Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other cultures are far more invested in their DCs education than UK parents?

339 replies

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 11:45

Just an observation from our area... We live in a really diverse area & it's amazing. My dc go to state school with children with Eastern European, Chinese, German, Scandinavian, Bangladeshi, Nigerian & Japanese parents... The work ethic is unbelievable & the parents don't seem to trust the school to educate their kids, they do alot themselves outside school with the dc.. The UK parents in the class are alot more relaxed when it comes to education...
Aibu to think the UK just isn't as invested in education as other cultures?
The Ukranian refugee crisis also highlighted that the ukranian children joining British & Irish schools were away ahead in maths in comparison to their new counterparts & many also had excellent English... The UK really lag behind in foreign languages.. In years to come my dc who only speak English so far will be competing for jobs with dc who speak 4 or 5 languages fluently... I know come September I'll be doing my best to prepare my dc better!

OP posts:
Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 18:08

LochJam · 14/07/2022 17:56

I love this thread. It's a kick in the bum as I'm way too laissez faire with mine. Never did homework in primary but dc are doing very well. Thank you.

Mine are doing well too but up until now I've been very blasé & more focused on playdates & sleepovers 😂 I'm turning a little bit tiger in Sept!
On a serious note though I think if my children stand a chance of getting a decent, high paying job they'll need to keep up with their peers... As I said above we are in an ordinary state primary with a very diverse & not wealthy catchment, the immigrant parents are going well beyond the shools expectations.. They know their dc will be competing against the wealthy, immigrant & uk kids in private schools & want their kids equipped & with a fighting chance of success... They're leaving nothing to chance!

OP posts:
LochJam · 14/07/2022 17:56

I love this thread. It's a kick in the bum as I'm way too laissez faire with mine. Never did homework in primary but dc are doing very well. Thank you.

ChilleyCheesecake · 14/07/2022 17:53

Saragossa · 14/07/2022 17:04

This is largely true. I was friends with a lady in France who was aiming for a teaching career. It was extremely competitive. She even had to pass a swimming exam, where she had to swim a length in a ridiculous number of minutes.

How interesting, do the teachers themselves teach the children to swim in France? I have a rough idea about what I think the requirements should be to teach, it includes playing an instrument such as the recorder but I hadn't thought about swimming. Wouldn't it be fantastic if teaching was a competitive career like it is in some other countries. I think we could benefit a lot by looking at those countries and transitioning to a similar system here. It is a great responsibility to educate the future generations, it is such a shame the bar is so low here.

rainbowmilk · 14/07/2022 17:50

SheepingStandingUp · 14/07/2022 14:13

I'm curious whether all those posters agreeing British parents are ambivalent and not invested in their kids etc are conceding They are like that, or whether they y of course are the exception to the rule because THEY are so much better than their contemporaries

I don’t (can’t) have kids so no, I’m not. I do however have teacher friends and parent colleagues and have heard on many occasions school being described only in terms of getting the kids out from under the parents’ feet.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 14/07/2022 17:35

Gah, bold fail - sorry!

TheWayTheLightFalls · 14/07/2022 17:34

my Gdcs recent school fair had - among many others - a stall where the children could throw wet sponges at teachers, 2 at a time. It was purely a fun thing, and must have raised a fair bit of cash for the school, which was the whole point of the fair.*

it certainly didn’t mean a lack of respect for the teachers - if anything they were more respected for being game enough!

I understand that this is how you see it (and lots of others, clearly!) but to me it goes against something fundamental about how I regard teachers and expect my children to regard them.

WibblyWobblyLane · 14/07/2022 17:28

AntlerRose · 14/07/2022 16:59

I was slightly bemused to find the ukrainian refugee in top set English in year 10 (above my son who is English). He was studying English in ukraine as a subject but had never been here. They obviously teach languages very well.

This is more likely down to research that says foreign children learn English faster in higher sets amongst children who have a strong command of the language.

Piggywaspushed · 14/07/2022 17:16

You really need to stepaway from anecdote OP. Try data. What makes French and Italuan systems 'better'? There has to be some objectivity here.I think material, rather than cultural explanations about eg school funding might be more fruitful.

No comment on Scandinavian systems? Estonia does well. Canada too.

Saragossa · 14/07/2022 17:04

ChilleyCheesecake · 14/07/2022 16:05

Generally speaking, the UK does not value education highly.
In some countries it is harder to become a teacher than a doctor. The pay is very good. Here we really don't care that the bar is so low, teaching is the backup for many. We don't find it unacceptable that teachers don't have to do grammar tests, they are teaching children to write, grammar and they themselves do not understand simple concepts like if they ought to use to or too. We don't demand better. I feel the whole education system needs a shake up. There are so many teachers here that wouldn't have the slightest hope in becoming a teacher in another country. I really feel this speaks volumes. Any questions or concerns are teacher bashing.
Personally I'd love to see the UK find value in education and demand better standards. However, most see it as childcare. As long as they are paid and don't have to watch the children, then that is good enough.
Other cultures certainly value education a lot more.

This is largely true. I was friends with a lady in France who was aiming for a teaching career. It was extremely competitive. She even had to pass a swimming exam, where she had to swim a length in a ridiculous number of minutes.

karmakameleon · 14/07/2022 17:02

Sova · 14/07/2022 16:47

I’m surprised about the comment that Polish mum said this about year 1 as in Poland kids don’t go to school till they are 7 ye old so yr 1 aged children only play in Poland anyway.
i think it’s not just culture but being an immigrant. If you’re an immigrant you’ve worked really hard already and already have higher aspirations which you would then pass to your kids. You want them to do well and you don’t usually have a back up cushion of a family locally and what you know about your own childhood is irrelevant as you’re in a different reality and you’re disadvantaged and don’t want your kids to be.
plenty of parents in Poland don’t care about their kids education but these are not the people who would emigrate usually if that makes sense!

In my “home” country education is valued, so I don’t think it’s just about immigrants having a different attitude. My relatives who still live there, feel the same way about education as my parents who migrated.

Also not all foreign cultures value education more than the British. I was talking to a school mum who is Chinese. She has the same culture clashes about the value of education with her DH as I do with mine, and he’s also an immigrant but not from a country where education has the same priority status as it does for the Chinese.

AntlerRose · 14/07/2022 16:59

I was slightly bemused to find the ukrainian refugee in top set English in year 10 (above my son who is English). He was studying English in ukraine as a subject but had never been here. They obviously teach languages very well.

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 16:47

Piggywaspushed · 14/07/2022 16:43

Also, we are not French and Italian.

I think the French & Italian system is much better than ours & also more aspirational @Piggywaspushed especially the French system... So it really says something that the Ukranians are outperforming these nationalities... Also if you read the article 😉😉 you will find the UK reporting the same regarding the Ukranians hence why the times wrote an article on the subject 🙄👍

OP posts:
Sova · 14/07/2022 16:47

I’m surprised about the comment that Polish mum said this about year 1 as in Poland kids don’t go to school till they are 7 ye old so yr 1 aged children only play in Poland anyway.
i think it’s not just culture but being an immigrant. If you’re an immigrant you’ve worked really hard already and already have higher aspirations which you would then pass to your kids. You want them to do well and you don’t usually have a back up cushion of a family locally and what you know about your own childhood is irrelevant as you’re in a different reality and you’re disadvantaged and don’t want your kids to be.
plenty of parents in Poland don’t care about their kids education but these are not the people who would emigrate usually if that makes sense!

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 14/07/2022 16:46

I've not met many British people I can have a thoroughly in-depth conversation about complex issues, DP oft uses logical allegories to explain her opinions and thoughts. I'm sure that is directly related to her education back home (Former Soviet country).

Piggywaspushed · 14/07/2022 16:44

Since we are engaging in anecdotes, I do know Primary teachers who have found Ukraininian children's maths skills poor. Obviously, a paper won't run with that story.

QuizzlyBear · 14/07/2022 16:44

YANBU - my DS goes to a grammar school which he worked his socks off to get into.

In a VERY white British area, his school is probably about 70% Asian. The parents of the kids in his class have pushed, encouraged and prepared their sons for academic success in a way that his primary school friends parents never did. Academics are definitely a cultural failing in this country.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/07/2022 16:43

@TheWayTheLightFalls , my Gdcs* recent school fair had - among many others - a stall where the children could throw wet sponges at teachers, 2 at a time. It was purely a fun thing, and must have raised a fair bit of cash for the school, which was the whole point of the fair.

it certainly didn’t mean a lack of respect for the teachers - if anything they were more respected for being game enough!

It’s a lovely school, an invariably over-subscribed C of E primary.

Piggywaspushed · 14/07/2022 16:43

Also, we are not French and Italian.

Piggywaspushed · 14/07/2022 16:42

That's not robust international evidence from PISA tests.

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 16:38

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/ukrainian-children-dazzle-french-and-italian-teachers-with-their-maths-abilities-0595c9zbr

There you go @Piggywaspushed

OP posts:
Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 16:34

Piggywaspushed · 14/07/2022 16:30

Your bit about the year 1 Polish mother is interesting. Also, your unfounded assertion about Ukraine's maths standards . Look up the PISA tests and see what you find about those countries. Is playing in year 1 a bad thing?

The countries with the best educational outcomes, Europe wise are Scandinavian. They may not have the 'culture' you seem to hanker after (hothousing?). Formal education starts at 7 or 8 , total mixed ability settings, highly qualified , high paid and respected workforces.

It's not unfounded, google it! The French newspapers reported the same Ukranian kids that joined were a year ahead of peers!

OP posts:
Piggywaspushed · 14/07/2022 16:30

Your bit about the year 1 Polish mother is interesting. Also, your unfounded assertion about Ukraine's maths standards . Look up the PISA tests and see what you find about those countries. Is playing in year 1 a bad thing?

The countries with the best educational outcomes, Europe wise are Scandinavian. They may not have the 'culture' you seem to hanker after (hothousing?). Formal education starts at 7 or 8 , total mixed ability settings, highly qualified , high paid and respected workforces.

IRememberXanadu · 14/07/2022 16:30

I think the comparison is not necessarily between British kids and 'foreign' kids in the UK. It's between British kids in UK schools and foreign kids in their own countries. I was schooled outside the UK and I entirely agree that in the UK parents are less 'pushy' when it comes to their kids education. It seems British kids here are only encouraged to do the bare minimum - in other countries they are pushed to do their best and work much harder. At least IME of course.

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 16:26

Glad to see I'm not imagining it! I thought I was going to be flamed! @Suetwo I see the same with DCs Eastern European friends parents... They said growing up in the Soviet Union the arts were to be accessible to all, Bolshoi ballet threatre shows , classical music etc & was affordable to all.. They can't believe the price of theatre tickets 100 quid per ticket to the Nutcracker etc... These families travel back to their home countries twice, three times a year & treat their kids to theatre there... And skiing! Apparently so much cheaper & absolutely not viewed a "posh pursuit" in Eastern Europe, accessible to all very cheaply if they have the means to get to a mountain if not cross country is extremely popular...

OP posts: