Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this fair? £800 spent only on one of four children?

235 replies

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 06:47

My dad has four children and has been speaking about getting my brother a new bike which costs around £800 for his birthday. He is the only boy and us others are girls. We are all adults well into our 40's.

We all work. Most minimum wage jobs but brother probably has the least disposable income due to house/family costs.

I just got a card for my birthday this year.

Is that fair?

Am I right to be annoyed that we are being treated differently or should I accept it's his money to do as he pleases?

OP posts:
ancientgran · 15/07/2022 13:09

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 07:08

Does it make it any more or less fair depending on what the reason is?

Favouritism

Subsidy for the fact they have more bills / less disposable income

Somehow trying to win approval (this sibling visits the least, us others are the ones taking to appointments/shopping etc)

If the reason is enough for your father to decide to give more then yes I think it is. I'm thinking of a friend who had a hissy fit when her husband wanted to give xthousand pounds a year to her step daughter when she was at university. Her daughter hadn't gone to university so he felt she didn't need help with university which seemed perfectly reasonable to me but she thought it was very unfair.

Was funny when her daughter decided to go to uni as a mature student and was very grateful for the help which she wouldn't have got if she'd had it just because ten years earlier.

Or there is my cousin who got several thousand pounds from her parents when she needed IVF is she was going to be able to have a baby. Her siblings had children, if her parents had to give them all the same she couldn't have afforded that treatment as she had spent every penny already so I think that was fair and her siblings seemed to think so as well.

So I suppose I'd think would your father help you if you needed it and if he would then I'd think it was OK, if he'd only give to your brother even if he was OK and you were in need then no I wouldn't think it was OK but what I think isn't really relevant as it is his money.

AmyDudley · 15/07/2022 13:08

You are not unreasonable to feel as you do and your feelings are valid. Of course it is your Dad's money to do as he pleases but, he has made a choice to treat one child differently and that is hurtful. I'm guessing it is not about the money it is about fairness and if he spent a fiver on each of you you would be fine with that.

I have found (after a lifetime, from childhood, of being treated unfairly and one sibling being very much the favourite) that you have to let it go for your own peace of mind. Otherwise you only upset yourself mulling it over, feeling hurt or angry.

I just decided to ignore whatever was given to my oldest sibling, (and we are talking private school fees for her children, her rent paid every month, driving lessons as an adult, lawyers fees for her very protracted divorce and custody battles and many many other things over the course of many years) It hurts because we equate being treated equally with being loved equally. It doesn't necessarily equate, I think a lot of it comes out of guilt, out of being pressurized and being unable to say no to the favourite.

I have a very close relationship with my other sibling, and with my children an that is worth far more to me than any kind of money or gifts. I think you have to let it drift over you, cherish what you have and accept that this is the way it is. Your dad will probably not change, if you bring it up he'll probably just be secretive about what he gives your brother.

Gymnopedie · 15/07/2022 13:07

GCAcademic · 15/07/2022 12:35

I’m curious to hear from the posters telling the OP that she is being unreasonable and that her father perfectly justified in his spending whether they also treat their children inequitably and — if so — how they justify this? In what circumstances would you give one adult child a card for their birthday and another a £800 gift?

And by the same token I wonder how many of these keyboard warrior PPs saying it's all perfectly OK and the OP's an adult so she doesn't have the right to be upset, would be equally sanguine if it was happening to them and they got a cheap card while the golden child got everything? But still being expected to be the one who does all the fetching and carrying?

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 15/07/2022 13:02

And PS, there is a big difference between 'its not fair' meaning that person got a £20 present and mine was £10 and that person got an extravagant present and I got nothing.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 15/07/2022 13:01

I wonder if your dad has a blind spot about what he is doing? My mother was like this, all the daughters knew the only son was the favourite but mum was genuinely flabbergasted when the unfairness was pointed out by one of my uncles. On one level she has to have known but she was obviously able to explain it away. It still hurts she did that though, and you have every right to feel upset. Have you told him how you feel?

Flakjacketon · 15/07/2022 12:57

My mum did this. She clearly favoured my brother over my sister and I and this extended into adulthood - to the tune of thousands of pounds. I tried to talk to her about it - unemotionally, logically and with examples - but she just couldn't/wouldn't see it.
One day I told her that my brother was upset by the fact that she clearly favoured him and by the way she treated my sister and I (he was).
She burst into tears - not because she had seen the light - but because the last thing she wanted to do was upset her son. 😆

girlmom21 · 15/07/2022 12:54

GCAcademic · 15/07/2022 12:35

I’m curious to hear from the posters telling the OP that she is being unreasonable and that her father perfectly justified in his spending whether they also treat their children inequitably and — if so — how they justify this? In what circumstances would you give one adult child a card for their birthday and another a £800 gift?

In circumstances where realistically you're not in a position to give gifts to all your children but in this instance you feel the child's need is greater than anybody else's?

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/07/2022 12:53

The question was about adult children

but why is it different for adult children? Like pp have said as long as it’s not always one child, but why can’t a parent spend £800 on a birthday for an adult child, as long as if ever another child wants/needs a similar value item in the future they will get it?

in the o/p’s case it does sound like she is fairly sure this won’t happen and the brother is being treated differently, but in the general scheme of things there’s nothing wrong with splashing out on one child one year and doing the same for another a few years later.

ThisMuch · 15/07/2022 12:49

AryaStarkWolf · 15/07/2022 12:11

I find it kind of weird that so many people are saying that she's BU, just because (by the nature of this forum) I presume that most of the posters are mothers(or fathers) themselves? As a mother I can't fathom only buying one of my children a birthday gift and just giving a card to the other

Agreed!

ouch321 · 15/07/2022 12:49

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:57

Exactly, and it's almost ALWAYS the daughters/women who do everything, like looking after elderly parents and relatives etc, and very rarely the sons/men.

Yet the sons/men are almost always favoured. As I said earlier, it doesn't seem to be as bad as it used to be, and I think daughters (born post 1990) seem to be valued more now, but certainly the vast majority of women born 1980s or earlier will have a story to tell about how they have a brother who is favoured - sometimes more than one.

In addition, I know about 9 or 10 families where there are 3 or 4 sons and just 1 daughter (or 2) and the sons have never done ANYTHING for the parents, the daughter(s) do everything for them, yet the sun shines out the sons arses. Fucks me right off it does. Always has!

Have two brothers.

Am female, 1980s born.

Can concur.

Unforgettablefire · 15/07/2022 12:47

OP you have every right to be upset. It's not so much about the cost or help, or what the gift is it's the meaning behind it. I've watched blatant favouritism my whole life and I'm very careful to treat all family members the same no matter their ages or finances. It's vile singling one person out for special treatment it's hurtful and so damaging I couldn't do it to anyone.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 15/07/2022 12:47

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/07/2022 12:37

In what circumstances would you give one adult child a card for their birthday and another a £800 gift?

see my post above. I bought one child a 2k laptop, the other got about £100 in gifts.

this will balance out in a few years when the youngest is doing their a’levels and needs a laptop.

The question was about adult children.

Your solution of buying a big gift when anyone reaches 16 seems perfectly reasonable, for dependent children (as long as it happens that way).

ThisMuch · 15/07/2022 12:46

Hurstlandshome · 15/07/2022 07:34

I hate the 'fair' debate. You should be able to give your money to whomsoever you wish.

Your dad wants to treat his son and will probably get a lot of gratification from handing the bike over. He might not want to spend another £2400. Let him live.

Sure. Obtaining gratification from buying an expensive gift for the favoured child is far more important than being sensitive about and mindful of his other children's feelings.

It's not the damn money, it's the attention and love. It makes the other children feel less worthy of their dad's love.

AryaStarkWolf · 15/07/2022 12:44

@Reallyreallyborednow Sorry for tagging you again, I just wanted to expand on what I think the differences are, obviously your daughter needed a decent laptop for her education (and she'll also be able to use it for entertainment etc) There's really no circumstances where the brother of the OP needed a bike worth £800 that's ALOT to spend on a bike and it's obviously for a hobby/competing, you could get a decent bike for transport (if that's why he needed it) for a fraction of that price

maddy68 · 15/07/2022 12:44

Why didn't you say? Where's my present you tight arse?.

DashOfMilkNoSugar · 15/07/2022 12:43

It's strange because I really don't actually want his money. I earn my own and take pride in that.

I also get in well with brother and don't want to begrudge him anything.

Youve answered your own question - you should accept that it’s his money and forget about it. Or you could always let the tyres down when your brother isn’t looking 😉

AryaStarkWolf · 15/07/2022 12:40

@Reallyreallyborednow Sure there's nothing wrong with that, you still didn't get your other child no present at all though and this is what the main issue is

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/07/2022 12:37

In what circumstances would you give one adult child a card for their birthday and another a £800 gift?

see my post above. I bought one child a 2k laptop, the other got about £100 in gifts.

this will balance out in a few years when the youngest is doing their a’levels and needs a laptop.

GCAcademic · 15/07/2022 12:35

I’m curious to hear from the posters telling the OP that she is being unreasonable and that her father perfectly justified in his spending whether they also treat their children inequitably and — if so — how they justify this? In what circumstances would you give one adult child a card for their birthday and another a £800 gift?

Ponderingwindow · 15/07/2022 12:35

If it is always biased in one direction, then rifts will form and that is a problem. As long as things balance in the long term, I don’t think gifts need to be equal all the time.

i was visiting with my family once and my dad had just bought my sister a piece of furniture as a gift. It was something that had come up that she that she absolutely loved but couldn’t afford. He wanted to give me cash to make things fair. I declined and told him that some day there would be some perfect gift for me and I would get my turn then. He wouldn’t be able to afford to splurge on either of us if he always had to match the cost.

that is my philosophy with gift giving as well. I have a general budget. Occasionally I find the perfect thing for someone and break that budget. I just make sure I’m not always doing that for the same person repeatedly.

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/07/2022 12:35

As a mother I can't fathom only buying one of my children a birthday gift and just giving a card to the other

no, but my eldest got a macbook for her 16th as she needs it for her a’levels.

my youngest got a gift, but nowhere near that value. However they will also get a macbook for their 16th, or, if they choose, something of equivalent value.

i can’t afford to spend 4k on birthdays because one is getting something they need as a gift and I am expected to match both kids every time.

I’m on my 40s and if my Mum goes out clothes shopping with my sister and buys her something, I get the same amount of money in the post to spend.

this is ok if you can afford it. But I will just spend the money the next time I take the other one shopping, or top up a birthday gift, or buy something they need. Constantly matching every single penny seems a bit overkill.

Arucanafeather · 15/07/2022 12:23

I’m on my 40s and if my Mum goes out clothes shopping with my sister and buys her something, I get the same amount of money in the post to spend 😁I always say thank you but there is no need but my Mum and Dad have always wanted us to feel equally valued. Doesn’t always mean we get treated the same as we have had different needs and my sister lives a lot closer than I do etc but in circumstance where they can - eg amount spent on birthdays they always do. It does matter IMO.

FeliciaFancybottom · 15/07/2022 12:16

As a fully grown adult you really should be past all this 'it's not fair' crap.

AryaStarkWolf · 15/07/2022 12:11

I find it kind of weird that so many people are saying that she's BU, just because (by the nature of this forum) I presume that most of the posters are mothers(or fathers) themselves? As a mother I can't fathom only buying one of my children a birthday gift and just giving a card to the other

SpeckledlyHen · 15/07/2022 12:05

Nipplestoyou · 15/07/2022 11:51

Oh come on! You're all grown adults!

Maybe a lovely bike is something your dad always regretted not being able to afford for himself so he's excited to be able to treat your brother.

Maybe another year, you'll get the big present and the others will get the card.

Why don't people get the full gist of the thread and read it before commenting?