Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To walk out of A&E

116 replies

Usernamqwerty · 14/07/2022 23:53

I've been here since 18:00 with what started as suspected appendicitis (from a GP visit this afternoon). Surgeon examined me and said looks like a kidney infection. I had a CT scan nearly 4 hours ago and still waiting on a chair in the busy stuffy waiting area.

There are trolleys lining the corridors here. It's so busy. I asked the nurse when I might hear and she said the doctor will get to me when they can. I might be here all night, I have no idea!

I am shattered, hot and bored and I just want to go home 😭. What happens if I leave? Can I ask them to send my GP the scan report and antibiotics request?

OP posts:
Spottingtwerps · 16/07/2022 21:52

@Rosessmelllike wow, judgmental much? She was sent by her GP with suspected appendicitis! Presumably if that happened to you, You would obviously know better and not follow medical advice and go home. What a ridiculous comment.

Spottingtwerps · 16/07/2022 21:47

@Wombat100 A GP visit earlier and suspected appendicitis doesn't warrant a trip to hospital? Where do you get your appendicitis treated usually, Asda??

SpeakingMyThoughts · 16/07/2022 20:55

Private is not always best. Just because we throw money at the situation, doesn’t make it better.

antelopevalley · 16/07/2022 18:38

LoisLane66 · 16/07/2022 18:17

When I went into the nursing profession aged 17, things were VASTLY different. That was 1963.
It's really depressing nowadays.
A friend went through BUPA to have a mole removed from her leg.
She was meant to be in overnight.
At 10pm after the op, I received a call asking me to pick her up from the hospital in Chertsey. There were dishes with dried food on under the bed from a previous patient and a dirty dressing on the toilet cistern in the en-suite bathroom.
Friend was terribly upset at the lack of standards, especially as she thought the care and hygiene would be exemplary in a private facility. She had previously given me a letter of authorisations to take to Halifax bank so I could withdraw 2200 which had to be paid before the op was performed. This was 1997.

A friend had a routine operation privately due to waiting lists on NHS. When she came around she asked for water - she still couldn't get out of bed - someone rushed in and left water too far away for her to reach. No one came near her again for hours in spite of her calling. She had a private room.

Ginandtonics · 16/07/2022 18:27

If you leave with things left open it'll invalidate your travel insurance, so if you are planning a foreign holiday, stay put. I'd personally feel like leaving too but in case things need following up best stay. Even a kidney infection can result in serious damage if not treated

LoisLane66 · 16/07/2022 18:17

When I went into the nursing profession aged 17, things were VASTLY different. That was 1963.
It's really depressing nowadays.
A friend went through BUPA to have a mole removed from her leg.
She was meant to be in overnight.
At 10pm after the op, I received a call asking me to pick her up from the hospital in Chertsey. There were dishes with dried food on under the bed from a previous patient and a dirty dressing on the toilet cistern in the en-suite bathroom.
Friend was terribly upset at the lack of standards, especially as she thought the care and hygiene would be exemplary in a private facility. She had previously given me a letter of authorisations to take to Halifax bank so I could withdraw 2200 which had to be paid before the op was performed. This was 1997.

Roystonv · 15/07/2022 14:08

Also why is the provision of minor injury units so patchy. We do not have one with our local a and e, nearest next a and e 1 hour away so it is hardly nearby. So, gp's not doing minor wounds etc, no minor wounds dept so a and e the only option.

TheFridayRabbit · 15/07/2022 12:43

I do find it a toss up between whether to stay or go. If you don’t go you can get into bed but you will probably decline, if you do go there’s a good chance you’ll be waiting a long time feeling awful 😢

I’m sorry for everyone who is needing emergency care at this time. It’s a miserable experience even when the service is running well. I cannot begin to imagine how stressful it must be for staff.

cottagegardenflower · 15/07/2022 12:35

A&E needs a massive upgrade as people are using it as a GP service. Why can't they have a system where people with suspected surgical needs, can't return home if they are able and return for treatment if needed, or their GP be informed of results.

Did the GP test OPs urine I wonder?

antelopevalley · 15/07/2022 12:33

@Badbadbunny Might help if you did not share inaccurate stats? I have already pointed out what is inaccurate.

Somethingneedstochange · 15/07/2022 12:33

Her GP sent her there GP's don't have the facilities to investigate further than doing a urine sample. Hospital have the equipment to do investigative scan's and blood test's.

I know a mother that was accused of wasting doctors time. She repeatedly took him to the GP and hospital. They just fobbed her off with antibiotics and iron tablets.

One morning he collapsed she got a taxi to a children's hospital 2 hours away. By the next day she was told he had cancer. The day after they diagnosed the type of cancer he had a started on the treatment pathway.

Badbadbunny · 15/07/2022 12:31

Pyewhacket · 15/07/2022 11:15

The total cost of the UK NHS increased from approximately £9.2 billion in 1978/79 to £37.4 billion in 1991/92. Adjusting this figure to account for general inflation shows a real increase of 50.4% over this period. I could go on. Currently, the NHS is 40% of all government spending. An additional £12b has been awarded to the health service, above the planned increase in funding. At this rate, the NHS will represent 50% of all spending. If you increase funding then you have to pay for somehow. You either increase taxes, on top of the cost of living crisis, or you take it from elsewhere. Where do you suggest, Universal Credit, Education or Defence ?.

Or you improve efficiency and reduce waste, so you don't need to keep increasing the funding, a proportion of which is lost to waste, fraud and inefficiency.

Somethingneedstochange · 15/07/2022 12:26

It's absolutely diabolical it used to be maximum 4 hour wait at our local hospital. Since the open access has stopped it's a minimum of 8 hour's.

With covid restrictions I couldn't even order food to collect from reception. I had to literally beg staff to allow family to drop some food off for us.

A friend of mine was suicidal she was taken by ambulance and waited 13 hour's with her husband.

Badbadbunny · 15/07/2022 12:23

The Conservatives destroyed the out-of-hours GP service.

I see you're ignoring Blairs brilliant new GP contract which was designed to "cure" the GP problems that were evidence back as far as the early 00's. Well that worked well didn't it? The whole idea of paying them more and letting them opt out of anti-social hours work was to encourage more GPs and reduce the numbers leaving. Worked well didn't it!

TiddyTidTwo · 15/07/2022 12:02

@FrenchFancie

52 hours!!! That's fucking abysmal 😕

antelopevalley · 15/07/2022 11:53

By the way, 40% of all government spending stat is for NHS and social care. So carers for disabled people and elderly people, residential homes, etc for people without money to pay for it themselves.

antelopevalley · 15/07/2022 11:52

@Pyewhacket I know figures always get trotted out. This does not account for a rise in population. The population in 2022 is predicted to be 10 million people higher than in 1991. We also have an ageing population, and social care crisis that eats up large chunks of the NHS budget.
I have a long-standing condition and I know in practice my treatment is now worse than under Labour, because the criteria for different non drug treatments has been raised. It is rationing. I am sure after about 5 years of Labour the criteria will be lowered again.
We spend less per head on healthcare than equivalent developed countries. We need to pay more. Even the government accepts this. Except they want us to pay more directly as individuals to private companies rather than through tax.

Pyewhacket · 15/07/2022 11:15

antelopevalley · 15/07/2022 10:55

@Somethingneedstochange I have known waiting times to be so bad. The mid 1990s when Conservatives had been in power for a long time and had destroyed the NHS then. We then had lots of stories in the press about very long waiting times. But people keep voting for them.

The total cost of the UK NHS increased from approximately £9.2 billion in 1978/79 to £37.4 billion in 1991/92. Adjusting this figure to account for general inflation shows a real increase of 50.4% over this period. I could go on. Currently, the NHS is 40% of all government spending. An additional £12b has been awarded to the health service, above the planned increase in funding. At this rate, the NHS will represent 50% of all spending. If you increase funding then you have to pay for somehow. You either increase taxes, on top of the cost of living crisis, or you take it from elsewhere. Where do you suggest, Universal Credit, Education or Defence ?.

yourmysafespace · 15/07/2022 11:07

Rosessmelllike · 15/07/2022 08:38

If you're well enough to be on Mumsnet and bored and tempted to leave...stop wasting their time and taking up a valuable place in the queue for lifesaving emergency treatment

Her gp sent her there !!!
Hope you feel better soon op

mrsparsnip · 15/07/2022 11:06

I can only write from my own experience. However, after hearing how 'A and E is busier than ever' now, I reflected on what has happened to me.

I went to my GP because I had chest pains and shortness of breath. Both these symptoms had been present for a long time. The GP, listened to my chest and said there may be a little infection there. That was it.

I asked if that would explain the chest pain, which had been going on for weeks. The GP said if I had a pain in that part of the chest, then I needed to go straight to A and E. I replied that it had been going on for weeks, so the GP referred me for an X ray at the local hospital. I had the X ray a few days later.

The X ray showed hyperinflated lungs and I am now waiting for a spirometry test, and have no idea how long the waiting list may be.

My husband was told to go the A and E because his blood pressure was high. A few more minutes with the GP would have indicated that he was under a lot of stress and that could account for the high blood pressure.

So, from these experiences, I am tempted to think that due to pressure on GP services, patients may not be given the time for a more thorough consultation with their GP (or the GP they see at the surgery), and a trip to A and E is advised for some cases that really do not require it.

I am not saying this is the case for the OP, but it could explain in part why A and E departments are always full beyond capacity.

antelopevalley · 15/07/2022 10:55

@Somethingneedstochange I have known waiting times to be so bad. The mid 1990s when Conservatives had been in power for a long time and had destroyed the NHS then. We then had lots of stories in the press about very long waiting times. But people keep voting for them.

MrsSkylerWhite · 15/07/2022 10:54

Please hang on. If it takes a turn for the worse, you’ll be right back at the beginning again.

antelopevalley · 15/07/2022 10:52

When the NHS was first designed, GPs did things that A and E now do. A nurse would visit an elderly person who had a fall and put dressings on. GPs would stitch wounds or visit ill children at home out of hours. I am not suggesting we go back to that, but out-of-hour home visits treated a lot of the more minor stuff that needed to be treated but does not need hospital treatment. A lot of the things people here advise going to A and E just in case, you would have rung your GP for.
The Conservatives destroyed the out-of-hours GP service. Jeremy Hunt to be precise. He was warned about the impact and ignored it. In OPs case she could have gone to A and E had scan within two hours, gone home and been treated by an out-of-hours GP. Waiting for antibiotics while you are in your own home is much more pleasant.

Somethingneedstochange · 15/07/2022 10:24

I have never known waiting time's to be so bad as the last few years It doesn't help that anyone with an underlying health condition now has to go through A&E instead of having open access to a ward for assessment. This was to cut the number of admissions and costs. But this is people's lives we are talking about. It doesn't help patients are having to wait much longer to see they're consultant for medication reviews. It should be 6 monthly.

My daughter has siezures she had a drop in the kitchen on Monday without her helmet on and cut her head. I was going to take her to A&E but luckily I had some skin closure's. Managed to patch her up and stop the bleeding. I know they would have just told me to keep an eye on her for signs of concussion. If I can avoid a trip to A&E I will.

A and E would have been at least an 8 hour wait. Thursday-Sunday nights are the worse because there's more drunk's and they get seen straight away.

Even if she's taken by ambulance for uncontrolled siezures there's still a wait. There's some weeks I can be there 2 or 3 time's with her and we have to wait along with everyone else there. But they often don't treat the cause of her uncontrolled siezures so we end up back there again the next day and they admit her.

Cloudsarebright · 15/07/2022 10:21

Such nonsense that if you can walk out you’re fine. I have had potentially fatal electrolyte imbalances and heart arrhythmias and I got myself there on a bus and was doing work on my laptop as I sat there whilst I was in a bed in majors department with 2 drips and a continuous ECG monitor.

If your doctor tells you to go to A&E…. then go.