Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Other people’s dogs!

60 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/07/2022 08:16

I will preface this by saying I love dogs and I had one growing up (a well behaved one!) but the amount of people who have no control/recall of their dogs is driving me mad.

We live in an area with lots of dogs and every time we try to go for a walk there’s some bouncy dog that comes bouncing up to us/jumping up with muddy paws etc.

Owners always ineffectually shout “oh he’s so friendly, he just wants to say hello!” Well I don’t want your bloody dog jumping on me!

My daughter is terrified of dogs having been knocked over by one as a toddler in this situation. And her fear is being made worse by all these huge dogs bowling up to her and nearly knocking her down again. I nearly had to kick one the other day that wouldn’t leave us alone.

Why are all these owners so irresponsible 😡

OP posts:
GrilledWatermelon · 14/07/2022 12:00

I missed @twistyizzy 's post before I posted my reply, so my dog proves their point. My dog has been reinforced for running and jumping up at strangers by them giving him food (because they're dog lovers, "don't mind" and think he's cute).

Unfortunately, I failed to prevent it and now my small dog jumps up at everyone hoping for a treat. That's on me, I need to work out how to unravel it (any tips from anyone welcome, the dog is two and a half and very food motivated).

GrilledWatermelon · 14/07/2022 11:55

I totally agree, sorry your child has been frightened by dogs. Such a shame when they have the capacity to give so much joy!

My small dog, a border terrier, is super friendly and wouldn't hurt a fly. Unfortunately, due to me carrying treats in my pockets when first training recall, plus the number of bloody dog owners who feed him handfuls of treats from pockets and treat bags, he has been trained that strangers are usually carrying food.

We've had to start keeping him on a lead again because once he's greeted and played with a dog, he turns to the owner and starts persistently jumping up at their pockets. So embarrassing, people don't appreciate it and I don't know how to stop it now. So, back on the lead he goes until I can undo it...

twistyizzy · 14/07/2022 11:35

EarthwormJane · 14/07/2022 11:32

It sounds like dogs are approaching the Op even without treats, so having treats to throw is hardly going to make it worse.

Are non dog walkers not allowed to have any food whatsoever on their person when out and about just in case it attracts dogs? Hmm

Having food on your person is a different scenario than throwing dog treats around you when a dog approaches. Surely you can see that?
The former is fine as you wouldn't offer your sandwich to a stranger dog however the latter is reinforcing dogs coming up to strangers. Dogs will work on a reward principle ie if running up to 1 or 2 strangers and getting treats thrown down for them then they will run up to every stranger expecting the same result. This is basic dog psyche.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 14/07/2022 11:34

I adore dogs and usually will stick up for them no matter what, however I did bollock a dog owner a few weeks ago when they let their dog with zero recall run into a picnic area of the park and eat, sniff and lick everyone's food. I was furious as I had just queued up at the chippy van for close to half an hour to get tea for the kids, DH and I. It was a nice end of week treat and not something we can afford to do often.
Dog stuck his head straight in DS(5)s portion of food which caused him to drop the whole thing and then as I was trying to get the dog away from the food and comfort DS dog managed to knock over DHs portion and started to eat mine. Do that was 3 out of 5 meals ruined. I had to actually pick up the dog to stop it trying to eat everything in site and only then did the owners come over. They started to try and tell me off for picking up their dog but I was furious and demanded the money back for the ruined meals. They started to argue but soon gave in when my friends DS started recording them and promised to put it online.

Honestly owners are the problem.

EarthwormJane · 14/07/2022 11:32

girlmom21 · 14/07/2022 11:05

@EarthwormJane the point is dogs are more likely to approach if they smell biscuits which is the exact opposite of what the OP wants

It sounds like dogs are approaching the Op even without treats, so having treats to throw is hardly going to make it worse.

Are non dog walkers not allowed to have any food whatsoever on their person when out and about just in case it attracts dogs? Hmm

HermioneKipper · 14/07/2022 11:11

Feelfreetocallme · 14/07/2022 09:59

Yabu to nearly kick an animal just because it wouldn’t ‘leave us alone’. Would you kick a person for being in very friendly? No, didn’t think so.

It was jumping up and putting its paws in my children’s buggy!

Its owners were doing nothing.

i wouldn’t want to kick it but if I needed to I would’ve

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 14/07/2022 11:05

@EarthwormJane the point is dogs are more likely to approach if they smell biscuits which is the exact opposite of what the OP wants

EarthwormJane · 14/07/2022 11:02

WinterMusings · 14/07/2022 09:38

Yeah, make yourself smell like a tasty treat, that'll work perfectly to stop them approaching you! 🙄🙄

Dog approaches, throw treats on floor, and walk away while dog is distracted eating treats.

It's always worked for me.

Have a Biscuit

WhackingPhoenix · 14/07/2022 10:05

I was at the beach with my dog a couple of days ago, happily playing fetch with him. He does NOT like to share his toys, he’s a street rescue and grew up competing for resources so he’s a bit selfish now.

A (beautiful) golden retriever came bumbling along and tried to take his ball, my dog was livid but pretty restrained, just air-snapping and barking at the thief whilst trying to hide the ball. I called over and explained to the goldie’s owners that mine wasn’t keen on sharing his toys and he was on the verge of giving their dog a proper telling-off. Of course, they shouted back ‘oh, he’s friendly, he just wants to join in the game!’ 🙄

They couldn’t recall him at all so we put the toys away and my dog and I ended up walking him back to his owners. I wasn’t happy, if my dog had nipped the goldie for constantly getting in his space, that would’ve been my fault.

Feelfreetocallme · 14/07/2022 09:59

Yabu to nearly kick an animal just because it wouldn’t ‘leave us alone’. Would you kick a person for being in very friendly? No, didn’t think so.

WinterMusings · 14/07/2022 09:38

EarthwormJane · 14/07/2022 09:10

Carry a pocketful of dog treats to throw on the floor if a dog approaches.

Yeah, make yourself smell like a tasty treat, that'll work perfectly to stop them approaching you! 🙄🙄

GaspingGekko · 14/07/2022 09:30

I visit the UK once a year usually. This year this is something that has really jumped out to me. Not dogs off the lead, but dogs on the lead that owners will allow to come right over to you to sniff at you.
I've frequently had to step into the road or off the path to avoid the dog whole the owner smiles obliviously at me not even noticing (or maybe noticing but not caring) that their dog is approaching us and blocking the way.

This is something we don't experience elsewhere and while it's always been one or two owners here who do it, this year it feels like 90% of owners are doing it.

HavfrueDenizKisi · 14/07/2022 09:29

Well I'm with you on this.

I have a nervous dog who is now always on the lead. She has fabulous recall but I can no longer let her off lead as so many friendly untrained dogs race up to her. She was scared once and ran being pursued be another dog and an ineffectual owner shouting platitudes like 'she's friendly/wants to play/ they'll come back'. She's run home twice and I've lost her once for three hours. I avoid our lovely park now too due to this.

I dislike dogs with zero recall but even more I actually judge their shit owners.

Also I see many toddlers or small kids who are wary of dogs and I make sure mine gives them a wide berth (even though she adores kids).

So you're not wrong!

catwomando · 14/07/2022 09:27

newnamethanks · 14/07/2022 08:20

Why are some parents so unreasonable that they insist on walking their already scared toddler where there are loose dogs? Don't kick anyone's dog, you won't like the consequences.

Are you really serious? Translating:

My unruly dog is more important than your child. Totally nuts.

Dogs should be under control at all times and if you can't control your dog and recall it immediately it gets out of hand, it should be on a lead.

In a reverse If a small child with sticky hands came running up to you, jumped up putting crap all over your clothes, or took a sandwich out of your hand whilst you Picknicked you'd be OK with that?

It's just unacceptable behaviour (for kids or dogs) , and people like you not apologising for it -in fact, victim blaming - just shows how distorted some peoples thinking is about their precious dogs.

ComDummings · 14/07/2022 09:20

I hate the ‘he’s so friendly’ brigade. Just train your dog. People are too lazy to train them properly. My MILs dog is absolutely angelic, off lead he just trots next to you, isn’t bothered by people walking past. Then some idiot will let their dog run up and start jumping all over us and him. If dogs jump at my kids I do put my foot out to push them away.

SavoirFlair · 14/07/2022 09:19

twistyizzy · 14/07/2022 09:17

It is also encouraging dogs to approach other people in the hopes of getting fed. Not good advice.

Agreed!

twistyizzy · 14/07/2022 09:17

SavoirFlair · 14/07/2022 09:15

What an absurd suggestion. I have to carry stuff to mitigate against the lack of training provided by a dog owner? Forget it

It is also encouraging dogs to approach other people in the hopes of getting fed. Not good advice.

SavoirFlair · 14/07/2022 09:15

EarthwormJane · 14/07/2022 09:10

Carry a pocketful of dog treats to throw on the floor if a dog approaches.

What an absurd suggestion. I have to carry stuff to mitigate against the lack of training provided by a dog owner? Forget it

coffeetofunction · 14/07/2022 09:12

As a dog owner my dogs have good recall and are allowed off the lead on big walks but I get so annoyed with other dog owners that allow their dogs to run up to me and my dogs. I keep my dogs out of the way of ours and their dogs. My old dog doesn't like big dogs because they tend to stand on her and my puppy is scared due to being attacked.... If someone looks uncomfortable with your dog near them then a responsible owner should take full control of the dog. A dog is an animal, you never know what they might do!!!

EarthwormJane · 14/07/2022 09:10

Carry a pocketful of dog treats to throw on the floor if a dog approaches.

Musti · 14/07/2022 09:07

I love dogs and I have a dog but don’t let my dog bounce onto people and I don’t want dogs coming up to me unless I am engaging with them.

there’s a lady that I know with a huge dog. He’s lovely but he’s huge and she hasn’t trained him at all so when he comes over and jumps all over me, it is really painful and I also have to protect my much smaller dog. She has no awareness!

riesenrad · 14/07/2022 08:59

I also don't understand why owners want snarly dogs. I am grateful that they keep them on short leads, but the number of times they have to keep really tight hold of their aggressive dogs (of all breeds, not just the more well known aggressive types) is quite amazing. How is such an animal fun to keep?

Most dogs just run along sniffing around and ignore me which is the way I like it.

But some rear up and growl and pull hard on the lead as soon as they see you.

gjrogjegkek · 14/07/2022 08:59

Agree! We were at the beach at the weekend and my son was sitting right on the shoreline happily admiring a hermit crab. Cue a Shih Tzu type coming right up to him, right in his face - while the owner looked on as if it was the cutest thing in the world. Imagine that dog had taken a dislike to my son and gone for his face?

riesenrad · 14/07/2022 08:56

newnamethanks · 14/07/2022 08:20

Why are some parents so unreasonable that they insist on walking their already scared toddler where there are loose dogs? Don't kick anyone's dog, you won't like the consequences.

It's pretty difficult to avoid dogs, you can't even go into a clothes shop without someone taking their dog in there!

Of course you shouldn't kick a dog (other than in self-defence, though I suspect you'd still come off worse if it sunk its jaws into you) but the proliferation of dogs appearing everywhere is having a serious impact on the quality of life of people who don't want them around them. If I don't have a dog, that doesn't affect anyone else. If I do have a dog, it does, and I should be keeping it under close control at all times.

HermioneKipper · 14/07/2022 08:55

yourmysafespace · 14/07/2022 08:49

My ds3 is now scared of dog's since a lab with no recall jumped up to him in his buggy and stole his food

A dog ran up to me at a picnic in a national trust place last month and stole the sandwich out of my hand!

The owner came running up and was like “oh dear! What’s he like?!” As though it was all really funny!

Erm no, he could’ve bitten one of my children snatching their food! And now you’d better buy me another sandwich! That was my lunch! Cheeky woman didn’t even say sorry

OP posts: