Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other cultures are far more invested in their DCs education than UK parents?

339 replies

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 11:45

Just an observation from our area... We live in a really diverse area & it's amazing. My dc go to state school with children with Eastern European, Chinese, German, Scandinavian, Bangladeshi, Nigerian & Japanese parents... The work ethic is unbelievable & the parents don't seem to trust the school to educate their kids, they do alot themselves outside school with the dc.. The UK parents in the class are alot more relaxed when it comes to education...
Aibu to think the UK just isn't as invested in education as other cultures?
The Ukranian refugee crisis also highlighted that the ukranian children joining British & Irish schools were away ahead in maths in comparison to their new counterparts & many also had excellent English... The UK really lag behind in foreign languages.. In years to come my dc who only speak English so far will be competing for jobs with dc who speak 4 or 5 languages fluently... I know come September I'll be doing my best to prepare my dc better!

OP posts:
SheepingStandingUp · 16/07/2022 19:27

But you do realise that some of those lower classes will have kids who go to Uni, who have jobs aside your kids

SheepingStandingUp · 16/07/2022 19:26

I'm just saying that they community I was first exposed to, that community I will never associate with unless it's via the service sector. no I did clarify the working class bit, or would you prefer underclass? The ones only good enough to serve you, not be friends with your kids incase they catch WC cooties

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 16/07/2022 19:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 16/07/2022 19:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

SheepingStandingUp · 16/07/2022 19:17

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Well you've said yourself, there's no pont asking her. You have the wisdom to speak for an entire nation who all hate everyone in their new country apart from the people at University. I mean it isn't like those Uni kids came from "normal" families before Uni. No kid who goes to a school in a WC area from WC parents EVER go to Uni. It's a revelation to know that if DS or his brothers go to Uni in 12/16 years time, I'll be worthy of her friendship.

Interestingly one of the reasons they're resolved against going home is that she remembers how intense her own education was and likes that her child can do dancing and art classes after school instead of studying until 9 pm like she was. As much as she values education and is well educated, she also sees that different isn't wrong or sub par, and that her bright daughter isn't being tainted with the filth of English white kids.

MarshaBradyo · 16/07/2022 19:08

You assume my history I’m predominantly Australian I chose U.K. as I like the culture, I wouldn’t do so otherwise. And I’ve found good schools for dc

I find it odd you’d surround yourself with any culture you don’t like. But I guess you could be in your own bubble which is up to you, no skin off my nose.

Meanwhile we will be around British dc and our dc are British, as they don’t have ties to Aus as I do beyond family there or a passport etc

Anyway I’m finding it unusually antagonistic so I’ll leave you to it.

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 16/07/2022 19:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 16/07/2022 19:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

SheepingStandingUp · 16/07/2022 19:02

It's only when you get to university you meet white British people that seem 'normal' as in they care about education and progress
The white British families immigrants are first exposed to are their fear - their children will end up like that .
Well its interesting in know that DSs best friends parents secretly hate us / fear ever being like us and are counting down the next 12 years until they can meet "normal" people through their child. I'll be sure to tell her we shouldn't be friends any more and to keep my child away from hers should I?

MarshaBradyo · 16/07/2022 19:00

They don't come here for you.

I didn’t say they did. But with your views I’m wondering why they would choose U.K. with such a negative outlook of it

But yes get posts removed as you wish they read badly in terms of prejudice

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 16/07/2022 18:54

Snoopsnoggysnog · 16/07/2022 05:23

Awful post and this poster has got some really dodgy opinions - are you just trying to be goady?

I'll ask for my posts to be removed.
I've always said Mumsnet is a working class white woman forum.
Hopefully, they'll have a forum for Indian people like they do for black people.

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 16/07/2022 18:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 16/07/2022 18:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

TheFridayRabbit · 16/07/2022 17:23

OooErr · 16/07/2022 17:08

I've also posted this on many threads, but get shouted down on how 'elitist' I am. Same when I discuss it IRL.

A degree in 2022 means nothing. Almost anything can be a degree provided it means the NVQ Level 6 criteria. A lot of professional qualifications are cheaper, also NVQ Level 6 or higher, and more importantly relevant to the profession.
The ACA accounting qualification final exam (NVQ Level 7) has a very complex case study, to be completed in conjunction with a supervisor. Critical thinking, analysis and wider knowledge all reflected.

Why is all of that ignored in favor of a degree as the ultimate goal?

A lot of things like event management simply isn't worth going into 27K worth of depth for. Employers should hire and train people, pay for qualifications.

What we have now is so many degrees that even entry-level jobs like receptionists, admin staff etc require them! It's really irrelevant. Some 'form' of higher qualification perhaps, but not only a degree. At least then people can still change fields without having paid lots for it.

Even in technology there are a lot of high-level roles that require more practical ability. Service/Product/Project management. People need to learn things, but they can do courses as they go along. They really don't need to have passed exams in an irrelevant subject/written a dissertation to be able to do the job, or think creatively.

Exactly. It’s pure ignorance to assume that a degree is required to launch a career.

A qualified tradesperson can earn more by their mid-20s than most university graduates ever can. It can also be a paid route to say, project management in construction and engineering as opposed to racking up huge debt by taking the study only route.

OooErr · 16/07/2022 17:09

debt

OooErr · 16/07/2022 17:08

MangyInseam · 16/07/2022 15:08

Something that strikes me though is that the differences you see in attitude don't always just refer to university bound kids.

There is a tendency in the UK to see kids going into trades as a sort of failure and trades training, or really any other type of higher education, is poorly done.

That isn't the case in many European systems. It's very repectable to go into business, trades, or whatever, and fewer people may go to university at all, and they are seen as people who are going to go into a small number of specialized types of work.

I think this is a much better attitude, you end up with people having a really good education in their area of concentration, often the basic education is better, people feel valued in all kinds of work, and university education is what it is supposed to be, challenging and rigorous for a few people who have the right kind of capacity for highly developed abstract thought and attention to detail in their field, and are actually interested in spending their time doing that (which honestly even many people who could do it aren't keen to spend years of their lives on.)

I've also posted this on many threads, but get shouted down on how 'elitist' I am. Same when I discuss it IRL.

A degree in 2022 means nothing. Almost anything can be a degree provided it means the NVQ Level 6 criteria. A lot of professional qualifications are cheaper, also NVQ Level 6 or higher, and more importantly relevant to the profession.
The ACA accounting qualification final exam (NVQ Level 7) has a very complex case study, to be completed in conjunction with a supervisor. Critical thinking, analysis and wider knowledge all reflected.

Why is all of that ignored in favor of a degree as the ultimate goal?

A lot of things like event management simply isn't worth going into 27K worth of depth for. Employers should hire and train people, pay for qualifications.

What we have now is so many degrees that even entry-level jobs like receptionists, admin staff etc require them! It's really irrelevant. Some 'form' of higher qualification perhaps, but not only a degree. At least then people can still change fields without having paid lots for it.

Even in technology there are a lot of high-level roles that require more practical ability. Service/Product/Project management. People need to learn things, but they can do courses as they go along. They really don't need to have passed exams in an irrelevant subject/written a dissertation to be able to do the job, or think creatively.

Commentqueen · 16/07/2022 16:43

Agree with less screen time

OP posts:
MangyInseam · 16/07/2022 16:19

MercurialMonday · 15/07/2022 10:56

Another key piece of advice I would give is that parents should drastically limit screen time- especially for boys.
Screen time should be a privilege that has to be earned through studying and excellent grades.

I don't disagree but sometimes the help is on screens.

There are many excellent educational apps out there and sometime they can feel like play - I'm thinking dragon box and teach your Monster how to read - and even less fun one can free a parent up to work with other kids or do tea - around but only if needed.

I think that in general parents and teachers should consider these entertainment rather than learning. If you are giving screen time limits, these should count.

They do not substitute for real teaching and learning and overall they are quite thin in terms of the amount of practice vs the amount of time spent. Even doing writing or math work on screens using things like regular wp programs doesn't have the same effect as using pencil and paper.

I worked as a reading tutor for a number of years and we used programs like this and for the most part they made little difference at all with the kids learning, and they weren't even more fun than other kinds of games. The real advantage is that they do not involve teacher or parent input.

But in terms of using time well your kid is probably better off going outside or playing with some sort of hands on construction toy or drawing or something like that.

Now there are assistive technologies and such that can make a huge difference for certain children, that's a different scenario altogether.

MangyInseam · 16/07/2022 15:08

Something that strikes me though is that the differences you see in attitude don't always just refer to university bound kids.

There is a tendency in the UK to see kids going into trades as a sort of failure and trades training, or really any other type of higher education, is poorly done.

That isn't the case in many European systems. It's very repectable to go into business, trades, or whatever, and fewer people may go to university at all, and they are seen as people who are going to go into a small number of specialized types of work.

I think this is a much better attitude, you end up with people having a really good education in their area of concentration, often the basic education is better, people feel valued in all kinds of work, and university education is what it is supposed to be, challenging and rigorous for a few people who have the right kind of capacity for highly developed abstract thought and attention to detail in their field, and are actually interested in spending their time doing that (which honestly even many people who could do it aren't keen to spend years of their lives on.)

LeoOliver · 16/07/2022 14:07

This is an interesting observation. My observation is that the immigrant communities you mentioned are probably from middle class backgrounds where they value education, wealth and status. Immigration tends to often attracts the poorest communities or the well-educated and middle class. Immigrants are not a true representation of a whole group.

I have family from China and Hong Kong. I would say that overall Asia has differently mentality from places like the UK, however not all Asian fit the model minority stereotype. I know quite a few low achieving Asians.

I value education. I will push and encourage my child to succeed but I won't be a tiger mum. My goal is to cultivate the love of learning and encourage them to work hard. I will reward effort and not results. I value both my child's success and happiness.

PrisonerofZeroCovid · 16/07/2022 13:52

Well tbh at the moment being a bit lazy is a fairly safe strategy to demonstrate your disengagement. Whether that continues remains to be seen. China already has a demographic crisis so it does need to be ‘all hands to the pumps’ in terms of workforce. Will be interesting to see how the rhetoric around that develops. The other interesting trend is #lastgeneration which is somewhat more provocative.

Andante57 · 16/07/2022 13:23

Prisoner - I googled ‘lying flat’ - that’s fascinating. Those that do it are very brave, considering the punishments that are meted out to dissenters in China.

PrisonerofZeroCovid · 16/07/2022 13:09

plus now there's the whole "lie flat" thing going on on the Mainland.

PrisonerofZeroCovid · 16/07/2022 13:07

The difference is that DC in places like Hong Kong and South Korea (where DH is from) are expected to work extremely hard, and there is pressure from society and DC to do so.

But my argument is basically the opposite- i.e. that the Hong Kongers you meet in UK are not necessarily representative of the whole (I live in HK) because the ones who you meet tend to be the middle class ones or the working class ones who are the risk takers/more motivated ones and who emigrated. Equally, there are loads of parents and students in HK who don't give that much of a shit about academics for whatever reason. There are plenty of young people in HK who don't have a great deal to show for their education. When we think of Hong Kong "societal" norms in the west, we essentially mean middle class norms.

LockAqua · 16/07/2022 10:59

@PrisonerofZeroCovid

The difference is that DC in places like Hong Kong and South Korea (where DH is from) are expected to work extremely hard, and there is pressure from society and DC to do so.

In the UK, many parents don't make their DC work extremely hard and there isn't the expectation from society or school to do so.

A neighbour of ours had a DC sitting GCSEs this year and yet went on holiday over easter. This was absolutely incredible to DH and I as well as DS1 who will be sitting GCSEs next year. All of his time during easter will be spent studying and revising as that is the expectation both from us and the standards he sets for himself.