Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other cultures are far more invested in their DCs education than UK parents?

339 replies

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 11:45

Just an observation from our area... We live in a really diverse area & it's amazing. My dc go to state school with children with Eastern European, Chinese, German, Scandinavian, Bangladeshi, Nigerian & Japanese parents... The work ethic is unbelievable & the parents don't seem to trust the school to educate their kids, they do alot themselves outside school with the dc.. The UK parents in the class are alot more relaxed when it comes to education...
Aibu to think the UK just isn't as invested in education as other cultures?
The Ukranian refugee crisis also highlighted that the ukranian children joining British & Irish schools were away ahead in maths in comparison to their new counterparts & many also had excellent English... The UK really lag behind in foreign languages.. In years to come my dc who only speak English so far will be competing for jobs with dc who speak 4 or 5 languages fluently... I know come September I'll be doing my best to prepare my dc better!

OP posts:
karmakameleon · 15/07/2022 14:15

EV117 · 15/07/2022 13:47

The parents on the WhatsApp group were up in arms & at least 7 or 8 emailed her to say "can you confirm you received my children's work & please respond with corrections /feedback"... No problem whatsoever being so blunt! This trend continued everytime a day slipped with no response until eventually the work was marked accordingly within a reasonable time frame...

Oh dear. ‘Every time a day slipped…’, ‘up in arms…’ Yeah, this is just quite inappropriate and cringeworthy and has nothing to with parents valuing education.
FYI I was rushed to hospital with an ectopic pregnancy during lockdown, so my home learning feedback took a set back before I could notify anyone - I’m glad that after that traumatic experience I didn’t have 7 or 8 emails from people who are not my employers trying to hold me accountable for a missed day of marking.

If a teacher was on sick leave, of course I wouldn’t expect them to be marking work. But I would also expect the school to communicate with parents and explain the situation, and with longer term sickness ensure alternative arrangements were made. There is nothing rude or overstepping about expecting your children to get feedback on the work they produce.

JemimaPuddleducksWaddle · 15/07/2022 14:06

EV117 · 15/07/2022 13:47

The parents on the WhatsApp group were up in arms & at least 7 or 8 emailed her to say "can you confirm you received my children's work & please respond with corrections /feedback"... No problem whatsoever being so blunt! This trend continued everytime a day slipped with no response until eventually the work was marked accordingly within a reasonable time frame...

Oh dear. ‘Every time a day slipped…’, ‘up in arms…’ Yeah, this is just quite inappropriate and cringeworthy and has nothing to with parents valuing education.
FYI I was rushed to hospital with an ectopic pregnancy during lockdown, so my home learning feedback took a set back before I could notify anyone - I’m glad that after that traumatic experience I didn’t have 7 or 8 emails from people who are not my employers trying to hold me accountable for a missed day of marking.

Exactly. What those parents did wasn't 'assertive' it way overstepped a mark.

abit like this thread and the ridiculous assumptions and sweeping statements and stereotyping

MercurialMonday · 15/07/2022 13:55

So must admit I was taken aback to realize that it was just a bland 'we won't say if your kid is good or bad at anything we only say anything if there's a real problem'.

There's very little feedback from some schools - and IME it's not uncommon when you do raise concerns to be told it's all fine - then next meeting exact opposite and when you ask what can you do at home to support - there's frequently no suggestions.

DC secondary reports we get are two numbers and two words towards learning - that's it - luckily our children do talk to us - but actual feedback from schools or opportunities to see their books can be sparse.

I know my parents used to see more of my work as even in primary we did lots of essays - and they'd check through on occasions as my spelling wasn't great. Our children don't nor do they have text books in secondary and even their work books are frequently kept in school - as so many students apparently lose them - though school has form for doing so as well.

Theoneinthemiddle · 15/07/2022 13:51

Obviously everyone is different and we shouldn’t generalise. Some cultures are much more relaxed about achievement! However, certain cultures definitely take it very seriously and see it in a much more competitive way. So they would have extra lessons, sports, music and expect all homework done and good results as standard. However, the ones who come here are the brightest and best very often. In their own countries I am sure there are many unmotivated students as well.

EV117 · 15/07/2022 13:47

The parents on the WhatsApp group were up in arms & at least 7 or 8 emailed her to say "can you confirm you received my children's work & please respond with corrections /feedback"... No problem whatsoever being so blunt! This trend continued everytime a day slipped with no response until eventually the work was marked accordingly within a reasonable time frame...

Oh dear. ‘Every time a day slipped…’, ‘up in arms…’ Yeah, this is just quite inappropriate and cringeworthy and has nothing to with parents valuing education.
FYI I was rushed to hospital with an ectopic pregnancy during lockdown, so my home learning feedback took a set back before I could notify anyone - I’m glad that after that traumatic experience I didn’t have 7 or 8 emails from people who are not my employers trying to hold me accountable for a missed day of marking.

DyingForACuppa · 15/07/2022 13:37

I do think the stereotype here is that if you are white/middle class and you care about your kids education you are 'pushy'.

I view it much the same as when I grew up in 80s Greater London and the 'cool' kids all said they didn't study/do school work - I remember kids literally bragging about how quickly they left an exam because they'd done so little of the questions. I liked reading/learning, and passing exams (my ticket away from those kids!) so was bullied as a 'swot', so have learned to have a thick skin and not give a fuck. I value education and don't care if that makes me 'pushy'. I play games with my kids that teach number skills/reading etc.

I got my reception aged child's first ever school report last week, and while I am all for education at this age to be 'through play' I was expecting to learn from it something about her current school strengths/weaknesses. So must admit I was taken aback to realize that it was just a bland 'we won't say if your kid is good or bad at anything we only say anything if there's a real problem'.

Commentqueen · 15/07/2022 13:04

@karmakameleon exactly. They absolutely value the teachers expertise & 100 % not rude but assertive & confident enough to enquire if the work had been recieved & if the teacher could send feedback & corrections back to the children. It was her job that she was paid to do, they should not have had to do this & most wouldn't have (myself included as I'm not assertive & hate confrontation 🙈)

OP posts:
karmakameleon · 15/07/2022 12:49

lollipoprainbow · 15/07/2022 11:39

@Commentqueen assertive or rude ??

I can’t imagine my immigrant parents ever being rude to a teacher! If education is valued, it follows that those who provide it are respected. But they are very results driven and if their child wasn’t getting feedback, they definitely wouldn’t be shy in asking for it.

Commentqueen · 15/07/2022 11:47

lollipoprainbow · 15/07/2022 11:39

@Commentqueen assertive or rude ??

Absolutely assertive 100%... The group was in agreement that the teacher in question was being paid to teach for a full day, we had no zooms whatsoever only set work which was being sent back & not acknowledged let alone corrected which is the bare minimum one would expect!

OP posts:
lollipoprainbow · 15/07/2022 11:39

@Commentqueen assertive or rude ??

MercurialMonday · 15/07/2022 11:27

Also the key thing really is parental involvement, rather than the specifics of what they actually do. Whether it’s taking kids to museums or being tiger mums.

DD2 twice did topic of Roman once in primary and once briefly in secondary.

We're in an area with many Roman sites - free ones you can easily walk to to expensive world heritage sites a small journey away. They asked in secondary how many had been to any nearby sites - only her .

School took them to nearby site - we couldn't get to as don't drive - but it's the kind of distance my parents would have driven us to with picnic as cheap and rare day out.

Same with Titanic - couldn't take her anywhere but there was coincidently quiet a few documentaries on it and we recorded and watched. Her friends all thought it very odd behaviour.

Even my MIL who's least bothered about education of their GP took DH to library to pick up books on topics or if there were nearby locations did visits.

We thought this was standard parenting - my single parent DSis also does it - it's apparently not.

TomPinch · 15/07/2022 11:20

TheFridayRabbit · 14/07/2022 19:53

I’m in NZ too and I agree with you that it is very noticeable how anxious many new migrants are about their children’s progress in early childhood settings and in primary. It goes against everything in our culture which is the freedom of being a child and learning through play. On the whole, our EC and primary settings are highly successful. Obviously there are exceptions but for the most part, they deliver very well to their communities.

Beyond primary it gets more tricky as for decades now schools have had to “market” to parents which they have done by prioritising elitism over the delivering to the needs of every student.

There is also the huge issue of colonisation which has negatively impacted great swathes of the population.

Thankfully, change is afoot as will become evident when the new curriculum kicks in next year. It is in the trial stages and the results thus far are phenomenal. It is grounded in delivering to every learner and promoting belonging as of key importance with every child’s heritage being treasured and drawn upon as a tool for learning.

I don't agree. My kids have gone though the NZ state system and in that time its revealed some real problems. Most maths at primary level is taught by people who have no liking for the subject and as a result the kids do poorly, comparatively speaking. Children don't get subject-specific teaching until they're 13 or 14, leaving little time to cover anything non-essential. The teachers seem to lack a lot of general knowledge. There is little provision for SEN. A teacher in Wellington was locking an ASD boy in a cupboard. On all measures, such as they are (PISA etc), NZ education has had a pronounced decline over the last 15 years. Everyone I've met who has experience of overseas education says there is less rigour and content in NZ. Hopefully decolonising the curriculum will lead to some improvement in curriculum and teaching methods, but it could easily be just a colossal distraction, e.g., if the science curriculum has to accommodate traditional indigenous beliefs.

Beware the Kiwi tendency to really big up things about NZ when the reality is mediocre.

Commentqueen · 15/07/2022 11:06

In relation to the children I think the immigrant parents are absolutely more assertive... During lockdown all the children sent back work to this particular teacher but she wasn't responding... The parents on the WhatsApp group were up in arms & at least 7 or 8 emailed her to say "can you confirm you received my children's work & please respond with corrections /feedback"... No problem whatsoever being so blunt! This trend continued everytime a day slipped with no response until eventually the work was marked accordingly within a reasonable time frame...

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 15/07/2022 11:01

A lot of people are proud of not knowing anything other than what’s in TV. No respect for anything artistic or intellectual, no curiosity.

this may be true but it’s tough to break

It’s the opposite here tbh. I think you have to break it down as it varies so much.

OooErr · 15/07/2022 10:57

Also the key thing really is parental involvement, rather than the specifics of what they actually do. Whether it’s taking kids to museums or being tiger mums.

Plenty of parents think that educating the children is 100% the job of schools. They bristle at being asked to do anything extra. Of course there are limits, if children have parents who are incapable of helping they’re disadvantaged. and not everyone has time to make 100 costumes.

But even my illiterate grandmother attempted to help educate her children by getting them books, talking to teachers about competitions etc. She couldn’t guide them, but she scrimped to get them what they needed.

It’s the outlook really

MercurialMonday · 15/07/2022 10:56

Another key piece of advice I would give is that parents should drastically limit screen time- especially for boys.
Screen time should be a privilege that has to be earned through studying and excellent grades.

I don't disagree but sometimes the help is on screens.

There are many excellent educational apps out there and sometime they can feel like play - I'm thinking dragon box and teach your Monster how to read - and even less fun one can free a parent up to work with other kids or do tea - around but only if needed.

OooErr · 15/07/2022 10:51

birthdaytou · 15/07/2022 07:31

There is a lot to unpick here. Education is extremely important and of course those from immigrant backgrounds are going to be more motivated to succeed in the U.K. It takes courage and determination to uproot your life and move abroad for a better life. The British middle classes are often obsessed with their kids education too though!

Kids need pushing but I also don’t think it’s wise to pressure kids like some of the descriptions in this post, maybe they’ll end up with good grades (or very average ones) but they’ll grow up believing their worth is based on their academic performance but they’ll also have terrible self esteem, anxiety and generally poor mental health.
As we most things in life it’s about balance, giving kids the opportunities to try different things and playing to their strengths.

My partner is German and went to a gymnasium (German Grammar) he’s extremely creative and artistic but that was never encouraged, it was a solely academic focus, he feels he really missed out by not being able to peruse an artistic route.

We have a much broader approach to education here. There’s a reason we have such a thriving creative industry in this country. We are also getting better at recognising things like dyslexia and that different children learn in different ways.

I wouldnt say it’s about ‘education’ = grades alone. More of an achievement culture.
A lot of people are proud of not knowing anything other than what’s in TV. No respect for anything artistic or intellectual, no curiosity.

With the cuts in govennrment funding etc it’s a battle for SEN parents. Again it’s the parents who value education who advocate, sacrifice so that they can hire private help for their children. Spend time teaching their own children. Making up for the underfunding (and consequently lack of individual focus) in UK schools.

The ones who don’t care and don’t see why grades matter just ‘accept’ their kids are ‘stupid’ and don’t bother.

LockAqua · 15/07/2022 08:14

Another key piece of advice I would give is that parents should drastically limit screen time- especially for boys.

Screen time should be a privilege that has to be earned through studying and excellent grades.

My DC have to earn an age appropriate amount of screen time through completing their study. Because they're not used to having lots of screen time, this works well.

For example, DS2 (year 6) only gets 1 hour a day on weekdays and 2 hours a day at weekends.

Commentqueen · 15/07/2022 08:00

I'm speaking about the dc's in my children's classes

OP posts:
emmathedilemma · 15/07/2022 07:54

Definitely, a number of poor schools (in poor areas) near me have significantly improved performance which they put down in part due to the influx of immigrant families and kids who take education seriously.

RedWingBoots · 15/07/2022 07:49

CatsArePeople · 14/07/2022 21:57

Do you think its because native British people are able to scale back their expectations. You see it a lot on Mumsnet.

What I see is British people tend to write themselves off because of "class". And yes, i see that a lot of Mumsnet. Like -- "you can't possibly expect me to READ BOOKS after work with my kids, we're POOR!" then turn aroung and complain about unfair advantages for "middle class kids"

I must have been brought up and live in aspirational neighbourhoods in London, as the white British kids were the ones who mothers read books with them from when they were babies. Some of these mothers are/were single mothers too.

The bigger issue I find - and which schools needed to address and have done - is that lots of working class kids of many ethnicities thought that further or higher education wasn't for them.

So I know families where older children who were capable didn't go into an sort of further or higher education there as their young siblings did. This means I know families where the older adult children do manual jobs and semi-skilled jobs there as the younger ones do professional ones.

birthdaytou · 15/07/2022 07:40

I agree our schools could do better ( there is always room for improvement) and we should be teaching a second language from an early age.

birthdaytou · 15/07/2022 07:31

There is a lot to unpick here. Education is extremely important and of course those from immigrant backgrounds are going to be more motivated to succeed in the U.K. It takes courage and determination to uproot your life and move abroad for a better life. The British middle classes are often obsessed with their kids education too though!

Kids need pushing but I also don’t think it’s wise to pressure kids like some of the descriptions in this post, maybe they’ll end up with good grades (or very average ones) but they’ll grow up believing their worth is based on their academic performance but they’ll also have terrible self esteem, anxiety and generally poor mental health.
As we most things in life it’s about balance, giving kids the opportunities to try different things and playing to their strengths.

My partner is German and went to a gymnasium (German Grammar) he’s extremely creative and artistic but that was never encouraged, it was a solely academic focus, he feels he really missed out by not being able to peruse an artistic route.

We have a much broader approach to education here. There’s a reason we have such a thriving creative industry in this country. We are also getting better at recognising things like dyslexia and that different children learn in different ways.

Piggywaspushed · 15/07/2022 06:53

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 23:53

That's really interesting.. I would say the British kids parents are the least aspirational in the dc's classes, myself included (but I'm reformed now!)

That statistic has been parroted out and believed . It is spun by the government for a range of reasons. It's not true and depends entirely on how you disaggregate various ethnic minority groups, which the sewage Sewell report did to 'prove' structural and institutional racism don't exist.

Crazykatie · 15/07/2022 06:53

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

This is my town it’s a good place to have a family - if you can afford it, house prices are high, social housing is good too, my youngest son has just moved into a brand new 2 bed semi after a year in private rented.