Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other cultures are far more invested in their DCs education than UK parents?

339 replies

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 11:45

Just an observation from our area... We live in a really diverse area & it's amazing. My dc go to state school with children with Eastern European, Chinese, German, Scandinavian, Bangladeshi, Nigerian & Japanese parents... The work ethic is unbelievable & the parents don't seem to trust the school to educate their kids, they do alot themselves outside school with the dc.. The UK parents in the class are alot more relaxed when it comes to education...
Aibu to think the UK just isn't as invested in education as other cultures?
The Ukranian refugee crisis also highlighted that the ukranian children joining British & Irish schools were away ahead in maths in comparison to their new counterparts & many also had excellent English... The UK really lag behind in foreign languages.. In years to come my dc who only speak English so far will be competing for jobs with dc who speak 4 or 5 languages fluently... I know come September I'll be doing my best to prepare my dc better!

OP posts:
Bigmouthshouthotair · 16/07/2022 10:52

Snoopsnoggysnog · 16/07/2022 05:23

Awful post and this poster has got some really dodgy opinions - are you just trying to be goady?

The whole thread is goady full of sweeping stereotypes and is quite snide at times.

Hatsoff5 · 16/07/2022 08:31

whatwhhat · 14/07/2022 13:15

I disagree with op. I think the uk focuses a lot more on the whole child. Doesn't japan have really high sucide rates that is largely contributed to stress. And I'm sure I read that china doesn't allow special needs into mainstream schools. And a lot of polish parents I know are shocked at how much we help children with special needs in school and have clubs as they wouldn't get that in Poland. Some countries you basically have to pay for schools so that already cuts out the parents that don't value education.

If you look into a classroom and children are reciting things by rote it looks impressive, however it's proven it's not very effective. When you look into a lot of British classrooms (and I'm sure a lot of other countries) it's a lot more interactive and child led. The model I feel you are idealising is very much a one size fits all. I think if you saw me (as a immigrant but white and from an English speaking country but outwardly looks British) you'd think I was very relaxed with education but my kids attend 4 clubs each, after homework my children are expected to do ten minutes of reading or an extra task like writing. We read everyday. Most days out out are educational. But my children also have fun and days to the park and play sports (sports is very frowned upon in some countries). I won't push them if the stress isn't worth the outcome. They're in top sets and achieving above national averages etc but that's only part of who they are not their whole identify

You just said it yourself your an expaxt and you are sending your kids to 4 classes and they are top sets.

This is OPS point. The UK mentality is very different towards learning unless it involves private school!

Commentqueen · 16/07/2022 08:09

FreudayNight · 16/07/2022 05:47

I’m sorry but Irish universities do not rank in the best in the world.
This year Trinity came in at 167, below Cardiff.

Ireland has many many good things, but the quality of its 3rd level education system is not one. Other factors take up the slack.

I was a bit mystified at @IrishMama2015 claim about Irish universities... None in the top 100 means they absolutely don't rank with the best in the world🙄

OP posts:
TomPinch · 16/07/2022 06:15

RedWingBoots · 15/07/2022 22:38

@lollipoprainbow it's an awful post but true.

Also there is no such thing as reverse racism.

Unfortunately the stereotypes of white English people - notice I didn't say British - and their behaviour are strong amongst immigrants to the UK and foreigners.

Which kind of shows the ignorance of those attitudes. I used to live in the west of Scotland and....

I agree there is no such thing as reverse racism though. There is only racism, and the attitudes described in that post and yours are examples of it.

FreudayNight · 16/07/2022 05:47

IrishMama2015 · 14/07/2022 13:09

YABU to include Ireland in your post. Children here learn a second language from the very beginning of school and our universities rank amongst the best in the world

I’m sorry but Irish universities do not rank in the best in the world.
This year Trinity came in at 167, below Cardiff.

Ireland has many many good things, but the quality of its 3rd level education system is not one. Other factors take up the slack.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 16/07/2022 05:23

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Awful post and this poster has got some really dodgy opinions - are you just trying to be goady?

PrisonerofZeroCovid · 16/07/2022 04:01

Not really a fair comparison, I don't think to compare people who emigrate to give their children a better life as they are usually pretty intelligent, go-getting people whereas with people born and brought up in a country there will always be a mixture.

Yep - I'd agree. For example, in Hong Kong, there are tier 1 schools where everyone works super hard, gets amazing grades, plays 3 instruments to Grade 8, gets a distinction in LAMDA, speak 3 languages etc and there are tier 3 schools where most kids get few qualifications/ lots of drop outs/ don't speak any language other than their mother tongue etc. When you meet Hong Kongers in the UK their kids are almost always knocking it out of the park but in Hong Kong they'd be the tier 1 school students so you're just seeing a subset of the whole population.

Rosehugger · 16/07/2022 03:44

Not really a fair comparison, I don't think to compare people who emigrate to give their children a better life as they are usually pretty intelligent, go-getting people whereas with people born and brought up in a country there will always be a mixture. Lots of people here are getting left behind by society and it's only getting worse.

TheFridayRabbit · 16/07/2022 03:27

So much ignorance and snobbery in this thread.

Firstly, it is possible to be happy and to be educated, the two are not mutually exclusive. In fact, it’s more like that we will raise happy young people by supporting them to be well educated.

Being well educated is quite different to being pressured to attain high grades. A person can be extremely well educated without being “top”.

And what we know now is that grades are such a small part of what we need in life. Yes we need to be literate and numerate, and it is just as important to be emotionally literate, to think critically, collaborate, be respectful, and to have a sense of belonging and purpose.

That has nothing to do with going to museums every weekend. Ideally we will give our children wide range of experiences and opportunities, and much of this can be done at a very low cost. The skills acquired through Scouts or Girl Guides, the characteristics of the person who does voluntary work, collaborative skills developed during team sports - all of these are extremely valuable.

And so too is knowing your home is a soft place to fall, that you are loved unconditionally, and making a meaningful contribution to family life.

None of this is dependent on culture or class, it is about being a decent and useful citizen, and a person of integrity.

Phewthatwasclose · 15/07/2022 23:56

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

What an awfully depressing outlook on life. Do you never read books, go to the theatre, watch movies then? Who would provide all these things if everyone’s DC went into medicine or law?

lollipoprainbow · 15/07/2022 22:45

@LockAqua sorry but you sound very

MarshaBradyo · 15/07/2022 22:41

RedWingBoots · 15/07/2022 22:38

@lollipoprainbow it's an awful post but true.

Also there is no such thing as reverse racism.

Unfortunately the stereotypes of white English people - notice I didn't say British - and their behaviour are strong amongst immigrants to the UK and foreigners.

Stereotypes aren’t true usually they are prejudice

but also why make the effort to be here if such a negative view

RedWingBoots · 15/07/2022 22:38

@lollipoprainbow it's an awful post but true.

Also there is no such thing as reverse racism.

Unfortunately the stereotypes of white English people - notice I didn't say British - and their behaviour are strong amongst immigrants to the UK and foreigners.

MarshaBradyo · 15/07/2022 22:33

lollipoprainbow · 15/07/2022 22:29

Most Indian families don't want their kids to be like white Brits.
They are not considered the top.
Not the ones they have to first associate with when they get here.
It's only when you get to university you meet white British people that seem 'normal' as in they care about education and progress.
The white British families immigrants are first exposed to are their fear - their children will end up like that.

What a vile post. The reverse racism on this post is staggering.

Agree it’s a pretty awful post

lollipoprainbow · 15/07/2022 22:29

Most Indian families don't want their kids to be like white Brits.
They are not considered the top.
Not the ones they have to first associate with when they get here.
It's only when you get to university you meet white British people that seem 'normal' as in they care about education and progress.
The white British families immigrants are first exposed to are their fear - their children will end up like that.

What a vile post. The reverse racism on this post is staggering.

CatsArePeople · 15/07/2022 22:26

I think i need to make another observation here. Being Eastern European - we care about results much more than the process.
Back at home school was work, not playtime and not making friends. It was grades and a place at university.
For my kids here - are they making friends? who are they playing with?

  1. i always hated school. i was on the top of the class, but so what? I went to university but dropped out very soon to have a family (finished a degree later).
  2. my kids like school. the oldest chose army instead of university (seen as my failure in the eyes of the extended family - but so what? he can go to uni later if he wants to)

Again, from my school time i miss the 3 months of summer holidays. I do resent that my kids have to wear stupid uniforms.
On the other hand, i am grateful they don't see school as prison time.

OooErr · 15/07/2022 19:00

LockAqua · 15/07/2022 18:49

@OooErr

My DC do lots of extra curricular activities. What they don't have is constant 'screen time'.

The vast majority of DC in the UK could easily be doing the amount of study mine do while still having time for other things.

DS1 (year 10) will get up at 8 am tomorrow and have 4 of his study hours for the weekend done by 12.30pm. He plays football in the afternoon and will then go out with friends in the evening.

Sunday morning he will do 2 more hours of study before a family lunch and then a cycle ride. He'll do 2 more hours of revision in the evening.

There is a balance to be struck but let's not pretend that DC who work hard and put effort in have no lives- every year 10 could be following DS's study routine if they had the discipline and work ethic.

That’s very little compared to some of the DC I’ve seen.
Again - relative. Reasonably smart kid, reasonable effort, great grades.
Not so smart kid, reasonable effort, probs ok grades.
Maybe not so smart kid might just about get A’s, and possibly A*’s if they devoted all of their effort but is it worth it?

LockAqua · 15/07/2022 18:49

@OooErr

My DC do lots of extra curricular activities. What they don't have is constant 'screen time'.

The vast majority of DC in the UK could easily be doing the amount of study mine do while still having time for other things.

DS1 (year 10) will get up at 8 am tomorrow and have 4 of his study hours for the weekend done by 12.30pm. He plays football in the afternoon and will then go out with friends in the evening.

Sunday morning he will do 2 more hours of study before a family lunch and then a cycle ride. He'll do 2 more hours of revision in the evening.

There is a balance to be struck but let's not pretend that DC who work hard and put effort in have no lives- every year 10 could be following DS's study routine if they had the discipline and work ethic.

OooErr · 15/07/2022 18:29

@wejammin I’ve seen a lot of people like you.
Not just the interest but when you push for perfection something changes in your character. You become anxious, eager to please. Everything is formulaic. I was like that as a teen.

However the world isn’t like that. It takes a certain amount of accepting chaos, taking risks and basically getting stuck in to really succeed. And although it sounds shitty a lot of BS-ing

I was lucky to be ‘awakened’ at uni but many people only find out waaay later.

OooErr · 15/07/2022 18:26

LockAqua · 15/07/2022 17:52

I don't agree with the "you only need grades good enough for what you want to do' attitude at all and it isn't accepted in my house.

DC should be expected to try their absolute hardest and get the best grades they personally are capable of.

My DC are all capable of getting A* grades with hard work so that is what is expected. They are expected to get excellent grades, and consequences are handed out if they don't put the effort in.

But what is ‘absolute hardest’?
Is it someone like me, who got A*s with no tutoring at all? I spent most of my time reading, playing music, daydreaming.
Or my best mate, who had lots of tutoring and spent every waking hour studying.

I used to have your attitude but after years of working with, hiring and training people from all walks of life my conclusion - doesn’t make much difference. A lot of academically excellent people aren’t very good in the workplace, and as discussed in the higher earning thread don’t have the emotional resilience, creativity or people skills to make it big.

In my first year at a prestigious university I focused solely on my studies and got a first. But nobody cares about that at interviews. They wanted to know what else I had done. Huh?

After observing other people I realised that nobody cares. It was the attitude. They wanted examples of stuff I had done, not my grades.
I partied more, did more extracurriculars, freed myself. I learnt to take risks, ask for what I wanted.

In my final year I got several job offers, and throughout my career it has been my personal skills that have gotten me jobs. Yes, I need certain technical skills for my profession but you don’t get promoted for just doing a great technical job. There are more important skills. The best people and bosses I have worked with didn’t go to prestigious unis. Look at the CIO’, CTO’s of many companies.

Again - if your child is perfect , has both the academic and others. Great. But if you have a choice of pushing, pushing, pushing to get A*’s. Or letting them develop other skills. Choose the other skills, and let them be with average grades.

Btw all of those hours I spent with reading and music. Didn’t really reflect on my grades. But I can see the beauty of patterns.

Many people like my DP never got good grades but their mind is top class. Equally so the excellent project managers etc I have worked with, got all C’s, but who saw through billion dollar projects with aplomb.

Grades are just a door. If you want to do academic stuff they’re more important. Top unis have some better opportunities.

but they’re not the be all and end all for a child who isn’t so inclined and has to be dragged, kicking and screaming to study.

wejammin · 15/07/2022 18:21

I had a very very pushy parent and I know it is because of her own experiences as a mixed race child in the 60s and the struggles she faced (I also have a very relaxed parent who is naturally extremely gifted/genuinely a genius but autistic and did not apply himself).
I was pushed and pushed and came out with amazing GCSE and A levels. Went to a RG university and got a very "well respected" job. Never travelled, studied for hours.
My sister resisted the pushing and coasted through school and higher education, had loads of fun in her teens and 20s.
I have become an anxious mess with massive imposter syndrome issues and I struggle to be motivated at work because I'm not really interested despite the 'prestige'.
My sister has found a job she genuinely adores, earns double what I do and is very happy.
I have 3 kids, one is autistic and one is dyslexic (the other is pre-school) and I am very supportive of their schooling but will not push them or make them think their value is in educational achievement. My autistic son is extremely gifted at maths and has chosen to take the 11+ so he has had some tutoring this year, my daughter will probably choose not to as she is not academic but she is extremely creative. That's fine by me.
I absolutely value their happiness over their academics.
I agree that financial stability plays into happiness but in this country that seems to be more and more out of the control of the individual and a much wider issue of politics and power than a child's exam results.

Wbeezer · 15/07/2022 18:17

There's a hell of a lot of generalisation going on here and a lot of snobbery.
In my extended scottish family there are a mixture of trades and professions, some traditional others more creative.
Valuing someone's life based on their qualifications and career is not right, everyone makes a contribution to society. I also don't recognise the white parents unfussed about education, its not my experience, I think we accept a wider range of careers as acceptable but that is a good thing.

Commentqueen · 15/07/2022 17:55

IRememberXanadu · 15/07/2022 17:45

the bullshit about 'being happy' is such a waste, working hard and earning well are more important imo.

The issue is that if someone is happy as a kid (focussing on 'being a kid' rather than working hard at school) they may not be very happy as adults because they won't find many open doors. If, instead, they focus on achieving high grades, they can absolutely still have a happy childhood, AND they will have many more opportunities for a happy adulthood once they earn enough to afford what makes them happy e.g. a family, holidays, etc.

@IRememberXanadu this is what I am after realising! The cost of living crisis has been an eye opener for me & the way things are headed my dc will need to be high earners to enjoy a decent quality of life as we can't afford to support them beyond college ...

OP posts:
Commentqueen · 15/07/2022 17:53

YesGotIt · 15/07/2022 17:31

Yanbu. British attitudes to parenting are all about 'I want my kids to be happy'.. other cultures seem to focus on academics.

I wish British culture was more interested in high achievement academically, the bullshit about 'being happy' is such a waste, working hard and earning well are more important imo.

Yes myself included, the playground, playdates, cinema trips inflatable parks fill up our leisure time.. I was very conscious of my friends socialising & mixing... My British friends are the same with theirs... I have a few Eastern European friends & they rarely meet us as they're always busy. Last time we met them was at a park in the nearby city, they had gone to an exhibition in transport museum first though 😁

OP posts:
LockAqua · 15/07/2022 17:52

I don't agree with the "you only need grades good enough for what you want to do' attitude at all and it isn't accepted in my house.

DC should be expected to try their absolute hardest and get the best grades they personally are capable of.

My DC are all capable of getting A* grades with hard work so that is what is expected. They are expected to get excellent grades, and consequences are handed out if they don't put the effort in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread