Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other cultures are far more invested in their DCs education than UK parents?

339 replies

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 11:45

Just an observation from our area... We live in a really diverse area & it's amazing. My dc go to state school with children with Eastern European, Chinese, German, Scandinavian, Bangladeshi, Nigerian & Japanese parents... The work ethic is unbelievable & the parents don't seem to trust the school to educate their kids, they do alot themselves outside school with the dc.. The UK parents in the class are alot more relaxed when it comes to education...
Aibu to think the UK just isn't as invested in education as other cultures?
The Ukranian refugee crisis also highlighted that the ukranian children joining British & Irish schools were away ahead in maths in comparison to their new counterparts & many also had excellent English... The UK really lag behind in foreign languages.. In years to come my dc who only speak English so far will be competing for jobs with dc who speak 4 or 5 languages fluently... I know come September I'll be doing my best to prepare my dc better!

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 15/07/2022 01:09

I agree though many parents are very much involved we have become a child centred society

in some cultures there is no or little discussion around what a child may want to do in their life the expectation is they work hard at school (many parents have had to make huge sacrifices to give them a better life like leaving their families as we are often reminded) become a professional/wealthy through hard work and help support their family

A friend asked me why a colleague of ours was allowing her son (21) to go wondering around the world to experience other cultures and find himself 😆 (she is Nigerian) other colleagues agreed (no surprise that were not from British background) it’s just considered strange in some cultures that you are not always striving to improve your life

lollipoprainbow · 15/07/2022 00:53

I'm glad I figured it out now while my kids are still young, I can make a difference & I need to... I'm delighted they have so many children from immigrant backgrounds in their classes, those children are raising the bar, their parents aren't accepting mediocre or good from the school & have no problem questioning everything 😁 also behaviour issues really aren't an issue as the kids themselves want to learn... I think many British parents like myself can learn so much from these parents even by observation, it's made me really question my beliefs & see DH & I really aren't doing our best of dc in the long run...

Could you suck up anymore?? We get it you love the way immigrants raise their children.

lollipoprainbow · 15/07/2022 00:51

’I'm a teacher but I’m not remotely interested in pushing my children. I’ll support, but far more interested in them being decent people with the skills to find happiness. All this coaching and tutoring is just utterly bewildering to me.

Me too, I was very pleased with my dd10 school report that said she tries her best especially as she is autistic, but reading this thread that would be horrific to many of the posters here!

Commentqueen · 15/07/2022 00:13

Hermione101 · 14/07/2022 20:26

I’m a child of immigrants who “got up and went” 3 decades ago and there is no way I would let my child squander the opportunity given to him by the risks my parents took.

My 6-year old goes to a private school in London, has extracurricular math on the weekend (completely differently than the U.K. style of teaching math) and we do a lot with them at home. We don’t make a big deal out of it, but we do a bit of math/reading/writing every day (not all of them!). We also do a lot of sports and outdoor activities. I don’t talk about any of this with friends, we just do what’s best for us and what works for our family.

We make it fun for him, but it helps that I have the immigrant work ethic/mentality and DP is English and entirely self made. We both highly value education, curiosity, and openness.

The lack of aspiration in this country in insane. Even worse is tall poppy syndrome, but being an immigrant, I don’t care about any of it. I raise my child to hold himself to high expectations, then with his three passports, the world is his oyster.

All parents want their kids to be happy in the end, but it’s a lot easier to be happy when you have career options and eventually some degree of control over the direction of your life, career, etc..

Firstly love the username & secondly you & DH sound like wonderful parents, best of luck to your DC x
I'm so glad I started this thread, I genuinely thought I was going to be flamed for highlighting the lack of aspiration in our schools (as I repeatedly said me included) & the honest responses have been so encouraging. My socks are well & truely pulled up, my lovely dc needs me to do better for them 🥰

OP posts:
Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 23:53

40andlovelife · 14/07/2022 19:55

I'm a teacher. White British children are the lowest performing ethnic group in Britain especially working class white British boys

That's really interesting.. I would say the British kids parents are the least aspirational in the dc's classes, myself included (but I'm reformed now!)

OP posts:
Simonjt · 14/07/2022 22:17

JemimaPuddleducksWaddle · 14/07/2022 22:15

also behaviour issues really aren't an issue as the kids themselves want to learn

Sorry but that just isn't true.

There is a wide variety of behaviours in all cultures and children.

This thread is full of huge sweeping statements.

Yep, I’m Asian and I have two siblings, one of us was very well behaved, the other two weren’t, I was in detention in a regular basis and had a fair few exclusions.

JemimaPuddleducksWaddle · 14/07/2022 22:15

also behaviour issues really aren't an issue as the kids themselves want to learn

Sorry but that just isn't true.

There is a wide variety of behaviours in all cultures and children.

This thread is full of huge sweeping statements.

CatsArePeople · 14/07/2022 22:13

no way do those parents casually throw away a week’s schooling because it’s hot outside… that attitude is utterly alien to me.

They wouldn't because its hot and they can't be arsed, but they totally would to visit extended family. As I said up thread, other countries have much longer holidays.

they also don't like people who succeed or make money

There is resentment of those who didn't work hard for their success, but had inherited privilege. I think you'll find similar attitude outside of UK too.

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 22:11

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 14/07/2022 19:19

Yes I agree OP and it aligns to my own observations. I’m mixed race/first generation. It was drummed into me that education was my ticket to a better life. It worked out for me and thus I still believe this, so although I’m not a tiger parent, I push my children to do well.

Its not like back in the day where you could leave school with next to no qualifications and work your way up. It’s an arms race. I’m not going to disadvantage my kids by refusing to get them to do homework so they can play a bit more. They have many hours and days out of school to play.

I'm glad I figured it out now while my kids are still young, I can make a difference & I need to... I'm delighted they have so many children from immigrant backgrounds in their classes, those children are raising the bar, their parents aren't accepting mediocre or good from the school & have no problem questioning everything 😁 also behaviour issues really aren't an issue as the kids themselves want to learn... I think many British parents like myself can learn so much from these parents even by observation, it's made me really question my beliefs & see DH & I really aren't doing our best of dc in the long run...

OP posts:
onthefencesitter · 14/07/2022 22:08

Jalisco · 14/07/2022 21:56

Have you done any research into the damage that is done by "Tiger Parenting"? There's shed loads of research on how the children suffer high levels of depressive illnesses, alienation from family and parents, and feelings of failure and self-loathing. That doesn't mean that parents shouldn't be supportive or encouraging to their children's learning. Education is important but it isn't everything.

tiger parenting is a bit of a caricature even in Asian countries. I see it as a bit boastful tbh. most people are not that crazy. Or they exaggerate a lot.

Btw even the lady who wrote battle hymn of the tiger mother said the book was a bit tongue in cheek. I think she exaggerated a lot of it. Her daughters had boyfriends in high school and they had movie nights. Her father was a pretty chill guy and was the counterbalance.

Hermione101 · 14/07/2022 22:06

@Jalisco this is true. We do a lot at home with our child, privately educated him, and hold high expectations of him, but we are very careful and very intentionally do not equate love/happiness etc...with any kind of "achievement." He's still very young, and we want him to develop curiosity and a love of learning most of all.

Hermione101 · 14/07/2022 21:59

@CrappyNHappy I know you didn't ask me, but I do a lot with my 5-year-old while I'm cooking dinner. I don't need to be hovering over him, but am on hand to help with his writing and spelling. DP does numeracy at least 3 mornings a week with him (on weekends and one WFH day before work), Reading and talking about the books we read every night before bedtime. We make learning fun and no pressure, but he knows that there is something to do every day. There's zero screen time until he's done. It helps a lot if your husband is on board and pulling their weight.

@onthefencesitter I think very broadly, native British are used to having lower expectations about most things, but they also don't like people who succeed or make money. In many countries, success and ambition are celebrated, here, not so much. As an aside. when I moved to London 10 years ago, I lived in Golders Green and have some nice memories from up there.

CatsArePeople · 14/07/2022 21:57

Do you think its because native British people are able to scale back their expectations. You see it a lot on Mumsnet.

What I see is British people tend to write themselves off because of "class". And yes, i see that a lot of Mumsnet. Like -- "you can't possibly expect me to READ BOOKS after work with my kids, we're POOR!" then turn aroung and complain about unfair advantages for "middle class kids"

Jalisco · 14/07/2022 21:56

Have you done any research into the damage that is done by "Tiger Parenting"? There's shed loads of research on how the children suffer high levels of depressive illnesses, alienation from family and parents, and feelings of failure and self-loathing. That doesn't mean that parents shouldn't be supportive or encouraging to their children's learning. Education is important but it isn't everything.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 14/07/2022 21:41

Not read whole thread but agree with the OP.

There’s a thread going at the moment about the heat - one poster said she’d taken her kids out of school for the week to enjoy the weather because they’re not doing much at school this week anyway.
No way in the world would you get an immigrant family doing that. Those who have struggled to get to this country and benefit from free education, or those like my parents who worked hard to send us to private school - no way do those parents casually throw away a week’s schooling because it’s hot outside… that attitude is utterly alien to me.

Dancingwithhyenas · 14/07/2022 21:29

I’m a teacher but I’m not remotely interested in pushing my children. I’ll support, but far more interested in them being decent people with the skills to find happiness. All this coaching and tutoring is just utterly bewildering to me.

LockAqua · 14/07/2022 21:26

@CrappyNHappy

The time to be spent on studying is age dependent and increases with age.

DS1 (year 10) is expected to do 3 hours of work a night with 6 hours over the weekend- this will increase next year.

DD (year 8) is expected to do 2 hours a night and 3 hours over the weekend.

The expectation for DS2 (year 6) is 1 hour a night and 1 hour at the weekend.

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 14/07/2022 21:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

CrappyNHappy · 14/07/2022 21:19

LockAqua · 14/07/2022 21:12

@CrappyNHappy

It's about priorities for me. In my house education and academics are a top priority, so we ensure sufficient time is allocated to study.

Every DC in my house is set an age appropriate amount of study that has to be completed each evening/weekend. It is non negotiable and there is no screen time or free time until it is completed.

I'm genuinely curious because this is something that has been worrying me a lot (ie the lack of playtime for the kids).

can I ask how much time your kids spend on school related work every day and how much time on playing? And how old are they?

I'm asking because I wonder if it's just my lack of time management that makes the days seem so impossibly short rather than the long school hours.

RedAngel19 · 14/07/2022 21:13

Second generation immigrant here. It was absolutely expected that we studied and worked as possible growing up. My parents come from a country where the entitlement to free education didn't exist. As they grew up poor, they left school at a very young age to work. One parent is still illiterate as a result and it massively held them back in life (things I take for granted such as reading the news, reading for joy or understanding instructions, my parent is unable to do). So it was always understood that education was a privilege (even though we went to a poor performing State school).

We also experienced a lot of racism growing up and also picked on for being poor. We were never on FSM or benefits as my parents worked super hard to just have enough (an issue of pride in their culture not to accept help). We saw how hard our parents worked and how little respect they got. So we studied hard to avoid this.

That said, my parents never pushed us to do extra work or to study. It was simply expected that we understood the sacrifices they had made and for us to do our best. As a child, I did understand and was very self motivated and disciplined as a result in my school work. I was also the child who had to translate and scribe for my parents from an early age - as they couldn't read or write - and knew how much my parents wished they could have gone to school. So I genuinely appreciated my education and never took it for granted.

I have my own kids now and they don't have the same drive. They know how hard their grandparents had it but they never lived through and they live comfortable lives.

LockAqua · 14/07/2022 21:12

@CrappyNHappy

It's about priorities for me. In my house education and academics are a top priority, so we ensure sufficient time is allocated to study.

Every DC in my house is set an age appropriate amount of study that has to be completed each evening/weekend. It is non negotiable and there is no screen time or free time until it is completed.

CrappyNHappy · 14/07/2022 21:10

LockAqua · 14/07/2022 21:05

@CrappyNHappy

Personally I see no issue with DC being expected to work hard. All DC should be expected to complete lots of homework and additional study and revision.

I'm not sure if you are being sarcastic but in case you aren't, when do the kids have time to play or to do things that haven't been prescribed? My kids come home around 4pm absolutely exhausted and it takes them ages to just kind of remove their shoes and wash their hands an loll about. and before we know it it's time for dinner (at 6pm) and then bed. If I fit in reading they won't get to play at all (they are 4 and 7 so fairly young in my eyes. Too young to be put through the grind). They are thankfully excelling academically but I dread when they go to higher classes where they actually will have to study at home to continue doing well academically. Where is the time?

LockAqua · 14/07/2022 21:05

@CrappyNHappy

Personally I see no issue with DC being expected to work hard. All DC should be expected to complete lots of homework and additional study and revision.

Swimminginthelake · 14/07/2022 21:03

I agree that there is a general lack.of aspiration in the UK but I also think parents and schools are way too focused on traditional academic education and performance. From an early age in the UK there is a fixation with what reading level your child is on and very little emphasis on whether they actually enjoy reading and are reading books that they love, regardless of level.

My DS didn't enjoy learning to read. It was always a battle to get him to pick up a book. Until we moved to the US where he was introduced to such a wide range of books and where the focus was on pretty much reading whatever you want. It worked and he's read way more books than I ever thought possible.

While the US is definitely not known for its great schools, and standards vary widely in the public sector, there is a strong sense that àspiration is good and that, whatever your background, you can achieve a college education and get a job that pays well.

But, unlike the UK, schools offer a variety of subjects ar high school like philosophy, driver's Ed, all sorts of languages, and tons of sports which all count towards your final mark.

There is also a strong sense that just getting good grades is not enough , colleges want to know about leadership and community experience and sporting or other achievements outside of the classroom... it makes for a lot of variety of experiences and skills that are vital for the workplace. So while academics is important, I want my kids to learn so much more than that.. and most of all I want them to enjoy learning. I feel that many UK state schools focus on data, essentially, rather than on developing a love of learning and a curiosity about life, whether that's in traditional subjects or not.

CrappyNHappy · 14/07/2022 20:55

Just to add while I love India I wouldn't want my kids to get educated there or even work there. Too competitive and too cut throat. And way too much homework. I think childhood is for playing and learning how to learn.

I don't like the British education system either (and a lot of it has influenced obviously the Indian one). I think 4-5 is way too early to start school and I hate the long school days. I don't think kids necessarily have a more relaxed childhood here. It seems to be a constant struggle for resources and facilities.

I grew up in a different north European country and I'm not sure if it's still the same but our education in primary was extremely play based while still effective. School finished at 1pm (though most kids now would have to go to the after-school club even there I'm sure) and we had small class sizes. In state school. Private schools were almost unheard of. And you don't start school till you are 6-7.

I think my primary education was ideal and I feel sorry for my kids for having to put them through the grind at such a young age.