Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband loaning me money and expecting gratitude..

290 replies

Lindasllama · 13/07/2022 16:16

Big row with H (not at DH atm !)

At the end of last month I mentioned I had just had my car cleaned.and noticed a few scratches on it. H said take it to Johns garage and he will sort it out. I said ok I will get a quote and go from there.

'John' is a good friend of DH . Two days later he tells me he has had a word and to take the car to the garage. Where one of the panel beaters would have a look at it and tell me how much.

I arrived at the garage meeting DH there and the panel beater had a look at the door and said £200.. I said there is also a scratch on the wheel arch .. he quoted £250. I thanked him and said I would be in touch soon as it's not in the budget this month but could possibly be next month depending upon increased bill costs.

DH joins the conversation and says 'what about this one on the boot and a couple on the passenger side . (These scratches are v minor the sort of thing you get around my way when you pull in next to a hedge on a small lane to let a car pass you.. ) really superficial - nothing that's going to cause rust etc .

I say to DH that it's not in my budget to have it all done as I can't afford it and there are many more bills and expenses ahead of polishing my car.

DH says 'don't worry about the money' just get it done. He then asks the panel beater how much for the whole thing ? I interrupt him and say 'it's not doable at the moment I'll do it but by bit when I can afford it. I need to get to work now ' Again DH says 'don't worry about the money just do it'

I jump in the car and drive to work. 5 minutes into he journey DH rings and says 'just text 'John' and say you want the whole lot done I will sort out the money. I say thank you. Text and book it in.

Yesterday I went to pick it up. The price was £350. DH gives me the cash and asks when am I going to get this back ? You need to tell me the repayment plan. I am furious as I didn't want it done now as I can't afford it. !! I am so hacked off with him. He is fuming with me because I am ungrateful..' I did a nice thing for you - I know how much you love your car - you are so rude and ungrateful !

I tell him I have nothing to be grateful for. If he had paid as an act of generosity then absolutely ! Extremely grateful. But in my eyes he has simply moved a debt from the garage on to me for something I didn't want to do now. I couldn't afford the work when it was £250 let alone £350 I only agreed to do it because he was so insistent. !!

Some important information. We have not only separate finances but also live in separate houses. We are 12 years married and in separate homes for the last few years. It may sound strange but works for us. We stay with each other 3-4 nights a week.

DH has always been very secretive with money . I also now think he was just showing off in front of his mates . Looking to be the benevolent husband paying for his wife's car..

AIBU to be really angry to have a debt I had already said I couldn't afford foisted up me

Or am I an ungrateful cow who now has a lovely shiny car but may not be able to pay all my bills next month .- which is my fault for not nailing him down at the time and getting 'don't worry about the money' clarified from the start. ?

OP posts:
SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 13/07/2022 20:44

As @ProfessorFusspot says

But I think marital status is (mostly) a red herring here. The principle would be the same if you'd had this mix-up with, say, a parent or a rich sibling or a well-off good platonic friend and that person then asked for repayment of an apparent gift and became angry when you balked. He's definitely in large part in the wrong, if not completely, based on what you've written

Nothing wrong with separate houses if it works for you. Entirely different issue to the 'loan' one. A good friend of mine bought the adjoining semi, and her DH lives in one half, with an interlinking door. Works for them. I used to have an air raid shelter in my garden. When I got divorced I said the next man could live in there, and come out for shelves, other DIY and occasional rumpy pumpy. Only part of me was actually joking Grin

Crazykatie · 13/07/2022 20:41

You have separate finances and live in separate houses no wonder finances are tight, if you are arguing over £350 is it worth staying married.

ProfessorFusspot · 13/07/2022 20:25

I always thought Frida Kahlo's and Diego Rivera's domestic arrangements sounded pretty good: married, no children, two houses next door to each other (one each). And married couples with completely separate financial arragements has become a much more mainstream concept, too - look at RIshi Sunak.

But I think marital status is (mostly) a red herring here. The principle would be the same if you'd had this mix-up with, say, a parent or a rich sibling or a well-off good platonic friend and that person then asked for repayment of an apparent gift and became angry when you balked. He's definitely in large part in the wrong, if not completely, based on what you've written. But I'd hash out what happened with him before making any big decisions. In your place, it would make a difference to me if he was intentionally screwing me over or "just" being hideously careless (not listening to what you were saying about your budget, assuming you knew what he was thinking rather than what he said, making bad assumptions on the basis of some other arrangement or conversation, etc.)

CambsAlways · 13/07/2022 20:25

Crikey! Your husband sounds very immature showing off in front of his friend, not listening to a word you saying to him or caring, I’ve not known a situation like yours before but I know I wouldn’t be giving him a penny! But saying that I couldn’t live like you, all our money is pooled together, my husband doesn’t have secrets about money! But if it works for you that’s good,

Deadringer · 13/07/2022 20:18

So he wants gratitude and the money back. I would pay him on the 12th of fucking never.

TheOrigRights · 13/07/2022 20:18

We are 12 years married and in separate homes for the last few years. It may sound strange but works for us.

It doesn't sound like it. His money, your money? Paying him back?

HangOnToYourself · 13/07/2022 20:16

Lindasllama · 13/07/2022 18:03

Absolutely. He owns and doesn't have a will. I rent. My job comes with a very good pension but the lump some is willed to the kids. If I die first he will get a spousal pension. If he dies first I get his flat (worth £250 k so all mine under intestacty rules) , and half his occupational pension and the secret hoard of money 💰 If there is one.. who knows . It's a secret !

In that case I'd just kill him.

QueenCamilla · 13/07/2022 20:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

hedgehogger1 · 13/07/2022 20:07

I don't understand how people can have marriages like this. We have a joint account and just spend sensibly

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 13/07/2022 20:04

coffeecupsandfairylights · 13/07/2022 19:04

Do you not see how messed up this is?

Why is this messed up? In some ways, it's the ideal situation (unless he acts like a dick and says he's paying for a car repair when it's actually a loan). There are a gazillion threads on here about couples who find that their shared money is being blown on drink/drugs/gambling etc by one party. And even more threads about the annoying nature of living with a spouse. Separate houses and separate finances sounds pretty good to me. It also protects the interests of both sets of children from the first marriages (which is crucially important).

Awombaweh · 13/07/2022 19:56

I’d scratch his car then divorce him.

LoisLane66 · 13/07/2022 19:53

On his next stay at yours, tell him that you'll pay him back but no money will be involved.
Your prices are more than the scratch prices so he can have 3 bjs and one ps.

mastertomsmum · 13/07/2022 19:53

If you are married then he can’t loan you money as your finances are shared. If it’s his idea then he should be happy to help sustain what’s to most a shared financial matter

ifonly4 · 13/07/2022 19:51

You're meant to be married and a team, so sorry, but your post almost comes across as a joke. You shouldn't have to worry how owing one another money and repayments.

All our money goes in one pot (no matter who earns what). Something like car scratches, if we both agreed to get them sorted, would just come out of joint funds.

cottagegardenflower · 13/07/2022 19:51

I'd pay him your original quote of £200, and say you'll pay the rest later. Then don't

Colourmeclear · 13/07/2022 19:50

He sounds like my very emotionally immature first boyfriend. Absolutely hated all conflict unless it was with me, saw money as a status symbol and was completely uncompromising. It was infuriating. I don't know how you cope.

Sparklybutold · 13/07/2022 19:48

Sounds like such a strange set up. I think you're absolutely right with about him trying to look like the benevolent and ‘rich’ husband. OP - seriously why are you with him?

WilsonMilson · 13/07/2022 19:47

I should have read the update. So you don’t even live together? I’m even more bamboozled now. I guess whatever works for you, but what’s the point being married?!

bembridge11 · 13/07/2022 19:45

Do NOT pay him back for any of it!
That will teach him to show off in front of his mates

WilsonMilson · 13/07/2022 19:44

I can never get over these threads where married couples have entirely separate finances and talk about lending each other money.

You're married. Your money is his money. His money is your money. Honestly, why bother getting married if you want to have it any other way? Crazy.

Moonchair1 · 13/07/2022 19:44

also £350 for a few scratches by good friend is not a friend
defo not mates rates that price

Moonchair1 · 13/07/2022 19:43

dont pay it…. It cost him £350 for showing off haha

Tiani4 · 13/07/2022 19:41

Sorry that's not legal advice at all! And my autocorrect didn't kick in to word gobbledegook
But you are married

It sure keeping your finances separate when you rent is really in your best interests if you have DCs together

araucanadendrophobia · 13/07/2022 19:41

He is being totally unreasonable. Don't pay him a penny, and remind him he offered to pay it and that you didn't want it done in the first place every time he asks for it.

Tiani4 · 13/07/2022 19:39

As I noticed he's out you as his inheriter for his property
Mfrsbkly you're married so it should go to you anyway (unless he has his own DCs) and you at have a 50% claim whether he dies or you divorce !

Swipe left for the next trending thread