Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband loaning me money and expecting gratitude..

290 replies

Lindasllama · 13/07/2022 16:16

Big row with H (not at DH atm !)

At the end of last month I mentioned I had just had my car cleaned.and noticed a few scratches on it. H said take it to Johns garage and he will sort it out. I said ok I will get a quote and go from there.

'John' is a good friend of DH . Two days later he tells me he has had a word and to take the car to the garage. Where one of the panel beaters would have a look at it and tell me how much.

I arrived at the garage meeting DH there and the panel beater had a look at the door and said £200.. I said there is also a scratch on the wheel arch .. he quoted £250. I thanked him and said I would be in touch soon as it's not in the budget this month but could possibly be next month depending upon increased bill costs.

DH joins the conversation and says 'what about this one on the boot and a couple on the passenger side . (These scratches are v minor the sort of thing you get around my way when you pull in next to a hedge on a small lane to let a car pass you.. ) really superficial - nothing that's going to cause rust etc .

I say to DH that it's not in my budget to have it all done as I can't afford it and there are many more bills and expenses ahead of polishing my car.

DH says 'don't worry about the money' just get it done. He then asks the panel beater how much for the whole thing ? I interrupt him and say 'it's not doable at the moment I'll do it but by bit when I can afford it. I need to get to work now ' Again DH says 'don't worry about the money just do it'

I jump in the car and drive to work. 5 minutes into he journey DH rings and says 'just text 'John' and say you want the whole lot done I will sort out the money. I say thank you. Text and book it in.

Yesterday I went to pick it up. The price was £350. DH gives me the cash and asks when am I going to get this back ? You need to tell me the repayment plan. I am furious as I didn't want it done now as I can't afford it. !! I am so hacked off with him. He is fuming with me because I am ungrateful..' I did a nice thing for you - I know how much you love your car - you are so rude and ungrateful !

I tell him I have nothing to be grateful for. If he had paid as an act of generosity then absolutely ! Extremely grateful. But in my eyes he has simply moved a debt from the garage on to me for something I didn't want to do now. I couldn't afford the work when it was £250 let alone £350 I only agreed to do it because he was so insistent. !!

Some important information. We have not only separate finances but also live in separate houses. We are 12 years married and in separate homes for the last few years. It may sound strange but works for us. We stay with each other 3-4 nights a week.

DH has always been very secretive with money . I also now think he was just showing off in front of his mates . Looking to be the benevolent husband paying for his wife's car..

AIBU to be really angry to have a debt I had already said I couldn't afford foisted up me

Or am I an ungrateful cow who now has a lovely shiny car but may not be able to pay all my bills next month .- which is my fault for not nailing him down at the time and getting 'don't worry about the money' clarified from the start. ?

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 15:24

Mean with money, mean with love.

I've never seen an exception.

PerseverancePays · 14/07/2022 15:22

I think it sounds like a terrific , intelligent arrangement that works long term for all of you. Shame more people aren’t more creative with their living arrangements.
so glad it all got resolved, crossed wires and all that.

billy1966 · 14/07/2022 15:21

adriftabroad · 14/07/2022 09:00

... A secretive man I am legally, financially tied to.

Write down every single bit of information you can remember and talk to a solicitor about a forensic accountant.

They pay for themselves if money you can access is being hidden.

Get every bit of information you can about his employer too.
Employee pension information is not hard to come by if you know where to look.

adriftabroad · 14/07/2022 15:14

Public declaration of love. Great.
Private non declaration of finances in a financial contract.Not great.

I have not lived with my husband for years. Irrelevant.
I expect support for our DD, of course. You ignored my correction to your feminist slant on my needing xhild allowance money for myself (not our DD) and you supporting yourself.
I do not care if you leave him or not!

I am just giving you a free bit of legal advice. Expensive advice, that I have received.

Your husband can make a will at any time.

Your husband can quite easily become ill and make odd choices.

You should know about his investments/tax/pensions/banks. Not touch them, KNOW about them.

Seeing as your one argument is about money and his odd reaction, you seriously need to think about it.

Glad he is cooking you dinner 👌

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 14:55

Lindasllama · 14/07/2022 14:51

R*emeBumsWombat
*
This is where your argument fails..

He isn't the father of my child. He is their step father. Myself and my ex husband provide for our children. He provided for his own children together with his ex wife.

Sorry, I missed that.

But you're still in a financial contract with someone who wants to keep his money a secret from you and with whom you can't stand living.

Public declarations of love are great, though.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 14:52

We married because we wanted to make a public declaration of our love for each other.

It's a financial contract. I wouldn't generally advise doing it without love, but that's what it is.

Lindasllama · 14/07/2022 14:51

R*emeBumsWombat
*
This is where your argument fails..

He isn't the father of my child. He is their step father. Myself and my ex husband provide for our children. He provided for his own children together with his ex wife.

OP posts:
Lindasllama · 14/07/2022 14:48

adriftabroad · 14/07/2022 13:34

It is NOT abouting wanting or needing his money, it is about not wanting his debts/tax reasons for marriage? Egocentric investments that tank.

Spouses should legally know what they are potentially liable for.

I have my suspicions here. If you do not, good for you. But I do not know why you got married. There was absolutely zero reason to.

Here's a radical idea for getting married ... because we fell in love with each other and still love each other.

Money had absolutely no bearing on the decision. I didn't expect him to support me and the kids before we married. Nor did he expect me to support him and his.

This didn't change on marriage.
We married because we wanted to make a public declaration of our love for each other. 14 years later we both feel the same and if anything it's even stronger . Not living together means making more of an effort to see each other. More things to talk about.

Financially he has more to lose than me. I have a pension /death in service lump sum. Which is willed to my kids. Half the flat left to him for his life and then divided between my kids. My savings divided between my kids, a spousal pension which will go to him.

He has half a flat an occupational pension and I presume savings. He hasn't made a will and never will. Believe me. He will never do it - thinks it's 'bad luck' and will cause him to die. So majority will come to me. With remainder divided amongst his kids.

I know MN loves a drama but he is neither a Machiavellian schemer, financial abuser or philanderer. He was a dick yesterday about the money thing. Has apologised. Many many times since last night and coming over this evening to cook me supper as another apology.

I am sorry if I you are all dissatisfied for my failure to LTB over one row.. but that is the last thing in my mind. We are about 18 months from retirement and are busy planning that exciting stage in our lives. Which will involve long periods of living together again.. (too outing to be specific) we are both excited to do this and are counting the days.

OP posts:
adriftabroad · 14/07/2022 13:34

It is NOT abouting wanting or needing his money, it is about not wanting his debts/tax reasons for marriage? Egocentric investments that tank.

Spouses should legally know what they are potentially liable for.

I have my suspicions here. If you do not, good for you. But I do not know why you got married. There was absolutely zero reason to.

SheepingStandingUp · 14/07/2022 13:21

because your husband, father of your someone else's children, can't cope with living with his family wife and her children.

won't tell you about money (how do you know he's not being mean with it or how much richer you are if you don't know how much he's got?)
Well I have no idea what is in the bank account of the DH I live with. I know what he earns, what he pays towards bills but I don't expect to know what happens to it beyond that. But if he'd brought me flowers twice a week, paid for presents for for his bio and none bio kids at Xmas, generally paid when we went out for dinner etc I could assess he wasn't stingy / was generous with his money. I don't need to know what % of his money he's spending on me. The value of my birthday presents is measured against what he's picked and put thought in to, not how much he could have afforded.

adriftabroad · 14/07/2022 12:48

You are deliberately missing the point.

I am divorcing my husband as I do not trust he is upfront and honest and I am legally bound, financially to him.

I want out. Why will he not share this with me?

I don[t give a shit where you live. You do not have DCs together, so of course you do not get a monthly child allowance, for your adult DCs. 🤔And of course, I do.

Just make sure it is not all invested in Bitcoin, that he doesnt have a second mortgage, that he is honest about tax. Things like that. Because you are liable for it all, whether you know about it or not.

Good luck and sorry I struck a nerve.

MintJulia · 14/07/2022 12:26

YANBU.

Offer to pay the original £200 - the bit you wanted done - first, and then pay £25 a month until the rest is paid.

If H moans, tell him, he shouldn't have put you in this position.

And no, you have no reason to be grateful. He's just interfering.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 12:17

For all those who think you can't have a marriage without living together.. how about the thousands whose DH works away all week ?

They're apart because their husbands are stationed somewhere, not because he couldn't cope with living at home and didn't want them to know about his money.

Do you truly not see the difference?

As for starfishing in bed, a spare room will do that. I've been in ours all week in this heat. Not an option for everyone, of course, but shouldn't be too hard for a family that can run two homes without even knowing how much money there is.

Awombaweh · 14/07/2022 12:12

Lindasllama · 14/07/2022 12:10

Married to a woman he is also financially tied to.

(Secretive about money btw.. not secretive generally)

but this seems to have made him very paranoid that I am somehow out to fleece him.!

This stood out to me.

Lindasllama · 14/07/2022 12:10

adriftabroad · 14/07/2022 09:00

... A secretive man I am legally, financially tied to.

Married to a woman he is also financially tied to.

(Secretive about money btw.. not secretive generally)

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 12:08

What I can't get my head around is why so many people are screaming ' divorce the bastard' because he doesn't share his money with me.. (especially with me 'bringing up a child' )It's completely bizarre.. he lives in a different house. A house with a mortgage that I have a 50/50 ownership of. He pays the mortgage. He pays HIs bills .

Your situation is what's bizarre.

Marriage is a financial contract designed to facilitate the running of a home. Something is really off when you make a contract like that, but split homes and make a secret out of your money. It literally defeats the object. Why bother getting married if you're offended at the idea of sharing money and don't want your spouse to know about it?

You say it works for you but it clearly doesn't when you're on here asking for advice because your husband, father of your children, can't cope with living with his family, won't tell you about money (how do you know he's not being mean with it or how much richer you are if you don't know how much he's got?) and puts on weird displays of faux generosity to look good in front of the mechanics while fucking you over and demanding a repayment plan from you, his wife, who lives separately to him with the kids. With separate, secretive finances.

The few things you mention, like making a bit of effort for dinner or flowers or whatever aren't shining examples of his towering generosity and wonderfulness. They're minor, bog standard bits of decency that seem so amazing only because they're occurring in such a weird setup.

Lindasllama · 14/07/2022 12:07

GabriellaMontez · 14/07/2022 09:56

The house he lives in is owned by him? But you call it 'ours'? Have I got this right?

It's just that you say he's secretive... for all you know he's remortgaged it.

I'm glad your unusual situation works and he's acknowledged that he wouldn't like it to get back to John...!

No he hasn't remortgaged our flat !!
We are married.
The mortgage is in joint names.
Just because we spend a few nights a part each week and have had a row about a loan/gift. Doesn't make him Bernie fucking Madoff. !

I do all the post at both homes so pretty sure I might have been asked to sign something if he was going to try and remortgage without me .

OP posts:
Awombaweh · 14/07/2022 12:04

He still sounds like an arse who wanted to look good in front of his pal on your behalf. Even if he said he is sorry now (that he has seen this thread) that says pretty much what he is really like. But all happy and good, so that’s that then.

Lindasllama · 14/07/2022 11:57

What I can't get my head around is why so many people are screaming ' divorce the bastard' because he doesn't share his money with me.. (especially with me 'bringing up a child' )

It's completely bizarre.. he lives in a different house. A house with a mortgage that I have a 50/50 ownership of. He pays the mortgage. He pays HIs bills .

I chose to live separately. I choose to rent. (If you saw my house you would understand why) . The 'child' is 21 !! And not his child.

A pp says she is divorcing her DH because he was the 'same as mine' ..stingy with her allowance...let me make something abundantly clear

I DONT NEED A BLOODY ALLOWANCE !! I DO NOT WANT HIS MONEY OR IMPORTANTLY. - NEED IT !!

In the same way that DH doesn't share with me - I equally don't share with him !

He is secretive with money . However as I neither want nor need his money due to my financial independence.. it's annoying but otherwise unimportant.

It seems the inference on here is that DH should 'share' his money with me . When in fact you mean he should give me some of his.. because I must be a poor little woman who can't finance herself .

You could t be further away from the truth. I am a saver and a budgeter. I could have paid for my own car from my savings. However I set myself a monthly budget in order to have savings to put away. I had budgeted £250 for the car next month or possibly august depending on rising living costs. I was just angry at being bounced into a cost that I had said three times was not in this months budget.

DH is not mean with money. He is just secretive. It's very different. When we go out it is invariably him that pays unless it's his birthday or a specific celebration for him. He is generators to all 7 kids on birthdays/Christmas.
He buys me flowers every time he comes over (twice a week on average ) and never appears without something nice for supper or a pudding.. so for all of you who have an image of a miser sitting in his home counting his gold.. with poor little me and 'child' surviving on breadcrumbs.. you really have read this wrong !

For all I know - I m wealthier than him. ! As for the poor 'child' - she survives quite well. She works 2 p/t jobs in the Uni holidays, has a financially solvent mother, a doting dad and a generous step father. She lives the life of Riley !

OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 14/07/2022 09:56

The house he lives in is owned by him? But you call it 'ours'? Have I got this right?

It's just that you say he's secretive... for all you know he's remortgaged it.

I'm glad your unusual situation works and he's acknowledged that he wouldn't like it to get back to John...!

Hoppinggreen · 14/07/2022 09:17

I think OPs living arrangements are her business and in some ways sound quite nice.
However, when she says that her H is secretive about money and doesn’t live with her because he’s a big sulky baby it doesn’t sound great
No idea why she married him instead of just being in a relationship and not having the legal ties

adriftabroad · 14/07/2022 09:00

... A secretive man I am legally, financially tied to.

adriftabroad · 14/07/2022 08:58

LovelyYellowLabrador · 13/07/2022 23:33

Also he could be upto his eyeballs in debt for all you know and legally that’s your problem too

This is why I am getting divorced. My husband is so secretive about his so called assets. His tax/pension. It[s all overseas.

I am not being stuck with that mess. Now DD is an age where she can be listened to about who she wants to live with (in court) I am definitely out of it.

We also live apart, this is not the problem. The financial abuse (I do not get a big enough allowance to look after DD properly and have had to take out a loan, for example, to buy her a phone, go to the dentist) that is the problem.

But as @LovelyYellowLabrador says, you will be responsible for any odd decisions he makes over finances/any debts.

I hope his moral compass is not usually so off kilter, as it was with John. THAT is what would keep me awake at night. THAT is why I am getting divorced. I can trust myself, not a secretive man.

Topseyt123 · 14/07/2022 08:23

Lindasllama · 13/07/2022 23:08

Absolutely! and what great night to have my bedtime myself ! No other body getting all hot and sticky next to me... I can 'starfish' all night. Bliss !

For all those who think you can't have a marriage without living together.. how about the thousands whose DH works away all week ? Those who are military wives. Are their marriages 'invalid' ? I am quite insulted people would judge my marriage on their narrow idea of the word.

Well, I think your living arrangements sound excellent. Sometimes I could be jealous of you. 🤣

This man virtually forced the repair of your car on you and insisted you shouldn't worry about the money. To me that would mean that he was paying for it and I would not give him any repayment plan. He could whistle for that.

Thank him for paying for it for you and just ignore any protests or stropping. It is the foolish arse's own fault for showing off and trying to flash the cash in front of his mate.

TheOrigRights · 14/07/2022 08:04

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 14/07/2022 07:30

Its a shame that pp can't be more open minded about how people choose to live their lives. Good for you op for being brave enough to live a lifestyle that suits you and your family.

Oh I think most people are pretty open minded about a married couple living apart, it's the financial situation which is not healthy.
Her husband being a financial arse is nothing to do with how they live. He's 'lending' her money to get her car repaired and as if that wasn't bad enough he then asked for a payment plan to pay it back.

Swipe left for the next trending thread