Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I believe we’re related

64 replies

SharingTheLove · 16/07/2022 00:04

Regardless of how the cold letter of the law considers us, I believe that any siblings of our adopted (now adult) son are family.

Two years ago our son’s sister contacted us via Facebook and since then we have grown to love her and her children and treat them as family. Her ex partner and she are currently negotiating contact as she has moved close to us for support. He is claiming we aren’t family so it’s not in the children’s best interests to have us in their lives. He also insists two years isn’t long enough for a 3 and 7 year old to know us before considering us family.

We brought our son home just 10 days after first meeting him and we’ve been a devoted family ever since. I met and married my husband with 18 months and we’ve been married 30 years! So the 2 year isn’t enough idea is bull.

So what makes a family in 2022?

I’ve posted under AIBU because I know adoption is a very difficult subject for some. I empathise with that, but know (mainly because of recent contact and actions) that our son has been entrusted to for the very reason we have sacrificed careers, social life etc to give him every opportunity we can afford (he isn’t spoilt, I promise, but he has a work ethic and appreciation of relationships we know he wouldn’t have got if he’d stayed with birth mum). His sister is an amazing mum but her ex tells everyone who’ll listen that she’s selfish and a drunk (her recycling bin doesn’t clink!)

Sock it to me. AIBU that she’s family and not just somebody from our son’s past that no longer has a relationship?

OP posts:
Mellowyellow222 · 16/07/2022 12:26

SharingTheLove · 16/07/2022 02:58

No I don’t believe I am a saviour. I’m just trying to work out if our situation is that of a modern day blended family.

i have picked up that you think the ex doesn’t fit into your definition of family. And you don’t fit into his.

but you have become very quickly and very intensely embroiled in this families life - which to be honest I would see as a red flag.

it is really important that the children maintain a good relationship with their dad. You are not their parent, or even their grandparent so your needs do not come first, second or even third.

I think you are trying to create a happily ever after with you at the centre - and anyone who doesn’t agree with your version of your family is kept outside.

I think this could be damaging in the long run for the children.

the mum will in all likelihood meet someone else - she won’t need you as much - the relationship will cool. But the dad will have missed out on time with his children because they were moved away from him to be close to you.

SharingTheLove · 16/07/2022 12:12

I love this! I’m not aware of anything like this here though.

OP posts:
Mellowyellow222 · 16/07/2022 09:20

This insta family does disturb me a little to be honest.

I am assuming the children’s father doesn’t abuse them.

from your post you met this lady two years ago, have developed an incredibly close reaction ship and she relies heavily on you.

she has moved her children a distance to be close to you.

this has impacted on the dads time with the children and he is annoyed.

you are arguing that you are family - although you aren’t related.

when the children grow up will they be happy that their mum moved them away from their dad to be close to their biological uncles adoptive family?

I know you think you are family - but at there adults in therapy because they didn’t get to maintain a relationship with their uncles adoptive parents, or are they in therapy beciase they didn’t get to maintain a relationship with their dad?

there is something quite selfish about your post. You seem incapable of seeing this from the childrens or their fathers perspective. It’s all about this really intense relationship you have with your sons biological sister.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 16/07/2022 09:18

Why the need to have the "family" label?

You're not family. You adopted your son but you didn't adopt his siblings and become related to them as a result of that adoption.

That doesn't mean you can't help her or be close and "like family" but I do think it's a bit inflammatory towards the ex to keep using the phrase "but we're family" - especially when it means his kids are being taken away from him.

TreePoser · 16/07/2022 09:14

SharingTheLove · 16/07/2022 02:38

The distance is irrelevant, it’s his claim that we aren’t “family” is the issue.

When I left my x, one of the things I needed to ''heal through'' was feeling the weight of his opinion. I really had to channel very strongly ''what you think of me is none of my business''.

So, what he thinks is none of your business. If he thinks you're not family, then that's what he thinks. What he thinks won't change what you do or say or feel, so disconnect from that.

It's not an issue. You don't need to win his approval. You don't need to be on the same page.

You just need to know that the people in your life want to be in your life.

jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey · 16/07/2022 09:12

Your son is family.
You are not family.
You do not get to dictate to the children's father about your relationship being as important as his.
It isn't!
It really isn't!

Minimalme · 16/07/2022 09:11

I understand op. I also think you can choose people to form an extended family without a bio link or court order.

He ex sounds awful and it is brilliant that you have the capacity and ability to support her.

ChagSameachDoreen · 16/07/2022 09:10

You sound quite defensive about it.

Personally, as an adoptee myself, I wouldn't consider my biological siblings to be my adoptive parents' "family".

But horses for courses!

Mellowyellow222 · 16/07/2022 09:05

It all sounds very intense.

you son is her brother and uncle to her children. You are not related - however you think of her as family which so nice. But yes strictly speaking you aren’t close family members. You aren’t her parents.

I can see where her ex is coming from. She has fast developed a bind that has resulted in her moving their children - and distance does matter. Of course it does.

you can all feel however you want about each other - but is this new intense relationship resulting in her children’s dad seeing less of his children?

CPL593H · 16/07/2022 08:29

Unless there is a valid safeguarding reason, the ex has no say over who is in your son's sister and her children's lives so he can think what he wants about the relationship with you, it is irrelevant. However, if she has moved a significant distance (even for support) and it impinges on their contact with their father, different issue. The same would apply if the move was nearer to biological family.

I think possibly more is going on here than the ex claiming that you are not family, apologies if I'm wrong.

erikbloodaxe · 16/07/2022 08:13

You might believe you are related but you are not. You are a supportive friend.

Would you consider her family if you didn't like her? If she was nasty to you? What about if your son didn't like her and wanted nothing to do with her?

She's your son's family but not yours sadly.

AuntieStella · 16/07/2022 08:07

An XH doesn't get to say what his XW can and can't do during the time the DC are resident with her.

If she sees you as family (irrespective of how that came about) then she'll act accordingly. Ditto if she sees you as good supportive friends. Or whatever.

You aren't a party to the Child Arrangments though. No grandparent has an automatic right to be included. Just keep being friend with the mother, amnd leave them to work it out

DecimatedDreams · 16/07/2022 08:01

You can consider them your family if you want, but they aren't legally. This makes zero difference is your case - as Pavlova said, the ex can't stop you having contact if mum facilitates that on her time.

GoldenGorilla · 16/07/2022 07:55

I consider lots of people to be “family” that I have no biological or legal connection to.

my children call all my close friends aunts and uncles, and consider those friends’ children to be their cousins.

when my son in year 1 had to draw his family tree it was massive, which I think is great!

nobody else can really define for you who your family is. If you and your son’s sister are happy to consider each other family then that’s it. You are family.

i would say that from a court perspective describing you as “family” may not help her, as a judge may have concerns/questions about that. So she may do better focusing on moving closer to her brother and his relationship with the niblings.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 16/07/2022 07:54

In the United States there is a legal relationship called "fictive kinship" that is used mostly for custodial cases. It allows for the idea that people can be close to other people and form a "kinship" without blood or marriage. For example, the nice old lady next door who your children call "Granny Nell" who bakes them birthday cakes every year. Or your best friend from University who is called "Aunt Helen" by your children. If these people can show length of time and/or involvement in a child's life, they can be recognized by the courts as "family".
Maybe the UK has something similar?

Onceuponaheartache · 16/07/2022 07:42

She is absolutely his family and as he is your she becomes yours also if it what you all want.

Her ex sounds abusive and manipulative. He is a classic abuser trying to separate and isolate her from her support network.

Ignore him and keep doing what you are doing. You sound amazing!!

CornishGem1975 · 16/07/2022 07:30

Families come in all shapes and sizes these days.

Aprilx · 16/07/2022 07:24

Why does it matter whether he classified you as family or not? How would it impact his access and since when did one parent start to tell the other one who they can socialise with?

I don’t understand what you are getting at really. To your question, no you are not her family, your son is as he is her brother, but you are not. But again, I am not sure why it matters here, but if it is because she is trying to justify a move away from the father because of you, then actually I agree with him.

sidheandlight · 16/07/2022 07:16

no, he is your son, that is where it should stop.You are being naive, step back, let him be free but you will get burned here. You know nothing only what you are told. Do not be foolish.

Wickywickyyow · 16/07/2022 06:51

SharingTheLove · 16/07/2022 02:38

The distance is irrelevant, it’s his claim that we aren’t “family” is the issue.

It's not irrelevant, his relationship with his children is more important than your opinions on whether you are family with their mother.

Arashi · 16/07/2022 06:46

I mean I would say you are family yes.

Whether that is a reason to move (far?) away from her ex and limiting his contact due to distance is a whole other ball game though ..

Christinatheastonishing · 16/07/2022 04:30

If the ex is arguing that the kids' time with him should be prioritised over time with you because he's closer family than you are, he's right. All other things being equal i.e. he's not an abusive dick. I think you're getting yourself too involved in this particular argument.

HoppingPavlova · 16/07/2022 04:10

I don’t get the conundrum here. If she wants contact then she can have it and her kids can have contact with you and their biological uncle when they are with her on her time. If he ex doesn’t want the kids to have contact then he doesn’t facilitate that on his time. Easy.

starrynight21 · 16/07/2022 04:00

SharingTheLove · 16/07/2022 02:38

The distance is irrelevant, it’s his claim that we aren’t “family” is the issue.

Personally I'd say that the distance is very relevant. If she has moved away from him in order to be near you, then of course it's relevant since that means he is further away from his kids.

You might like the idea that you have now got a blended family with her, but meantime her ex partner is losing his family. I think you've got rose-coloured glasses on, with a large dose of saviour complex thrown in.

Cadot · 16/07/2022 03:37

It's lovely that you've built such a good relationship and can play a supporting and loving role in each other's lives. Of course you are family.

The father is probably feeling threatened that his role in their lives is going to be diminished. You say they are negotiating contact because she has moved close to you - I'd say the distance is relevant because if it makes it difficult for the father to see his children then that will be why he is trying to diminish your importance and reduce your influence.

Do you consider him family as well? Would it be possible to build up your relationship with him?

Swipe left for the next trending thread