Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking for an exception to the 'water-only' rule at DD's school?

136 replies

Lem0ndrizzl3 · 12/07/2022 22:29

I know there's another discussion about water at school at the moment but it didn't really apply to my DDs situation. DD is starting primary school in September and she will not drink water. At all. She is autistic and has a lot of sensory issues around food and drink.

She currently attends half days at nursery 5 days a week and she is sent with water every day but will not even have a sip. She is always so thirsty when she gets home and I'm really concerned about her going all day without a drink.

I understand the issue with squash in the classroom but I'd even be happy to bring in a drink at lunchtime every day if it meant she wasn't getting dehydrated. Would this be an unreasonable request??

Also she has difficulties around eating at nursery. Most days she hasn't touched her lunch, even with lots of encouragement from the nursery assistants. Any suggestions on making sure she eats at school?

Sorry if these questions seem ridiculous, I'm just scared about the transition to primary school and I've been trying to contact the SENCO but I've had no luck.

OP posts:
Onlyforcake · 13/07/2022 09:13

Tell the school. Use a metal water bottle so other children don't notice and get jealous/ vocal. It's worth trying flavoured water out too, but my middle one has never taken to those.

Zilla1 · 13/07/2022 09:12

HNRTT and I would hope the school make a reasonable adjustment regarding water. Would a packed lunch help with lunch or a side room if the benefits outweighed the costs? Would need to check but I think most children at school when I went to school didn't take water bottles nor drink at school and survived even during heatwaves. Water fountains went unused. I send DC with water bottles (opaque metal) but am mildly surprised at the life-threatening consequences some PPs have stated. I know children can become dehydrated, equally have seen complete rubbish stated as fact - 'drink and hold the water in the mouth so it can hydrate the brain' was stated as fact by a firm that I think was paid by the UK government or schools.

Knittingnanny2 · 13/07/2022 09:11

@TimeToGoUpAGear I agree in principle with telling not hiding, but if needs must....

BlackeyedSusan · 13/07/2022 09:11

Silverbirch2 · 12/07/2022 22:46

If the squash is an issue for you then school should work to reduce it to water- either gradually dilute or she has a sip of water then juice and increase this.
If it's not a problem for you then just send a
Squash.
Same for the food, send a little of what she likes. If you want her to eat the school will work gradually towards this.
Put on EHCP as a target. ASD is no reason to not drink water or eat in school, it might be her habit at the moment but not an issue to change gradually, especially with new expectations in September.

ASD is absolutely a reason why a kid will not drink water. You seem to have poor understanding of the condition. What works for one kid will not work for another.

PixiesFeet · 13/07/2022 09:08

@Soontobe60 It is because attitudes like yours as to why my autistic DD was hospitalised over the weekend with severe constipation and UTI. Her school refuses to allow juice also and she will flat out refuse water to the point she would end up in hospital. She was so thirsty last week every day coming out of school, as she had not drunk all day because of this. In this heat how is that at all acceptable. And your attitude as a teacher is concerning regarding your views on an autistic child, clearly you have no experience of a child who will refuse water not because they are being awkward but as they have a disability.

Knittingnanny2 · 13/07/2022 09:08

I’m retired now but was an infant teacher for almost 40 years. I could write a list of why I retired early. It was all of the ridiculousness basically.
On the list in my head was schools insistence on policing what children brought in from home to eat and drink. Parents have brought their children up for 5 years and they are the only experts with their children. Therefore they know what they need to eat and drink not the teachers.
Obviously I’m not talking about the children who have cans of fizzy drinks and a cold Mac Donald’s from the night before. Unless of course that was for specified medical need.
Dilute the squash to disguise it or keep reinforcing to the school that your child has a particular reason for having it.
Good luck, if your child was in my class and you had shared this info with me I would feel no need to report you to the chief!

MoonBat · 13/07/2022 09:03

I have three children in my current reception class who have squash or flavoured water, for various medical reqsons, including autism. The one who has squash has an opaque bottle so none of the children can tell.

Discuss it with the class teacher, and SENCO if necessary, don't just try to "hide" it!

TimeToGoUpAGear · 13/07/2022 08:55

Meant to add to my comment above, don't send flavoured water or squash without speaking to them, it's hiding her true needs and they need the full picture. This isn't going to be the only adjustment they might need to make or support they need to give over her time at school so they might as well get used to it now!

Be polite but firm!

Heartofglass12345 · 13/07/2022 08:51

@Soontobe60 you might know but why do you care so much? Cordial is different to sugar free squash which is what my son has and millions of people probably grew up drinking (including me and I had my first filling last year at aged 37) honestly what kids drink really shouldn't be the schools problem if all they are having is sugar free squash. If they were bringing in cans of energy drink or coke, fair enough!

parenthood1989 · 13/07/2022 08:49

@Soontobe60

It's not that daft. Reasonable adjustment should be expected here.

TimeToGoUpAGear · 13/07/2022 08:49

My son is autistic.

Hated water when he started school. Try the flavoured water again but get one in a really fancy lovely looking bottle and show it to her first. Get a similar flavour to the squash she drinks.

Regardless of whether that works, speak to the school. It is not an option for her not to drink so if flavoured water doesn't work, get a metal hype bottle (you can't see through them) and put squash in it. TELL THEM, don't ask. If they can't accommodate this, they don't understand autism and aren't the right school.

My son started drinking water in year 3 but we didn't push it too far.

Re lunches, is there something she will eat? Packed lunch? Jacket potato? My son's school cook him the one item he will always eat any day that the main menu has only things he won't. He decided in the morning and tells them. Sometimes they cook his favourite food plus a small amount of what's on the menu if it's a new thing. That way he can try it without pressure. Occasionally he likes the new item and will then have it once the menu rolls around to that day again.

Good luck. This can all be sorted, just needs an amazing head teacher!

youcantparktheresir · 13/07/2022 08:47

Flavoured water tipped into a normal water bottle?

SueSaid · 13/07/2022 08:44

Teachers please just teach the kids. That is your job. This ridiculous obsession with squash is crazy. They need to drink so long as they aren't necking cans of Redbull a day it is none of your business.

Op, as others have said just keep on trying flavoured cleared water it if she won't drink it tell the teachers she will have whatever you provide, the end.

It's funny we put up with this bossy crap at primary school, over invested teachers checking lunch boxes and water bottles then they go to secondary school and no one would dare police what the kids consume!

Stag82 · 13/07/2022 08:44

Echoing lots of other people. Meet with the SENCO as early as possible. In my experience you will be needing many adjustments over the school years. And will also need to keep on top of any learning plans etc as sadly some teachers just do not follow them.

Squash sounds like a reasonable adjustment. Some of my kids friends have squash and they all have SEN needs. If parents want to complain about 'special treatment' that's for the school to deal with...

rainylake · 13/07/2022 08:36

Soontobe60 · 13/07/2022 06:58

I love how loads of you think teachers in schools will never know who’s got juice in their water bottles! Trust me, we always know!
With regard to making reasonable adjustments, medically, there is no need for someone who is able to have a drink before and after school and at lunch time to also be drinking during lesson time. They will not get dehydrated! Obviously the present hot weather is a bit of an exception. Drinking juice throughout the day can have a massive impact on a child’s teeth, and I’d argue that having to have dental work as a result is far worse than not drinking for a few hours.
When I’ve had parents come to me with this issue (who’s children are diagnosed ASD) I’ve asked them to provide sugar free flavoured water as opposed to cordial and had a quiet word with the class teacher. I also suggest the parent provides a snack such as fruit which has a high water content and makes sure their child has a big drink before school. It’s amazing how many parents send their child in with unhealthy snacks whilst insisting they have free access to water for health reasons.
Surprisingly, yesterday in school after repeatedly encouraging children to have a drink of water when they came in from breaks, at the end of the day half of them still had almost full water bottles. Don’t send your child in with massive water bottles where the water gets too warm to taste nice - many of those children end up pouring that water away and then refill with cold water.
as far as I’m concerned as a teacher, the biggest issue with water bottles is spillage. Please, whatever you do, get your child a bottle with a pull up spout or built in straw. Bottles where the top has to be unscrewed to drink from are the bane of our lives because that’s how spills happen. There’s nothing worse than a full bottle being dropped onto someone’s exercise books, or as happened in my class a few weeks ago, onto an iPad even though my children are supposed to put their bottles on the side or floor when they have iPads out! Oh, and wash the bottles out properly - it’s amazing how dirty they get :(

All children should be aiming to have 6-8 drinks a day, the majority before 4pm (medical advice given to us). Not drinking enough can cause various issues including constipation and urinary incontinence and is a big cause of bedwetting. So restricting drinking before and after school and at lunch is not okay.

And children, like all human beings, should be able to drink when they are thirsty.

Justrealised · 13/07/2022 08:32

I'd speak to the sendco as soon as possible. This is a relatively minor thing and if they're not willing to support on this it maybe a sign of things to come.

My ds has autism and has cordial in his bottle, I also send in a bottle every now and then when they need it so school can refill it. He has the bottle with him at all times.

Ask for a referal to the dietitian to help with eating, as a min it may reassure school that if she doesn't eat there it is ok. They may offer dietary supplements too to make sure she's getting what she needs.

Slso see if they can refer for sensory ot. They can help with environment, utensils, taste, texture programs etc.

CometCupidDonnerBlitzen · 13/07/2022 08:25

Oh and just to add - my daughter started coming home in tears in year one because the lunch hall was so noisy. I asked about somewhere quiet for her and they gave her ear defenders. I was skeptical (was worried they'd made her stand out more) but she loved them and it made a huge difference to her being able to eat her lunch with the other kids.

CometCupidDonnerBlitzen · 13/07/2022 08:16

Your questions aren't ridiculous OP, but be prepared that school will potentially treat you like they are. However a child who barely eats all day and drinks nothing with have problems concentrating. Add SEN on top and it's a recipe for disaster.

I think the truth is this rule varies from school to school and flexibility on issues like this will probably mean they will be better with dealing with SEN than schools unwilling to budge. Unfortunately, in our personal experience, the teachers at our primary had very little understanding of ASD. Particularly in girls. I remember early on being told by one teacher that "girls don't really get autism".

We found primary school for our eldest daughter a nightmare because of having to navigate stupid crap like "water only" rules on top of all the other added difficulties her SEN would bring. IMO things like this should be considered reasonable adjustments for someone with sensory issues. She ended up with constipation and headaches and was finally put on medication. It was a ridiculous outcome when it could have been cured by allowing her to drink watered down juice like she has at home. The school would say things like "when she's thirsty she'll drink". However anyone with experience with ASD knows what a ridiculous statement that is.

Unfortunately for us the water really just became the tip of the iceberg. They couldn't seem to connect her sensory issues to her social problems and ultimately to her learning difficulties in class. "She says it's too loud, but it's not at all" was another one we got. Looking back I thought they would get better when in fact we should have taken these early interactions for the red flags they were and looked for a better school.

The food issue is a tricky one and we went through similar. I'd ask school to keep a log of what she's eating and how much just to ensure she's having something. I actually found the lunchtime staff much more helpful than the teachers tbh. In the end we moved to packed lunches and that solved the issue. These days she has far fewer issues with food, it just took a lot of time (and worry). The drinking problem persists at 9 though.

Withthewind · 13/07/2022 08:15

Never understood why it’s so bad to drink squash. My DS drinks water but that’s because he loves it. I grew up on squash.

Quia · 13/07/2022 08:11

We aren't sure on her reason for not eating at nursery. Its not the food - she eats it fine at home. We think it might be that the environment is overwhelming but we really don't know and she just gets grumpy when we ask her.

Talk to the school about letting her eat her lunch in a separate room, perhaps with a friend or two. It might also be worth asking your doctor for a referral to a nutritionist who may well have come across these issues before and have some suggestions.

Soontobe60 · 13/07/2022 07:00

Muzzyarker · 13/07/2022 00:34

For the school to refuse would be disability discrimination.

Don’t be daft!

Soontobe60 · 13/07/2022 06:58

I love how loads of you think teachers in schools will never know who’s got juice in their water bottles! Trust me, we always know!
With regard to making reasonable adjustments, medically, there is no need for someone who is able to have a drink before and after school and at lunch time to also be drinking during lesson time. They will not get dehydrated! Obviously the present hot weather is a bit of an exception. Drinking juice throughout the day can have a massive impact on a child’s teeth, and I’d argue that having to have dental work as a result is far worse than not drinking for a few hours.
When I’ve had parents come to me with this issue (who’s children are diagnosed ASD) I’ve asked them to provide sugar free flavoured water as opposed to cordial and had a quiet word with the class teacher. I also suggest the parent provides a snack such as fruit which has a high water content and makes sure their child has a big drink before school. It’s amazing how many parents send their child in with unhealthy snacks whilst insisting they have free access to water for health reasons.
Surprisingly, yesterday in school after repeatedly encouraging children to have a drink of water when they came in from breaks, at the end of the day half of them still had almost full water bottles. Don’t send your child in with massive water bottles where the water gets too warm to taste nice - many of those children end up pouring that water away and then refill with cold water.
as far as I’m concerned as a teacher, the biggest issue with water bottles is spillage. Please, whatever you do, get your child a bottle with a pull up spout or built in straw. Bottles where the top has to be unscrewed to drink from are the bane of our lives because that’s how spills happen. There’s nothing worse than a full bottle being dropped onto someone’s exercise books, or as happened in my class a few weeks ago, onto an iPad even though my children are supposed to put their bottles on the side or floor when they have iPads out! Oh, and wash the bottles out properly - it’s amazing how dirty they get :(

blessedbethebutter · 13/07/2022 06:49

My son will not drink water he's now 11 and just takes flavoured water in his bottle no one knows.

Dippydinosaurus · 13/07/2022 06:33

Having juice in a bottle that she'll drink from is not an unreasonable request for an SEN child, in fact it's not unusual. I'd be surprised if the senco would say no to this.

Jossfromtenko · 13/07/2022 06:21

I don't want a smell, I want squash! I think water bottles are gross spit havens. I would never drink from one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread