Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this fair? £800 spent only on one of four children?

235 replies

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 06:47

My dad has four children and has been speaking about getting my brother a new bike which costs around £800 for his birthday. He is the only boy and us others are girls. We are all adults well into our 40's.

We all work. Most minimum wage jobs but brother probably has the least disposable income due to house/family costs.

I just got a card for my birthday this year.

Is that fair?

Am I right to be annoyed that we are being treated differently or should I accept it's his money to do as he pleases?

OP posts:
WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 12:00

Nipplestoyou · 15/07/2022 11:51

Oh come on! You're all grown adults!

Maybe a lovely bike is something your dad always regretted not being able to afford for himself so he's excited to be able to treat your brother.

Maybe another year, you'll get the big present and the others will get the card.

Maybe another year, you'll get the big present and the others will get the card.

Yeah that's not going to happen . What a naive comment!

Have you actually bothered reading ANY of the OP's posts apart from the first one?!

As for 'oh come on! You're all grown adults.' Do you feel pleased with yourself for making the OP feel even more shit than she already does. Nice one!!! 👏

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:57

HeckyPeck · 15/07/2022 11:46

They sure are.

And it's always the ones who do the most looking after etc that are overlooked in favour of the one that doesn't.

Exactly, and it's almost ALWAYS the daughters/women who do everything, like looking after elderly parents and relatives etc, and very rarely the sons/men.

Yet the sons/men are almost always favoured. As I said earlier, it doesn't seem to be as bad as it used to be, and I think daughters (born post 1990) seem to be valued more now, but certainly the vast majority of women born 1980s or earlier will have a story to tell about how they have a brother who is favoured - sometimes more than one.

In addition, I know about 9 or 10 families where there are 3 or 4 sons and just 1 daughter (or 2) and the sons have never done ANYTHING for the parents, the daughter(s) do everything for them, yet the sun shines out the sons arses. Fucks me right off it does. Always has!

Nipplestoyou · 15/07/2022 11:51

Oh come on! You're all grown adults!

Maybe a lovely bike is something your dad always regretted not being able to afford for himself so he's excited to be able to treat your brother.

Maybe another year, you'll get the big present and the others will get the card.

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/07/2022 11:50

Sometimes as well kids, people forget.

dh’s (adult) dc was whinging recently about a big ticket item (particular phone) we bought for one of my kids, why did they get that and I didn’t etc.

to start that phone was something they needed for a hobby. It needed to run a particular app that our usual custom of cheap second hand phones wouldn’t do.

secondly when sdc was a similar age his hobby was cycling. We bought him a fairly expensive proper bike, in addition to having bought him previous ones he outgrew. The other kids didn’t get equivalent gifts in the name of fairness.

so as a parent money spent generally averages out over a lifetime. While £800 in one go seems a lot, over 10 or 20 years it’s perfectly possible for him to have spent the equivalent and you have forgotten or not noticed.

BetterFuture1985 · 15/07/2022 11:49

I think it depends on circumstances and needs. I wouldn't worry myself too much if I spent more on one child than another, within reason, provided I was meeting their needs. For example, if one of my children had a hobby that cost twice as much as my other children's hobbies or if one child needed to go on an expensive trip for school or a hobby I wouldn't deny them to be fair on the other two. However, I think giving one child an £800 bike and another just a card is a bit ridiculous even if they are in their 40s, unless next year it's the other child who benefits.

There's also a factor that incomes fluctuate. I can't be as generous to child 2 and child 3 at the moment as I was with child 1 at the same age because my electricity bill is three times as large, the interest rates on my mortgage have risen and things in the shops are more expensive right now. So what people can provide for their children at any given time are going to be shaped by what they have in the bank.

Isonthecase · 15/07/2022 11:47

I think I'd feel a bit funny about this too. It's not the money that matters, it's the changing the goalposts to make things less fair.

My family has always taken the policy that children can be treated differently in terms of spends but the goal should be the same. For instance, my brother's education cost a lot more but the end result was we both had an education somewhere suitable for us. But we also discuss any big differences to make sure everyone understands the thought process and sees why it's the case.

I can't imagine feeling ok with seeing the difference in treatment and not understanding why it's happening but somehow magically being ok with it.

Parkperson00 · 15/07/2022 11:46

There is a lot of research to support this favoritism between mothers and daughters in the UK
theconversation.com/daughters-are-more-willing-to-sacrifice-for-their-mothers-than-for-their-romantic-partners-182410

HeckyPeck · 15/07/2022 11:46

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:44

Vile aren't they?

They sure are.

And it's always the ones who do the most looking after etc that are overlooked in favour of the one that doesn't.

PimmsOfCourse · 15/07/2022 11:45

YANBU. Children have an enormous sense of justice/ injustice. My parents have always given equally to my sister and I but when we bought our respective first homes. they gave more to me as I needed more to buy. She does feel that they favour me more because I was the one who was more uni, job, flat, car, marriage, kids. But I have never felt loved by my parents in any way other than them giving me material stuff.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:45

@entropynow

You're all in your 40s? Blimey. Honestly I couldn't get worked up about this (and yes, I've been in the same situation with a lot more than a few hundred quid involved). Primary school was a long time ago mate.

@Puffalicious

This is really, really unfair. It clearly hurts the OP. She's said she doesn't want his money and loves her brother, it's the blatant injustice of her and her sisters being the ones doing the visiting and her brother being treated as the prodigal son. We can all be hurt no matter what age we are.

My own DF was like this with my sister (there are 5 of us, 3 girls, 2 boys)- she and her children were always clearly his favourites. She didn't ask for it and I love my sister very, very much, but the fact that she accepted lots of money/ things over the years didn't go unnoticed. It actually means her and my brother are NC. Very sad, and we've tried to resolve it, but can't. We all get on with living - I love all of them and find them such wonderful people- it's just sad I can't invite all of my brothers and sisters at the same time. Things like big birthdays/ weddings/ parties it's sad.

Not only really really unfair but quite a spiteful and mean comment too from entropynow Hmm

People don't stop feeling hurt and pain and rejection when they hit the official age of an adult FFS. No, not even when they're in their 40s. Or 50s, or 60s, or 70s etc etc. My grandmother's brother was the golden child and hugely favoured by her parents, especially her mother, and he could do no wrong.

My gran got the shit end of the stick with everything; made to do household chores as a girl when he was made to do NOTHING, more pocket money for him, (as he is a boy!) Hmm cash given to him whenever he asked, and many things bought for him/things done for him. And when the mother died 6 months after the father, the will gave him two thirds of everything and her one third.

Even when she was in her 80s, (some 15-20 years ago not long before she died,) she still talked about how hurt she had always been by her brother being CONSTANTLY favoured, and how upset it still made her. She said it made her insecure and always fearing rejection, and made her feel like she was less worthy. @entropynow your comment is really REALLY mean.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:44

HeckyPeck · 15/07/2022 11:43

I feel sorry for the children of the posters telling you to get over it and it's none of their business.

Are they going to tell their children no presents this year and then have the cheek to ask for a lift to collect a very expensive present for the golden child?

It's a real piss take OP and you're not at all unreasonable to be upset by it.

Vile aren't they?

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:43

Parkperson00 · 15/07/2022 11:41

I don't think it is crappy research. It is a proper study from the Carlson School of Management and Rutgers Business School in the States

I don't care where it's from. It's just a small dose of research that is basically worthless. And as I said, it does NOT negate or cancel out the experiences of millions of women with brothers who have had the brothers favoured over them.

HeckyPeck · 15/07/2022 11:43

I feel sorry for the children of the posters telling you to get over it and it's none of their business.

Are they going to tell their children no presents this year and then have the cheek to ask for a lift to collect a very expensive present for the golden child?

It's a real piss take OP and you're not at all unreasonable to be upset by it.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:42

And even if girls ARE occasionally favoured over boys, a little bit more than they USED to be, that doesn't change the fact that boys have been MASSIVELY favoured over girls for centuries. If you're female and have brothers and THEY were not favoured then you are very fortunate.

Parkperson00 · 15/07/2022 11:41

I don't think it is crappy research. It is a proper study from the Carlson School of Management and Rutgers Business School in the States

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:39

Parkperson00 · 15/07/2022 11:36

@WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps
Not true about UK parents favouring sons. There is a lot of research to show most parents favour the daughter over sons
www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3143788/Bad-news-boys-Researchers-say-parents-prefer-daughters-times-tough.html

One crappy little biased article does not negate the real life experiences of millions of women with brothers, who have had the brothers massively favoured over them.

Parkperson00 · 15/07/2022 11:39

Sorry that article is from the Mail. Here is one that references the original research
www.business-standard.com/article/news-ians/daughters-favoured-over-sons-in-hard-times-115063000497_1.html

Parkperson00 · 15/07/2022 11:36

@WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps
Not true about UK parents favouring sons. There is a lot of research to show most parents favour the daughter over sons
www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3143788/Bad-news-boys-Researchers-say-parents-prefer-daughters-times-tough.html

luxxlisbon · 15/07/2022 11:36

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 08:01

You know this is actually what I intend to do. There really isn't any other option.

I guess I just wanted to sense check if my feelings were valid.

Out of interest so you spend different amounts on family members and if so is there a reason for this?

Yes, I have 2 brothers one is working full time and the other is at university. I treat the youngest more as he doesn’t have the means himself.
I really don’t think there’s anything unfair about that.

GCHeretic · 15/07/2022 11:34

Libre55 · 15/07/2022 10:40

My sister is the golden child, along with her 3 DC. My other DS and I are treated totally differently, maybe because we don’t have DC. My Mothers will splits everything equally between her 3 dc and 3 GC. Fuck it, they can look after her now she is in the early stages of dementia.

It looks as though she maybe understood you quite well and acted accordingly.

AryaStarkWolf · 15/07/2022 11:34

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 08:14

Completely get that especially having seen some examples on this thread.

I think I have a particularly strong moral compass and that draws my attention to what I deem as unfairness.

At the start of the year around my birthday it was all oh no presents for anyone this year etc etc now it's brothers birthday next week and the tune has changed to can you take me to collect his bike!

If it were me I'd say something, he's spending £800 on 1 of his children, he could have gotten all his kids birthday presents worth £200 which would have been very generous and fair. I have 2 kids I couldn't imagine buying a birthday present for one of them and just giving the other a card.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 15/07/2022 11:34

So glad my adult DC. aren’t self absorbed twits.

Sounds like their mother is a bit of twit though.

Shame for them.

OhItsSpicyy · 15/07/2022 11:33

I think more details needed. Why does he need an £800 bike? Is it a hobby, does he drive? Does he not drive and his old bike is knackered so he has no way go getting around and this is a sensible purchase? If £800 was to be spent on you what would be the equivalent? I think a bike is a bit different to a flatscreen TV.

As an adult I wouldn’t get too worked up about this really. I have younger siblings (11+12) and my parents make sure to spend the same on them as they notice and get jealous. I’m in my 20’s and she doesn’t spend anywhere near as much as me. I don’t need her to buy me a gaming computer or a PS5. When I was 19/21 I know she spent a hell of a lot more on me than she did on them because she’d help me out with some bills, food & she bought me a MacBook for uni. She was constantly chucking me £50 here and £50 there.

savebuckbeak · 15/07/2022 11:32

Did you brother particularly want a bike? Is it something he'd been expressing for a while?

Last year I really wanted to buy a new camera and had been going on about it for ages; I earn less much less than my older brother, so my parents got me one for my birthday. My brother had expressed no similar wish in terms of something he particularly wanted. Were my parents obliged to give him £1200 (the cost of my camera) just to make it "fair"? Other times, I'm sure he's gotten things or gifts from my parents due to specifically wanting those things. I've not expected to receive the monetary value of his gift, just for the sake of evening it out!

But it sounds like this is maybe a deeper rooted issue, and not just about the bike? Has your dad historically favoured your brother? Do you generally feel you're treated with generosity?

ifIwerenotanandroid · 15/07/2022 11:27

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 08:14

Completely get that especially having seen some examples on this thread.

I think I have a particularly strong moral compass and that draws my attention to what I deem as unfairness.

At the start of the year around my birthday it was all oh no presents for anyone this year etc etc now it's brothers birthday next week and the tune has changed to can you take me to collect his bike!

I must admit I'd be tempted to say, "No," to that last request. Or maybe to ask, "Are we picking up mine & my sisters' bikes at the same time? No? Well, sort it out yourself, then!".

The only time my parents announced that they would give me exactly what they'd given my brother was when DH & I announced our engagement: they said they'd given him £X as a wedding present a few years before, & we could decide if we wanted that amount as a wedding present or to pay for the reception.

This was decades ago, when it was traditional for the bride's parents to pay for the wedding, & this was their way of getting out of that. I wonder how long they'd tried to find a way to weasel out of paying & still feel they were in the right!