Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

time for England to re-jig their school year?

144 replies

KnittingNeedles · 16/07/2022 08:48

As someone who grew up in Scotland and who has kids at school in Scotland, July is holiday month and always has been. Kids at school until around 20th July always seems insanely late to me.

Statistically, July is the hottest month in the UK and with climate change upon us, temperatures are going to get more extreme. Most Scottish schools finish the last week in June, returning around 15th August. England/Wales keeps their kids in school 3-4 weeks later and then they stay off into September.

Time for a total shake-up of the school year to account for climate change? The school year was originally based around the farming year as far as I know, and as that's not really an issue any more, should they be adopting a more Scottish/N Irish approach to shifting the holidays?

(Actually, I hope they don't because we take advantage of that beginning of July period to travel to England and enjoy the weather/visitor attractions when the kids are all still in school, and enjoy the cheaper prices too).

OP posts:
howshouldibehave · 16/07/2022 12:31

Do schools in Ireland and Scotland have to do a set number of days? I think it’s 190 in England.

DownNative · 16/07/2022 12:30

bluekostree · 16/07/2022 11:28

@DownNative
Those dates aren't universal in NI. My dc gets a week off starting 31st Oct and a week off starting 13th feb. Only 2 days off end of may then finish on 29th June and back 29th august. 2 weeks at Xmas and Easter.

The dates are taken from NI Direct which is the Executive's website (for those who aren't aware).

Even so, a small difference in dates would be expected. Your child still has the same number of days off per year irrespective of start/end dates.

I always preferred our holiday dates over England's and I did go to school in England for a time as well. Most of my schooling was in Northern Ireland, obviously.

Calmdown14 · 16/07/2022 12:27

@KnittingNeedles there must be variation by region then because we don't get those.
We get the extra days in the tattie holidays in October I think tied to traditional farming patterns. And six days in February. It always feels a lot of winter holidays with two weeks in October, two at Christmas and then a strange split week and a bit in February

TenoringBehind · 16/07/2022 12:18

The main downside of the Leicestershire system is that the autumn term is very long indeed. Lots of tired and grumpy children (and teachers) by Christmas.

StEthelburgaRose · 16/07/2022 12:15

I'm guessing Leicestershire still have 13 weeks holiday? So no extra expense. Sounds good

TenoringBehind · 16/07/2022 12:10

Leicestershire have it right. Finish early July. Go back late August.

KnittingNeedles · 16/07/2022 12:06

Calmdown14 · 16/07/2022 11:48

The downside of this is that we have no Whitsun holiday.

Go from beginning of April to summer holidays. Not even an in service day. It always feels long to me and I wish we had a couple of long weekends at least in May or June

No - on a normal non-Jubilee year in Scotland there are two bank holidays in May. So we get the first MOnday in May as a day off school (for teachers too) and then at the end of May when England/Wales gets a whole week off we have usually Monday and Tuesday and then an in-service day on the Wednesday. So you don't go from mid-April to end June with no break.

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 16/07/2022 12:02

Totally agree.

I live up in Northumberland by the border and August is autumnal half the time.

ChiselandBits · 16/07/2022 11:58

@bendmeoverbackwards ok, so exactly what would your "holistic view" of education be? Do away with exams and set content? Each student to work through a 46 week scheme of work at their own pace with input from whichever teacher is in the room? That would lead to less individual attention not more. We saw during covid massive disengagement from education taught via PowerPoint and even live lessons. It's simply not comparable. What you're suggesting is literally impossible even if there were a bottomless pit of money and no teacher shortages.

StEthelburgaRose · 16/07/2022 11:51

Yanbu. I've been thinking the same for years. It starts getting Autumnal towards the end of the August holiday. July is the hottest month and can be sweltering

howshouldibehave · 16/07/2022 11:49

I think what she suggests would cost about 10 times more to deliver than our current system. The government are cutting spending not increasing it.

Exactly. The government won’t do this in a million years. With that amount of money, there are loads of better ways to spend it that would actually raise standards.

Calmdown14 · 16/07/2022 11:48

The downside of this is that we have no Whitsun holiday.

Go from beginning of April to summer holidays. Not even an in service day. It always feels long to me and I wish we had a couple of long weekends at least in May or June

AntlerRose · 16/07/2022 11:43

MolkosTeenageAngst · 16/07/2022 11:18

Most students do not miss 6 weeks of teaching time for coughs and colds, most kids only miss the odd day here and there. If all students are getting almost 6 weeks off school during teaching hours how are you going to catch them up on the work they’ve missed?

And what happens when the teachers are off? Who teaches the class for those 6 weeks?

Also students and teachers currently get 13 weeks off a year, how will we afford to increase teachers pay to make up for the extra 7 weeks a year they are expected to work, plus pay to provide cover teachers for their 6 weeks of holiday for the children who are still in school, plus pay to provide extra teachers to help students who have missed 6 weeks of teaching time (on top of the time missed for the regular coughs, cold and other illnesses) catch up with that missed learning?

I dont think my post was clear. I was asking the poster whose idea it was how it was the same thing. Not agreeing with her.

I think what she suggests would cost about 10 times more to deliver than our current system. The government are cutting spending not increasing it.

girlmom21 · 16/07/2022 11:38

Yes please because then I don't need to worry about my 31st august baby being the youngest - she could be one of the oldest 😭

MolkosTeenageAngst · 16/07/2022 11:37

bendmeoverbackwards · 16/07/2022 11:26

With more teaching time in the year, there wouldn’t be pressure to teach a certain topic in a particular week and if you miss it you’re stuffed. I am suggesting a more holistic approach to education.

But how would that actually work in the classroom? I’m an SEN teacher and all students have personalised individual curriculums. It works well but class sizes are very small (3-6 students) to account for the fact there is a huge amount of planning and preparation into teaching in that way. You can’t possibly teach individual curriculums to a class of 30, one teacher can only deliver one lesson at a time and whilst you can differentiate within that, especially with good TA support, it’s not realistic to be teaching some kids fractions, some multiplication, some algebra and some division all at the same time depending on what they’ve missed out on across the year.

I guess with much, much smaller class sizes that might be possible, but realistically if you are already having to increase the pay of all school staff (teachers, TAs, cleaners, kitchen staff etc) and have an increase in energy bills to account for the extra 7 weeks of teaching time the likelihood of being able to stretch the budget to double or triple the teacher workforce, plus provide extra classrooms for them to teach in, doesn’t seem very realistic.

Bluepiano · 16/07/2022 11:32

Bluepiano · 16/07/2022 11:31

This would be a nightmare. How would teachers ensure all children have covered the curriculum when they’re all missing different parts of the year? It’s hard enough (although obviously no one’s fault) when children are ill or taken out on holiday. When would school staff have their holidays? How would this impact a school’s running costs?

Sorry this was I. Reply to children all having different holidays and schools being open all year.

FredGarland · 16/07/2022 11:32

MolkosTeenageAngst · 16/07/2022 11:18

Most students do not miss 6 weeks of teaching time for coughs and colds, most kids only miss the odd day here and there. If all students are getting almost 6 weeks off school during teaching hours how are you going to catch them up on the work they’ve missed?

And what happens when the teachers are off? Who teaches the class for those 6 weeks?

Also students and teachers currently get 13 weeks off a year, how will we afford to increase teachers pay to make up for the extra 7 weeks a year they are expected to work, plus pay to provide cover teachers for their 6 weeks of holiday for the children who are still in school, plus pay to provide extra teachers to help students who have missed 6 weeks of teaching time (on top of the time missed for the regular coughs, cold and other illnesses) catch up with that missed learning?

Absolutely this.
Combined with the current shortage of teachers, it's a recipe for disaster.
It's fascinating to see how deep people's lack of understanding of how schools work runs.

Bluepiano · 16/07/2022 11:31

This would be a nightmare. How would teachers ensure all children have covered the curriculum when they’re all missing different parts of the year? It’s hard enough (although obviously no one’s fault) when children are ill or taken out on holiday. When would school staff have their holidays? How would this impact a school’s running costs?

Orangello · 16/07/2022 11:29

I'm from Northern Europe - summer holidays were always 1st of June to 1st of September. Yes, 3 months. Now I'm in France and you get early July - 1st of September. School until late July when the weather is the best you can get in the UK and kids could spend time outdoors seems such a waste.

bluekostree · 16/07/2022 11:28

@DownNative
Those dates aren't universal in NI. My dc gets a week off starting 31st Oct and a week off starting 13th feb. Only 2 days off end of may then finish on 29th June and back 29th august. 2 weeks at Xmas and Easter.

bendmeoverbackwards · 16/07/2022 11:26

1AngelicFruitCake · 16/07/2022 11:11

I don’t see why it would. Parents who care, maybe but the planning to apply for time off in a specific time just wouldn’t happen by some people. Council run activities and fairs that some of these children may get the benefit of, they wouldn’t be on if everyone was different.
End of term treats that these children enjoy wouldn’t happen.

Could make planning to meet up with friends really hard!

That’s before you consider what a nightmare it would be! Teach fractions on week 3 and someone misses it - how would you keep on top of that?! You can’t keep recapping, there’s no replacement for teaching it fully and practising the new learning as a class with the teacher.

With more teaching time in the year, there wouldn’t be pressure to teach a certain topic in a particular week and if you miss it you’re stuffed. I am suggesting a more holistic approach to education.

taybert · 16/07/2022 11:22

@MrsRhodes I think it varied from town to town, it was based on the old Wakes Weeks (a few people still referred to it as that even then, though I hadn’t realised there was a religious connection), the school summer holidays just continued after the traditional town holidays.

howshouldibehave · 16/07/2022 11:20

It would be a very sad state of affairs if we had a two-tier system where state school children went to school every day apart from the 6 weeks they could apply for as holiday, but their private/public school counterparts had 15+ weeks off a year.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 16/07/2022 11:18

AntlerRose · 16/07/2022 11:09

So you have a class of 30 and a teacher. Each person is allowed statutory annual leave I presume - so 5.6 weeks each?

And this is basically the same as the odd child having a day off for a cold, in terms of continuity for lessons.

Most students do not miss 6 weeks of teaching time for coughs and colds, most kids only miss the odd day here and there. If all students are getting almost 6 weeks off school during teaching hours how are you going to catch them up on the work they’ve missed?

And what happens when the teachers are off? Who teaches the class for those 6 weeks?

Also students and teachers currently get 13 weeks off a year, how will we afford to increase teachers pay to make up for the extra 7 weeks a year they are expected to work, plus pay to provide cover teachers for their 6 weeks of holiday for the children who are still in school, plus pay to provide extra teachers to help students who have missed 6 weeks of teaching time (on top of the time missed for the regular coughs, cold and other illnesses) catch up with that missed learning?

49er · 16/07/2022 11:15

If schools in England and Wales were off 10th July to 24th august that would surely cover the hottest weeks most years?