Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She just needs a spanking !

197 replies

toddleedoo · 13/07/2022 21:30

Does anyone here spank their kids ? I don't mean serious hitting, but a light clap on the bottom ?

I ask because I recently went on a shopping trip with my DS and my mother. My DS was an absolute nightmare. Having tantrums every time something didn't go his way and continuously throwing himself on the floor.

I don't shout at him in any way when he does this. I just try to distract him and if it doesn't work and he continues, I just kind of let him have his moment and do the whole, name his feelings ( you're so frustrated, mummy understands, it's not nice when we can't do what we want ) and then when he's ready I give him a cuddle. Or other times I just kind of stay near him and don't say much and just try to offer support by being near him. Recently it worked well when I said to him in a really call voice ' poor darling you're so sad and frustrated '. He seemed to calm down. Anyway, long story short, I try to be there, rather than tell him off.

My mum said I should just give him a little smack on his bottom and that would sort it out entirely. Some older people at the shopping centre got involved and were basically saying the same. I don't want to do that.

Am I being too soft though? At home, when he does something naughty like kick or jump around on the sofa, I put him on the step as a punishment. Only when he's actively defiant and hits or does something dangerous. I see him not listening / ignoring me / hitting and throwing stuff, as something that needs consequences, like going on the step.

Having melt downs because he can't get his way is a different thing to me and shouldn't be ' punished ' with a time out. Or should it ? How do you do it in public ?

Open to suggestions, I don't know what I'm doing ! I keep being told I'm too soft.

He is two and a half !

OP posts:
BiasedBinding · 14/07/2022 11:38

nightshade · 14/07/2022 11:32

Thank you biasedbinding.

In my experience ( unfortunately) parents who hold tight to the mantra of remaining sympathetic and gentle all of the time are generally permissive and scared of their children's reactions.

It is important to remember that anger and protectection are also valid emotions in certain circumstances.

I hope that my two girls are able to protect themselves and shout and hit and protect themselves SHOULD they ever need to.

Yes, which is why I validated your emotions about it. They were valid and I would have reacted in the same way

you are equating what the OP is talking about with something different.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 11:36

nightshade · 14/07/2022 11:32

Thank you biasedbinding.

In my experience ( unfortunately) parents who hold tight to the mantra of remaining sympathetic and gentle all of the time are generally permissive and scared of their children's reactions.

It is important to remember that anger and protectection are also valid emotions in certain circumstances.

I hope that my two girls are able to protect themselves and shout and hit and protect themselves SHOULD they ever need to.

That is not my expereince at all. Also, in my experience, most parents still tell of their kids where appropriate. As many have mentioned recognising feelings doens't mean not holding boundaries or explaining/ preventing unacceptable behaviour.

Research suggests children who are hit are more likely to hit themselves, so really your girls are probably at greater risk from those children....

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 14/07/2022 11:34

One of the problems with smacking is that the discipline method you reach for when you are calm and in control is often the discipline method you reach for instinctively when you are tired or angry or overwhelmed.

So my mum used to smack us when we were little when we misbehaved. But then as she got older and had a chronic illness she would hit us because she couldn't cope, not because we had done anything particularly wrong.

So I remember getting smacked for asking if she had seen an item, or if she wanted a drink etc

Because she didn't understand how to express her negative emotions, her adult version of a tantrum was to smack her children.

Its taken me until I was in my 30s to learn to be able to say that I'm sad, or I'm frustrated and so on. I nearly had a nervous breakdown in my early 30s because I was taking everything on and struggling and feeling like I had to smile through it and keep going or I would be a failure. Because I was taught having negative feelings was a failure.

By punishing children for having negative feeling you are not just teaching them that they can't show them, you are also teaching them that they shouldn't have them. So you are basically setting them up to fail your teaching their entire life.

nightshade · 14/07/2022 11:32

BiasedBinding · 14/07/2022 11:23

How awful for you, yours was a completely natural reaction, your child needed to be kept safe. That mother’s reaction though is not what most people who tend towards the “naming feelings” things would do, you happened to encounter a permissive person .

Thank you biasedbinding.

In my experience ( unfortunately) parents who hold tight to the mantra of remaining sympathetic and gentle all of the time are generally permissive and scared of their children's reactions.

It is important to remember that anger and protectection are also valid emotions in certain circumstances.

I hope that my two girls are able to protect themselves and shout and hit and protect themselves SHOULD they ever need to.

toddleedoo · 14/07/2022 11:29

I agree with @BiasedBinding.

Just because I name feelings when he's upset does not mean I don't intervene when it's clearly necessary. I saw him pull his cousins hair the other day and reacted sternly by pulling him away and telling him off for doing so. I would not be at all worried about trying to save him from kicking a baby in the head. I would very much avoid allowing him to get that close, but if it did look like he was going to do something like that, I would go nuts to stop it. I also would be happy for any other adult to shout and do whatever needed to stop something like that.

OP posts:
Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 11:25

43prego · 14/07/2022 11:24

Me too. "I'm angry mommy" "I'm happy mommy". The sweet little voice. 😘

And wouldn't it be great if more adults had learnt to do this too....

BiasedBinding · 14/07/2022 11:25

Seywot · 14/07/2022 08:38

The way parents choose to discipline their child is their decision. Those that choose not to parent their children create life-long problems for their children that often span over to the next generation.
Children without secure boundaries develop coping mechanisms that are often blamed for their parents fear of discipline.
Whether it's lawful, legal or just frowned upon, the paperwork that says what you can and cannot do with your children when it comes to regulating their behaviour will be readily available with parenting courses and teenage correction programmes for you to pay for with both your purse and your time if this is the way you choose to parent also.

Don’t be mealy-mouthed. Specifically what do you mean by parents choosing not to parent? What problems as teenagers?

43prego · 14/07/2022 11:24

3WildOnes · 14/07/2022 07:12

I've done the naming of feelings with my youngest. She is the one out of mine who tantrums the least at her age. She now cones to me and tells me 'I feeling sad' or 'I feeling cross' and we have a cuddle.

Me too. "I'm angry mommy" "I'm happy mommy". The sweet little voice. 😘

BiasedBinding · 14/07/2022 11:23

nightshade · 14/07/2022 11:15

I hate the 'you are just feeling frustrated' and sympathetic attitude when kids get totally out of line.

Especially when many years ago a 4 yr old went to sink her heavy boot into my 6mth old babies head at a group...

I shouted loudly at her..she stopped before her boot gave my baby brain damage...she didn't come near us again...

Her mother was aghast at my reaction...she stayed away also..

Job done...my baby is now a healthy 13 yr old ( without brain damage)... and also behaves herself.

How awful for you, yours was a completely natural reaction, your child needed to be kept safe. That mother’s reaction though is not what most people who tend towards the “naming feelings” things would do, you happened to encounter a permissive person .

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 11:18

The whole recognising feelings thing does not mean never telling your kids off or preventing htem from doing damage (to themselves, others, or things).

nightshade · 14/07/2022 11:15

I hate the 'you are just feeling frustrated' and sympathetic attitude when kids get totally out of line.

Especially when many years ago a 4 yr old went to sink her heavy boot into my 6mth old babies head at a group...

I shouted loudly at her..she stopped before her boot gave my baby brain damage...she didn't come near us again...

Her mother was aghast at my reaction...she stayed away also..

Job done...my baby is now a healthy 13 yr old ( without brain damage)... and also behaves herself.

pigsDOfly · 14/07/2022 11:14

Apart from learning that you're bigger than him, you have all power and you can hurt him by inflicting a painful slap, on his body, what exactly does your DM think he is going to learn from being hit?

Have you asked her?

I'm not sure how a 2.5 year old is going to grasp the meaning of words like frustrated but if it works for you then it's your choice.

The important thing is to remain calm, which is what you're doing.

Taking out your own frustration on a small child, or any child or adult, come to that by hitting them is the absolute opposite of remaining calm and is never an appropriate response to any kind of behaviour.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 11:10

HippoLover2 · 14/07/2022 11:06

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer

Is still having tantrums at 5 really a good thing though? Most kids don’t and it won’t go down well with his peers in school. Don’t you think that perhaps your approach has allowed this to continue so long?

He doesn't really tantrum out and about and he doesn't really tantrum due to specific things. But he does, when he is at home with me, sometimes have a big let out emotions. Often emotions that he has been carrying and obviously hasn't been able to process. He's always been an emotional child. I truly believe that fact he is able to identify and find a safe outlet for his feelings is super healthy for him and has a positive impact on his behaviour too - as l say he is super empathetic, very well liked, never hits, doesn't seem to fall out with his friends, can express how he feels when he needs to - good and bad.
Also I an not sure it's right taht 5 year olds (or older) can't ever have big emotional outbursts. Certainly that's not my experience of children - mine or others.

PMAmostofthetime · 14/07/2022 11:08

It's illegal in Scotland and Wales now- as it's proven to not teach children right from wrong.

thenightsky · 14/07/2022 11:08

I never dare leave my DC with my mother as I just knew she'd smack them given half a chance. When DD used to have meltdowns, my mother's response was to say... 'that child needs a good smacking!' I could see her itching to hit her.

Many years later she admitted to me that I'd done the right thing by never hitting my kids and stated she could see they had turned out to be such lovely, kind human beings. She said 'I thought you were far too soft, but I can see now what a lovely relationship you have with them as teens/young adults. Looking back she wished she hadn't hit me and my sister so quickly.

toddleedoo · 14/07/2022 11:07

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 11:00

tanturms aren't wrong though. They are uncontrolled emotions and entirely age appropriate. Punishing them for tantrums don't teach them how to control their emotions before they are ready.

By labelling feelins you teach them what the feelings are and in time they learn to process them. 2 is REALLY young. most adults aren't properly able to regulate their feelings all the time, how can you expect a 2 year old to do so. Taking this approach is not the same as giving into the tanturm.

e,g, tanrtum because toddler wants an ice cream. Parent says "oh you are sad you didn't get an ice cream, I'll get you one" - encourages tantrum. Conversely ""oh you are sad you didn't get an ice cream, I understand you feel disappointed but we are not having an ice cream today. Shall we go to the park?" Recognise the feeling, empathise/ ok the feeling, distract from the feeling.

Btw my son is 5 and still has huge emotional outbursts (aka tanturms). He can name his feels and identify why he feels them. He's not quite got to the processing yet, but it's getting there. He is one of the most empathetic kids I know.

That's a really good point actually. It's not like anyone is saying you actually need to just give into their tantrum's demand! I hadn't even thought of that.

OP posts:
HippoLover2 · 14/07/2022 11:06

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer

Is still having tantrums at 5 really a good thing though? Most kids don’t and it won’t go down well with his peers in school. Don’t you think that perhaps your approach has allowed this to continue so long?

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 11:00

tanturms aren't wrong though. They are uncontrolled emotions and entirely age appropriate. Punishing them for tantrums don't teach them how to control their emotions before they are ready.

By labelling feelins you teach them what the feelings are and in time they learn to process them. 2 is REALLY young. most adults aren't properly able to regulate their feelings all the time, how can you expect a 2 year old to do so. Taking this approach is not the same as giving into the tanturm.

e,g, tanrtum because toddler wants an ice cream. Parent says "oh you are sad you didn't get an ice cream, I'll get you one" - encourages tantrum. Conversely ""oh you are sad you didn't get an ice cream, I understand you feel disappointed but we are not having an ice cream today. Shall we go to the park?" Recognise the feeling, empathise/ ok the feeling, distract from the feeling.

Btw my son is 5 and still has huge emotional outbursts (aka tanturms). He can name his feels and identify why he feels them. He's not quite got to the processing yet, but it's getting there. He is one of the most empathetic kids I know.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 10:59

By labelling feelings etc only, are you not just showing them it's OK to have that tantrums?

Of course not. You're teaching them that feelings are normal, and we have words for them. Recognising them is the first step towards learning to handle them. It also helps to create an outlet for them. Children often tantrum because they have no other outlet for the emotion. Once they can articulate what they're feeling, they have a safe and appropriate way of expressing it.

It's a stunted mind whose only way to handle a negative emotion is to cause pain and humiliation for having it.

Discovereads · 14/07/2022 10:57

HailAdrian · 14/07/2022 10:51

I think this is spot on. The only problem is, I can't physically carry my squirming, angry 9yo 😆 I have to do the whole getting on his level somewhere out of the way and trying to reason with him thing.

Yes when an ASD child is too big/old to carry, it turned into more seeing the signs of impending meltdown and deciding to abort the trip before it reached critical mass. Every child is different but you learn to read the signs. My DD used to get closer and closer to me, hold my hand and the more distress she’d feel the faster she would squeeze/pump my hand. If it got to a certain point , I’d know hmmmm a meltdown is going to happen if we don’t head home sharpish. So I’d usually say, that’s enough for today, let’s go home and she’d usually be relieved and relax and we’d make tracks as fast as we could back home. We also tried to time outings based on what we knew their tolerance to be.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 10:56

If you were really upset and someone hit you, someone you really cared about, would that make you feel better? It might shut you up, but would you feel less angry or sad?

I would never smack my children. I don't consider it good parenting.I wouldn't smack my dog either - which the majority of people agree with. I am not sure why they then feel it's ok to hit a small human.

toddleedoo · 14/07/2022 10:52

@HippoLover2 I agree with your points to an extent too, which are the points my mum makes. If you don't directly show them that tantrums are wrong, then how can they learn ?

By labelling feelings etc only, are you not just showing them it's OK to have that tantrums?

The way I do it, is to tell him as soon as he starts the tantrum that it's NOT OK to throw yourself on the floor because you can't have what you want. If it continues, then I do the naming of feelings etc as described and remove them from the place. I have no idea if that's the right way. My mum would react angrily, telling the child off during the tantrum and possibly smacking etc.

My mum says what you say, which is, that the child will grow up thinking it's OK if they're not properly punished for a tantrum.

I've just been thinking that by age 4-5, when they lessen and when understanding improves, that would be the point at which you can properly explain to them that it's completely out of line and they cannot act that way. Surely there are lots of things which we cannot learn at 2-3 years old, which we later learn are not OK ? Once comprehension has improved ? Just my theory. An example is going to the toilet in a nappy.. most 2 year olds are in nappies and then learn to get out of nappies once they're older. It's not like we have lots of adults running around in nappies, just because we didn't teach them at age 2-3 ?

OP posts:
Discovereads · 14/07/2022 10:52

@HippoLover2
To me enforcing rules and boundaries in parenting should somewhat reflect real world (at its best) consequences rather than totally fantastic ones.

To a child, their interaction with their parents is the real world. There’s no reason to make it harsh because the outside world can be harsh with many children growing up in abusive homes.

It’s not just for when they are adults but also when they go to school.
But you were just advocating smacking a tantruming child to teach them a lesson they shouldn’t act badly. Corporal punishment was banned in U.K. schools decades ago. And adults cannot smack each other to correct misbehaviour- that’s criminal assault. So I dont know any “real world” where hitting is acceptable in school or as an adult.

HailAdrian · 14/07/2022 10:51

Discovereads · 14/07/2022 10:26

Spanking/smacking is abuse imho. I never hit my kids. And yes they did have full on melt downs and tantrums, especially the ASD ones. In a shop/public though we didn’t sit by and wait it out though, we simply picked them up and carried them out of the shop/back to the car and then went home. We abandoned trollies of stuff sometimes, but it worked. We were consistent, as soon as a tantrum/meltdown started…that’s it going home. It wasnt a punishment per se, we always said hey obviously you can’t cope with being out right now so best thing is to get you away from this environment which is causing the meltdown and try again later/tomorrow.

I think this is spot on. The only problem is, I can't physically carry my squirming, angry 9yo 😆 I have to do the whole getting on his level somewhere out of the way and trying to reason with him thing.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 10:51

Lol, yes well point well made by I still can’t fully agree. To me enforcing rules and boundaries in parenting should somewhat reflect real world (at its best) consequences rather than totally fantastic ones.

There's nothing totally fantastic about teaching kids that tantrumming won't get them what they want and will result only in them being removed from a situation until they can do better. That's pretty much how it works at the adult level. Unless you find yourself surrounded by very indulgent people, which does happen, but there's really only so much we can do.

A two year old isn't going to understand that Mummy is being inconvenienced. The whole day is probably being spent doing things Mummy doesn't really want to do. They'll just understand that tantrumming didn't get them the sweets or whatever, and indeed took them further from them. The age of tantrums (assuming a child is NT; obviously it's different otherwise) is too young to teach much more complex lessons than that.

Parenting is one long inconvenience. Perhaps you shouldn't teach your kids that it isn't!

Even if this isn't a perfect solution, nothing is worse than attempting to teach children self control and self regulation by hitting them. The only thing that teaches is that might is right, no thinking involved.