Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this fair? £800 spent only on one of four children?

235 replies

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 06:47

My dad has four children and has been speaking about getting my brother a new bike which costs around £800 for his birthday. He is the only boy and us others are girls. We are all adults well into our 40's.

We all work. Most minimum wage jobs but brother probably has the least disposable income due to house/family costs.

I just got a card for my birthday this year.

Is that fair?

Am I right to be annoyed that we are being treated differently or should I accept it's his money to do as he pleases?

OP posts:
bumpytrumpy · 15/07/2022 11:26

Meraas · 15/07/2022 08:56

At the start of the year around my birthday it was all oh no presents for anyone this year etc etc now it's brothers birthday next week and the tune has changed to can you take me to collect his bike!

Did you not say, as pinkstinks suggests “oh, I thought this was a no presents year?! When did that change!”?

You need to raise these things then and there, don't be passive!

This. Why done you ask them? Perfect opportunity if they're asking you for a lift to actually facilitate this present?

If you feel like you can't ask them then that's a problem in itself. I suggest you look up the book Toxic Parents and maybe peruse the "stately homes" support threads on here

Freeme31 · 15/07/2022 11:23

How do your other siblings feel ?i think i would feel as you do (it's important to feel your being treated fairly its about respect) do you have good open communication with your family to be able to discuss this without it causing an argument- it is already a problem- can you ask why your brother needs to be treated differently it may help you come to terms with why your parents favour one sibling over another?

Bunty55 · 15/07/2022 11:20

OP Is there anything we need to know about your brother ? How old is he ?

Puffalicious · 15/07/2022 11:20

entropynow · 15/07/2022 07:41

You're all in your 40s? Blimey. Honestly I couldn't get worked up about this (and yes, I've been in the same situation with a lot more than a few hundred quid involved).
Primary school was a long time ago mate.

This is really, really unfair. It clearly hurts the OP. She's said she doesn't want his money and loves her brother, it's the blatant injustice of her and her sisters being the ones doing the visiting and her brother being treated as the prodigal son. We can all be hurt no matter what age we are.

My own DF was like this with my sister (there are 5 of us, 3 girls, 2 boys)- she and her children were always clearly his favourites. She didn't ask for it and I love my sister very, very much, but the fact that she accepted lots of money/ things over the years didn't go unnoticed. It actually means her and my brother are NC. Very sad, and we've tried to resolve it, but can't. We all get on with living - I love all of them and find them such wonderful people- it's just sad I can't invite all of my brothers and sisters at the same time. Things like big birthdays/ weddings/ parties it's sad.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:20

Ooops, sorry, my comment there ^ was in response to @Greenberg (the 3rd or 4th post on the thread...)

I think there is a moral obligation on parents to be fair, within reason. This is such blatant favouritism. The present is not a necessity, it's a want.

Carriemac · 15/07/2022 11:19

OP I would be hurt by this. I certainly would not take him to pick up the bike and I would say that you are hurt by his actions .

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:18

Agree with this. It's very unfair to favour one child over another, whether they're 4 or 14 or 40. Also, it does almost ALWAYS seem to be BOYS/MEN who are favoured over girls/women.

I have lost count of the amount of women I know who have brothers who were/are massively favoured over them. Always been the same. Not as bad as it was say, pre 1980s, but still prevalent.

@fairfayrefare YANBU. Flowers

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 11:15

@Léighméleabhair

So glad my adult DC. aren’t self absorbed twits. 😂

Do you say this because you don't spend equally and no one has an issue with this or are you making an assumption that there wouldn't be an issue if you did spend a significant amount on one and nothing on the other?

OP posts:
goldfinchonthelawn · 15/07/2022 11:15

You have every right to feel upset. I would flag it with him and say in an unemotional way, 'I noticed you bought Bro an £800 bike while i just got a card. These things will be remembered when you are old and need care. I hope he plans to look after you since he's clearly the favourite.'

I don't believe in being nice and accommodating to manipulative parents. Make it clear you see what they are up to and it affects how well you regard them.

Floella22 · 15/07/2022 11:12

My db is the golden dc, he also earns the most.
Dm goes to John Lewis and buys him a really expensive Christmas present.
One year she forgot shed bought something and sent him money as well.
I got nothing.
I didn't need a gift but I did and do need to feel loved and I don't.
It's shit OP.

VioletInsolence · 15/07/2022 11:09

I don’t think that anyone can say whether it’s fair because we don’t know the family dynamics. I’m given money because I’m one of society’s failures (in a financial sense only) due to autism (not saying all autistics are failures!) and I’m sure my brother would be perfectly happy with this because he owns a lot of money and it’s clear my mum loves him.

My sister (who has a terrible relationship with my mum) would think very differently.

SpeckledlyHen · 15/07/2022 11:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I think this is a really weird response, and there are some others too. I have two siblings - one has no money so we all chip in and help him and no one begrudges what is spent as we can all see he struggles financially due to ill health. Both my other sibling and I have fairly decent incomes and are self sufficient. If my parents suddenly decided to buy my self sufficient sibling a really expensive birthday present and gave me a card, of course I would be hurt. Whilst it is up to them what they spend their money on the equality of it would sting. I think that is a fairly natural response to most people to be honest.

RubbishRobotFromTheDawnOfTime · 15/07/2022 10:56

I wonder if the posters who say it’s all fine and up to the dad what he does, would do the same to their own children? How would you justify spending £800 on one’s birthday and just a card for the others?

stratforduponavon · 15/07/2022 10:51

Lots of parents do this. I had a friend whose parent said their will would be split amongst the 3 children. What they didnt say is that it wasnt a third split. It was massively in favour of one of the children. They never mentioned it during their lifetime.

It was a horrible thing to do and they left the Executor role to the child getting the least amount as the golden child wasnt even living in the UK and they didnt want to bother them doing all the paperwork.

Our wills are 50% to each child. That wont change.

WonderingWanda · 15/07/2022 10:51

I think it is unfair and a huge disparity. I wouldn't get worked up if my parents spent more on the poorest sibling as an adult but I would be pissed off if they couldn't even bother to buy me a small token on my birthday when they were lavishing extravagant gifts on a sibling. I am sure op if your Dad was unable to afford any gifts and just gave all of you a card that you would feel entirely happy with that because it s the though that counts, but if the thought is this child deserves a big ticket gift and this one deserves none then that is favouritism and I would distance myself in your situation. Your Dad has made it clear how he feels about you.

Glittertwins · 15/07/2022 10:49

Had the same with the in-laws. They got DH nothing out of ordinary for a milestone birthday and had the nerve to ask us to rearrange a birthday meal for his sister to get there.
On the same milestone birthday for the golden sister, she had a holiday and all expenses paid for her.
In their eyes it was fair because she married a deadbeat and I was not that female equivalent for their son.
It never changes, the favouritism is still rife today and we are NC for many reasons.

Gymnopedie · 15/07/2022 10:49

BoJoGoGo · 15/07/2022 08:33

Buying the bike for his DS will give your dad pleasure, focus on that.

Good grief. So the OP is supposed to think of all the pleasure he will get from buying his son something. Doesn't that just rub in the fact that he gets no pleasure from doing anything for the OP? Yet she is the one who's expected to do all the running around for him. Including taking the father to buy the bike for her brother.

OP I hope you at least tell your dad to make his own arrangements for collecting the bike, and stop being so available to do all the other things he expects you to do. You obviously love your brother so I'm not going to say make him pick up the slack, but you don't have to do it either. Your dad should have to work something out for himself.

RubbishRobotFromTheDawnOfTime · 15/07/2022 10:46

I bet when your dad is older and needing help it will be his daughters he thinks of first, not his son.

FernlovingNodosaur · 15/07/2022 10:45

My partners mother and her sisters had this all their lives with their one brother.

Yet when the time came they were still expected to be their fathers default carers, not their life long indulged brother by both their father and said brother. The final insult was dad then sneakily left all his estate including a house to greedy brother, who had done zero caring and not the daughters who had cared for him( He had stated rather deviously. That of course it would be shared out fairly with those looking after him).
So you and your sisters would well be within your rights, when your dad could well need help in his later years. That with your dads obvious devotion between the two, your brother will of course be the one to care for dad and not you ladies.

MrsSkylerWhite · 15/07/2022 10:43

Very much depends on personal circumstances.
we have our eldest several thousand pounds towards a house deposit a couple of years ago. Their much younger sibling didn’t need such money at that time. No doubt we’ll help them in future.

Does your brother need a bike to get to work? We’re looking at them atm and the prices are shocking.

LizziesTwin · 15/07/2022 10:42

You can’t change your dad’s behaviour so the easiest thing is to come to terms with it. Can you and your sisters joke together about how ridiculous it is that your dad has a transparent favourite? I’d try and turn it into a silly habit rather than bear a grudge, it isn’t your brother’s fault that your dad is sexist.

Libre55 · 15/07/2022 10:40

My sister is the golden child, along with her 3 DC. My other DS and I are treated totally differently, maybe because we don’t have DC. My Mothers will splits everything equally between her 3 dc and 3 GC. Fuck it, they can look after her now she is in the early stages of dementia.

Parkperson00 · 15/07/2022 10:39

Usually on MN it is the daughter who is gifted more than the son. Anecdotally, I know loads of my friends who have always been the favoured ones in terms of childcare and house deposits. I think there is some research to support this. I think it is common in Western societies.
I love my siblings and it never really bothered me when some were helped more than others but it was generally in response to need. My MIL favoured her daughter over her son but I saw how much pleasure it gave her and I found it hard to begrudge the happiness and joy it brought to mother and daughter.It truly did not bother me (it wasn't huge sums). It certainly didn't bother my husband which was the main thing.

BeerPongChampion · 15/07/2022 10:39

It’s his money to do as he pleases, but a history of unequal treatment like this affects relationships.

I don’t believe things always have to be equal with every individual thing, but with parents, children should know that overall things are pretty much fair or if they’re not, there’s a good reason.

My partner has 2 siblings, the oldest has always been ‘helped’, given things the others haven't, can do no wrong, it’s a really fucked up dynamic and has affected all of their relationships, parent child and sibling ones. This sibling is not a particular low earner, no health needs, no traumatic events, he’s just favoured and it’s really weird. Of course the parents can do whatever they like, but they have to accept the consequences, and that’s been a lack of closeness to their other children.

On the other hand, my friends sister has had a really bad few years. My friends parents have really helped her out, both with money and their time. My friend is of course fine with this, her sister really needed help getting back on her feet, my friend has helped her too. No bad feeling, they’re family and one of them was in need.

laurajayneinkent · 15/07/2022 10:35

Hi! Do you get thankyou cards/presents for people like Brownie/Guide/Scout leaders and piano/dance teachers at the end of the school year? We do little gifts (max £5 pp) and handmade cards for teachers and TAs, but that's already £30 spent and all my bills are going up at the moment... I do kinda feel like I should get something for the Brownie/Guide leaders as they're volunteers...but there are 4 of them! What do you do?
Same question at Christmas. Thanks!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread