Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To walk out of A&E

116 replies

Usernamqwerty · 14/07/2022 23:53

I've been here since 18:00 with what started as suspected appendicitis (from a GP visit this afternoon). Surgeon examined me and said looks like a kidney infection. I had a CT scan nearly 4 hours ago and still waiting on a chair in the busy stuffy waiting area.

There are trolleys lining the corridors here. It's so busy. I asked the nurse when I might hear and she said the doctor will get to me when they can. I might be here all night, I have no idea!

I am shattered, hot and bored and I just want to go home 😭. What happens if I leave? Can I ask them to send my GP the scan report and antibiotics request?

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 15/07/2022 10:12

@viques

We either all need to pay more directly through taxation ( and hope the system is made more efficient so as not to waste our payments)

We ARE paying more. Brown/Blair increased NIC twice to "save the NHS" but they spunked the money on pay rises and PFI. NIC has been rising over the past 20 years and bringing in huge amounts of extra money. Spending on the NHS trebled under Blair/Brown. Unfortunately, they didn't match that with improving efficiency and reducing waste nor any meaningful reform. The sad truth is that the NHS is a leaky bucket, and the holes in the bucket are getting bigger. Throwing ever increasing amounts of money at it without proper reform is pointless - a bit will indeed get to improve treatment, but the majority will either be wasted or lost to fraud. More layers of management/bureaucracy isn't the answer.

Badbadbunny · 15/07/2022 10:03

@iloveeverykindofcat

Trying to get a hospital and GP to talk to each other after you've left is one of the hardest things.

Same with long term condition supposedly "jointly" managed between the GP and a hospital consultant.

My OH has incurable cancer. It's a constant game of "ping pong" between the oncologist and GP surgery with OH being piggy in the middle. They simply won't talk to eachother - it's always messages passed between them via my OH.

Latest fiasco is an oncology blood test showing very low Vit D. Oncologist wouldn't prescribe, so told OH to ask the GP to prescribe. Six sodding months later and he's still not got a prescription! GP insisted on doing their own blood tests as they couldn't access the oncology results. Then, yes, saw Vit D was dangerously low, but wouldn't prescribe because of "possible" effects of taking chemo at the same time, so told OH to go back and ask oncologist about contra-indications. Oncologist told OH, no, it's fine, that's why she said to get them, so back to GP, who then decided he needed to consult with a colleague, and so it goes on. He was already on the higher over the counter Vit D tablet, which he told the oncologist and GP (oncologist had recommended it at start of chemo), but latest "message" from GP via the receptionist is that he and his colleague think the strongest over the counter Vit D is the answer - they're absolutely and utterly hopeless!

TheFallenMadonna · 15/07/2022 10:01

10% on diabetes overall, T1D and T2D. And the way to effectively address that is to screen, and support people at risk of T2D to complete an intensive lifestyle change programme. That's going to require an investment now, while costs of treating complications are still so high.

Roystonv · 15/07/2022 09:39

Many years ago I worked in the planning department of a hospital. Those who they could not discharge were called bed blockers. It has gone on for years and never been resolved just got worse. As long as you have the split between social and medical care it will continue. As long as there are no convalescent homes it will continue and very bluntly and against many peoples beliefs as long as we continue to think that the elderly must be saved it will continue. I am a member of dignity in dying and would be quite happy to choose my time to go. My mother too but a fall then dementia kept her in living death for months. Sorry if I have offended or upset readers.

viques · 15/07/2022 09:37

applesandoranges221 · 15/07/2022 09:09

Errrm.... I don't know how your car insurance works, but I pay mine and then - and this is the VERY crucial difference - if I have a problem, they are there and fix it! They don't ask me what solution I suggest to my dented bumper, they assess it, arrange repairs, deal with the other party etc.

Unlike the NHS, where seemingly I have to pay the premium only to have a nurse shrug at me and ask me what solution I suggest to being ill.

Also: please speak for yourself - I rarely go near the NHS, never mind wasting appointments or drugs or the rest of the things in your ramble.

That’s excellent news, thank you for staying healthy, unfortunately we are a country of getting on for 60 million people and a fair number of those do abuse the system one way or another. And sadly many don’t take care of their own health, take diabetes T2 for example, estimates are that 10% of the entire NHS budget is spent on this one, largely preventable, disease and its complications. Like you I pay car insurance, but also try to maintain my car so that the chance of an accident because of brake failure, or other mechanical problems is reduced.

safetyfreak · 15/07/2022 09:36

We went to A&E which was recommended by our useless doctor regarding our baby daughter. She had a fever and was not drinking much fluids.
We waited over 4 hours and then in anger we left, we felt able to leave as thankfully during that time she perked up/fever went down and she took a bottle.

I feel the GPs are failing the public and the easy answer now is for them to say “go to A&E” which are making the problems worse.

There was also a man there who been patched up but had to wait in A&E to make sure his test results got sent to another hospital, why? Again its stupid.

peridito · 15/07/2022 09:33

I take your point that there isn't the physical space ,this is what I assumed I suppose .

Don't agree with this As there’s no actual reason to be there else though - it's pretty dire waiting in pain ,scared ,uncomfortable and surrounded by others who are variously calling out ,vomiting and bleeding (not exaggerating here) and staff too busy to cope .

Still ,that's the situation we're in .

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 15/07/2022 09:18

@applesandoranges221 PALS don't actually handle complaints - if you want to put in a formal complaint there will be a different process. Lots of people 'complain' to PALS, get a conciliatory letter, and CBA to push.

The NHS is currently broken. Unless you have cancer or a serious emergency you're going to wait.

And the candidates for leadership are competing on how much and how quickly they are going to cut taxes.

We're doomed.

(See also: reductions in social care funding, fetishisation of "independence" in old age + focus on quantity not quality of life, short-termism of NHS funding, Brexit, closed-shop NHS management processes...).

CallOnMe · 15/07/2022 09:13

Can someone tell me what the position is re being accompanied by a responsible person while you wait in A&E ? To fetch water/fold up coat to make pillow /hold hand .

Unless the person is a child, elderly or vulnerable then other people shouldn’t be there.

It’s the reason why so many people have nowhere to sit and why it’s so hot in there because people come with an extra person.

It would be better to drop off some food and drink or phone charger etc. As there’s no actual reason to be there else.

applesandoranges221 · 15/07/2022 09:09

viques · 15/07/2022 07:21

Haven’t needed the NHS in years …. Continue to get hundreds in NI from me every month

that being the way insurance works. If you had been taken to A and E by air ambulance after a serious car crash , had needed extensive surgery and rehab then you would have got the value of your NI contributions back instantly. I personally would rather just know it was there like my house and car insurance.

We have a chronically underfunded service because a) it is a hugely expensive and inefficiently run dinosaur and b) none of us are actually paying enough to fund it properly. The whole thing needs a rethink, when the NHS started the medical procedures on offer were remarkably basic, if you had a cancer diagnosis you had surgery then you died. If you had a heart attack you died. If you got older than 70 you died, if you were born with certain conditions you died. We now have an ageing population with often increasingly complicated health needs , we also have much higher expectations of what can be offered medically and surgically for previously terminal or life limiting conditions, we expect very expensive interventions to be offered routinely either through drug therapy, medical or surgical intervention. All of this is right and proper and no one wants to go back to Nightingale wards of patients obediently lying in their beautifully made beds waiting for visiting hour.

But we then waste appointments by not bothering to turn up, we demand and then not use our heavily subsidised medications, we abuse and overwork expensively trained staff so they don’t stay in the job, we phone for ambulances for minor ailments , and essentially piss a lot of the resources we have paid for up the wall. We don’t take care of our basic health so that largely preventable diseases like diabetes are not draining resources from other areas of the service.

And painful truth, we don’t pay enough, we don’t pay enough to fund the NHS primary care and to fund additional care for those who need it through disability or age. We either all need to pay more directly through taxation ( and hope the system is made more efficient so as not to waste our payments) or we need to look at how we can source additional funding by following those countries who expect their citizens to top up a basic service by additional private insurance.

Errrm.... I don't know how your car insurance works, but I pay mine and then - and this is the VERY crucial difference - if I have a problem, they are there and fix it! They don't ask me what solution I suggest to my dented bumper, they assess it, arrange repairs, deal with the other party etc.

Unlike the NHS, where seemingly I have to pay the premium only to have a nurse shrug at me and ask me what solution I suggest to being ill.

Also: please speak for yourself - I rarely go near the NHS, never mind wasting appointments or drugs or the rest of the things in your ramble.

ElbowGreaseLightning · 15/07/2022 09:04

I'm glad you waited. If your GP thought you should go to A&E then it must have been quite serious and that they couldn't deal with it. You could have gone home and got much worse.

I had to go to A&E last year after my GP sent me there. I was told there was a 10 month waiting list for tests. I got a call from the hospital last month (10 months later) and the first thing they said was "do you need these tests as someone else may need them more".

Well, sorry, but yes, you are going to test me whether I feel alright today or not. At A&E I waited 8 hours and when I asked why other people went in before me, with the same condition, clearly younger, I was told that men are more statistically likely to die from that condition so, tough.

So, from now on I won't be bypassing tests I need to make sure I am alive and healthy to bring up my young children, a luxury I didn't have as my mum died when I was young. I pay tax and NI and I am just as entitled to medical help as the next person.

Rant over, and don't feel guilty at going to A&E OP.

peridito · 15/07/2022 09:01

Can someone tell me what the position is re being accompanied by a responsible person while you wait in A&E ? To fetch water/fold up coat to make pillow /hold hand .

I'm guessing A&E too overcrowded and this would only be possible for the under 16 /18year olds and elderly .Or someone needing support due to other difficulties .

Is at discretion of staff ?

girlmom21 · 15/07/2022 08:48

Can't doctors diagnose kidney infections with a urine sample?

CallOnMe · 15/07/2022 08:46

I’m glad you stayed OP.

The waits are always really busy and I’ve idiotically gone home after hours of waiting thinking I’m not that bad as I just want my bed and ending up having to return a few hours later and having to wait all over again.

Rosessmelllike · 15/07/2022 08:38

If you're well enough to be on Mumsnet and bored and tempted to leave...stop wasting their time and taking up a valuable place in the queue for lifesaving emergency treatment

TheRussianDoll · 15/07/2022 08:28

This sounds harrowing. I’m worried that if you left, you might worsen and then have to return. The fact you were able to walk out, is a good sign. Hopefully, your GP will receive a copy of your A&E results and come back to you fairly quickly.

I’m just listening to Radio4. It’s appalling what’s going on with the NHS. People are dying, at home, waiting for ambulances which are queuing for hours outside emergency. How did we get here? … No care staff for community social care jobs (Brexit and poor pay/conditions); bed blocking in the wards; when you’re IN hospital, the staff are run off their feet so, basic cleanliness goes out the window as they’re needing to do “essential” jobs only.

I’m furious and terrified. Not everything can be blamed on Covid; it was almost this bad before Covid. And the people who’ve allowed this to happen? They will never ever sit, like us, in A&E for 18hrs waiting to be seen.

OP, I hope you feel better soon and don’t need to return to hospital. They’re death traps.

Iphigeniaa · 15/07/2022 08:22

FrenchFancie · 15/07/2022 08:02

A few weeks ago my 94 year old grandmother was 52 hours in a&e (yes you read that right) with A possible infection having been brought in by ambulance because they thought she had sepsis. She was on a trolley all that time but was neither admitted nor discharged. It’s fucking shocking the state of the NHS now - no dig and the staff, but dear god it needs sorting out.

The sad truth is she would've been in a huge queue behind loads of patients with the exact same presentation.

And the beds ahead are blocked by the same elderly people who've been treated but can't return home because their family can't help care for them, their home is unsafe and nobody has made a plan for this situation despite them being 80+ years old.

Our hospital has over 150 medically fit elderly patients who are waiting for care packages.

Honeyroar · 15/07/2022 08:19

FrenchFancie · 15/07/2022 08:02

A few weeks ago my 94 year old grandmother was 52 hours in a&e (yes you read that right) with A possible infection having been brought in by ambulance because they thought she had sepsis. She was on a trolley all that time but was neither admitted nor discharged. It’s fucking shocking the state of the NHS now - no dig and the staff, but dear god it needs sorting out.

I sympathise, my dad was in A&E for nearly two days a couple of weeks ago. The care there was great though. When he was finally put on a ward they just left him to rot for ten days and discharged him to intermediate care (back in an ambulance 48 hours later). It absolutely terrifies me. I don’t see how the NHS can survive much longer.

Discovereads · 15/07/2022 08:11

Wombat100 · 15/07/2022 00:10

Sorry to be brutal but if you’re feeling well enough to go home then you probably shouldn’t be in a&e (although I can totally understand why you went if your GP sent you there - a&e seems to be GP’s answer to everything these days!!).

This isn’t exactly true. As mammals we do have an instinct to go to our nest when critically wounded. A&E is a very hard and tiring place to be, so a severely ill or injured person can actually “feel” they should go home when they should not. It happened to a friend of mine after a car accident. After waiting four hours in A&E with neck pain/suspected whiplash she was so exhausted that she went home. What she didn’t know is she had a broken neck and concussion- so went to bed and literally did not wake up/died in her sleep.

9to5jingles · 15/07/2022 08:08

It really does. A lot of my family work for the NHS and are deeply defensive about it but the current system is not fit for purpose it's not working. We wouldn't treat animals the way some people are being treated its beyond belief.

9to5jingles · 15/07/2022 08:06

lemmein · 15/07/2022 01:50

Only in this country would 8 hours in A&E be described as 'not too bad' Confused

Our standards are depressingly low!

Absolutely it's bloody dire.
Glad you got there in the end op.

FrenchFancie · 15/07/2022 08:02

A few weeks ago my 94 year old grandmother was 52 hours in a&e (yes you read that right) with A possible infection having been brought in by ambulance because they thought she had sepsis. She was on a trolley all that time but was neither admitted nor discharged. It’s fucking shocking the state of the NHS now - no dig and the staff, but dear god it needs sorting out.

Iphigeniaa · 15/07/2022 08:00

The problem is the amount of stuff the NHS has to deal with now.

In the old days, surgical emergencies like appendicitis, renal stones, gallstones would've been assessed and treated easily. Along with heart attacks. Now you've got hundreds of 80+ "off legs"/"generally unwell"/"social admissions", plus middle aged people with metabolic syndrome/diabetes, plus increasingly anxious younger people who present convinced they've got an urgent condition because they read about it online but actually it's trapped wind or gastroenteritis.

The system wasn't designed for complex care of lifestyle diseases, to hold off the inevitable conditions of old age or to deal with societal mental illness.

Honeyroar · 15/07/2022 07:59

I’m glad you stayed. My dad was taken to hospital from an intermediate care centre (he’d recently been discharged from hospital where he’d had sepsis and a heart attack. The first hospital they went to turned the ambulance away as it had too many waiting. We got to the second hospital at 7pm and he was on a trolley in the corridor until 3am (with a load more very sick people). I left at 4am and the waiting room was packed. The announcements were saying seven hours wait time. Despite my dad still looking very poorly they’ve discharged him 12 hours later (they’re just desperate for beds). I’m absolutely terrified by how on its knees the nhs is.

Sunnysideup999 · 15/07/2022 07:42

Glad you stayed and got your results and diagnosis. I had a similar experience and was there for 12 hours from start to finish. Overnight with no bed, sleep, water , company etc. it was an endurance test to say the least and when you are feeling unwell and in pain it is horrendous. and inhumane.
still. You we’re in the right place . You got treated . And I hope you start to feel much better soon