Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this fair? £800 spent only on one of four children?

235 replies

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 06:47

My dad has four children and has been speaking about getting my brother a new bike which costs around £800 for his birthday. He is the only boy and us others are girls. We are all adults well into our 40's.

We all work. Most minimum wage jobs but brother probably has the least disposable income due to house/family costs.

I just got a card for my birthday this year.

Is that fair?

Am I right to be annoyed that we are being treated differently or should I accept it's his money to do as he pleases?

OP posts:
GCHeretic · 15/07/2022 16:18

GCAcademic · 15/07/2022 12:35

I’m curious to hear from the posters telling the OP that she is being unreasonable and that her father perfectly justified in his spending whether they also treat their children inequitably and — if so — how they justify this? In what circumstances would you give one adult child a card for their birthday and another a £800 gift?

If one had had their bike stolen and couldn’t get to work, or was depressed and thought that getting out on a bike might help.

If my parents bought my brother a bike that he wanted it needed I’d be happy for him. If they ever got me more than a bar of chocolate of an M&S top I’d be unhappy, as I earn far, far more than they ever did and I’d not want them spending money on me.

Hatsoff5 · 15/07/2022 16:16

Lilbunnyfufu · 15/07/2022 15:41

My mum always put £50 in my birthday card, £25 in my younger sisters card and buys my brother's high value items.
It's always been like this.
She's the same with the Grandkids the two girls can ask for anything they want and she will get it. The boys are lucky if the get £5.00 off her.
At the end of the day it may seem unfair but it's her money and she can spend it how she wants. she works hard to earn so nobody should tell her how to spend it.

With your mums own children your mum can do whatever she likes. However her grandkids which are YOUR children.... no the buck stops with you. I wouldn't want my children to notice that type of pattern or to think that's how life works it's not correct.

bobbinsboo · 15/07/2022 16:15

My in-laws are like this but much more extreme. They've just treated BIL family to a £15k holiday (one of many); spent £30k on their wedding whilst not wanting to contribute to ours; temporarily paid off BIL mortgage to help them buy a house; moving closer to BIL family so now barely see our kids-the list is endless. We confronted them, huge argument that there's no going back from. I'm now NC due to this blatant favouritism that has completely ruined this relationship. They however see me as the bad guy though as I've dared stand up to them (for once). It's their choice what they do with their money but there is also a consequence to these actions and it's bit them on the ass!!

GCHeretic · 15/07/2022 16:14

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 11:39

One crappy little biased article does not negate the real life experiences of millions of women with brothers, who have had the brothers massively favoured over them.

The research it references does though.

Lilbunnyfufu · 15/07/2022 15:41

My mum always put £50 in my birthday card, £25 in my younger sisters card and buys my brother's high value items.
It's always been like this.
She's the same with the Grandkids the two girls can ask for anything they want and she will get it. The boys are lucky if the get £5.00 off her.
At the end of the day it may seem unfair but it's her money and she can spend it how she wants. she works hard to earn so nobody should tell her how to spend it.

ThisMuch · 15/07/2022 15:35

Isonthecase · 15/07/2022 11:47

I think I'd feel a bit funny about this too. It's not the money that matters, it's the changing the goalposts to make things less fair.

My family has always taken the policy that children can be treated differently in terms of spends but the goal should be the same. For instance, my brother's education cost a lot more but the end result was we both had an education somewhere suitable for us. But we also discuss any big differences to make sure everyone understands the thought process and sees why it's the case.

I can't imagine feeling ok with seeing the difference in treatment and not understanding why it's happening but somehow magically being ok with it.

I think this is actually a brilliant approach as parents. Sometimes you don't need as much money as your sibling because your needs/ interests are different, and that's okay. What matters is that everyone is part of the conversation and decision-making process, so as a result no one ends up feeling like they are being excluded or getting the short end of the stick. Again, money is often symbolic and not the reason why favouritism hurts.

And as a bonus, siblings learn to acknowledge and respect each other's needs and to be generous when it's their turn, which is fundamental if the parents want to foster a healthy relationship among their children. Fantastic approach indeed.

OP, YANBU. The people telling you that you are, are probably parents that have unsuccessfully managed this dilemma with their own kids or the favoured child in their family.

strivingtosucceed · 15/07/2022 15:22

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 06:47

My dad has four children and has been speaking about getting my brother a new bike which costs around £800 for his birthday. He is the only boy and us others are girls. We are all adults well into our 40's.

We all work. Most minimum wage jobs but brother probably has the least disposable income due to house/family costs.

I just got a card for my birthday this year.

Is that fair?

Am I right to be annoyed that we are being treated differently or should I accept it's his money to do as he pleases?

When you said £800 bike, I thought you were all teens/young adults. I don't know if I could get worked up about that amount in my 40s especially if I wasn't destitute at the time.

Maybe your brother just has a better relationship or he's the golden child, I don't see a point totting up what's been done for each child and keeping score.

AryaStarkWolf · 15/07/2022 14:45

AlexandriasWindmill · 15/07/2022 14:15

It's not that you have a strong moral compass. It's that you're confusing treating everyone the exact same with equality or fairness. A PP explained very eloquently why that isn't the case.
For example, in our school, pupils can't use the elevator. But if a pupil is on crutches or in a wheelchair - saying they can't use the elevator puts them at a disadvantage. Letting them (and only them) use the lift gives them 'equal' access to the second floor. That's not favouritism. It's equity
My DM always gave more money and gifts to my DB. It wasn't because of favouritism. It was because DB (for a number of reasons) had more bills, less income and always struggled financially.
You seem to be equating money with love but sometimes a bike is just a bike.

I understand that but I don't think the OPs situation is an example of that. Announcing to your 4 children that you're not getting any Birthday presents for them this year and giving 3 of them a card and then turning around and spending a huge amount on one is not equity. A child on crutches needs to use the elevator to get to the second floor, no one needs an £800 bike.........

BeggarsMeddle · 15/07/2022 14:36

I think the problem is not that OP's brother was given a bike costing £800 but more that OP's father has told everyone what it cost.

Bearsan · 15/07/2022 14:33

Yanbu.
Parents that do these nasty moves motives are not because they are being kind or helping out, it's to divide and conquer, play silly games and control. They're fucked up and the favourite golden child is always fucked up too.
Don't waste your breath talking about it to your father, he knows exactly what he is doing, he won't change.

Charmatt · 15/07/2022 14:20

My parents had/have treated us differently, but according to need. I don't have any problems with it, but I think the way we were all treated was fair, if not equally at different times.

I think some of my siblings have not treated them fairly though, in return!

I think fairness incorporates many different things - need, necessity, emergency, etc. eg, I moved out at 22, but my siblings stayed longer (for different lengths of time), my brother needed expensive equipment when he was a student and it was bought for him, I had my wedding paid for (I was the only girl and it was the custom at that time)....

Ultimately, if you think you have been treated unfairly, and this is a consistent pattern, you either need to talk to your father, or keep quiet, but it will fester if you aren't happy with it.

AlexandriasWindmill · 15/07/2022 14:15

It's not that you have a strong moral compass. It's that you're confusing treating everyone the exact same with equality or fairness. A PP explained very eloquently why that isn't the case.
For example, in our school, pupils can't use the elevator. But if a pupil is on crutches or in a wheelchair - saying they can't use the elevator puts them at a disadvantage. Letting them (and only them) use the lift gives them 'equal' access to the second floor. That's not favouritism. It's equity
My DM always gave more money and gifts to my DB. It wasn't because of favouritism. It was because DB (for a number of reasons) had more bills, less income and always struggled financially.
You seem to be equating money with love but sometimes a bike is just a bike.

AryaStarkWolf · 15/07/2022 14:10

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 15/07/2022 13:02

And PS, there is a big difference between 'its not fair' meaning that person got a £20 present and mine was £10 and that person got an extravagant present and I got nothing.

Exactly

IvorCutler · 15/07/2022 14:06

Meh. Maybe your time will come around? If he feels compelled/really wants to buy it for your brother, I don’t see the harm.

IncompleteSenten · 15/07/2022 13:55

It is both his own money therefore his choice and unfair.

I am very much of the 'fuck him' school of thought.

When he reaches a point he needs help, golden boy can do it. I wouldn't be helping with shopping or appointments or anything.

He picked his winner. He should stick with them.

BritWifeInUSA · 15/07/2022 13:44

As much you get along with and like your brother, you don’t know the full story because that’s between him and your dad.

You don’t know if your brother helped your dad out with something (not necessarily financially) and this is your dad’s way of thanking him. Or maybe the bike is because your brother is going to use it to make money as a bicycle delivery man or something to help feed his family and your dad is helping him get started. You don’t know the full story because they don’t have to tell you the full story.

At the risk of trotting out an old MN cliche…”at least you have a dad and you still have a good relationship with him”… Not everyone can say that.

It’s a bike. It’s your father and your brother. Is it really worth so much negative energy?

Crafty09 · 15/07/2022 13:40

My mother might do something like this if one of us really needed something. She would try and level it up at some point but not always possible. Generally I just think it’s her money she can do what she likes and she has helped me loads in the past. I wonder if you are not secure about your place in his affections so this bothers you? Which would be an entirely reasonable reaction, because it’s not really about the bike is it?

AmyDudley · 15/07/2022 13:37

*Oldest has received £k thousands more in financial support from us than middle child as he earns far less. Eldest has a first from an elite University, middle child dropped out in final year. Middle child has an exceedingly well paid career and our youngest is still at school.

Recently, middle child and dad were discussing finances and he mentioned in passing that he had to pay an extra £30k when buying his house because it’s not classed as his only home. Oldest didn’t want to sell the house they both jointly own and rent out. (That was from an inheritance given to them both many years ago).

I strongly suspect that middle child didn’t bother to tell oldest that it was going to cost him an extra 30k to buy the house otherwise, I’m certain that oldest would have immediately agreed to sell their joint asset. Oldest is kindness itself, and he chooses to work in a social care type field which despite working unsocial hours, is very poorly paid in contrast to middle child’s earnings.

When my mum died, 3/4 of what she left went to my disabled brother because that’s what all 5 siblings agreed was the right thing to do.

I feel sorry for children who are growing up expecting equal shares in everything. It’s completely the wrong lesson to teach, in my opinion. 🤔*

What is really hurtful is not the lack of equal financial gifts, but the knowledge that a parent has a clear and obvious favourite and has no shame about it. That hurts and causes long term damage.

Inertia · 15/07/2022 13:36

It’s not about the money, it’s about demonstrations of love and thoughtfulness. I can see where OP is coming from. It’s fair enough to spend more on certain items for one child if everything balances out over time. However, if one child repeatedly receives extravagant gifts and others are ignored then it’s easy to see why the siblings would feel rejected.

I think there’s something in the suggestion that the more you do to help out your relatives, the more they take you for granted.

If I were feeling diplomatic I’d say what @Pheasantplucker2 suggested. What I’d actually feel like doing is clubbing together with siblings to buy bike panniers or a rucksack, and say how great it is that brother can now do all the shopping/prescription collections for parents on his bike.

AStar98 · 15/07/2022 13:35

I thought I was on my own on this one, glad I'm not after reading a few comments!

My dad has always favoured my brother over me, very emotional speech at his wedding, expensive gifts, hobbies, first car(s).

My brother has never been career-orientated or particularly driven in that sense, I've been the opposite so I can earn a decent living (not rely on parents) and qualified in my profession a few years ago... I don't recall even a 'well done'.

I do remember one particular Christmas being told a few days beforehand by my dad that brother would have significantly more gifts than me... I'm not sure how a 9yo is supposed to take that.

I got the feeling he has a taste of his own when my mum (treats everyone fairly!) had a significant birthday this year and we took her away for the weekend. Presumably he compared it to his significant birthday and felt deflated. Although, my gift to him was more considerate than his gift to me for my 30th... a '30s survival kit' consisting of a handful of plastic crap stuffed into an organza bag.

IWentAwayIStayedAway · 15/07/2022 13:27

and they've asked you for help to collect it!!

UnbeatenMum · 15/07/2022 13:26

I think I would have to say something tbh. It's just such a lack of care for your feelings to do this and expect you to drive him to pick it up.

gamerchick · 15/07/2022 13:20

OP your feelings are valid, it's blatantly unfair but it is what it is. It's cheap for you though as you're a part of the no present thing. Cards for him for his birthday.

Léighméleabhair · 15/07/2022 13:19

fairfayrefare · 15/07/2022 11:15

@Léighméleabhair

So glad my adult DC. aren’t self absorbed twits. 😂

Do you say this because you don't spend equally and no one has an issue with this or are you making an assumption that there wouldn't be an issue if you did spend a significant amount on one and nothing on the other?

Oldest has received £k thousands more in financial support from us than middle child as he earns far less. Eldest has a first from an elite University, middle child dropped out in final year. Middle child has an exceedingly well paid career and our youngest is still at school.

Recently, middle child and dad were discussing finances and he mentioned in passing that he had to pay an extra £30k when buying his house because it’s not classed as his only home. Oldest didn’t want to sell the house they both jointly own and rent out. (That was from an inheritance given to them both many years ago).

I strongly suspect that middle child didn’t bother to tell oldest that it was going to cost him an extra 30k to buy the house otherwise, I’m certain that oldest would have immediately agreed to sell their joint asset. Oldest is kindness itself, and he chooses to work in a social care type field which despite working unsocial hours, is very poorly paid in contrast to middle child’s earnings.

When my mum died, 3/4 of what she left went to my disabled brother because that’s what all 5 siblings agreed was the right thing to do.

I feel sorry for children who are growing up expecting equal shares in everything. It’s completely the wrong lesson to teach, in my opinion. 🤔

waterSpider · 15/07/2022 13:10

I think children carry mental scars for a long time if they see their parents treating their siblings differently from them, at any age, and even if in quite trivial ways. See various threads about wills and inheritance, for instance.