Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other cultures are far more invested in their DCs education than UK parents?

339 replies

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 11:45

Just an observation from our area... We live in a really diverse area & it's amazing. My dc go to state school with children with Eastern European, Chinese, German, Scandinavian, Bangladeshi, Nigerian & Japanese parents... The work ethic is unbelievable & the parents don't seem to trust the school to educate their kids, they do alot themselves outside school with the dc.. The UK parents in the class are alot more relaxed when it comes to education...
Aibu to think the UK just isn't as invested in education as other cultures?
The Ukranian refugee crisis also highlighted that the ukranian children joining British & Irish schools were away ahead in maths in comparison to their new counterparts & many also had excellent English... The UK really lag behind in foreign languages.. In years to come my dc who only speak English so far will be competing for jobs with dc who speak 4 or 5 languages fluently... I know come September I'll be doing my best to prepare my dc better!

OP posts:
tulips27 · 14/07/2022 16:26

*is not an alien idea

tulips27 · 14/07/2022 16:25

I agree with the points people are making but we also have a class divide with this here in the UK; some of the best fee-paying schools will foster that kind of academically challenging environment and really "push" the students. In that respect a strong emphasis on education not an alien idea to this country, it's just one that is provided to a minority.

Pipsquiggle · 14/07/2022 16:21

Completely dependent on the area and the aspirations of the parents. If there is low deprivation & you have engaged parents, particularly at primary school, the academic achievements are usually higher.

OP are you in the UK or a different country? If so which country?

alpenguin · 14/07/2022 16:19

Yanbu- my child goes to a top ten school but it’s more to do with how the school filters out low attaining students at post15/16 exam time than parents supporting their kids education. Quite a few of the wealthier parents pay for tutors but we can’t afford that.

When I was growing up here there was such a low emphasis on educational attainment and it was considered snobbery to have gone to university 🤦‍♀️ . It has changed a little since then but there is still more emphasis on material wealth and sporting success than academic success.

ChilleyCheesecake · 14/07/2022 16:05

Generally speaking, the UK does not value education highly.
In some countries it is harder to become a teacher than a doctor. The pay is very good. Here we really don't care that the bar is so low, teaching is the backup for many. We don't find it unacceptable that teachers don't have to do grammar tests, they are teaching children to write, grammar and they themselves do not understand simple concepts like if they ought to use to or too. We don't demand better. I feel the whole education system needs a shake up. There are so many teachers here that wouldn't have the slightest hope in becoming a teacher in another country. I really feel this speaks volumes. Any questions or concerns are teacher bashing.
Personally I'd love to see the UK find value in education and demand better standards. However, most see it as childcare. As long as they are paid and don't have to watch the children, then that is good enough.
Other cultures certainly value education a lot more.

Suetwo · 14/07/2022 16:02

Yes, I know exactly what you mean. I am often amazed by other Europeans (and Brexit or not, we ARE still Europeans). My friend works for a Dutch company, and he often remarks how backward he feels compared to his colleagues. They are a mix of Dutch, Danes, Italians and Swedes, and all of them speak flawless English (better than he does!!), plus French and sometimes German. They also seem more knowledgeable about science and art and so on.

The standard of education is definitely higher in some countries. But it’s not just that. The cultural/intellectual bar seems to be higher as well. The French and Italians know their own literature and are proud of it. And they don’t think you are pretentious or weird for quoting a poem or talking about philosophy or painting or whatever. We seem such ignorant, beer-swilling oafs in comparison.

One of the saddest things about the British is how little pride we take in our own literature. We have one of the greatest literary traditions in the world, but people ignore it. This is the island that produced Chaucer, Shakespeare, Donne, Milton, Blake, Byron, Jane Austen, Keats, the Brontes, Dickens, Woolf, not to mention scientists like Newton and Darwin. We ought to bring our children up to be proud of that.

Funkyblues101 · 14/07/2022 15:53

We can get away with being lazier here - in China, an army applicant, for entry at the lowest rank, requires at least a bachelor's degree. A university degree is not even necessary to join the British Army as a commissioned officer in Britain. To join the infantry as a private soldier, you literally have to be able to only sign your name on the dotted line.

OooErr · 14/07/2022 15:43

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 14/07/2022 15:13

100 million % agree. But it's not always a good thing. I know (and DH and DC know) quite a number of people from certain cultures - especially Asian - where it's not an option to simply be a shop assistant or even a manager of a shop, or to work in a factory etc. They MUST get a university degree, it MUST be an academic one, and they MUST go into a 'proper' profession (in their eyes...) EG, medical, science, law, lecturer, mathematician, etc... I know/have known many a person of certain cultures who are doing a certain job because it was expected of them by their family, and NOT because it was their dream.

GPs, vets, dentists, consultants, surgeons, lawyers, all manner of professions have many people who would not have been in these jobs if it had been their own choice. My DC knew many students at college and Uni who were studying Law or Medicine or Science, but they really wanted to do drama or music or media. Their parents laughed in their face, and said 'no WAY! You are getting a proper degree, and doing a proper job!' Now IMO, any job is a proper job and any degree is worthy and so are all careers, but in some cultures, you MUST go into Law or Medicine or Science, or something similar, and it MUST be 'academic!'

As for the ones who DON'T go and get the swanky academic degree (and the career) that their family demands, they end up working for the family business.

nb; there are, of course, many people in these professions who ARE happy with it, but some are only there because it was expected of them.

There's certainly a lot of that mentality which can be quite unhealthy.
However.. 'any job is a proper job and any degree is worthy and so are all careers'.
Just isn't true.

3rd+ generation immigrants with a safety net and a more liberal outlook are happier to let their kids be free. Myself included. In fact I would be thrilled if they went into an artistic profession! I'm very musical, loved literature, drama dance etc. Had I been born in the UK, and had opportunity that's where I would have ended up.

However I will (hopefully!) have a house for my children to come home to if things don't work out. Enough experience to guide them into getting a job unrelated to their degree (indeed, this is easier in the UK), and more importantly some £££ to get them started.

First generation parents however have the experience of hard living. They don't want their kids to struggle, and having worked so hard for their money they're not going to throw it away for kids to chase a dream.

There's also historically been a lot of racism in the arts. You can see it getting better with Asian artists like Simu Liu, Ritu Arya, Anya Chalotra and firms delibrately going for diversity but back then if you didn't fit a certain profile you were unlikely to make it big. Now even 'standard' BBC shows have a multi-ethnic cast.

I don't think parents should force their kids into one of 3 acceptable professions (doctor, lawyer, engineer) but equally they don't need to be 100% supportive of EVERYTHING. If a kid wants something so much they're willing to risk everything, so be it but they shouldn't expect parental funding.

blandnessneveroffends · 14/07/2022 15:39

Simonjt · 14/07/2022 12:14

The UK has essentially caused aspiration to be pointless for many, your average working class child can work their arse off only to be living on value noodles at university to leave with £50 of debt. They then often can’t afford to move to where graduate jobs are available and their families can’t afford to help them with rent etc.

The UK is basically set up to keep the poor in their place.

THIS

CornPlaster · 14/07/2022 15:35

The catchment of my DCs’ school isn’t very affluent overall. The parents I know who are immigrants tend to have a higher level of education themselves than the other parents and that to me seems to be the difference - it’s mainly the immigrant parents who have that level of education whereas the “non-immigrant” parents who are educated to that higher level are less likely to have DCs at the school.

Shanghai1 · 14/07/2022 15:35

PaperTyger · 14/07/2022 13:41

@Shanghai1
That's really moving in so many ways! Is that actually Shanghai?

It's so interesting how people there really see education as a route out of poverty. Why don't we see it like that here?

Yes, Shanghai.

IME almost every parent cares a great deal about their children. I worked for a decade in comprehensive-type schools in the UK that had catchments where very few parents had gone to university, so fairly working-class. Almost all parents I had contact with were interested to know how their children were doing and clearly wanted them to do well.

However, I think in general there is a culture in the uk of trying not to stress our children and prioritising their friendships, and giving children more freedom to decide what they want to do. Attending classes (or being made to study) for 2 hours each night and doing several on Saturday and Sunday will give your children higher grades, but at what expense? And if you did that in the UK where it's not a norm, you're likely to end up with a resentful child.

There probably is a happy medium there somewhere.

I am talking about my perception of general culture, not individuals, of course.

Dinoteeth · 14/07/2022 15:31

Hope lack of hope, in areas with high unemployment, people in and out of work, low wages they can't see education as a way out. And to be fair many would have other hurdles to jump, the kid with the scheme accent is going to struggle in an interview against the posh kid from across town.

A degree / good education is no guarantee of a good job or a decent standard of living. Trades people are out earning those with degrees. And degrees cost £££, even just looking at accommodation costs.

So many areas have 'working poor' and the working poor can be worse off than benefits people.

MercurialMonday · 14/07/2022 15:30

DH and I getting to University was a big deal in our families - and lead to better paying jobs which helped us get on housing ladder eventually by saving bloody hard - there no inheritance coming our way - and more options than if we stayed where we grew up.

There was an obvious benefit to us - I wonder if with student debt house price rises and less opportunities post graduation if that advantage is less and less clear cut.

FIL, a builder who owned his own small company by end of working life, told DH if he could earn a living with his brain rather than his back he really should do so.

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 15:29

Eatingchips · 14/07/2022 14:56

You included Ireland in your OP but Ireland is very similar to the countries you spoke of. In my parents generation abject poverty was the norm. My father’s family was dirt poor as were those around him and they lived rurally, urban poverty was absolutely slum like throughout the 1950s here. Education was literally the only way out of that and there is enormous emphasis on education here too. Teaching is still a very highly regarded career here too.

These last 2 generations are the first two where the country isn’t completely impoverished.

I just mentioned that thw ukranian children arriving were away ahead of British & Irish children in maths...

OP posts:
Turnthatoff · 14/07/2022 15:27

Public school = paid for by the state where I come from.

Mally100 · 14/07/2022 15:26

On the other hand parents from some countries where they’ve seen what poverty close up can be very focused on ensuring that their children are educated enough to get a high paid job.

I'm from one of these countries. Education was a priority while growing up and its ingrained in me to raise my dc the same. Same with work ethic.

CharlotteOH · 14/07/2022 15:24

Yeah, it’s weird. I know some parents who never teach their children at home or help with homework, then shrug when their children get low grades and say with some satisfaction that their children just aren’t academic.

I think there’s some reverse snobbery in it maybe? Or just laziness? I don’t get it at all. My parents generation worked much harder at school.

On the other hand parents from some countries where they’ve seen what poverty close up can be very focused on ensuring that their children are educated enough to get a high paid job.

Hoppinggreen · 14/07/2022 15:20

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Bloody Hell calm down
In some countries they say Public school where we say State. So that person presumably means that

Commentqueen · 14/07/2022 15:19

SheepingStandingUp · 14/07/2022 14:11

Well according to this thread, because the WC parents just use school for childcare and are happy knowing their kids can just live off benefits like they do, happy in the knowledge that they don't have to interact with their kids more than the bare minimum.

Absolutely not what is being said! Many of the immigrant families are working class/very cash poor (many supporting family members at home still) yet are totally aspirational for their own children.
Class as in working class middle class etc doesn't come into it it's cultural differences to education!

OP posts:
MercurialMonday · 14/07/2022 15:16

SheepingStandingUp · 14/07/2022 14:13

I'm curious whether all those posters agreeing British parents are ambivalent and not invested in their kids etc are conceding They are like that, or whether they y of course are the exception to the rule because THEY are so much better than their contemporaries

My kids struggled so I had to step in - and other parents were so negative about that if and when it came up.

Our own parents were working class and generally supportive all left school at 15 for work though DDad spent large part of his working life gaining additional qualifications - though primary schools DH and I went at time 1980s actively discouraged the supporting basics at primary as it would confuse us.

If the kids fly and the schools are good then it's much easier to step back and leave it to the school but often that advantage if forgotten and such parents IME negatively comment on other parents trying to level the field for their kids.

DS Y10 report missing 4 subjects because he doesn't have a teacher in those subject - succession of temps. He'd still doing well - but that him and us plugging gaps.

There are differing attitude to education across areas and there also difference in how good the schools and education actually is.

But there are students with families who don't value education - who may well be disruptive - my kids complain about it as do some of their teachers in p/t meetings education isn't seen as a way to a better life for many here.

onthefencesitter · 14/07/2022 15:14

CheeseandBeetrootSandwiches · 14/07/2022 15:01

When my daughter was in primary she had a friend of Malay heritage and this friend's mum filled every waking hour outside of school with tuition, sports and music clubs. To us, a white British family, it looked exhausting.

But on the other hand, we are fortunate to have been able to supplement our DD's education with trips out, going to the library, having educational toys and books, museum visits etc...maybe soft options but we wanted to enable her to learn as a pleasure, not just to pass exams. Lifelong learning, if you will.

Maybe I'm not as aspirational for my child as some of her friends parents are but I still want her to do her best and ultimately be happy.

My parents have never considered my happiness tbh, it isn't very important to them. What they want for me is to be able to earn enough to have a decent pension fund without relying on my inheritance (because if you let every generation spend the family's wealth, there wouldn't be anything left at some point). Their premise is that a capitalist society is ultimately an unequal one, whether you are in USA/UK/Asia and the government primarily acts in the interests of the wealthy so if you don't have money, you are at a high risk of losing control over your life and being exploited. Inherited money can be easily lost so its better to invest in education as that cannot be taken away..

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 14/07/2022 15:13

100 million % agree. But it's not always a good thing. I know (and DH and DC know) quite a number of people from certain cultures - especially Asian - where it's not an option to simply be a shop assistant or even a manager of a shop, or to work in a factory etc. They MUST get a university degree, it MUST be an academic one, and they MUST go into a 'proper' profession (in their eyes...) EG, medical, science, law, lecturer, mathematician, etc... I know/have known many a person of certain cultures who are doing a certain job because it was expected of them by their family, and NOT because it was their dream.

GPs, vets, dentists, consultants, surgeons, lawyers, all manner of professions have many people who would not have been in these jobs if it had been their own choice. My DC knew many students at college and Uni who were studying Law or Medicine or Science, but they really wanted to do drama or music or media. Their parents laughed in their face, and said 'no WAY! You are getting a proper degree, and doing a proper job!' Now IMO, any job is a proper job and any degree is worthy and so are all careers, but in some cultures, you MUST go into Law or Medicine or Science, or something similar, and it MUST be 'academic!'

As for the ones who DON'T go and get the swanky academic degree (and the career) that their family demands, they end up working for the family business.

nb; there are, of course, many people in these professions who ARE happy with it, but some are only there because it was expected of them.

karmakameleon · 14/07/2022 15:07

I’m not saying luck and privilege doesn’t play a part btw but it’s rarely the whole story.

karmakameleon · 14/07/2022 15:06

onthefencesitter · 14/07/2022 14:56

An average earner here can expect free healthcare, to buy a small house with 2-3 bedrooms in a suburban town (not desirable or close to economic centres like London) if coupled up with another average earner, at least 1 holiday a year (even if its just camping or in a country with cheap cost of living), to run at least 1 car, to eat fairly well and a few luxuries. British culture is focused on leisure and one's personal happiness- countryside walks, nature, gardening, a pint or two on a sunny day, holidays, pets are prized. It is actually much less materialistic than many cultures and also very individualistic. So most people don't feel the need to push themselves academically because they are comfortable with the lifestyle of an average british person.

Yes there is also huge inequality and poverty but the tabloids have convinced the British public that the reason for their misery is not lack of education, but poor decision making i.e. not getting a job, having too many children.

This is very true but there also a nasty streak of jealousy that runs through the country. At times like this when the cost of living crisis means that people can’t maintain that life style, the answer isn’t to work harder but to blame “the rich” and ask people who did work hard to pay more tax. Equally on threads about high earners, there are plenty who deny that high earnings are down to hard work (at school and beyond) and an element of risk taking but put it all down to luck and privilege.

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 14/07/2022 15:06

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request