Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other cultures are far more invested in their DCs education than UK parents?

339 replies

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 11:45

Just an observation from our area... We live in a really diverse area & it's amazing. My dc go to state school with children with Eastern European, Chinese, German, Scandinavian, Bangladeshi, Nigerian & Japanese parents... The work ethic is unbelievable & the parents don't seem to trust the school to educate their kids, they do alot themselves outside school with the dc.. The UK parents in the class are alot more relaxed when it comes to education...
Aibu to think the UK just isn't as invested in education as other cultures?
The Ukranian refugee crisis also highlighted that the ukranian children joining British & Irish schools were away ahead in maths in comparison to their new counterparts & many also had excellent English... The UK really lag behind in foreign languages.. In years to come my dc who only speak English so far will be competing for jobs with dc who speak 4 or 5 languages fluently... I know come September I'll be doing my best to prepare my dc better!

OP posts:
DuarPorte · 14/07/2022 15:05

From sample size of 1 - our household - I entirely agree.

My spouse (white British) is completely chilled about DC education whilst I (Indian, first gen migrant, academic by profession) am definitely way more involved, do lots outside school. I do think other confounding variables like - gender (me being the woman), and profession (me being a university academic) May also have to do with this difference but most definitely there’s a perceptible cultural difference between approach to education in India versus what I see here for example!

aggressivesleeper · 14/07/2022 15:04

My parents are Eastern European immigrants and very much took this kind of approach with me when I was growing up (born here).

It opened up a lot of doors for me in terms of university and subsequently career, but a small part of me still resents them for not letting me just be a kid. I love them very much and am hugely grateful - they definitely thought they were doing the right thing, and put their whole hearts into it. But it often felt quite restrictive and dull, and I wish I'd had more independence and more fun.

Funnily enough, they actually think they were very liberal (and they probably were, compared to some of their friends from similar backgrounds) but I always felt smothered. No Spice Girls or sleepovers, it was classical music and novels on repeat...

At my first job (very competitive grad scheme) it struck me how many of the other grads were also second-generation immigrants. I can't speak for anyone else, but for me, so much of it was about proving myself and showing misplaced gratitude to my parents rather than it being something I "really wanted to do." In fairness, they never encouraged me to follow a certain career, but I felt I had to do the "difficult" thing to show it had not all been in vain.

RedWingBoots · 14/07/2022 15:03

@bigbluebus TV from as soon as they can talk. Plus computer games and books.

I've asked people I studied with and worked with plus interacted with their 2-5 year old children in their home countries. The children will talk to me in English.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 14/07/2022 15:03

I'd like to think, I'm teaching my children to look for opportunities, I've always, been what is classed as free-lance, then a business owner. I'd like my children to follow that path. I do not want them to become institutionalized simpletons.

CheeseandBeetrootSandwiches · 14/07/2022 15:01

When my daughter was in primary she had a friend of Malay heritage and this friend's mum filled every waking hour outside of school with tuition, sports and music clubs. To us, a white British family, it looked exhausting.

But on the other hand, we are fortunate to have been able to supplement our DD's education with trips out, going to the library, having educational toys and books, museum visits etc...maybe soft options but we wanted to enable her to learn as a pleasure, not just to pass exams. Lifelong learning, if you will.

Maybe I'm not as aspirational for my child as some of her friends parents are but I still want her to do her best and ultimately be happy.

feelingsareweird · 14/07/2022 14:59

Totally agree, I’ve taught both in the uk and Asia and there’s a clear cultural difference in terms of the value placed on education. In Britain we have strange negative assumptions about academic achievement - people who like to study/are good at studying are weird, overachieving ‘boffins’ etc. I have some higher level academic experience which I do not generally talk about with people I don’t know well in this country because I usually receive a negative/suspicious reaction. In Asia, the reaction is always a genuine ‘great, good for you!’. Perhaps this is partly as others have said because it’s possible to live comfortably without academic qualifications more easily here. But also I think linked to the class system - knowing your place, being humble and so on. Especially for women!!

Eatingchips · 14/07/2022 14:58

Oh and we are also a country of emigration and immigration. People moving and sometimes returning from the UK and US to try to support family at home.

Eatingchips · 14/07/2022 14:56

You included Ireland in your OP but Ireland is very similar to the countries you spoke of. In my parents generation abject poverty was the norm. My father’s family was dirt poor as were those around him and they lived rurally, urban poverty was absolutely slum like throughout the 1950s here. Education was literally the only way out of that and there is enormous emphasis on education here too. Teaching is still a very highly regarded career here too.

These last 2 generations are the first two where the country isn’t completely impoverished.

onthefencesitter · 14/07/2022 14:56

karmakameleon · 14/07/2022 14:18

I agree OP. You only have to look at the threads about what people wish they learnt at school and it’s obvious few people value an academic education.

I’m a second generation immigrant and my husband is white British and it’s one of the things we argue about. I think DS should work hard and do some school work over the holidays (11 plus coming up) and DH is of the “what does it matter, I did alright without getting top grades at school” mentality. It drives me nuts.

An average earner here can expect free healthcare, to buy a small house with 2-3 bedrooms in a suburban town (not desirable or close to economic centres like London) if coupled up with another average earner, at least 1 holiday a year (even if its just camping or in a country with cheap cost of living), to run at least 1 car, to eat fairly well and a few luxuries. British culture is focused on leisure and one's personal happiness- countryside walks, nature, gardening, a pint or two on a sunny day, holidays, pets are prized. It is actually much less materialistic than many cultures and also very individualistic. So most people don't feel the need to push themselves academically because they are comfortable with the lifestyle of an average british person.

Yes there is also huge inequality and poverty but the tabloids have convinced the British public that the reason for their misery is not lack of education, but poor decision making i.e. not getting a job, having too many children.

Turnthatoff · 14/07/2022 14:56

I think generally, immigrants who have done it tough, really tough, push their kids a lot more when it comes to education. I lived in China for a bit, and the kids face an enormous amount of pressure, some to the point of suicide. But, I hear nothing compares to the relentless pressure Korean children face. Hours and hours of lessons after school each day, from a very young age.

karmakameleon · 14/07/2022 14:55

riesenrad · 14/07/2022 14:42

I think DS should work hard and do some school work over the holidays (11 plus coming up) and DH is of the “what does it matter, I did alright without getting top grades at school” mentality. It drives me nuts

again, I don't think that is to do with which country you came from but simply reflects how you learn yourself. I was having a discussion with an acquaintance the other week whose daughter is in Y10. She was worrying over her dd's lack of revision for year 10 exams; her husband was laid back about it. And before you think it's a male/female thing, it isn't. My son is a lazy so and so and does the minimum to get by. DH was tearing his hair out because he is a grafter. I wasn't, because my son takes after me!

No, it’s because I know there is a gap between where he is and where he needs to be terms of achievement. He’s clever but he needs to practice as he makes silly mistakes in subjects that he’s capable in. FWIW I wasn’t a particularly hard worker at school but I was focused on what I needed to do to get the grades.

OooErr · 14/07/2022 14:50

Also we don’t have great language teachers.
We just have so many ethnic groups with their own language. We speak it because we have to.

I used 3 languages on a daily basis…. Not just to speak but TV shows, ads, documents, road signs. When it’s all around you there’s nothing to ‘learn’ you just absorb it.

OooErr · 14/07/2022 14:47

Also because education is so expensive it represents a substantial, whole family effort. Parents saving since children were born, selling cars, furniture anything they can get their hands on.
Some people do take private loans a but these obviously have massive interest.

’Enjoying’ life is only an option for the privileged and comfortable. Everyone else is too busy surviving.

OooErr · 14/07/2022 14:45

Well I don’t know how UK parents think but I’m from one of these countries.
Having an education is the difference between getting a decent job, or manual Labour for life.

Also while people complain about social mobility in the U.K. it’s a world away from those countries. The U.K. has benefits (whether enough is a separate question), there is at least some sense of needing to be social mobility, discrimination is illegal on paper, you can get government backed education loans/ qualifications. More importantly people don’t look at degree subject!

There are no benefits In my country. So the smartest one has to provide for the whole family, pay for siblings. Equality is deeply entrenched and accepted by society. Most people don’t think migrant workers deserve any rights, and that people from certain ethnic groups are lesser. And should stay there. I’m from one of those ‘lower’ groups and people even put up signs saying ‘only higher ethnic groups’ for renting properties, jobs, everything.

No work, no food. That’s it. Very simple. And education is a means of ensuring that you always have food.

bigbluebus · 14/07/2022 14:42

There was a Chinese doctor on on of those Emergency hospital programmes on tv today other day. He was talking about his education in China. He said if you got 98% in a test you were asked by your parents what happened to the other 2%. In this country a parent would probably buy a treat! I think there's a happy medium!
But I do wonder about how other countries teach English compared to how we teach MFL.
Our Scandinavian friends and their teenage children speak excellent English. My DS who has a natural aptitude for languages, studied French for GCSE and got an A is actually less fluent than I am - and I got a B in O level French in 1980.

riesenrad · 14/07/2022 14:42

I think DS should work hard and do some school work over the holidays (11 plus coming up) and DH is of the “what does it matter, I did alright without getting top grades at school” mentality. It drives me nuts

again, I don't think that is to do with which country you came from but simply reflects how you learn yourself. I was having a discussion with an acquaintance the other week whose daughter is in Y10. She was worrying over her dd's lack of revision for year 10 exams; her husband was laid back about it. And before you think it's a male/female thing, it isn't. My son is a lazy so and so and does the minimum to get by. DH was tearing his hair out because he is a grafter. I wasn't, because my son takes after me!

getalifesonny · 14/07/2022 14:42

I completely agree with you. I am an immigrant myself. It's a shame to see all that this country has to offer go to waste because people who have been living here for generations don't have aspirations. My child used to go to public school. Teachers work hard but there is very little parental involvement. Some parents even openly admit quite proudly that they don't know what their children are doing at school. Our child was getting bored because she wasn't challenged enough so we have to now send her to private school. I also feel like people don't have any aspirations. Like why work hard when you can get a job as a shelf stacker. Not that any thing wrong with it as we do need people to stack shelves but these jobs will most likely be replaced by robots at some point. What will they do then?

riesenrad · 14/07/2022 14:38

they can just give up if it's not a core subject, because it's not important

this certainly applies to MFL. Only in the UK are languages too hard to learn (complete nonsense - our kids aren't any less intelligent than kids in eg Norway or the Netherlands).

Caspianberg · 14/07/2022 14:37

In England though people feel they don’t need another language

As an ‘expat’ living abroad, I know lots of other ‘English foreigners’ also. All of them have to speak the local language to get by, and all their children go to local, not international schools. Many are also married to someone from a different European country, so speak English and say Hungarian at home, and then local language for work and school.

Ds will start local kindergarten soon. That and all schooling will be local, so not in English.

riesenrad · 14/07/2022 14:36

I don't know if I agree that UK parents care less than other parents (other than the obvious "Tiger Mums" in places like Singapore or South Korea.

In other countries teachers are better respected and trusted to get on with teaching (eg Finland); and parents do not take credit for their kids in the same way UK kids do - eg Dutch parents accept their kids are their own people and don't boast about them (and on the other side of the coin, presumably don't blame the parents for every sin of the child either).

I think it's different, not better or worse.

WibblyWobblyLane · 14/07/2022 14:29

I agree. We are from a country in Europe that has a stereotype of being lazy, yet children here finish school around lunchtime when it gets too hot, will go home, eat and have a nap, do homework and then go to tuition from 5 till 9, when it's cooled down a lot. Tuition is in all subjects, not just ones you're bad at because there is a strong growth mentality. I definitely see in the UK a lack of growth mentality instilled in youth and just the acceptance that if they turn up and behave, it's good enough and if it's hard, they can just give up if it's not a core subject, because it's not important.

karmakameleon · 14/07/2022 14:18

I agree OP. You only have to look at the threads about what people wish they learnt at school and it’s obvious few people value an academic education.

I’m a second generation immigrant and my husband is white British and it’s one of the things we argue about. I think DS should work hard and do some school work over the holidays (11 plus coming up) and DH is of the “what does it matter, I did alright without getting top grades at school” mentality. It drives me nuts.

SheepingStandingUp · 14/07/2022 14:13

I'm curious whether all those posters agreeing British parents are ambivalent and not invested in their kids etc are conceding They are like that, or whether they y of course are the exception to the rule because THEY are so much better than their contemporaries

SheepingStandingUp · 14/07/2022 14:11

PaperTyger · 14/07/2022 13:41

@Shanghai1
That's really moving in so many ways! Is that actually Shanghai?

It's so interesting how people there really see education as a route out of poverty. Why don't we see it like that here?

Well according to this thread, because the WC parents just use school for childcare and are happy knowing their kids can just live off benefits like they do, happy in the knowledge that they don't have to interact with their kids more than the bare minimum.

Alexandra2001 · 14/07/2022 14:04

Simonjt · 14/07/2022 12:14

The UK has essentially caused aspiration to be pointless for many, your average working class child can work their arse off only to be living on value noodles at university to leave with £50 of debt. They then often can’t afford to move to where graduate jobs are available and their families can’t afford to help them with rent etc.

The UK is basically set up to keep the poor in their place.

Very true, we are were working class, my DD has 47k of debt, working her arse off in the NHS for very little reward, its pathetic.

So she is off soon, Australia, their gain, our loss.

People have no idea of the numbers who have left or are leaving the NHS but you will when you need care and it'll be too late