Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking for an exception to the 'water-only' rule at DD's school?

136 replies

Lem0ndrizzl3 · 12/07/2022 22:29

I know there's another discussion about water at school at the moment but it didn't really apply to my DDs situation. DD is starting primary school in September and she will not drink water. At all. She is autistic and has a lot of sensory issues around food and drink.

She currently attends half days at nursery 5 days a week and she is sent with water every day but will not even have a sip. She is always so thirsty when she gets home and I'm really concerned about her going all day without a drink.

I understand the issue with squash in the classroom but I'd even be happy to bring in a drink at lunchtime every day if it meant she wasn't getting dehydrated. Would this be an unreasonable request??

Also she has difficulties around eating at nursery. Most days she hasn't touched her lunch, even with lots of encouragement from the nursery assistants. Any suggestions on making sure she eats at school?

Sorry if these questions seem ridiculous, I'm just scared about the transition to primary school and I've been trying to contact the SENCO but I've had no luck.

OP posts:
Newnormal99 · 13/07/2022 06:02

You can get air up bottles. They have a pod you attach to the spout and it has the smell of a flavour that tricks your train into thinking it is flavoured water.

They are pricey at £35 so may not be best option for a reception child that may lose things.

Jossfromtenko · 13/07/2022 05:37

I haven't lived in the UK with kids but it sounds like some sort of facist regime. I wouldn't be able to put up with such nonsense, fluids are fluids. The rest of the world have juice and I bet most of them have better teeth than Brits because we also have health care and dentists. Jeez, if someone took my kids drink away, I would go nuts.

stayathomer · 13/07/2022 01:14

We used to have blackcurrant squash in a blue coloured flask for 2 of the kids. Nobody ever said anything, one of the mums said they were probably just trying to stop people bringing in eg capri suns

Muzzyarker · 13/07/2022 00:34

For the school to refuse would be disability discrimination.

Heartofglass12345 · 13/07/2022 00:19

@Live4weekend my youngest did the same as your DS, mainly I think because the teachers were asking them what they had in their bottles and he was worried! He does choose water so home though so he must prefer it. I remember last year the teacher sending us a message saying 'please make sure your children bring a bottle of water to school, no squash. The children tell us if they have been given squash'!! What a weird thing for her to fixate on. Mine have always taken a drink anyway as they have packed lunches so I have just always given my eldest squash and they've never questioned it.

Nat6999 · 12/07/2022 23:57

I sent ds with flavoured water in a normal drinks bottle. I had a massive row with the head who said he drank plain water or went without as he is autistic & refuses to drink plain water, the head then said that he had to keep hus drinks bottle with the flavoured water in his office & had to ask if he wanted a drink. I contacted the autism team at the education department who ripped him a new one & ds was finally allowed to have his drinks bottle on his desk. Before this ds was coming out of school when the weather was like it is now nearly passing out because he hadn't had a drink all day, he was so dehydrated he couldn't even manage to wee.

AlwaysLatte · 12/07/2022 23:54

Can you give her flavoured water so that it looks the same? I think the school should be more accepting in the circumstances.

iknowthismuchis · 12/07/2022 23:52

@pogostickplastique - DS doesn't have autism but as a toddler he was plagued by chronic constipation, honestly it was controlling our life, he was in pain for days at a time. We couldn't get the medication into him because it needed to be mixed with water. It tasted awful. So we mixed it with squash and it honestly feels like it changed our life. His problem went but he still wouldn't drink water but would drink squash. I chose a child who could use the toilet, not be in pain and was happy over one that might possibly get some dental problems.

waterrat · 12/07/2022 23:51

Op you say you cant contact the senco. This isn't good enough on the part of the school. If your child is autistic yoi need one to one meetings with everyone who will come into contact with her and I'm surprised they wouldn't have offered a senco meeting? Just email the head and say you are very concerned you haven't had your senco meeting and term is ending.

Sadly ...and my daughter is autistic...you have to be pushy.

PickAChew · 12/07/2022 23:46

Silverbirch2 · 12/07/2022 22:46

If the squash is an issue for you then school should work to reduce it to water- either gradually dilute or she has a sip of water then juice and increase this.
If it's not a problem for you then just send a
Squash.
Same for the food, send a little of what she likes. If you want her to eat the school will work gradually towards this.
Put on EHCP as a target. ASD is no reason to not drink water or eat in school, it might be her habit at the moment but not an issue to change gradually, especially with new expectations in September.

Love the ignorance 😒

Live4weekend · 12/07/2022 23:45

My DD gets squash.

She wasn't drinking water so we gave her squash. School have never commented.

My DS got water then squash and back to water. All his choice. Again school have never commented.

A hydrated child is important.

Ellmau · 12/07/2022 23:43

Has sh only tried tap water? Would bottled water taste better to her?

AgathaMystery · 12/07/2022 23:39

rocksonrocks · 12/07/2022 23:14

Sorry if I'm missing something here but surely you, as the parent, have the absolute final say? There's a warning from the weather office regarding this heat, she cannot go all day without a drink. Send her in with whatever will keep her hydrated (safe).

I agree. I send DC with whatever is to hand. It’s up to me what I send in, not the school.

parenthood1989 · 12/07/2022 23:39

How do children end up drinking squash in the first place? Surely if they had never had it they wouldn't know any different?

In the case of some it's to avoid hospitalisation due to dehydration. Please don't point the 'parenting' finger. It's fucking hard to watch a child refuse the very most basic drink (and foods for that matter) which keep them alive.

Heartofglass12345 · 12/07/2022 23:38

I don't get the obsession with schools policing what the children eat and drink, it's squash not like she's taking in coke!
My son is autistic and has never liked water so he's always taken squash in and I just ignored the messages (they were for everyone not just me)
She needs to be drinking especially in this weather! I wouldn't even be asking if I were you, I would be telling them

pogostickplastique · 12/07/2022 23:36

pogostickplastique · 12/07/2022 23:36

I have a genuine question as I see this same issue pop up on various forums frequently.

How do children end up drinking squash in the first place? Surely if they had never had it they wouldn't know any different? Guidance when I had my children was water only for teeth purposes probably and I was always aware they'd need water in school so mine had never been given squash to know it was an option.
Mine have now been offered squash at various events and refuse and ask for water. Exception is DS2 will ask for an applied juice as a treat after having a slurp of nanny's one day I'm the garden.

*apple juice

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 12/07/2022 23:36

It's a reasonable adjustment and not unusual for an Autistic child. Have you tried gradually watering down what she usually drinks? Or tried very weak juice? No matter the result we always give lots of praise for trying. I wouldn't water down without explaining if DC tends to pick up on these sort of changes. Trust is important.

Not eating at lunchtime I'd think sensory overwhelm. Would she have one of those protein and milk poppers? I know a few people that use these for school lunches for Autistic children that can't eat at school.

As for the SENCO have you tried emailing the front office and asking them to pass the email on to the SENCO? You could attach a letter if it's sensitive information. I've found doing this gets better response then calling and asking for a call back. We don't know teacher till first day school, but the teacher once one is assigned. Teachers find out the week before school starts. I attach DC therapy reports and assessments and a letter where I've written relevant information the teacher needs to know. Our DC are all Autistic, 2 with anxiety as well, so I spend a lot of time communicating with the school, SENCO and teachers.

pogostickplastique · 12/07/2022 23:36

I have a genuine question as I see this same issue pop up on various forums frequently.

How do children end up drinking squash in the first place? Surely if they had never had it they wouldn't know any different? Guidance when I had my children was water only for teeth purposes probably and I was always aware they'd need water in school so mine had never been given squash to know it was an option.
Mine have now been offered squash at various events and refuse and ask for water. Exception is DS2 will ask for an applied juice as a treat after having a slurp of nanny's one day I'm the garden.

Emmelina · 12/07/2022 23:33

I have 2 ASD kids, neither would drink water until they were about 8 or 9. School allowed squash in the end as it became a risk to their health. I very very gradually made it more dilute so that over the course of over a year it was barely noticeable as squash in the bottle (lemon squash).

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 12/07/2022 23:29

Dd wasn't diagnosed at that stage but school were 100% clear bottle and water only. It was awful. A second school was a bit less militant and she was diagnosed a few months in.

LunchBoxPolice · 12/07/2022 23:22

My ds has SEN and refuses plain water. Our school has a “water only in a transparent bottle” rule. I bought him an orange bottle off Amazon that is semi transparent, so you can see there’s nothing fizzy in there but I can add a bit of orange squash without anyone noticing. No one has said anything, and if they do they’ll be told it’s a necessary adjustment 🤷🏻‍♀️. They can’t expect a child to go all day without a drink - it’s not as if they’re just being fussy, they aren’t trying to be difficult.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 12/07/2022 23:20

This may be a silly question, but is refusing water based on appearance? You mentioned she refused flavored water without trying. Have you tried a flavored water (or plain) with food coloring to get past the first refusal?

Theladybirdthatsaidboo · 12/07/2022 23:14

It’s not at all ridiculous, I have an autistic son and I’d feel exactly the same way. I think you need a conversation with her class teacher and/or senco, ideally before end of term but definitely before she starts in September - about water, food and anything else you’re worried about. Has she had any transition yet?

But the water thing should not be a problem or even up for debate - it’s a perfectly reasonable adjustment for her diagnosed and documented disability. Don’t get in to offering to go in each day, you shouldn’t have to. I’d just ask if they’d rather she had a non-transparent bottle to conceal it from the rest of the class. (I’d have an argument right now with her nursery too actually because she should be allowed whatever she will drink there too.)

My son barely touches lunch at school, despite trying all sorts of adjustments. He just eats more at home to make up for it.

rocksonrocks · 12/07/2022 23:14

Sorry if I'm missing something here but surely you, as the parent, have the absolute final say? There's a warning from the weather office regarding this heat, she cannot go all day without a drink. Send her in with whatever will keep her hydrated (safe).

Namechanger965 · 12/07/2022 23:12

DD is undergoing assessment for ASD at the moment, find into the dining hall was a huge issue for her. I work in a school and get why, they’re incredibly noisy and it echos and it’s smells like school dinners as well. It’s a lot for any nursery age child, let alone one with ASD. Can you ask if they have an alternative place she can have lunch, like a Nurture room? DD loves her schools nurture room and would actually eat in there. She has now built up to going into the dining hall (with ear defenders on).

Is she on packed lunches or school dinners? At our school packed lunch kids can take juice with them, would she drink that?

They cannot leave her without a drink all day, if they aren’t prepared to compromise ask to meet with the SENCO and reminded them they are required to make reasonable adjustments. I’d be prepared to escalate it as well, some schools are taking healthy schools to a stupid level. It’s not healthy to leave a child without a drink in this heat.

I would actually send her in with squash tomorrow, tell them that’s what she will be having and tell her teacher at the door, or ask to speak to the SENCO or head tomorrow and point out how dangerous it is. The guidance on reasonable adjustments mentions changes to uniform policy if a child has an allergy, this is a similar situation so they should be prepared to to allow it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread