Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want a bigger house? Please help me. Stay or Go?

90 replies

MrsWolfyWoo · 15/07/2022 10:48

We live in a small 2 bed . Me , dh and Ds. We are lucky it is affordable and absolutely love the house and location but it’s very small especially as I work from home . We want another baby so space will be tighter .

The thing is - DH is older . So if we are going to move - we have to do it now while we can get a 17 year mortgage together . The issue is a 17 year mortgage on a bigger house will mean out mortgage payment will double our current payments . Things will be much tighter and the price of living is going up . This worries me especially if I want to have another baby ( maternity pay is low - then nursery fees)

If we don’t move I’m worried that we will become stuck in a 2 bed as if I was to borrow alone I can only borrow about £100k . Which would not be enough for us to get a bigger house even with the equity we have .

Do we stay and know we are comfortable but always worry that we may not get a 3 bed . Or do we move now whilst we can and accept things will be tight for at least 5 years ?

There is no room for an extension !

Advice please ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Abitofalark · 16/07/2022 00:59

You haven't specified the age of your husband - understandably you may not want to give personal information but I'm wondering what assumption you are making about the upper age limit for having your mortgage paid off and whether you might be missing a trick by calculating the term and monthly payments on the wrong basis.

Many mortgage lenders have an upper age limit of 70 or maybe 75 in some cases, but some will give mortgages of up to the age of 80 or even 85, subject to satisfying their criteria. I know because I got one! That means your monthly payments would be much less than perhaps you think. So I'd say go and have your baby. It's important. You have only one life, one family. Seize the day.

Have a look online. Lots of calculators there. I've used London and Country in the past. Put in your criteria for upper age limit for paying off the mortgage and see what comes up. Or ring them and ask. They don't charge.

MrsWolfyWoo · 16/07/2022 00:20

riotlady · 16/07/2022 00:00

I agree with the pp who said stay where you are, have the second baby, and save the difference between the mortgage you’re paying now and the mortgage you would be paying if you’d moved (so potentially £500-700 a month). In a few years you’ll have a canny whack of savings, the equity in your house, you’ll be past the super expensive childcare phase and you can work with a broker to find a mortgage provider who can work with your DH’s situation (or you can get a shorter mortgage term). There’s no point putting yourself in financial difficulties now for an unknown “if” of struggling to move in 4-5 years time

This is what I am going to do! Thanks all!

OP posts:
riotlady · 16/07/2022 00:00

I agree with the pp who said stay where you are, have the second baby, and save the difference between the mortgage you’re paying now and the mortgage you would be paying if you’d moved (so potentially £500-700 a month). In a few years you’ll have a canny whack of savings, the equity in your house, you’ll be past the super expensive childcare phase and you can work with a broker to find a mortgage provider who can work with your DH’s situation (or you can get a shorter mortgage term). There’s no point putting yourself in financial difficulties now for an unknown “if” of struggling to move in 4-5 years time

gjrogjegkek · 15/07/2022 23:26

@ILikeHotWaterBottles harsh Grin

OP basically needs to accept their shit life by the sounds of it haha

(OP it’s not shit)

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 15/07/2022 23:06

Mat pay and nursery fees plus double the mortgage? I'd say it has to be one or the other.

We had two dc in a 2bed flat til the youngest was 3. That's another 4 years if you ttc now, and gets you to the free 30 hrs.

Do you have to get a 17yr mortgage? Don't they do them smaller?

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 15/07/2022 23:03

You need to compromise.

Second child and cramped living space, not a comfortable life
Second child and bigger house but in worse area probably or in bad condition that you can't afford to do up, not a comfortable life
No second child and have a relatively comfortable life

You can't afford the big house in nice area and done up, and the second child. You have to compromise and accept a bad situation in any form.

ApplesandBunions · 15/07/2022 21:38

The issue is we really want another child and I’ll always regret not having a second but I’m thinking that in the case of having a second child we need to accept we can’t relatively afford to move

In that case I'd maybe TTC the second, accept you're staying where you are at least until the mat leave and double nursery stage has passed, and be absolutely ruthless about clutter and storage.

soootiredddd · 15/07/2022 21:34

Oh meant to add that we are worrying about this and our income is quite a bit higher than yours. Around £5200 combined after tax.

soootiredddd · 15/07/2022 21:31

I’m sure someone will have already mentioned this but you need to calculate what will happen if interest rates rise a lot.

at the moment our payment is £1050 per month and we are on a rate we got fixed in 2020 of 1.7%. At current interest rates of 3.3% the repayments would jump to over £1300. Just think what they would be if rates rise to 6 or 7% which is really not that unlikely or god forbid 10% plus.

only move to a 3 bed if you can do it by moving to a cheaper area. Do not for the love of god double your mortgage payment when we are on the cusp of some huge interest rate rises.

MrsWolfyWoo · 15/07/2022 21:30

Ilady · 15/07/2022 19:24

I know at the moment you want to move into a bigger home and have a second child. You dh is older and you said you can only get a mortgage for 17 years because of his age. I presume he could be 52/53. You feel if you don't get a bigger home now you will miss out and you won't have the space for a 2nd child.

  1. Does your dh really want a 2nd child considering their age and the fact they could be retired before the child finishes secondary school? How will you afford to put your current child and this child through college?

2 Your mortgage is currently £750 pm. To move to a new house this could change to £1400pm or £1150/1200 pm if you buy a fixer upper? Interest rates are going up so what happens if rates go to 6 or 7%?

3 fixer upper house are out their but the cost of building materials, paint ect have risen a lot and it hard to get good trades people to do things and they are not cheap either. Then you start to work on a house like this find problems and end up with a lot of unexpected expense.

4 When you apply for a mortgage banks will stress test you to see if you can afford to replay.
Also they will look at car loans, credit card ect. They also take into consideration how many kids you have. If you have another child you can't borrow as much.

5 Another child means that you have to live on maternity pay so you less income coming in for X period of time. You have the cost of nursery fees and the hassle of finding a place.
As your current child get older the expenses will get higher. Your extending the length of time you will children dependant on you and doubling the costs of bringing up just one child
As children get older they get more expensive.

6 At the moment the cost of living has gone crazy. Electric, gas, petrol have all shot up and are due to rise even further. Foods bills will be rising further as well because the cost of fertilizer has doubled and farmers cost of diesel ect will have to be passed on.

7 What happens if you have a 2nd child and you or your dh can no longer work because this child needs care?

Even one of the posters here said she is good with money and budgeting but she can't budget at the moment with the way everything is rising. Another person here did what your planning on around your income and she is finding it hard to manage on their income.
It not just that prices are rising but people's wages are not going up at the same rate and taxes are rising also.

I think that you would be better off staying in your current home and not having a 2nd child.
If you move house, take on a bigger mortgage and have another child I think that your just going to make life more difficult for you all. It important to have some spare cash to put aside into savings and a pension as you get older. You also important in case anything unforeseen happens that you have some bit of a buffer.

@Ilady thank you so much for your reply . Lots of really important points . I hugely appreciate you taking the time .

The issue is we really want another child and I’ll always regret not having a second but I’m thinking that in the case of having a second child we need to accept we can’t relatively afford to move !

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 15/07/2022 20:33

I would only move if your income is set to increase.

Look into extending or putting an annexe in your garden for your office space.

You can manage with two bedrooms until DCs are at least 10/11. Wait out the current economic uncertainty. Build your equity. When the housing bubble bursts you will not find yourselves in over your heads.

PreggieGoldilocks86 · 15/07/2022 19:25

I’d say now is not the time to be living beyond your means - stay where you can afford, save save save, and look to buy again bigger and better when things settle down a bit. Even if you do have another baby, that’s 9 months of pregnancy, 6 months of the baby in your room at least - you have some time, I would use it personally.

Ilady · 15/07/2022 19:24

I know at the moment you want to move into a bigger home and have a second child. You dh is older and you said you can only get a mortgage for 17 years because of his age. I presume he could be 52/53. You feel if you don't get a bigger home now you will miss out and you won't have the space for a 2nd child.

  1. Does your dh really want a 2nd child considering their age and the fact they could be retired before the child finishes secondary school? How will you afford to put your current child and this child through college?

2 Your mortgage is currently £750 pm. To move to a new house this could change to £1400pm or £1150/1200 pm if you buy a fixer upper? Interest rates are going up so what happens if rates go to 6 or 7%?

3 fixer upper house are out their but the cost of building materials, paint ect have risen a lot and it hard to get good trades people to do things and they are not cheap either. Then you start to work on a house like this find problems and end up with a lot of unexpected expense.

4 When you apply for a mortgage banks will stress test you to see if you can afford to replay.
Also they will look at car loans, credit card ect. They also take into consideration how many kids you have. If you have another child you can't borrow as much.

5 Another child means that you have to live on maternity pay so you less income coming in for X period of time. You have the cost of nursery fees and the hassle of finding a place.
As your current child get older the expenses will get higher. Your extending the length of time you will children dependant on you and doubling the costs of bringing up just one child
As children get older they get more expensive.

6 At the moment the cost of living has gone crazy. Electric, gas, petrol have all shot up and are due to rise even further. Foods bills will be rising further as well because the cost of fertilizer has doubled and farmers cost of diesel ect will have to be passed on.

7 What happens if you have a 2nd child and you or your dh can no longer work because this child needs care?

Even one of the posters here said she is good with money and budgeting but she can't budget at the moment with the way everything is rising. Another person here did what your planning on around your income and she is finding it hard to manage on their income.
It not just that prices are rising but people's wages are not going up at the same rate and taxes are rising also.

I think that you would be better off staying in your current home and not having a 2nd child.
If you move house, take on a bigger mortgage and have another child I think that your just going to make life more difficult for you all. It important to have some spare cash to put aside into savings and a pension as you get older. You also important in case anything unforeseen happens that you have some bit of a buffer.

whereeverilaymycat · 15/07/2022 19:18

I'd caution a fixer upper. We've had to dramatically reduce what we are doing to our house (and do it in bits) because the cost of building work / materials is so much now. I daren't borrow any more money with mortgage rates, so we are saving up (and I'm mustering all my patience and gratitude in the process).

How big are your two bedrooms? A friend of mine had a generous master and a decent second bedroom. She's just rejigged them to create a small ish double and two singles. Now her children have a room each (boy and girl) and the house will do them for a few more years. Is there any possibility of that?

Also look at Pinterest and YouTube for maximising storage etc for small spaces.

Given the current climate you'll have to compromise somewhere. In your shoes I'd probably stay put, save like crazy and then see where you are in a year or two.

UnnecessaryFennel · 15/07/2022 18:28

Sorry, OP, on your current household income you'd be insane to double your mortgage. You're not wrong to want more space, of course not, but realistically life is only going to get more expensive for everyone, and adding in a big mortgage plus nursery fees / loss of income from mat leave...no way on earth would I consider it.

It sucks, though. I hope you find an alternative.

Mydogatemypurse · 15/07/2022 18:14

Id get a loft conversion and extention if you can.

Wazzzzzuuuuuuup · 15/07/2022 18:12

It's not affordable. Childcare is bloody expensive and even another £500 on your mortgage plus the cost of renovations in the current climate is not good idea. I earn the same as you, my kids are not in childcare and my mortgage is only £600. There is no way I would consider doubling it now. Quite apart form from the risk that you lose your income or your expenses rise to the point that your house becomes unaffordable, you won't have anything spare in the system for all the little things that make life nice, for you and your dcs

ApplesandBunions · 15/07/2022 18:02

BammBamm · 15/07/2022 17:59

Thanks @ApplesandBunions I've just started considering this. I've stuck with my bank since 2012 because it's been easier and only very slightly more than the best buys but I think I'll have to reconsider in the current climate!

Yeah, unless they are really competitive or the customer service is completely stunningly great then I don't think there's any room for brand loyalty in the current climate.

BammBamm · 15/07/2022 17:59

Thanks @ApplesandBunions I've just started considering this. I've stuck with my bank since 2012 because it's been easier and only very slightly more than the best buys but I think I'll have to reconsider in the current climate!

ApplesandBunions · 15/07/2022 17:57

BammBamm · 15/07/2022 13:24

We had this debate for several years and eventually moved in 2020 when DC2 was 4. In hindsight, we should have done it earlier because prices rose and we were upsizing. The current situation is starting to worry me. Our council tax doubled and our energy bills were and still are higher even though we've replaced heating and made other changes. Our mortgage is due to end in January and I'm dreading the increase. We still have a significant amount of work to do on the house too but some will have to wait.

If I was in your shoes, I would ride out this storm where you are and see what happens with house prices. I honestly think there will have to be some kind of readjustment and it will work in your favour if you're upsizing.

@BammBamm you may know this already, but if your mortgage finishes in January you can probably apply for a new one now, to lock in the rate. Likely higher than what you pay now, but cheaper than what will be available later in the year. May be worth considering?

Calmdown14 · 15/07/2022 17:53

Are you in a good catchment for primary schools? Does it change for secondary?

I think I'd plan to stay until second DC is about four. Get the expensive child care years out of the way and move before the next expensive teenage stage kicks in.

How big is your main bedroom? If you can fit in a cot/toddler bed then that might be okay for a few years

In the meantime, I'd either save the difference in mortgage costs or depending on your interest rate overpay as much as possible on your current mortgage to build equity.

While there's no knowing what house prices will do, I think by the time you get on the market they will have peaked. You've missed the upward curve and missed the decent fixed rates on mortgages that might offset paying a premium.
I don't expect a massive crash but I think they'll stabilise and dip in the short term in the places where things were going way over valuation.

I'd also imagine stock will be limited for you to choose from as there will be a lot of people staying put now

Goldfishmountainclimber · 15/07/2022 17:32

My concern would be interest rate rises. The interest rate will only go up in the short to medium term so your mortgage could go from just manageable to unaffordable in a few years.

Merryoldgoat · 15/07/2022 17:05

I think a mortgage of that size on your salaries would be tight.

ours is £1500 and we take home about £5.5k and we are FINE but not loads of give.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 15/07/2022 16:59

Do it as soon as you can.

We've moved from a three bed to a four in the last six months, and the relaxation that having a bit of extra space brings cannot be overstated. We also moved from a house with no garden to a house with garden and garage, and it’s amazing.

TheBatwoman · 15/07/2022 16:47

It all depends on your family finances and how comfortably you think you would manage the added expense. When we bought our house with a view to having a baby, we were torn between our smaller house and a significantly bigger place at the top end of our budget. Long story short, I ended up having twins. So trying to juggle maternity pay with the costs associated with having two little ones in the current economic climate has meant things have been extremely difficult financially, even in our previously below budget choice of house. I’m sure the stress of living in a slightly smaller space than we’d prefer for a family of four has been significantly less than the stress of not knowing if we could continue to pay our mortgage in our current circumstances. However, it’s all relative and only you will know if it’s affordable or sustainable longer term.