Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this fair? £800 spent only on one of four children?

235 replies

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 06:47

My dad has four children and has been speaking about getting my brother a new bike which costs around £800 for his birthday. He is the only boy and us others are girls. We are all adults well into our 40's.

We all work. Most minimum wage jobs but brother probably has the least disposable income due to house/family costs.

I just got a card for my birthday this year.

Is that fair?

Am I right to be annoyed that we are being treated differently or should I accept it's his money to do as he pleases?

OP posts:
fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 09:13

Meraas · 15/07/2022 08:56

At the start of the year around my birthday it was all oh no presents for anyone this year etc etc now it's brothers birthday next week and the tune has changed to can you take me to collect his bike!

Did you not say, as pinkstinks suggests “oh, I thought this was a no presents year?! When did that change!”?

You need to raise these things then and there, don't be passive!

But then in line with a lot of other posts here, it is not my money and not my place to say. My family is more important to me than £800 so I'd never make an issue of it.

As I've stated, just feels a bit unfair.

OP posts:
Léighméleabhair · 15/07/2022 09:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

pointythings · 15/07/2022 09:05

Of course parents are entitled to spend their money as they wish, but they do have to accept that inequity might well have an adverse effect on the relationship they have with the children who are not favoured. My parents were always completely evenhanded with me and my Dsis and I have carried this on to my 3 (now adult) DC.

CallOnMe · 15/07/2022 09:02

YANBU

My own brother is treated like this too.

Growing up there was a very obvious difference in the things he would get vs me and my sister.

Now we’re adults they still pay most of his household bills, all of his car insurance, tax, mot and garage bills and he’s never brought himself a car ever and then always moans when it breaks down because it’s just a cheap car.

I think they do it because he’s the baby but he’s only 2 years younger than me and I’m a single parent and can manage paying all of my own bills.

I don’t resent him for it but it does annoy me sometimes. I also worry about what will happen if my parents die because he actually has no sense of worry or paying bills so they’re doing him a disservice.

In your situation Id be tempted to say something but they’ll have a million excuses already and it’ll probably end up making you feel even more annoyed.

Meraas · 15/07/2022 08:56

At the start of the year around my birthday it was all oh no presents for anyone this year etc etc now it's brothers birthday next week and the tune has changed to can you take me to collect his bike!

Did you not say, as pinkstinks suggests “oh, I thought this was a no presents year?! When did that change!”?

You need to raise these things then and there, don't be passive!

SalmonEile · 15/07/2022 08:52

Is your Dad close to your brother?
maybe this is the only way he can feel connected to him? If they’re not close maybe he has some unresolved guilt ? buying him stuff is the only way he can feel involved with him ?

i get why you’re annoyed especially when he said no presents for the rest of you though :(
Is/was he a helpful supportive parent to you in other ways?

MsTSwift · 15/07/2022 08:43

Slightly cringing for you op you are not children any more ! They can use their money as they see fit.

BoJoGoGo · 15/07/2022 08:33

Buying the bike for his DS will give your dad pleasure, focus on that.

MarsQueen · 15/07/2022 08:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 08:23

pinkstinks · 15/07/2022 08:21

What would they say if you gently called them out? Ie “oh, I thought this was a no presents year?! When did that change!”

Hmmm what do I think they would say? Something not too defensive but in support of the fact they wanted to buy brother a bike.

I absolutely would not say that to them though as I appreciate and understand all the relevant points on this post about how I should get over it and not let it get to me etc.

So I'll just carry on.

OP posts:
pinkstinks · 15/07/2022 08:21

What would they say if you gently called them out? Ie “oh, I thought this was a no presents year?! When did that change!”

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 08:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Completely get that especially having seen some examples on this thread.

I think I have a particularly strong moral compass and that draws my attention to what I deem as unfairness.

At the start of the year around my birthday it was all oh no presents for anyone this year etc etc now it's brothers birthday next week and the tune has changed to can you take me to collect his bike!

OP posts:
MarsQueen · 15/07/2022 08:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BoJoGoGo · 15/07/2022 08:09

I wouldn’t be worrying about it if I was in my 40’s, maybe if I was 10 and my brother got a bike and I got a card but not 40’s.

Dacquoise · 15/07/2022 08:06

It's not fair but not uncommon in some families. In mine my brother was the golden child. New bike, own room, own TV, could behave how he liked. My sister and I had to make do. He was also given a deposit for a flat when he left home. My DM made it clear her assets were going only to him. It was a wider family trait too. Boys were seen as prince's, girls as servants.

But you know what? It hasn't done him any favours. He completely lacks empathy and compassion and has done some callous things. He's stuck in a bad marriage and made some bad decisions. I am NC with him and the rest of my family. Leave them to it.

I don't focus on anything I might be missing out on. I am very grateful not to be him. It's a win as far as I'm concerned. You can waste a lot of energy getting frustrated about this.

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 08:03

Hurstlandshome · 15/07/2022 07:34

I hate the 'fair' debate. You should be able to give your money to whomsoever you wish.

Your dad wants to treat his son and will probably get a lot of gratification from handing the bike over. He might not want to spend another £2400. Let him live.

Let a man live. That's a very fair point.

OP posts:
fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 08:01

luxxlisbon · 15/07/2022 07:55

You are fixated on the fairness of it all but fair actually doesn’t mean equal.
If it fair if he gave you all £100 and the other siblings could spend it on fun but one had to spend it on bills?

You are in your 40s, you have more disposable money than your brother anyway, just get on with your life.

You know this is actually what I intend to do. There really isn't any other option.

I guess I just wanted to sense check if my feelings were valid.

Out of interest so you spend different amounts on family members and if so is there a reason for this?

OP posts:
Windbeneathmybingowings · 15/07/2022 08:01

My mother in law is very much like this; she and SIL actively squirm when my kids are fighting/not sharing and I say things to the children like “we should share things, sharing is caring, let’s make things fair to everybody” etc. Also about lying. It’s just a concept they don’t understand, every man for himself is more their bag and was actively encouraged in a weird King Lear thing by their grandfather:

when SIL writes FB posts about their kind caring mother who treats them all the same, i don’t recognise those words at all.

luxxlisbon · 15/07/2022 07:55

You are fixated on the fairness of it all but fair actually doesn’t mean equal.
If it fair if he gave you all £100 and the other siblings could spend it on fun but one had to spend it on bills?

You are in your 40s, you have more disposable money than your brother anyway, just get on with your life.

entropynow · 15/07/2022 07:41

You're all in your 40s? Blimey. Honestly I couldn't get worked up about this (and yes, I've been in the same situation with a lot more than a few hundred quid involved).
Primary school was a long time ago mate.

girlmom21 · 15/07/2022 07:40

@fairfayrefare but it doesn't need to be 'fair'. It's your parents money to do with as they will.

If one of you had a £20 school trip as children were the others given £20? If one of you had a £1500 wedding dress was the other limited to £1500 too? If they chose a cheaper dress were they given the difference?

Do you all spend the exact same amount on your parents at birthdays and Christmas?

Do you all have the exact same amount of support from them and give them the exact same amount?

Could the bike be the difference between your brother being able to commute to a fancy new job or not?

Hurstlandshome · 15/07/2022 07:34

I hate the 'fair' debate. You should be able to give your money to whomsoever you wish.

Your dad wants to treat his son and will probably get a lot of gratification from handing the bike over. He might not want to spend another £2400. Let him live.

3WildOnes · 15/07/2022 07:31

I am pretty sure my parents have helped me out financially considerably more than they have helped out my siblings, to the tune of tens of thousands. My siblings are older , earn more and my family wanted to help us buy a house. They would have helped out my siblings as well but they wouldn't have needed as much as us.

daffodilandtulip · 15/07/2022 07:31

I only have one sibling and favouritism is just one of the reasons I am now no contact with the abusive lot.
I've always had a token few notes in a card for birthdays. Sister always had carefully chosen, expensive gifts; plus a household item/room decorated/new carpet/white good on top.
I'm always very careful to treat my two the same. They might not have exactly the same spent on them, but they always just have one expensive item plus around the same amount of smaller items for Christmas/birthdays, so it appears similar, even if the ££ are not identical.

Lingoflaming · 15/07/2022 07:08

I'd be leaving all the elderly care to brother if I were in your shoes as he's the golden child. Your dad favours you more than his other children so you're under no obligation to be his carer later on.