing him a member of your family because he is.

Goldencarp · 17/07/2022 20:16

Does your step child live with you?

Darbs76 · 17/07/2022 20:10

I don’t think he’s being ridiculous. It can hurt a lot when you think one child is being treated better than others. My ex’s family made a good effort with my eldest son, not the kind of relationship where any of them slept the night etc but they always asked after him, made effort to chat to him when visited and gave him gifts or money same as their biological grandchildren.

I don’t think it’s reasonable to take the oldest son away too given the big age gap. You could mention it to your family, say your DH is feeling a bit upset about it, see what they say. They could make more effort by the sounds of it

mummydoingamasters · 17/07/2022 20:01

My SS doesn't even see my family and it's 95% his choice. If my mum comes over, he stays upstairs and won't even say hello or goodbye to her even though she is polite if she does ever see him. His mum has a bigger issue about it than he does though.

My mum would never offer to take my SS on holiday, or even have him for the day, because she's seen first hand how hard it is to manage his behaviour and it's not fair to put that on her. I wouldn't expect her to even if they did speak and get along. She wouldn't feel comfortable telling him off like she does with my two and he would rather wet himself than ask her where the toilet is.

Treating all kids the same is lovely in theory, but it doesn't work for every child or family and that's just fine but it's not a popular opinion.

Stepfamilies are always a testy subject and incite a lot of debate!

GoldenSpiral · 17/07/2022 18:12

The issue is that if DSS is treated like family by OP's parents then the child has three sets of grandparents compared to her own DC having just two (assuming that all GPs are alive and well). How is that fair?

DSS might get to go on holidays with his own family as well as OP's relatives. Is there an expectation that OP's child go on holiday with DSS's aunts? No.

It sounds like your family have been warm to your stepchildren and included them to a reasonable degree. I don't believe that they need to do anything more.

I also find it confusing when stepchildren inherit from their step family as they then inherit from three 'parents' instead of two. It isn't OP's fault that her DSS's parents split up and she shouldn't have to skew everything to benefit DSS to make up for it at her DC's expense.