Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I pick up a crying newborn every time?

156 replies

DangerouslyBored · 13/07/2022 15:30

Currently 6 months pregnant with PFB. Chatting with in laws recently, my MiL said, “you’re not going to be one of those mothers that picks up the baby every time it cries are you?”. I said I hadn’t really thought about it. She said, “you will make a rod for your own back if you do”.

So, I Googled ‘should I pick up my newborn every time they cry?’ and I’m as much in the dark as I was when I started. Seems that there is a ton of contradictory advice / studies on the subject. Can anyone fill me in on the latest advice?

OP posts:
CactusBlossom · 13/07/2022 19:34

Pick up your baby; otherwise baby will call for help and find it doesn't come... Baby could be hungry, need changing, want a cuddle, be in pain... MiL can mind her own; you do what's comfortable for you and your family. It doesn't sound like she's trying to be helpful, more like trying to be bossy.

ReeseWitherfork · 13/07/2022 19:32

MrsHarrison87 · 13/07/2022 19:17

My husband's work colleague says he's exhausted with his newborn because he won't sleep unless he's on his mum's chest. So they take turns to sleep. But she rocks him to sleep and never puts him down. Her choice of course, but I found mine slept better if I put them down awake but sleepy. If they grumble, give them a gentle pat and shush so they know you're present. If they begin to cry, pick them up, cuddle and soothe, try putting them down again.

“Her choice of course”…. Or…. And hear me out here…. Her baby is different to yours? Plenty of babies only sleep on their parents, you’ve not cracked parenting where millions of others have failed.

GraceandMolly · 13/07/2022 19:17

Yes, you pick them up and don’t listen to the “you’ll make a rod for your own back thing”. If it’s not a problem now then you’ll deal with any future issues when and if they arrive.

I was so worried about spoiling my daughter with breastfeeding and her falling asleep on boob. I was made to worry she’ll never sleep on her own and kept on reading about all the strategies. But cosleeping and her feeding to sleep worked so well for us until she was 2 years old. And then she stopped.

MrsHarrison87 · 13/07/2022 19:17

My husband's work colleague says he's exhausted with his newborn because he won't sleep unless he's on his mum's chest. So they take turns to sleep. But she rocks him to sleep and never puts him down. Her choice of course, but I found mine slept better if I put them down awake but sleepy. If they grumble, give them a gentle pat and shush so they know you're present. If they begin to cry, pick them up, cuddle and soothe, try putting them down again.

IsAnyoneActuallyListening · 13/07/2022 19:11

I'm 63 so my kids are late 30s/early 40s. I never once let them cry without picking them up when they were babies. My MIL used to spout that same "making a rod" bollocks

Playmethechoralmusic · 13/07/2022 19:09

Please PLEASE ignore you mil, that’s a very outdated way of parenting and there is so much evidence that shows responding to your baby every time actually creates a happy and independent baby/child/adult. You are not making a rod for your own back in any way shape or form. Just remember that a baby isn’t even able to recognise that it is a separate being from its mother until around a year. Follow your gut instincts xx

Newmumatlast · 13/07/2022 19:00

Yes pick your baby up. It creates good healthy attachment. The rod for your own back nonsense is not good child development practice. I always picked up my daughter and she frequently slept cuddling me in the day etc. Now everyone always comments on how confident she is. She is always happy to go off to nursery or to play with others but also happy to return to me - because she feels secure in her attachment with me and doesnt need to cling. That because I met her needs when she was little so she had no worries about whether or not I would come or not if needed

DottyLittleRainbow · 13/07/2022 18:56

Yes you should pick your baby up when they cry if you can. Babies can’t be manipulative and you can’t ‘spoil’ a baby by cuddling them as some people like to say - they cry to communicate that they need something. Google the fourth trimester and ignore your MIL.

MrsHarrison87 · 13/07/2022 18:51

It depends. When you've got more than one small child you can't always stop what you're doing to tend to a baby if it's just whimpering. A baby that needs picking up, you will know about it. I never picked up for every whimper and my second, third and fourth babies all learned to self soothe (they had comfort then went down awake. If the whimpers went into full blown cries I'd pick up) and as a result they were great sleepers compared to my eldest who I would constantly pick up.

Favouritefruits · 13/07/2022 18:49

Yes, obviously you pick up a crying baby, what kind of person leaves a newborn baby to cry!

boupdeflouff · 13/07/2022 18:47

You can't spoil a baby, despite what our mothers tell us.

I am going to leave here the newborn commandments.

Dear mummy and daddy,

Please keep this letter from me in a place where you can read it and re-read it when things are rough and you are feeling down.
• Please don’t expect too much from me as a newborn baby, or too much from yourselves as parents. Give us both 6 weeks as a birthday present, 6 weeks for me to grow, develop, mature, and become more stable and predictable – 6 weeks for you to rest and relax and allow your body to get back to normal.
• Please feed me when I am hungry, I never knew hunger in your womb and clocks and time mean little to me.
• Please hold, cuddle, kiss, touch, stroke, and croon to me. I was always held closely in your womb and have never been alone before.
• Please forgive me if I cry a lot. I am not a tyrant who was sent to make your life miserable, the only way I can tell you I am not happy is with my cry, bear with me and in a short time, as I mature, I will spend less time crying and more time socialising.
• Please take the time to find out who I am, how I differ from you and how much I can bring to you. Watch me carefully and I’ll tell you things which sooth, console and please me.
• Please remember that I am resilient and can withstand the many natural mistakes you’ll make with me. As long as you make them with love, I cannot be harmed.
• Please don’t be disappointed when I am not the perfect baby you expected nor be disappointed with yourselves when you are not the perfect parents.
• Please take care of yourself; eat a balanced diet, rest, and exercise so that when we are together, you have the patience and energy to take care of me. The cure for a fussy baby is more rest for Mum.
• Please take care of your relationship with each other. What good is family bonding if there is no family left for me to bond with.
• Keep the “big picture” in mind. I’ll be like this for a very short time, though it seems like forever to you now. Although I may have turned your life upside down, please remind yourselves that things will be back to normal before long.
• Enjoy me – I’ll never be this little again!

43prego · 13/07/2022 18:47

Pick up and smother with love. Actually if you are 6 months prego get confi like you can. If you can't It's hubby's turn, as everyone said if you really can't of course it can wait. They are safe it's ok. You will have a calmer more confident child, it builds up.

Traveller3367 · 13/07/2022 18:43

Yes pick them up BUT I will add a caveat here to say if they are fed / clean / safe, you won't do harm to leave them crying for a few minutes e.g. if things get too much and you need a time out or if you need the loo etc.
As for children learning not to cry if you don't respond, this is a load of nonsense and based on the plight of Romanian orphans in the 80/90s but that situation was extreme and not equivalent to 5 mins while you have a quick wee or even cry it out imo (can see footage of Romanian orphanages on YouTube). Also I did try CIO with my eldest (now 2) and currently youngest (6 months old) will bawl eyes out if I need the loo for a few minutes. Neither have learned crying doesn't elicit a response and stopped crying. Clearly they didn't get that memo 🤣
Be easy on yourself when baby is here. Motherhood is hard without worrying every cry will leave lasting damage (it won't!)

PattyMelt · 13/07/2022 18:36

I picked mine up when they cried, when they didn't cry, when they were awake, sometimes even when they were asleep She's being archaic, her parenting was from when she had her kids, now it's your turn, do it your way.

alphapie · 13/07/2022 18:34

As a newborn you pick them up every time.

But I wouldn't be surprised if she was referring to a slightly older baby with the comments, as after a few months I don't know anyone who would drop everything to pick the child up if it was a ratty cry (not a cry for food, nappy, anything genuinely uncomfortable) they'd rub their belly or back. Play with them in situ, but not always pick right up

AuntySandrasDauphinois · 13/07/2022 18:33

Yes. Also go to antenatal group and learn latest advice.

Goldbar · 13/07/2022 18:32

Actual upset crying, yes. I think you can be more relaxed about a bit of moaning and grunting, though. I put a toy bar above my DC's cot from a few months old and that used to keep DC amused for a bit in the morning and after naps.

Though I think it's fine for the baby to wait a few minutes if you're on the loo or in the shower or similar. There will be times when you just can't pick up your screaming baby (in a traffic jam on the motorway, for example) and it feels terrible, but no long-term harm done.

Discovereads · 13/07/2022 18:11

My step monster in law said the exact same thing when I had my first DC. It’s old outdated advice and I think it is neglect as well.

Obviously, I or DH always picked them up every time they cried. Often when we could tell they wanted to be picked up but before they got to the crying stage. Babies will rustle about and make snuffling noises indicating they need you before they cry.

glamourousindierockandroll · 13/07/2022 18:10

I recommend just getting a stock phrase in place. Something along the lines of 'thank you, but advice is rather different these days'. Or 'thank you, but I'm going to do what feels right for me'.

This. And be prepared for a passive agressive eye roll, or a derisive little laugh that insinuates "hark at her - she'll learn!"

Pleasegodgotosleep · 13/07/2022 18:10

The only rod you'll be making gor your back is listening and being dictated to by MIL!

Not her baby not her business, unless you ASK for advice.

Borgonzola · 13/07/2022 18:07

The best thing I've read is that a baby's wants and needs are the same. You're not spoiling the baby by giving them comfort. They've spent 9 months wrapped up in the warmth and comfort in your body and suddenly they're out alone in the cold, and you picking them up and holding them close is the most reassuring and loving thing you can do.

I'd suggest that if MIL makes a big deal of you doing this once baby is here, or says 'you're spoiling her/him' you just do a little laugh and say 'gosh, no such thing' and continue to smile lovingly down at your baby as if she hasn't just said something ridiculous. She can't begrudge you for loving your own baby!

glamourousindierockandroll · 13/07/2022 18:06

Yes, if you can. I definitely did with my eldest. Couldn't always get there as fast with my youngest but I did my best.

Neither of my children are or have been tantrummers. Not saying it's because of anything I did, but I guess I haven't made them overly dependent on me.

The stressiest baby at our NCT group had the mum who said she never interrupted her meals to pick her crying newborn up as 'he needs to learn he can't always have his own way.'

NotMeekNotObedient · 13/07/2022 18:04

Of course you do!

ihavenocats · 13/07/2022 18:01

It's literally your only job right now and you can never ever do it again. You only get this time. Hold them every.single.time.

Inmyonesie · 13/07/2022 17:52

Yes. Every time. I hear so many people talk about how babies and young children are manipulating their parents by crying. No... they have unmet needs and are crying for you to help them.