Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

time for England to re-jig their school year?

144 replies

KnittingNeedles · 16/07/2022 08:48

As someone who grew up in Scotland and who has kids at school in Scotland, July is holiday month and always has been. Kids at school until around 20th July always seems insanely late to me.

Statistically, July is the hottest month in the UK and with climate change upon us, temperatures are going to get more extreme. Most Scottish schools finish the last week in June, returning around 15th August. England/Wales keeps their kids in school 3-4 weeks later and then they stay off into September.

Time for a total shake-up of the school year to account for climate change? The school year was originally based around the farming year as far as I know, and as that's not really an issue any more, should they be adopting a more Scottish/N Irish approach to shifting the holidays?

(Actually, I hope they don't because we take advantage of that beginning of July period to travel to England and enjoy the weather/visitor attractions when the kids are all still in school, and enjoy the cheaper prices too).

OP posts:
1AngelicFruitCake · 16/07/2022 11:11

bendmeoverbackwards · 16/07/2022 09:29

@howshouldibehave it would definitely be logistically difficult but not impossible. It would greatly benefit children from disadvantaged homes and also reduce the huge price difference between term time and school holidays when it comes to holidays.

I don’t see why it would. Parents who care, maybe but the planning to apply for time off in a specific time just wouldn’t happen by some people. Council run activities and fairs that some of these children may get the benefit of, they wouldn’t be on if everyone was different.
End of term treats that these children enjoy wouldn’t happen.

Could make planning to meet up with friends really hard!

That’s before you consider what a nightmare it would be! Teach fractions on week 3 and someone misses it - how would you keep on top of that?! You can’t keep recapping, there’s no replacement for teaching it fully and practising the new learning as a class with the teacher.

AntlerRose · 16/07/2022 11:09

So you have a class of 30 and a teacher. Each person is allowed statutory annual leave I presume - so 5.6 weeks each?

And this is basically the same as the odd child having a day off for a cold, in terms of continuity for lessons.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 16/07/2022 11:08

bendmeoverbackwards · 16/07/2022 10:58

@LouisRenault The number of children off at any one time might not be more than the number who would be off sick or off for other reasons. The point being, there will always be absences and whilst it can be a pain for sports, music etc it’s not impossible. It’s all about planning, music and sports fixtures can be set well in advance and children and teachers have to book their holidays in advance making sure not too many people are off at once.

Usually when children are off sick it is only for a few days at a time and most kids are only off once or twice over the year. With everyone choosing their own holidays you would regularly have kids off for 2+ weeks at a time, how would their teacher possibly help those children to catch up on the missed learning when there would probably be children going off and returning every day?

Plus who teaches the children in class whilst their teacher is off on a month long holiday?

DownNative · 16/07/2022 11:07

howshouldibehave · 16/07/2022 11:03

England could have July as school holidays like Scotland and Northern Ireland, but go back in the first week of September like in Northern Ireland.

So they would have all of July and all of August off?

Yes, see the dates I've posted for Northern Ireland above.

DownNative · 16/07/2022 11:06

KnittingNeedles · 16/07/2022 09:31

So in my part of Scotland we have:

a long weekend (Friday/Monday) in September
a week in October - but earlier than in England
2 weeks at Christmas
2 or 3 days in February
2 weeks at Easter - first two weeks in April whenever Easter is
couple of long weekends in May.
finish end June.

Other areas don't have the long weekend in September, go back a few days earlier in August and have 2 weeks off in October - not a fan of this to be honest. I also wouldn't want any more than 2 or 3 days in February when the weather is usually at its worst.

I also agree that you won't ever find a model which keeps everyone absolutely happy but it does seem that the current English/Welsh model isn't working for many.

Northern Ireland school holidays for 2022/23:

Schools resume after summer holiday - 1 September 2022

Halloween - 31 October & 1 November 2022

Christmas and New Year - 22 December 2022 to 3 January 2023

Mid-term - 16 & 17 February 2023

St Patrick's Day - 17 March 2023

Easter - 6 to 14 April 2023

May Day - 1 May 2023

Spring Bank Holiday - 29 May 2023

Summer holiday begins - 1 July 2023

School holidays in summer is about two weeks shorter, I think, than when I was in school there in the 1980s and 1990s.

howshouldibehave · 16/07/2022 11:03

England could have July as school holidays like Scotland and Northern Ireland, but go back in the first week of September like in Northern Ireland.

So they would have all of July and all of August off?

howshouldibehave · 16/07/2022 11:02

bendmeoverbackwards · 16/07/2022 10:58

@LouisRenault The number of children off at any one time might not be more than the number who would be off sick or off for other reasons. The point being, there will always be absences and whilst it can be a pain for sports, music etc it’s not impossible. It’s all about planning, music and sports fixtures can be set well in advance and children and teachers have to book their holidays in advance making sure not too many people are off at once.

Indulging your Fantasy School League for a moment, how many weeks each year would you grant pupils and staff off?

What if you’d got to the end of the year and some children hadn’t taken enough holiday?

DownNative · 16/07/2022 10:59

Aslii · 16/07/2022 08:57

Sorry posted too soon. You couldn't have kids in SE England returning to school in mid-August OP (like they do in Scotland). When it's 30 in London it's quite oppressive. Even September can be hot.

They don't have to go back around the same time as Scotland.

England could have July as school holidays like Scotland and Northern Ireland, but go back in the first week of September like in Northern Ireland.

bendmeoverbackwards · 16/07/2022 10:58

@LouisRenault The number of children off at any one time might not be more than the number who would be off sick or off for other reasons. The point being, there will always be absences and whilst it can be a pain for sports, music etc it’s not impossible. It’s all about planning, music and sports fixtures can be set well in advance and children and teachers have to book their holidays in advance making sure not too many people are off at once.

AntlerRose · 16/07/2022 10:56

The country now needs a national childcare service and an education system that work together well at primary level. I understand education is used as childcare but we need a system that recognises what is best educationally and what is needed childcare wise. I am genuinley suspicious. It would be so expensive compared to what we have now though.

Bigmouthshouthotair · 16/07/2022 10:54

KnittingNeedles · 16/07/2022 08:48

As someone who grew up in Scotland and who has kids at school in Scotland, July is holiday month and always has been. Kids at school until around 20th July always seems insanely late to me.

Statistically, July is the hottest month in the UK and with climate change upon us, temperatures are going to get more extreme. Most Scottish schools finish the last week in June, returning around 15th August. England/Wales keeps their kids in school 3-4 weeks later and then they stay off into September.

Time for a total shake-up of the school year to account for climate change? The school year was originally based around the farming year as far as I know, and as that's not really an issue any more, should they be adopting a more Scottish/N Irish approach to shifting the holidays?

(Actually, I hope they don't because we take advantage of that beginning of July period to travel to England and enjoy the weather/visitor attractions when the kids are all still in school, and enjoy the cheaper prices too).

Well that's ok until the last weeks of August are very hot (which they often are)

bluekostree · 16/07/2022 10:54

Selfishly I like to take advantage of cheaper holidays the first 3 weeks of July (NI based), but I agree in principle.

MrsRhodes · 16/07/2022 10:53

taybert · 16/07/2022 08:56

When I was at school (NW England) our school holidays did start in early July in line with historical local mill and factory holidays, we were back at school mid august then had a week off in September. It was all changed maybe 15 years ago so that schools all broadly had the same holidays. I’m sure other places must’ve had similar.

I'm in NW and never known that (I left school over 20 years ago). School holidays have always been like they are now in my experience.

I used to (pre covid) think the 6 weeks felt ridiculously long - but wouldn't like to lose any now for a longer midterm holiday.

What I would like is an extra week on the Xmas hols - 3 instead of two. Not sure where they could take it from 🤷🏼‍♀️

howshouldibehave · 16/07/2022 10:53

dameofdilemma · 16/07/2022 10:41

I agree the whole system needs a rethink. It's based on the needs of the population when most were agricultural workers and many children didn't go to school.

The needs of the population have vastly changed and (in the same way every other public service has moved with the times) schooling needs to also progress.

Blah blah school isn't childcare etc but there is no rational reason for schooling to remain in the Victorian era. Otherwise you might as well children can work from age 9 and women can't own property.

That’s a common misconception.

www.oxford-royale.com/articles/a-brief-history-summer-holiday/

taybert · 16/07/2022 10:52

@Georgeskitchen Cebter Parcs in that September week was full of people wearing football shirts from my home town 😂

LouisRenault · 16/07/2022 10:48

Schools open all year round. Each child gets a holiday allowance to be taken when they choose (within reason).

how do you run activities such as sports, orchestras, plays, if you never know who will be available from one week to the next? How do you practice/play a match/put on a performance?

Perhaps something like 8 weeks on, 2 weeks off throughout the year

when would schools carry out maintenance/building work that can't be fitted into two weeks?

bendmeoverbackwards · 16/07/2022 10:46

MolkosTeenageAngst · 16/07/2022 10:18

And when do teachers take their holidays?

They also get an allocation of days like in any other job. More teachers would be needed to allow for holiday cover.

bendmeoverbackwards · 16/07/2022 10:44

ChiselandBits · 16/07/2022 09:53

@bendmeoverbackwards that's crazy and couldn't possibly work. How could you cover a syllabus for all kids if they're all off at different times? Presumably teachers would have the same right to book holiday whenever so schools would have to find subject specialists to go and teach the classes. Impossible option.

I work in a private school. We have longer days, equivalent to one extra full day of teaching pw hence the longer holidays. It works well.

I’m not saying it would be easy at all and would require huge amounts of extra funding for more hours and more staff. But what I’m suggesting is a more relaxed approach to education rather than teachers and students running around frazzled trying to cram everything in in a fixed amount of time. Teachers wouldn’t necessarily ‘build on a lesson’, a completely different way of thinking and teaching would be employed. I don’t believe that if a child misses say one lesson they are doomed in that particular subject or topic. Children learn at different rates, some will understand the topic at the first go, for others it won’t sink in till much later.

dameofdilemma · 16/07/2022 10:41

I agree the whole system needs a rethink. It's based on the needs of the population when most were agricultural workers and many children didn't go to school.

The needs of the population have vastly changed and (in the same way every other public service has moved with the times) schooling needs to also progress.

Blah blah school isn't childcare etc but there is no rational reason for schooling to remain in the Victorian era. Otherwise you might as well children can work from age 9 and women can't own property.

howshouldibehave · 16/07/2022 10:37

With relaxed holiday club style childcare provision in all schools during all holidays.

This wouldn’t be possible-the schools need to do all of their maintenance work on the buildings during the holidays when there are no students there. I’m all for increasing options for childcare but that isn’t the school’s responsibility.

We could have used all the Sure Start buildings had the Conservatives not closed them all!

Schooldil3ma · 16/07/2022 10:34

@Heroicallyl0st I'm with you, I'd love a rolling 8 weeks on 2 weeks off, and it would be so much safer for children who aren't well cared for at home. Parents with social issues / poor mental health/ really limited finances / other caring responsibilities must really struggle in the 6 weeks holidays.

twinkletoesimnot · 16/07/2022 10:30

Heroicallyl0st · 16/07/2022 10:23

I think the whole system needs a revamp to cater for the fact that many parents work full time, as well as us not all being in farming anymore.

Kids end up worn out after the long autumn term and parents worn out after the far too long summer holidays. I always plan a couple of days annual leave on the first few days of school in September to recover!

Perhaps something like 8 weeks on, 2 weeks off throughout the year. That would add up to 50 weeks, so an extra week off at Christmas and in the summer. With relaxed holiday club style childcare provision in all schools during all holidays. That would be my ideal!

I'm sorry but I really don't get the parents being exhausted by their kids. Confused

As I said upthread, teachers are not paid for all of our holidays.

Where would the extra money come from?

Who would run the holiday child care?

Heroicallyl0st · 16/07/2022 10:23

I think the whole system needs a revamp to cater for the fact that many parents work full time, as well as us not all being in farming anymore.

Kids end up worn out after the long autumn term and parents worn out after the far too long summer holidays. I always plan a couple of days annual leave on the first few days of school in September to recover!

Perhaps something like 8 weeks on, 2 weeks off throughout the year. That would add up to 50 weeks, so an extra week off at Christmas and in the summer. With relaxed holiday club style childcare provision in all schools during all holidays. That would be my ideal!

49er · 16/07/2022 10:21

Is it cheaper in Scotland back end of August for holiday accommodation?

Not really @Bumtum126 as there's still loads of tourists. But cheaper overseas holidays from Scotland late august than in July

megletthesecond · 16/07/2022 10:21

I'd happily move and shorten the summer break, everything is easier to juggle in summer. I get horrific SAD and would rather have the dc's off for longer over Xmas and in February.