Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to worry about the schools bill

33 replies

LivingOnAPear · 13/07/2022 08:05

I’m surprised there’s not more chat about this on mumsnet. I’m a parent of an autistic child and I’m really worried about our rights as parents being eroded.

www.independent.co.uk/voices/schools-bill-nadhim-zahawi-attendance-send-b2121255.html?utm_term=Autofeed&utm_medium=Social&utm_content=Echobox&utm_source=Facebook&fbclid=IwAR3U0ovevI6-E6MLKpRb0uN-TLnf987Z4JyxKmrJL3FKx-om1jIMYRgLVo8#Echobox=1657630821

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Worried2478 · 16/07/2022 23:52

It is really worrying. My ASD DS who is 12 has been struggling with attending school in recent months and begging to be home educated. It hurts to see him so distressed and it's negatively affected the family as a whole.

DH and I have discussed HE endlessly, and it will be a challenge but we are in a position to do so as I am a SAHM. If the bill passes, when would it realistically kick in? Wondering if it would be best to deregister asap after the summer holidays.

BuffaloCauliflower · 16/07/2022 17:54

It’s absolutely worrying, for all parents, but particularly those who choose to home educate and those who’s children have additional needs. The fact it paints HE as a safeguarding issue when there is zero evidence to support this, it’s all about demonising parents and removing choice. If the school system worked perfectly for all that’d be one thing but it doesn’t even work for most kids, and there’s no appetite for real evidence based reform. The Schools Bill benefits no one but the government who want greater power

Threeboysandadog · 16/07/2022 15:57

As a parent with three dc with (very different) additional needs I’m thankful that my youngest is 16. They have never been close to getting it right for every child but this is definitely going in the wrong direction.

theanswerisalwaysgin · 16/07/2022 15:42

Apologies. I assumed everyone on Mumsnet was a Mum?
Completely agree it requires everyone coming together. Schools are finding it really hard too. And support services.

theanswerisalwaysgin · 16/07/2022 15:37

Yes, exactly right. And at the moment the Bill isn’t worded well at all, and is incredibly vague with it.

theanswerisalwaysgin · 16/07/2022 15:33

The research you’re referring to by Honorary Fellow Rona Epstein found that 9 out of 10 custodial sentences for truancy were mothers / women.

If you visit Square Peg’s website news section, this research is quoted in a submission to the DfE on the attendance consultation. Part 3 of the Schools Bill is all about attendance. 😔

UnityAndLight · 16/07/2022 15:11

Its Criminal what the schools bill is proposing and the more awareness raised amongst parents the better. it affects every single one of us. Pay attention, because if they get their way we as parents will have no rights at all over our Children. The Government will own our kids. time for people to wake up to whats happening, and also wake up to what they are teaching our children in schools with the sex ed. disgusting.

TriceratopsRocks · 16/07/2022 14:36

Agree OP. I have already signed the petition and written to my MP (no response yet). DD has autism and school based anxiety that triggers migraines. She is on a very reduced timetable in y10. We homeschooled in years 4&5 because of her anxiety. She has been medicated since age 8. We have been doing as best we can, with little support, for years. We would LOVE to be able to get her into school next year so she stands a chance at getting decent GCSEs. Criminalising us will likely increase her anxiety and make her attendance worse. She is already worried about the affect her autism and anxiety affects the family, although we do reassure her. This bill risks setting her back even further

QuattroFromagio · 16/07/2022 11:50

(we aren't 'all mums', though. Some of us are interested for other reasons, such as being involved as teachers, tutors, therapists, etc., or having friends or family members who home educate, etc.. Those in power should listen to people with experience and interest in the area, not because we are (or aren't) mums)

QuattroFromagio · 16/07/2022 11:48

the 'tracking' of children's attendance/alternative provision education worries me. If all other providers start having to register and be regulated, the variety and choice of these will decrease, and potentially the cost increase. Moreover, if the bill isn't worded well, then so many others could potentially be affected too, including extra-curricular teachers/tutors, and so on - who would possibly then refuse to take home educated children or those with ECHP plans to avoid the hassle of registering and monitoring.

theanswerisalwaysgin · 16/07/2022 11:42

You’re not BU!

I represent Square Peg, the org named in the article James wrote.

We are desperate for more parents to join our campaign and write to their MP about impact of these proposals on all children & families.

Parents have had enough of pernicious letters about attendance, questioning their opinion on whether their child is well enough to attend school or ‘legitimately’ is struggling to attend and is maybe a bit naughty or trying it on or ‘Mum’ is too weak to be firm.

These proposals are a ramp up of current policy and a fast track to surveillance, scrutiny and interference in family life.

Did you know under Part 3 of the Bill, Government will know the location, live, in real time, of every child every day and whether they are in school? Sounds harmless, but is it?

Did you know under proposals in the Schools Bill your child’s school attendance record will be kept and freely shared between all Government agencies (including policing) for 66 years after they leave education?! (Incidentally they’re not going after privately educated kids’ attendance because those are the right sort of families obvs).

So yes, we all should be concerned and pushing back. Contact your MP today!!

You might want to include info from our campaign page regarding our 3 Asks. Amendment 81 is our amendment proposing the 2nd of 3 Asks, an Attendance Code of Practice.

3 Asks Schools Bill Amendment 81

We'd be happy to speak to @mumsnet about this. 👍🏻

We’re all Mums and it’s high time the corridors of power started listening to us.

Aibu to worry about the schools bill
Evillynz · 16/07/2022 08:24

stickygotstuck · 13/07/2022 08:28

I am quite worried about it, for the same reason as OP. Is there no end to the amount of crap heaped on kids, instead of helping them?

This summarises the bill, with links to read the whole thing and the impact assessment.
schoolsweek.co.uk/schools-bill-the-15-new-laws-proposed/

What are peripheral activities? With these wankers, I'm assuming we're talking breaks and lunch?

LivingOnAPear · 13/07/2022 13:04

@lifeturnsonadime

I totally agree with everything you’ve said. I’m just surprised there’s so little talk about it in the media. Most of the articles I’ve seen refer to forced academisation as the main issue with the bill.

It’s really sad about the Coventry research.

It drives me mad that they are focussing on this rather than actually improving state schools and actually looking at the education system in countries where children are happier.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 13/07/2022 12:52

It is horrendous.

It is akin to criminalising parents for having the temerity of having children who can't manage in school, often due to unmet or undiagnosed needs.

I have two who came out of school before the end of primary due to 'so - called' school refusal which is a vile, parent blaming, name for what is actually school based anxiety.

It's hard enough for parents having to navigate the broken SEN and mental health systems without actually being criminalised for things out of your control. The choice will be a straight choice of putting your child at risk of REAL harm or being made a criminal. This will not help children. It will make things worse.

What is needed is investment in alternative provisions and mental health services not further parent blaming.

A few years ago Coventry University did a study on the parents who were receiving criminal fines and imprisonment for non attendance and quelle surprise, the majority of them parents of autistic kids. 10 MOTHERs were imprisoned. www.coventry.ac.uk/news/parents-most-at-need-are-being-penalised-over-childrens-school-attendance-report-finds/

basilmint · 13/07/2022 12:35

And now a PM wannabe is saying they want to remove superfluous support staff and peripheral activities in school.

Just goes to show he has never set foot in a school then. There are no superfluous support staff - there are not enough support staff.

pogostickplastique · 13/07/2022 12:32

There is a 'stop the schools bill' group on FB - I have also signed the petition. I was also surprised at the lack of talk about it on here

LivingOnAPear · 13/07/2022 10:57

We had to move my child’s school in year 1 as she wasn’t coping. But we felt like we had power as parents to choose to home educate, unschool, send her to forest and beach schools if we couldn’t find a suitable place. It seems like they are cracking down on some of the alternative providers whilst restricting parents’ choices to move their child (especially if their child has an echp) but also not doing anything to resolve the underlying issues.

OP posts:
Booklover3 · 13/07/2022 10:21

It’s bad news from the sound of it

HappyHappyHermit · 13/07/2022 10:11

There are no superfluous support staff in schools, most are managing with the bare minimum they can due to costs. How absolutely outrageous that someone with so little common sense can be allowed to damage our children's education in this way. Disgusting. They'll be taking the milk from under 5's and fsm's for ks1 away again next. This government is determined to punish anyone who is not in their elite moneyed bubble.

BotCrossHuns · 13/07/2022 10:08

and could be horrendous for extra provision as well, tutors, music teachers, support workers, forest school and some of the similar things that home ed children also benefit from even when they can't access school. If everything becomes ofsted regulated and inspected and registered, the admin hassle and expense will reduce the provision, and the lack of freedom in how it is provided will reduce choice. There needs to be exemption in the way the act is written for all these activities.

Lifelessordinary1 · 13/07/2022 10:05

If its bad for schools it is horrendous for Home Education - so if the support really is not there in school then Home Education will be less of a positive option.

There is a massive petition being presented to parliament today from the Home Education Community against it.

Fml1980 · 13/07/2022 09:26

My dd has struggled with school for over 2 years, we have done everything to help that we possibly can.
She is on a reduced timetable, we have been waiting for CAMHs for 2 years!
How on earth can they prosecute parents when they can't even give the tools to help parents and esp children who has mental health problems to actually be in school.

itsgettingweird · 13/07/2022 08:53

BotCrossHuns · 13/07/2022 08:44

Yes I heard Kemi Badenoch's speech the other day, all about how the focus needs to be on good 'whole class teaching' and not all these other support groups and things, which was a bit shocking. She has some good sense on certain other topics, but i found these policies really worrying. All very 'pull yourself up by your bootstraps and take responsibility for yourself' kind of thing.

Very worrying and narrow minded.

And good whole class teaching has been a policy for ages. But you can't teach a whole class when 2-3 have SEND which means they are non verbal or cannot sit for a period of time and don't even understand what you're saying.

When you have a teacher recruitment and retention problem I'm not sure how rhos policy will solve that.

itsgettingweird · 13/07/2022 08:51

The one I find most interesting is that if you have 1 child at home with an EHCP you have to register as a school.

I'll be interested to see if that means they'll also find the support on the EHCP for that "school" to provide which is currently the law.

Also a lot of pushing academies and MATs. I think this is their new way of trying to fund schools without actually funding them.

And the illegal but about removing children from school after attendance warnings.

This will damage a cohort of pupils who already have increasing MH difficulties (even more so after covid).

The only way this will work on any level is if they increase the specialist provision to provide a suitable education for those who can't manage large classrooms and a MS education. But we know they won't do anything to improve the lives of those with LT health problems or a disability.

BotCrossHuns · 13/07/2022 08:44

Yes I heard Kemi Badenoch's speech the other day, all about how the focus needs to be on good 'whole class teaching' and not all these other support groups and things, which was a bit shocking. She has some good sense on certain other topics, but i found these policies really worrying. All very 'pull yourself up by your bootstraps and take responsibility for yourself' kind of thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread