Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if the red weather warning will now make you take climate change seriously?

280 replies

YetiTeri · 16/07/2022 14:34

Now you know what impact this heat will have (schools closing, travel chaos, threat to life) will it make you take climate change more seriously?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
alphapie · 16/07/2022 16:29

@YetiTeri yep, but even those businesses listed don't contribute as much as they'd need to, to climate change to make a meaningful impact if anything were to be 'done' to them.

China, and predominantly one state owned fuel company, contributes 28% of all C02 emissions for example.

YetiTeri · 16/07/2022 16:27

DoubleShotEspresso · 16/07/2022 16:13

@YetiTeri

  • Vote for politicians that have climate change at the core of their policies.

Buy seasonal and local.

Use trains rather than plane/cars

Stop buying disposable fashion (Shein...)

Switch to a plant based diet even in part.

Don't post vacuous posts saying it was hot when you were young when the point is these days are no longer anomalies.

That stuff. But mostly the first.*

Whilst we might well be facing emergency stages with the environment as a whole , I really think the issue here is that voting on a single issue is not a sensible option given the range of challenges we currently face.
Policies from the Green Party etc don't sufficiently extend to these challenges any way enough to win enough voting power.
Whilst many of your points might be great I think they overlook what many here are most concerned about regarding our potential costs of living and just general inability to "afford life" right now.
People relying on food banks won't be adopting vegan diets (I don't really agree with you on this one but that's another thread). And some folks are just eat meat out of preference/need, neither are "wrong".
Train journeys versus planes are not feasible for many who are time poor and not blessed with affordable/reliable options.
Buying "seasonal and local" may feel virtuous but in real terms in no way guarantees better impacts upon the environment... it's also ridiculously often more expensive, especially for food.
"Disposable fashion"/(SHEIN is really no better or worse than many UK retailers when you research their ethics. ) None of these are especially palatable but again sustainable fashion comes at a huge cost.
We need to find and develop ways of making our daily living, consumables and habits far more considered of course. The fact is these retailers exist because they meet a growing demand-until affordable alternatives exist it's a tall order for the majority to make ethical choices.
Dictating to people on threads like this and ridiculing the comments others have taken the time to post is, if you don't mind me saying unhelpful to your cause. It's this type of tone which puts people ill at ease with the very point you're trying to get them on board with. If somebody here remembers living through hot summers why on earth is it vacuous to say so? Any positive discussion and change ones from drawing comparisons, identifying what shared factors exist and looking at different impacts. The important thing is that somebody is prepared to gauge in thought here, belittling them is rude and unhelpful. Sadly this is the case on so many forums where some clearly show such blinkered and closed thinking.

I'm not dictating to anyone and it's not 'my' cause. I actually didn't say vegan, but meat is expensive so if it's about affordability then cutting down on meat is win/win. Tbf I should have just stuck at the first point though.

And I'm sorry it really really is vacuous to question the science because you remember warm summers as a kid. It's fake news / Trumpism. Record temperatures means we have not had this temperature before, and then it gets broken again really soon (the last record was 2019).

Someone up thread questioned 'global warming' because there are extreme cold seasons. It's been climate change not global warming for 20 odd years as the science shows extreme weather becoming more common due to the overall increase in temperature.

OP posts:
Liebig · 16/07/2022 16:25

ITT, people not understanding climate science and statistics.

Don’t worry, guys. Winter still existing means climate change is a hoax perpetuated by the Chinese to deny you your three gov’t mandated holidays abroad each year, and the biggest house and car your tapped out credit lines can afford.

To ask if the red weather warning will now make you take climate change seriously?
Daftasabroom · 16/07/2022 16:23

@Sugerfree the media are really bad at explaining global warming and very few journalists have any STEM background.

The physics behind the green house effect and global warming is pretty simple. Light from the sun reaches earth mostly in the visible spectrum, light we can see. Most of that light passes through the atmosphere.

Light has energy, when that light hits something, either a solid, a liquid or a gas, some of that energy is absorbed. As that energy is absorbed the temperature of whatever it is increases. As the temperature increases whatever ii is will emit energy, often in the form of infra red light, which we can't see.

Green house gases tend to allow visible light through but reflect infra red back to earth, hence global warming.

My apologies if I haven't explained that very well, or if you are already up to speed on it.

Badqueeen · 16/07/2022 16:16

Chailatteplease · 16/07/2022 15:58

Tell me you’re privileged, without telling me.

In case you haven’t noticed, we’re in a cost of living crisis. Some of us can only afford ‘cheap/fast fashion’. Sometimes, individuals have to prioritise the ‘here and now’ over the bigger picture.

Someone asked why shein is bad for the environment. Answering that question isn't passing judgment on the people who need cheap clothing. I need cheap clothing. I choose to buy mine from vinted or charity shops and only when i need them, in order to not create more demand for new clothes to be created. There are more choices available than just choosing incredibly cheap clothes made by exploited people and shipped around the world.

I would hazard a guess that a lot of the people buying from shein are buying from there because its so cheap, if they don't like it, they can just throw it away and buy something else. Look at "haul" videos on social media. It's absolutely normalised buying a ton of stuff, trying it on and returning (or just throwing away) whatever you don't like. You can't pretend that's not problematic.

A generation or two ago, clothes would be worn to the end of their life, handed down and passed around then repurposed, and at the very end of their life, in my grandmother's case, turned into rags for cleaning. You suggest even repairing clothes, sewing on a button for eg and most under 25s would just look at you in confusion.

Here's an interesting article with some numbers.

uk.fashionnetwork.com/news/Throwaway-culture-60-of-shoppers-have-no-interest-in-long-lasting-clothing,1042181.html

MarshaMelrose · 16/07/2022 16:13

I live in the North West of England. I very rarely experience heat. But I can read and watch the news and what happening in the world. I don't need to have my finger chopped off to know it would hurt.

I do the best I can and whatever I can. I follow as much of the advice as practicable. But I fear it's a losing battle. In the west we've had years of being profligate over heating, and travelling, and using energy and polluting how we liked. We now recognise that was a mistake. But developing countries are now wanting to have the same opportunities. Its seems totally unfair and hypocritical to deny them the way of life that we've been having for years. And they're not going to listen anyway. So really, I'm happy to do all I can but I doubt the small efforts we make will counteract what's happening in the rest of the world.

DoubleShotEspresso · 16/07/2022 16:13

@YetiTeri

  • Vote for politicians that have climate change at the core of their policies.

Buy seasonal and local.

Use trains rather than plane/cars

Stop buying disposable fashion (Shein...)

Switch to a plant based diet even in part.

Don't post vacuous posts saying it was hot when you were young when the point is these days are no longer anomalies.

That stuff. But mostly the first.*

Whilst we might well be facing emergency stages with the environment as a whole , I really think the issue here is that voting on a single issue is not a sensible option given the range of challenges we currently face.
Policies from the Green Party etc don't sufficiently extend to these challenges any way enough to win enough voting power.
Whilst many of your points might be great I think they overlook what many here are most concerned about regarding our potential costs of living and just general inability to "afford life" right now.
People relying on food banks won't be adopting vegan diets (I don't really agree with you on this one but that's another thread). And some folks are just eat meat out of preference/need, neither are "wrong".
Train journeys versus planes are not feasible for many who are time poor and not blessed with affordable/reliable options.
Buying "seasonal and local" may feel virtuous but in real terms in no way guarantees better impacts upon the environment... it's also ridiculously often more expensive, especially for food.
"Disposable fashion"/(SHEIN is really no better or worse than many UK retailers when you research their ethics. ) None of these are especially palatable but again sustainable fashion comes at a huge cost.
We need to find and develop ways of making our daily living, consumables and habits far more considered of course. The fact is these retailers exist because they meet a growing demand-until affordable alternatives exist it's a tall order for the majority to make ethical choices.
Dictating to people on threads like this and ridiculing the comments others have taken the time to post is, if you don't mind me saying unhelpful to your cause. It's this type of tone which puts people ill at ease with the very point you're trying to get them on board with. If somebody here remembers living through hot summers why on earth is it vacuous to say so? Any positive discussion and change ones from drawing comparisons, identifying what shared factors exist and looking at different impacts. The important thing is that somebody is prepared to gauge in thought here, belittling them is rude and unhelpful. Sadly this is the case on so many forums where some clearly show such blinkered and closed thinking.

YetiTeri · 16/07/2022 16:12

Chailatteplease · 16/07/2022 15:58

Tell me you’re privileged, without telling me.

In case you haven’t noticed, we’re in a cost of living crisis. Some of us can only afford ‘cheap/fast fashion’. Sometimes, individuals have to prioritise the ‘here and now’ over the bigger picture.

Utter bullshit. You can get cheap better quality clothes in charity shops.

OP posts:
RudsyFarmer · 16/07/2022 16:11

By seriously what do you mean? Will it make me do anything differently? I don’t think my carbon footprint is particularly big to start with. Will it keep me up at night worrying? No. I’ve accepted we’re fucked. If a virus doesn’t get us first.

HauntingScream · 16/07/2022 16:10

What all countries need to do is support more local food production, more focus on real food rather than factory processed nonsense.
How many polluting and carbon producing factories do we have creating crap food including all the ultra processed plant based 'meat'?
Develop greener energy.
Use cars and planes less (and that includes all the rich people travelling everywhere in their private jets and big cars)
Produce more environmentally friendly products including clothes.
Plant more trees and plants.

Discovereads · 16/07/2022 16:09

Thatswhyimacat · 16/07/2022 15:14

Oh goody, all the 'I remember hot summers before' or 'the Thames used to freeze' people are out. I'm a former climate scientist and I'm slapping my head right now, I forgot to take that into account!

The average temperature in the United Kingdom has increased by roughly 1 degree in the last 50 years. That is a fact, what you 'remember' is an anecdote.

50yrs is not long enough to measure climate change, that’s merely recent changes in weather. Besides, it was a degree warmer in Britain than it is now 700yrs ago (medieval) and also 2,000yrs ago (Roman). So if medieval peasants and Romans could survive it, think we can safely not panic.

mydogisthebest · 16/07/2022 16:08

I have taken it seriously for years along with over population. Me and DH chose not to have children for those reasons and we are both so glad we made that decision.

I could not live with the worry or guilt if I had brought yet more humans into the world. I dread to think about the future for them and, selfishly, am glad I will almost certainly be dead before things get much worse

MsTSwift · 16/07/2022 16:08

You blame “the corporations” they don’t exist in a vacuum - who do you think their customers are?!

JudgeJ · 16/07/2022 16:07

Likeli · 16/07/2022 14:37

I already did. It’s the government and corporations who do not give enough fucks to change things.

The UK government seems far more aware than many other countries which are the major contributirs to global warning. Unless all countries make an equal effort, worldwide, it really is pointless trying to control pur relatively small contribution.

QuestionableMouse · 16/07/2022 16:05

Likeli · 16/07/2022 14:37

I already did. It’s the government and corporations who do not give enough fucks to change things.

This in spades.

My impact on the climate is very minimal - I don't fly, don't have kids, drive as little as possible, limit food waste and so on.

It's the corporations that are the problem. Individuals' impact is miniscule compared to them.

Suetwo · 16/07/2022 16:02

Yes. Unfortunately, what we do on this small island will make no difference at all. The U.K. could sink into the ocean and it would change nothing. China, India and the USA are the biggest polluters, and Africa has the highest birth rate.

VickyEadieofThigh · 16/07/2022 16:00

Likeli · 16/07/2022 14:37

I already did. It’s the government and corporations who do not give enough fucks to change things.

You beat me to it! Absolutely spot on.

We can all take it seriously (and many of us already do) but unless most governments do - and forever - we're fucked.

Norgie · 16/07/2022 15:59

No.

Chailatteplease · 16/07/2022 15:58

YetiTeri · 16/07/2022 15:22

Their whole business model is problematic. They sell poor quality clothes very cheaply then they fly them over to be worn just a few times before the consumer repeats the cycle. Every stage of their supply chain is considerably adding to environmental damage. So are others obviously, but it's the scale of Shein's expansion which is the problem.

Tell me you’re privileged, without telling me.

In case you haven’t noticed, we’re in a cost of living crisis. Some of us can only afford ‘cheap/fast fashion’. Sometimes, individuals have to prioritise the ‘here and now’ over the bigger picture.

Genevieva · 16/07/2022 15:56

You suggest you are addressing people who don't take it seriously. I think a lot of people do these days. However, I also remember heat waves live this in the 80s. We have to keep things in perspective. Clearly burning non-renewable resources is a bad idea. The work being done to change that has brought about some phenomenal innovations in recent years and a non-fossil fuel future is beginning to feel possible. Equally, the Green Levy is not a good example of a policy to tackle climate change. It is just another tax at a time when people are struggling to pay bills.

Zoeslatesttrope · 16/07/2022 15:56

I took it seriously before. But it's made me far more aware of the potential impact of higher temperatures

Daftasabroom · 16/07/2022 15:52

@Sugerfree China and India are not going to exponentially increase their use of fossil fuels, what on earth led you to believe that? Also the Indian pc CO2e is than the UK..

Louise0701 · 16/07/2022 15:49

@Bubblebubblebah We can’t eat them; Op wants us all to go plant based.

To answer the OPs question; no.

AtwilightRebellion · 16/07/2022 15:49

I have taken it seriously for years. But I won't change any of my habits going forward.

Until governments, industry, and the fawning over celebs who fly in private jets, summer on yachts etc stop what they are doing, it is pointless.

I have reached the pathetic point of resenting paper straw enforcement.

I don't fucking care anymore and won't be preached to either.

Velvettia · 16/07/2022 15:47

MorrisZapp · 16/07/2022 15:23

The Green Party here in Scotland purge members who think women don't have knobs, so I will never vote for them.

Until insane 'progressive' agendas are divorced from the climate change agenda nobody can take eco politics seriously.

Spot on!

Cynically though I feel that there’s more than a little connection between various big players within the “green” agenda and the “transgender “ movement. Lots of people making money from both.

no media scaremongering is not going to make me think any differently OP but you do you!