Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want bills to be split 60/40

81 replies

Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 13:12

Mine and and my husband's finances are all over the place. I pay for child care and food he pays for mortgage and bills. My family expenses are a little more that his.

I don't want us to have a joint account that we both just use because we have different spending habits. But I do want us to have a fair way of contributing to the household bills.

We have a joint account which I'm going to suggest all bills come out of. Let's say the family bill comes to £2000 per month.

I work 20 hours and the rest of my weeks is taken up with childcare we have 2 children. He works 40 hours a week.

Roughly our pro rata is the same. He earns £34,000 I earn £28000 per year actually not prorata.

I think he should pay £1200 and I pay £800 according to the ratio of what we both work rather than what we earn. Does that seem fair?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blush21 · 15/07/2022 23:43

That’s how it works in our house. Monthly household bills are out of the joint account. I contribute 40% he doesn’t 60% as he earns more. Food shops are 50/50 split along with all atoned expense so a takeaway or day out, he will always pay me back his half. Other adhoc expenses like replacing household goods or DIY are generally 50/50 but at times he will pay if I’m a bit short

Quincythequince · 15/07/2022 23:31

LondonQueen · 15/07/2022 18:23

That's how the world works darling. You sound very entitled, bet your DH can't wait for a divorce.

Good god!
No, that’s not how it works ‘darling’
Do you engage your brain and critical thinking before you respond?

Newmumatlast · 15/07/2022 18:33

Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 13:26

Well if it's off wheat we earn then the bill splice would be 55/45 rather than 60/40. So not much in it.

Do that then. It shouldn't be off of how many hours you do if him working more hours means you pay less yet you earn more per hour. That makes no sense. You split based on income as it is a financial transaction.

LondonQueen · 15/07/2022 18:23

Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 16:13

Your work is also flexible so you could arrange that DH has the DCs after work which will give you chance to work so you won’t need much childcare anyway.

So you think I should spend all my time either looking after kids or working? No thanks.

That's how the world works darling. You sound very entitled, bet your DH can't wait for a divorce.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 15/07/2022 17:18

Well tbh with the rapid rising energy bills in a couple of months I think he will be paying alot more then you soon

Headbandheart · 15/07/2022 17:15

I’d look at it round the other way…salaries and earring will change over your marriage as will your outgoings so you have to start thinking that you are mutually responsible for your outgoings.

make a budget for each year. Lists all your essential spends. Make sure you include everything . That include pensions, paying off debts etc Agree and compromise on things you include then that are less essentials but part of your standard of living for things you do as a family - eating out, days out, veinings out, gyms, holidays. Things that you’d say aren’t essentials but pretty fundamental

also calculate a essential budget for your own personal care and grooming..clothing, cosmetic hair etc. for women that is always higher (pink tax). But it should be just for essential not to fund your personal shoes habit, Botox habit or manicure habit.

play all your income into your joint account. Pay your outgoing budgetted items you’ve agreed direct form that. These are basic stuff. Always must come first

then you have your own single accounts. For the essential personal care and grooming pay that amount to each of you so you have full control over it individually.

Then if there is anything left ( which will vary over your lifetimes) you split it in ratio you are earring and pay that into your own accounts to do with as you like, unless one of you is stay at home parent in which case it’s 50:50 as that isn’t paid work but is work of same value.

budgetting is essential. If his spending habits are different form yours you are going to have to really sit down and agree that budget and what you agree is essential vs part of what your standard of living expectations are vs personal spends you can blow your own money on

you are married, everything you have is a joint marital asset. It matters not a jot where the money is sitting at the end of the day. What matters is that you start communicating and agreeing how you spend your money and when and why

Aquamarine1029 · 15/07/2022 17:03

Quincythequince · 15/07/2022 13:58

I will never, ever understand threads like this.
You both make sure all expenses are paid, contribute equally time wise (paid or unpaid) to family life each week, and you both get the same spending money each month.

How you achieve that is up to you, but this divvying up to the tune of a couple hundred quid per month when you are married with a kid is just mealy-mouthed, penny pinching.

Honestly.

I agree, and the fact you're afraid to talk to your husband about finances doesn't bode well at all. Yours sounds like a very unhealthy marriage.

CallOnMe · 15/07/2022 17:00

Well my husband works 9-5 and once the kids are in bed has time off. I hardly do as I'm working most evenings.

But when you separate if you need to work in the evenings then he’d have the children after work - so both of you would have the same amount of ‘time off’.

Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 16:49

The vast majority of parents are with their own children if they aren’t working, I don’t get it? Well my husband works 9-5 and once the kids are in bed has time off. I hardly do as I'm working most evenings.

OP posts:
Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 16:48

I've already explained that I do work some evenings I don't want to work anymore hours outside of nursery hours. Plus I'd loose his place in nursery...in a year he gets the 30 "free hours" which equates to a saving of about £200 per month.

OP posts:
TiddleyWink · 15/07/2022 16:42

Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 16:13

Your work is also flexible so you could arrange that DH has the DCs after work which will give you chance to work so you won’t need much childcare anyway.

So you think I should spend all my time either looking after kids or working? No thanks.

Um…yes?

Why wouldn’t you choose to focus your work in the time you don’t have your children so that you can maximise quality time with them and also enable yourself to leave an unhappy relationship and not have your children spend their formative years in a miserable and toxic household?

luxxlisbon · 15/07/2022 16:30

Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 16:13

Your work is also flexible so you could arrange that DH has the DCs after work which will give you chance to work so you won’t need much childcare anyway.

So you think I should spend all my time either looking after kids or working? No thanks.

The vast majority of parents are with their own children if they aren’t working, I don’t get it?

CallOnMe · 15/07/2022 16:27

So you think I should spend all my time either looking after kids or working? No thanks.

Ermm… what do you think the rest of the world does 😕

Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 16:13

Your work is also flexible so you could arrange that DH has the DCs after work which will give you chance to work so you won’t need much childcare anyway.

So you think I should spend all my time either looking after kids or working? No thanks.

OP posts:
CallOnMe · 15/07/2022 16:10

Youngest is 2. We are waiting until there's less childcare costs once he goes to school.

Sorry but I think this is ridiculous.

You can’t wait in an unhappy relationship for another 2 years because you want to wait until your child is in school.

You’ll be able to claim childcare costs back and they’ll be eligible for free childcare when they’re 3.
Your work is also flexible so you could arrange that DH has the DCs after work which will give you chance to work so you won’t need much childcare anyway.

Quincythequince · 15/07/2022 16:03

SuperCamp · 15/07/2022 15:42

We have a joint account for household and family expenditure.
So all bills, food shop, kids clothes, kids presents, family holidays, family days out, everything that is a shared family expense.

Then we have sole personal accounts for our own mobile bills, clothes, ‘our side’ family gifts, individual hobbies, subscriptions etc.

We put in a fixed amount each month, to cover all bills and build up a reserve for Christmas, maintenance bills etc.

I think your contribution should be on earnings, tbh. But as you are the higher earner per hour, I would suggest he does 4 days and you up your work a day.

Or perhaps they just reasonably share money given that there is enough so it seems.

Maybe she wants to be with her young DC at home right now, hence the part time work.

Quincythequince · 15/07/2022 16:01

All these people saying it’s not fair that OP thinks DH should be paying more, have you read it properly?

Her costs are currently more than his and she works per time so she can do childcare (for free obviously, that’s what mums do) which is what she does when she’s not working.

He earns more, but she does more overall, why should she be worse off?

In fact why should either of them be worse odd than the other?

TiddleyWink · 15/07/2022 15:58

Oh blimey, just seen your casually planning on splitting up in a couple of years anyway….what life is this? Just formally separate now surely?

TiddleyWink · 15/07/2022 15:57

Quincythequince · 15/07/2022 13:58

I will never, ever understand threads like this.
You both make sure all expenses are paid, contribute equally time wise (paid or unpaid) to family life each week, and you both get the same spending money each month.

How you achieve that is up to you, but this divvying up to the tune of a couple hundred quid per month when you are married with a kid is just mealy-mouthed, penny pinching.

Honestly.

I couldn’t have put it better!

Everything in one pot, bills paid, a standing order into each of your individual accounts for personal
spending money that the other has no interest in/say over.

Each works equally hard towards the family, be it paid work, childcare, housework.

I struggle to fathom long term couples with kids that are sitting there with the calculator deciding who is fleecing the other. Just seems so depressing!

GCHeretic · 15/07/2022 15:45

Given how close the amounts are that you bring in, putting equal amounts into a joint account would seem quite a sensible way to go here.

My husband and I have earned very different amounts to each other at various times, but are both most comfortable with putting the same amount each in to cover household expenses and keeping the excess that we each have to do what we each want with.

Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 15:45

We put in a fixed amount each month, to cover all bills and build up a reserve for Christmas, maintenance bills etc.

That's what I want us to do.

I think your contribution should be on earnings, tbh. But as you are the higher earner per hour, I would suggest he does 4 days and you up your work a day.

We are both happy with me working part time. I can't really earn more anyway due to the nature of my self employment.n

OP posts:
Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 15:43

@CallOnMe

Youngest is 2. We are waiting until there's less childcare costs once he goes to school.

OP posts:
SuperCamp · 15/07/2022 15:42

We have a joint account for household and family expenditure.
So all bills, food shop, kids clothes, kids presents, family holidays, family days out, everything that is a shared family expense.

Then we have sole personal accounts for our own mobile bills, clothes, ‘our side’ family gifts, individual hobbies, subscriptions etc.

We put in a fixed amount each month, to cover all bills and build up a reserve for Christmas, maintenance bills etc.

I think your contribution should be on earnings, tbh. But as you are the higher earner per hour, I would suggest he does 4 days and you up your work a day.

Soggycrisps · 15/07/2022 15:41

You said earlier you need the split adjusted because at the minute you have to ask him for money but on 28k and £800 a month on childcare I really don’t see how food is too much on top if he pays the bills and the mortgage.

I never ask for money for food. I pay all childcare and food. Which is more than what he pays which is for mortgage and bills.

The money that I ask for is for extra expenses like when the kids need clothes. He says this will even out the extra money I pay monthly.

But I think if what we paid monthly was fair then the extra expenses should just be split between us too.

We are defo not working as a team.

OP posts:
Shgytfgtf111 · 15/07/2022 15:31

I earn approx £10k more than my DP and I put proportionately more into our joint billing account, so all joint bills come out of that (mortgage, insurances, internet, petrol, utilities, food etc) and we have a similar amount left that we have in our personal accounts to use for our own mobile phone bills etc and is ours to spend as we wish. I wouldnt ask him for money and neither of us justifies what we are spending to the other as all our joint bills are covered.

It means you dont find yourself in a situation whereby you end up spending more simply because you pay for the food for example.

Swipe left for the next trending thread