Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tradespeople who insist on cash

118 replies

Oestrogelsmuggler · 13/07/2022 10:41

I am trying to get a wood burner installed. I have been given a price by a local company, but was told it'd have to be in cash, or else I'd need to pay an extra 20%, even for a bank transfer.

This annoys me. It looks to me like an obvious tax dodge, for starters. Yet this seems standard among tradespeople these days. I find it offensive when the rest of us dutifully pay our tax.

It's also inconvenient. I resent having to get thousands of pounds out in cash. I can't get it easily in one visit to a cashpoint.

It's made me want to not give him the business - but unfortunately he's the only one who bothered to visit my house and give me a reasonable quote.

Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Loics · 13/07/2022 17:51

All the people chomping at the bit to get him reported to HMRC, as if he won't be covering his back somehow. 😂 Some spiteful folk around.

ThreeLittleDots · 13/07/2022 16:44

Don't cut corners. Carbon monoxide poisoning is real!

LondonWolf · 13/07/2022 16:43

jimmyhill · 13/07/2022 13:36

Pay in cash then report him to HMRC. After the work is complete obviously.

Judge this thought process far more than the tradesman himself tbh.

ThreeLittleDots · 13/07/2022 16:40

Yup. Sounds like a cowboy. At the least you'll have a written quote. Search the Hetas register for your nearest installers:

www.hetas.co.uk/consumer/services/installers/

Oestrogelsmuggler · 13/07/2022 16:17

ArcticSkewer · 13/07/2022 14:58

He is giving you a morality test....

Will you ...
A pay cash in hand and save 20%
or...
B pay VAT at 20%

So, op, which are you choosing?

Yes, I think this is the thing that surprised me - that it's presented as an option to avoid tax. I asked for an itemised estimate, too, and all I got was a screen shot of my own attempt to summarise what I thought I was paying for.

I'm guessing the hive mind of Mumsnet would assume he's a cowboy and should be avoided? I got his details from Checkatrade, so assumed he'd be kosher.

Frustratingly, from a number of initial enquiries that I made, this is the only person in the trade who has actually come to my house to see the job. The rest of them seem content to go off photos alone. They don't know anything about the height of the chimney or other useful contextual factors.

I'm starting to go off the whole idea.

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · 13/07/2022 16:05

He didn’t insist on cash. He offered you a lower price for cash

he also gave you the option of bank transfer costing you more as would go via books

and fwiw dh often gets cash but he still banks it as needs the money into the the bills

burnoutbabe · 13/07/2022 15:40

if you are self employed as say a painter - you earn £50k, then you pay the 40% tax on the amount over 50k and 20% on the rest - very similar to you working for a company as an employee. (and plus NI as well)

yes its on "profits" but that just means you can take off your costs of say paint etc. Not deduct your OWN wages.

(different if the tradesman has his own company.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 13/07/2022 15:29

Badbadbunny · 13/07/2022 15:10

Err, I'm an accountant and have been doing small business accounts/tax returns for over 30 years! It's EXACTLY how it works. Most will continue to put the expenses through the books, so the cash IS straight off the profits as they're not just failing to declare the income, they're continuing to claim the associated expenses.

I've been involved in dozens, if not hundreds of tax enquiries where this is exactly the scenario. It's hard to believe that so many are so blatant to do it, as common sense would say you're more likely to be caught, but lots of traders buy on trade accounts so monthly statements show all their purchases, so not easy to hide anyway.

Obviously, some make cash payments to casual staff (thus also evading employers NIC, etc), or to other "cash" traders especially skip hire, scaffolders, etc., so in those cases, yes, you'd be right that it's only the profit being evaded by the trader in question, but the cash paid to their workers/subbies etc is also being used for tax evasion, which just multiplies the amount of income tax, NIC and VAT evaded over several different traders.

Having said that, some traders are a lot more cunning, and have, say, different trade accounts with different suppliers, so buy goods for "declared" jobs from one supplier with costs put through their books, and goods bought for "cash" jobs from a different supplier who they pay in cash and where the invoices don't go through the books. Of course, when the cunning ones get caught out, their punishment (i.e. tax penalties) are higher because they can't claim innocence or accidental poor book-keeping, and they face the highest tier of penalties for deliberate and concealed tax evasion.

The black economy, which includes this kind of thing is the largest component of the official UK tax gap - far higher than tax avoidance by global firms, millionaires etc, simply due to the numbers game, i.e. huge numbers of "normal" people evading a few thousands of pounds against a very small number of "big" people/firms evading millions.

But where does the 30%-40% tax come from?

The black economy paragraph is just twaddle.

TarasHarp55 · 13/07/2022 15:25

Hoppybunny · 13/07/2022 10:54

This is why we need to go cashless.

There's so many more reasons why we shouldn't.

abblie · 13/07/2022 15:23

My partner accepts cash only NOT because of trying to void the tax man BUT because customers on quite a few occasions never sent the money or forgot or banking app was down etc etc and he had to chase payments days and weeks after completing a job.

JudgeRindersMinder · 13/07/2022 15:14

ArcticSkewer · 13/07/2022 15:10

As if ...
Op is clearly going to choose the cash option but thinks whinging on here will balance out her lack of ethics.
Op has the choice - pay more and 'do the right thing' or 'pay less and be complicit'. There isn't option C - pay less but whine about tax evasion.

Precisely this. I’m happy to pay cash, as others have said a lot of guys pay their workers in cash. What they do with the cash is between them and their accountant.

2022babyhope · 13/07/2022 15:11

The drama 😅 it's common - not just amongst tradesmen - that you get a cheaper cash price.

Either give them cash for the discount, pay the VAT price or find someone else!

Badbadbunny · 13/07/2022 15:10

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 13/07/2022 14:59

He as a trader or the business will not pay 30-40% tax fgs.
It doesn't work like that.😂

TAX IS PAID ON PROFITS.🤓
I'm sorry to shout but my goodness, people are fiscally inept.

Err, I'm an accountant and have been doing small business accounts/tax returns for over 30 years! It's EXACTLY how it works. Most will continue to put the expenses through the books, so the cash IS straight off the profits as they're not just failing to declare the income, they're continuing to claim the associated expenses.

I've been involved in dozens, if not hundreds of tax enquiries where this is exactly the scenario. It's hard to believe that so many are so blatant to do it, as common sense would say you're more likely to be caught, but lots of traders buy on trade accounts so monthly statements show all their purchases, so not easy to hide anyway.

Obviously, some make cash payments to casual staff (thus also evading employers NIC, etc), or to other "cash" traders especially skip hire, scaffolders, etc., so in those cases, yes, you'd be right that it's only the profit being evaded by the trader in question, but the cash paid to their workers/subbies etc is also being used for tax evasion, which just multiplies the amount of income tax, NIC and VAT evaded over several different traders.

Having said that, some traders are a lot more cunning, and have, say, different trade accounts with different suppliers, so buy goods for "declared" jobs from one supplier with costs put through their books, and goods bought for "cash" jobs from a different supplier who they pay in cash and where the invoices don't go through the books. Of course, when the cunning ones get caught out, their punishment (i.e. tax penalties) are higher because they can't claim innocence or accidental poor book-keeping, and they face the highest tier of penalties for deliberate and concealed tax evasion.

The black economy, which includes this kind of thing is the largest component of the official UK tax gap - far higher than tax avoidance by global firms, millionaires etc, simply due to the numbers game, i.e. huge numbers of "normal" people evading a few thousands of pounds against a very small number of "big" people/firms evading millions.

ArcticSkewer · 13/07/2022 15:10

As if ...
Op is clearly going to choose the cash option but thinks whinging on here will balance out her lack of ethics.
Op has the choice - pay more and 'do the right thing' or 'pay less and be complicit'. There isn't option C - pay less but whine about tax evasion.

Mousemat25 · 13/07/2022 15:08

WeAreBob · 13/07/2022 15:02

If your problem is tax dodging then go with his second option. Pay by bank transfer and pay the extra 20% he has to charge for the VAT.

You want it done properly and officially and you want him to declare the income so you need to pay the VAT.

What's the problem? You've been given the option so just pay it.

Do not do this! Even if you pay the VAT and he pays it to HMRC think of all of the other people that opt to help him evade tax. you are dealing with a blatant criminal here! Don’t touch him with a barge pole and call HMRC.

ItsSnowJokes · 13/07/2022 15:07

I really don't see the issue. Just pay by bank transfer if you want it to be above board. I often pay cash. Its not up to me what he does with his finances. He gives x price for cash or y for bank transfer. Make your choice!

ginghamstarfish · 13/07/2022 15:07

It's not just about VAT, that is just passed on by the tradesman when charged to customer. He's clearly wanting to avoid paying tax on his earnings - no doubt declares some earnings but yes it's a tax dodge, and both immoral and illegal. Most of us don't have the luxury of choosing whether to declare our income. CHeating bastard.

WeAreBob · 13/07/2022 15:02

If your problem is tax dodging then go with his second option. Pay by bank transfer and pay the extra 20% he has to charge for the VAT.

You want it done properly and officially and you want him to declare the income so you need to pay the VAT.

What's the problem? You've been given the option so just pay it.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 13/07/2022 14:59

Badbadbunny · 13/07/2022 14:02

Not quite, by not declaring it, the builder is also saving himself 30-40% tax and NIC!

He as a trader or the business will not pay 30-40% tax fgs.
It doesn't work like that.😂

TAX IS PAID ON PROFITS.🤓
I'm sorry to shout but my goodness, people are fiscally inept.

ArcticSkewer · 13/07/2022 14:58

Oestrogelsmuggler · 13/07/2022 11:09

You are fine with tax dodging?

He is giving you a morality test....

Will you ...
A pay cash in hand and save 20%
or...
B pay VAT at 20%

So, op, which are you choosing?

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 13/07/2022 14:52

Report him to HMRC.
I am sure that they would be interested to know this.

It always surprises me that tradesmen are happy to tax dodge so blatantly.
Aren't they worried that people will report them?

There is an online form you can fill in.

Also it isn't VAT that they are avoiding as they would just pay that over to HMRC. They are avoiding personal tax or corporation tax depending on whether they are a sole trader or company.

riesenrad · 13/07/2022 14:34

I think there are a lot of people who are misunderstanding VAT. If you are registered for VAT you have to charge it to your customers - it isn't a voluntary thing! You don't get to take cash and not charge them (and in addition not pay income/corporation tax yourself depending on whether you are a sole trader or not).

Clearly if the tradesman takes cash HE is avoiding tax. He is not trying to save the customer money. That is inferring a great deal of "altruism" on the part of the trader that I doubt they have.

As far as I am concerned, tradespeople don't get to "insist" on cash. It's not that easy to get it now given the diminishing number of bank branches and you can only get a certain amount out of an ATM (and there are fewer of them as well).

gogohmm · 13/07/2022 14:27

I won't deal with any tradesperson who demands cash, I can only get £250 out of the atm and there's no branch left here. I pay by bank transfer

MeMe3Spoons · 13/07/2022 14:03

Tax evasion/morality aside please make sure that you will receive the correct documentation from which ever tradesperson/company you choose. This work will fall under building regulations and will need to be registered. If this doesn't happen it can cause problems when selling the property and can even invalidate your home insurance. You also need a receipt so that you have come back for any problems and I would make sure that they have a good trading history so are less likely to 'disappear'.

Badbadbunny · 13/07/2022 14:02

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 13/07/2022 10:52

Pay the extra 20% then, basically, the business is trying to save YOU the customer money.

Not quite, by not declaring it, the builder is also saving himself 30-40% tax and NIC!