Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want an independent relationship with partner's sister

106 replies

roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 12:42

There's a backstory. It's long. Main points: P's sister has been unreliable and hard work since P and I first met, including cancelling on us last minute for Christmas because she had a better offer. She gave us zero support when we had a baby despite so much talk and writing said baby letters about how close an aunt she would be(!!!). The biggest issue is that I I feel like she facilitated P in leaving us (he's back now - he had a breakdown) when baby was 8 months old (by giving him someone to stay) and not asking once if I was ok... but overall we are very different people. I find her very intense, needlessly emotional, and our politics are very different, but she's not a bad person.

For balance, I haven't been an angel. I called her some choice terms once (to her face) after P left. I was drunk (not something I make a habit of, I don't drink on the whole), she was there, I was full of hormones and grief after he left as baby was still small, and I said things I shouldn't have. I own that, it was bad behaviour, but I'm not actually sorry because it was a long time ago and for points mentioned above. I also tend to forgive and forget easily with everyone else in my life, so P doesn't get why I can't or don't when it comes to her. I think it's because I've never actually had any benefit to her being in my life - I don't have any love or history to fall back on.

Anyway. Partner wants us to have a relationship, he wants us both to apologise and to make an effort together. He wants us to be able to have dinner with her and her partner and spend time as a group. He doesn't have much family and he moved to my city (where she is too) when we got serious, so he doesn't have many friends here and this would mean a lot to him.

I think that me being civil and facilitating our son seeing her - and of course never bad mouthing her and always being pleasant when we do see each other - is enough, because a) anything else would be fake/forced and b) I gave her a big chance early on and I think she blew it with the Christmas thing. Maybe a closer relationship will grow in time, but I'm not there yet.

Well done if you got this far. AIBU? Issues with P are whole other post,

OP posts:
CPL593H · 16/07/2022 13:34

One question is does she actually want to spend more time with you? It sounds as if you have been just as unreasonable and dramatic with her as she has with you, TBH. Anyone expecting me not to take a brother experiencing acute mental health issues in would get very short shrift.

You don't have to have an artificially close relationship and frankly, it sounds as if you would both be better off keeping your limited stores of civility for unavoidable family gatherings rather than trying to force one. You don't like each other, there is history, better keeping a distance. Your partner should accept this.

roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:34

Of the doubt. Sorry! Typing with pram,

OP posts:
roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:33

@forrestgreen that's what I've done - said I'll always turn up, be friendly, move on from past things. I'm just not able to give more yet without it being disingenuous. Currently I don't like or trust her, but I'm very willing to work on it and will give her the benefit

OP posts:
roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:31

Interim.

Since all that, I've invited her to family events that I planned (and that were in my home, before P moved back in - I own it, we're not married). I've been genuinely friendly, I just don't feel the need to sit down and have a big heart to heart and do things just the two of us.

I get on with the rest of his family well for what it's worth.. His father calls me his daughter and often tells me how lucky his son is, what a good mother I am. I also get on well with P's friends and colleagues.

OP posts:
roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:25

@spotcheck the unreliability and Christmas happened before the rest, when I was very very welcoming (hence inviting for Christmas), asked her for lunch, drinks etc. I made a massive effort. It wasn't reciprocated. Stuff happened on the intCakeEnvy

OP posts:
forrestgreen · 16/07/2022 13:25

I think I'd tell him that you'll draw a line under everything.

But he can organise anything he wants and you'll rock up and be happy. He can also buy any presents he wants etc

Basically I think you've read way too much into what's happened but you also don't have to be best buds with her anyway

spotcheck · 16/07/2022 13:23

So, your partner had a breakdown, left and went to stay at his sisters.
You got pissed and said terrible things to her, and realise you behaved badly. Why would she ‘reach out’ to you? Did you apologise?

You’ve given yourself a pass for that, but you are clearly angry with her because she ‘isn’t involved enough with her nephew’. This sounds like an excuse to hold onto a grudge

I would lay money that you are not as ‘friendly and polite’ as you think you are, and she feels unwelcome, thus cancelling Christmas and not being involved with your son.

To me it sounds like your partner abandoned you, you don’t feel you can be angry with him, so your sister in law is getting it

pumpkinpie01 · 16/07/2022 13:22

I can see why your DH wants everyone to get on and especially as his sister is the only relative he has in the town . But he sounds like he is trying to forge a relationship between you that just isn't going to happen due to the fact you are totally different people. How do you get on with her partner ? Just wondering if you could have a bbq /meal out occasionally to make your dh happy whilst making it clear he shouldn't be pushing you and her to go on girly shopping afternoons/spa days as that won't be happening.

roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:21

saraclara · 16/07/2022 13:17

Why would your sister reach out to you when her brother had left you?
When my DD split from her partner and came back to stay with me, was I supposed to check that he was okay? You were being ridiculous to expect that.

You admit that you were absolutely foul to her, and I imagine it's very hard for your partner to have you and his sister at odds. Of course he wants to be able to sit down for a meal with his family as a whole. If that's not possible at the moment, then you're clearly not being as pleasant and civil to your SIL as you claim you are.

You don't have to do anything with just her (like a girly shopping trip). But responding and apologising for past behaviour, and being pleasant enough that the four if you can sit and share a meal sounds a reasonable enough ask to me.

Why? We didn't split because I had done anything wrong. We split because of his MH (work related + his lifestyle) he took himself away leaving me and his baby son. I'm her nephew's mother and was hurting a great deal too; plus while looking after the baby. I think it would've been the decent thing to do for her to send me a text to see if I was ok.

OP posts:
saraclara · 16/07/2022 13:17

Why would your sister reach out to you when her brother had left you?
When my DD split from her partner and came back to stay with me, was I supposed to check that he was okay? You were being ridiculous to expect that.

You admit that you were absolutely foul to her, and I imagine it's very hard for your partner to have you and his sister at odds. Of course he wants to be able to sit down for a meal with his family as a whole. If that's not possible at the moment, then you're clearly not being as pleasant and civil to your SIL as you claim you are.

You don't have to do anything with just her (like a girly shopping trip). But responding and apologising for past behaviour, and being pleasant enough that the four if you can sit and share a meal sounds a reasonable enough ask to me.

Realitea · 16/07/2022 13:16

She probably felt very awkward but family come first and I would support my brother if he showed up and needed somewhere to stay. It would’ve been better if you’d had a chat with her once your dh came back. It’s not too late. Try to make an effort with her even if you are very different because his family mean a lot to him.
However, there is no rule to say you have to be best friends with her. That’s not necessary.

NuffSaidSam · 16/07/2022 13:16

roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:08

@NuffSaidSam I'll always be ok with that, but I think the truth is that without me to organise they don't do much. I do organise things with my family, who I love, so P sees the discrepancy. I'm more than happy for him to make plans with his family, it's just not my responsibility especially after the history.

I think that's absolutely reasonable, it's not your responsibility to facilitate his relationship with his sister. That's for him to do.

roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:15

@Shinyandnew1 I'm saying I'm not there yet, but in the future I may be. She's made such little effort with me and our son over the years - despite all her dramatic talk - that I don't trust her not to be flakey again. I also just don't enjoy her company because we are so different.

OP posts:
roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:12

@Wilkolampshade that made my eyes well up. Yes, thank you, it's that I just had to suck it up with my 8 month old and was expected to be ok because P wasn't ok. I feel she showed me zero care, so why would I make an effort with her now? It's not like I cheated or abused him - I was suffering because of his MH problems and she didn't care.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 16/07/2022 13:12

He wants us to be able to have dinner with her and her partner and spend time as a group.

I think that is perfectly reasonable, he’s not saying he wants you and her to go shopping together every Saturday. Are you saying you won’t do that?

roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:08

@NuffSaidSam I'll always be ok with that, but I think the truth is that without me to organise they don't do much. I do organise things with my family, who I love, so P sees the discrepancy. I'm more than happy for him to make plans with his family, it's just not my responsibility especially after the history.

OP posts:
Purplecatshopaholic · 16/07/2022 13:07

RiojaRose · 16/07/2022 13:01

I wouldn’t be keen to cultivate an independent relationship with an in-law (or the equivalent) who I felt was hard work.

The back story isn’t relevant to my views on this. I just think life is short and sometimes complicated, and I don’t see the point of spending time or energy on relationships with people I don’t particularly like.

I do think you should be willing to be polite and civil four or five times a year for things like family birthdays and Christmas etc. More than that, not really.

Agree with this. I don’t cultivate separate relationships with my partners family - if we split I won’t see them again. Be polite when you do see them, and that’s all. Just because they are your partners family doesn’t mean you have anything in common.

Wilkolampshade · 16/07/2022 13:07

You know YABU re' her having him to stay, but no, it would have been perfectly reasonable for her to call and check you were OK.
I think maybe you feel you were expected to just suck it up with his breakdown and no one is acknowledging how tough that was? I can see why that hurts. Also, it's infuriating that your DH seems to think you can just pick up where you all left off and pretend all that never happened. It must feel like he isn't listening to you.

FWIW I don't think you have to be friends with people you don't like. Warm civility is fine.

ViaBlue · 16/07/2022 13:06

You don't need to be close with her and you don't need to facilitate anything. Your partner can mantain his relationship with her without your involvement if you don't feel it.

roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:05

RiojaRose · 16/07/2022 13:01

I wouldn’t be keen to cultivate an independent relationship with an in-law (or the equivalent) who I felt was hard work.

The back story isn’t relevant to my views on this. I just think life is short and sometimes complicated, and I don’t see the point of spending time or energy on relationships with people I don’t particularly like.

I do think you should be willing to be polite and civil four or five times a year for things like family birthdays and Christmas etc. More than that, not really.

This is what I would like. Thank you for phrasing it better. The sad thing is I really wanted us to be close once but her actions since have changed that.

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 16/07/2022 13:04

What do you think would have happened to your partner having a breakdown if he didn't have somewhere safe to stay? I'd suggest it could have been a lot worse! Maybe she saved you a lot of grief and heartache long-term.

Also, not being sorry for something because it was a long time ago makes absolutely no sense whatsoever!

But, all that said I don't think you need to be best friends with her if you don't feel it. You do need to allow your partner and child to have a full and close relationship with her. If you choose to miss out on activities and stuff they're doing together that's your choice.

roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:03

My main question was - am I not doing enough by being friendly when I see her and making it clear she's welcome in our home to see her brother / nephew? Do I really have to have an independent/close friendship with someone I feel has been unreliable in the past and who I wouldn't otherwise be friends with?

The Christmas thing - she can spend it where she likes. However cancelling two days in advance with a BS excuse is a bit shit.

OP posts:
RiojaRose · 16/07/2022 13:01

I wouldn’t be keen to cultivate an independent relationship with an in-law (or the equivalent) who I felt was hard work.

The back story isn’t relevant to my views on this. I just think life is short and sometimes complicated, and I don’t see the point of spending time or energy on relationships with people I don’t particularly like.

I do think you should be willing to be polite and civil four or five times a year for things like family birthdays and Christmas etc. More than that, not really.

PollyPingit · 16/07/2022 13:01

I have a brother who had a string of relationships before he settled down for good. Some of his gf’s I liked others not so much but whatever I felt about them my loyalty always stayed with him. So I don’t think she’s wrong in that respect. If it means a lot to him and he moved away from old friends to be with you I think you owe it to him to try. Have a couples relationship you don’t ever need to see her on a 1:1……

roarfeckingroarr · 16/07/2022 13:01

Maybe I phrased it badly.

I am very aware it's not her job to look after my child. What I don't like is her saying she wants to all the time then not doing so.

She doesn't need to make arrangements with me - she can do so with her brother, his father. Im always accommodating and polite,

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread