Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking for an exception to the 'water-only' rule at DD's school?

136 replies

Lem0ndrizzl3 · 12/07/2022 22:29

I know there's another discussion about water at school at the moment but it didn't really apply to my DDs situation. DD is starting primary school in September and she will not drink water. At all. She is autistic and has a lot of sensory issues around food and drink.

She currently attends half days at nursery 5 days a week and she is sent with water every day but will not even have a sip. She is always so thirsty when she gets home and I'm really concerned about her going all day without a drink.

I understand the issue with squash in the classroom but I'd even be happy to bring in a drink at lunchtime every day if it meant she wasn't getting dehydrated. Would this be an unreasonable request??

Also she has difficulties around eating at nursery. Most days she hasn't touched her lunch, even with lots of encouragement from the nursery assistants. Any suggestions on making sure she eats at school?

Sorry if these questions seem ridiculous, I'm just scared about the transition to primary school and I've been trying to contact the SENCO but I've had no luck.

OP posts:
serenghetti2011 · 13/07/2022 11:45

@parenthood1989 no that’s ok I wasn’t meaning it in a bad way, just that some kids like mine seek out heightened sensory experiences rather than dislike them. I’m getting an air up for myself and my son I don’t drink enough either 😀

SueSaid · 13/07/2022 11:42

Mellowyellow222 · 13/07/2022 11:31

sorry really stupid question - but why aren’t kids allowed sugar free squash?

Oh apparently it is sticky if spilt.

Can understand no fizzy drinks as kids get bloated and burp but sugar free squash would seem harmless imo.

Harridan1981 · 13/07/2022 11:39

An autistic child should be able to have what they are able to drink. In our school this wouldn't even be in question.

parenthood1989 · 13/07/2022 11:35

@serenghetti2011

Sorry I didn't mean to suggest all autistic children would not like the air up, more that I don't think it will change a non water drinker into a water drinker.

Mellowyellow222 · 13/07/2022 11:31

sorry really stupid question - but why aren’t kids allowed sugar free squash?

serenghetti2011 · 13/07/2022 11:03

My son loves the idea of the air up, some children are sensory seekers - like my son and enjoy this. He does drink water, however doesn’t drink enough and also has bowel and bladder issues and incontinence. He needs to drink more, paediatrician wants 1500 mls and I can’t get that in all before and after school as he wets bed too so it needs spread across the day. So we do what we need to do and school are now fine. His teeth are cleaned and perfect (11). It’s just another thing in the things you need to fight for at school for kids with additional needs. It’s like they’d rather your child struggled and hated school like mine has for the majority of school life!!

parenthood1989 · 13/07/2022 10:39

The air up idea is unlikely to work for an autistic child who has heightened taste and sensory issues. It's a much more complex issue.

CoastalWave · 13/07/2022 10:35

Lem0ndrizzl3 · 12/07/2022 22:47

Unfortunately they have stated she needs a transparent bottle. We have tried flavoured water in the past but it was a battle to get her to taste it and then she started gagging. But we may have to give it another go. If that doesn't work then hopefully they'll allow an opaque one.

Part of me thinks we should just try and get away with it, but if we were to get flagged up on it I feel like they would be less likely to believe me.

We aren't sure on her reason for not eating at nursery. Its not the food - she eats it fine at home. We think it might be that the environment is overwhelming but we really don't know and she just gets grumpy when we ask her.

I've just bought my child an Air Up.

Expensive but so worth it.

uk.air-up.com

Basically you put water in and add a pod that has a flavour and tricks you into thinking you're drinking flavoured water.

PinkButtercups · 13/07/2022 10:30

I don't agree with this water rule.

I'm lucky that my DS will only drink water and won't even entertain the idea of squash. I've tried and he refuses.

My nephew who is the same age will not touch water and would rather go thirsty but will guzzle down squash.

I don't see the problem with squash. As long as they're drinking and keeping hydrated is the most important thing.

parenthood1989 · 13/07/2022 10:29

Thank you all for your advice. It's all really reassuring. I'll stand my ground with them when I do finally get a meeting. We have a lot of things to discuss regarding her support needs in school and although the class teacher seemed to be really on the ball at first it seems to have dropped off.

Just remind them your DD is protected by law and that an alternative drink is a reasonable adjustment.

beachcitygirl · 13/07/2022 10:25

What the actual fuck is wrong with teachers sniffing kids drinks & not allowing mild squash.

I can't even.

beachcitygirl · 13/07/2022 10:23

What about these water bottles that you can add real fruit ? Can't remember what they are called? Maybe fruit infuser ?

Lem0ndrizzl3 · 13/07/2022 10:14

Thank you all for your advice. It's all really reassuring. I'll stand my ground with them when I do finally get a meeting. We have a lot of things to discuss regarding her support needs in school and although the class teacher seemed to be really on the ball at first it seems to have dropped off.

DD was meant to have a visit last week but it was cancelled due to covid, but she is going in tomorrow so hopefully I can atleast speak to the teacher. I've also got a last minute appointment with the SENCo at her nursery this afternoon so I will try and get some advice from her too.

DD has had food and drink issues since she was a baby. She was seen by a dietician at 13mo because she refused any solids and would be sick. We were encouraged to try squash with her to get her used to new flavours but in a texture she was familiar with. It helped massively, but now it's all she wants to drink. We have really tried to encourage water but she would rather suffer than drink it. I know people say "they'll drink if they're thirsty" but it's really not the case with ASD. I have no regrets about giving her squash because her being hydrated and actually eating food is much more important to me than it being "bad".

She takes a packed lunch to nursery and it's very simple. A sandwich and some fruit. She will always eat this at home but its hardly ever touched at school. She's most likely to eat her fruit but again it's not a guarantee.

We will try some flavoured water again (the food colouring idea sounds like the way to start) and if we have no progress then it'll be squash and theyll just have to deal with it.

OP posts:
SatinHeart · 13/07/2022 10:08

*water refusers!

SatinHeart · 13/07/2022 10:07

OP, the school should have experience of waster refusers. My DS is starting primary school in September with suspected ASD (no diagnosis yet). He actually does drink water, but the Reception teacher made a point of asking me if he did while we were discussing his needs and said that in the past they have allowed squash in an opaque bottle. I would suggest talking to the class teacher not the SENCO in this instance.

As for the eating, does your DD have a packed lunch at nursery or is it the nursery food she won't eat? My DS refuses most nursery food, I'm confident that the ability to send in a packed lunch is going to help but we will be specifying support with eating on his EHCP. We have also negotiated that we will send in an alternative morning snack as DS is unlikely to eat the free fruit. Again, all via the class teacher not the SENCO.

youcantparktheresir · 13/07/2022 10:07
  • @Soontobe60

With regard to making reasonable adjustments, medically, there is no need for someone who is able to have a drink before and after school and at lunch time to also be drinking during lesson time. They will not get dehydrated!
*
Utterly ridiculous. A child should have 6/8 drinks a day. Most before 4pm. That's not counting for this scorching heat.

THAT will cause far more damage than some very weak sugar free squash or flavoured water that a child will enjoy drinking, to keep themselves hydrated throughout the day, lesson time or not.

10HailMarys · 13/07/2022 09:59

I would have thought that if she has been diagnosed as autistic and will have SENCO support when she starts primary school, they will almost certainly make some adjustments for her.

I think a PP suggested that if she drinks squash at home, you could also try gradually making it weaker and weaker over time to gradually acclimatise her to water.

As a last resort ... if she has to take a transparent bottle, does it have to be colourless? Transparent just means see-through, not colourless. So I'm wondering if you could pull off some kind of deception by getting a transparent plastic bottle that's the same colour as her preferred squash. Would probably only work if it was a non-cloudy squash though - I don't think you'd manage it with orange or lemon but you could probably give it a shot with, say, weak blackcurrant...

Isaidnoalready · 13/07/2022 09:56

My school is sensible the child can drink what they can drink as long as its not fizzy etc water is encouraged promoted provided but squash is allowed they don't keep the drinks on their desks they have them on the side wall away from electric items and books

BlackeyedSusan · 13/07/2022 09:55

Soontobe60 · 13/07/2022 06:58

I love how loads of you think teachers in schools will never know who’s got juice in their water bottles! Trust me, we always know!
With regard to making reasonable adjustments, medically, there is no need for someone who is able to have a drink before and after school and at lunch time to also be drinking during lesson time. They will not get dehydrated! Obviously the present hot weather is a bit of an exception. Drinking juice throughout the day can have a massive impact on a child’s teeth, and I’d argue that having to have dental work as a result is far worse than not drinking for a few hours.
When I’ve had parents come to me with this issue (who’s children are diagnosed ASD) I’ve asked them to provide sugar free flavoured water as opposed to cordial and had a quiet word with the class teacher. I also suggest the parent provides a snack such as fruit which has a high water content and makes sure their child has a big drink before school. It’s amazing how many parents send their child in with unhealthy snacks whilst insisting they have free access to water for health reasons.
Surprisingly, yesterday in school after repeatedly encouraging children to have a drink of water when they came in from breaks, at the end of the day half of them still had almost full water bottles. Don’t send your child in with massive water bottles where the water gets too warm to taste nice - many of those children end up pouring that water away and then refill with cold water.
as far as I’m concerned as a teacher, the biggest issue with water bottles is spillage. Please, whatever you do, get your child a bottle with a pull up spout or built in straw. Bottles where the top has to be unscrewed to drink from are the bane of our lives because that’s how spills happen. There’s nothing worse than a full bottle being dropped onto someone’s exercise books, or as happened in my class a few weeks ago, onto an iPad even though my children are supposed to put their bottles on the side or floor when they have iPads out! Oh, and wash the bottles out properly - it’s amazing how dirty they get :(

Medics would disagree. Some children do have reason to drink during the day other than at lunch.

Zilla1 · 13/07/2022 09:52

@CometCupidDonnerBlitzen I'm not defending rigid policies nor am I saying that every child can cope without drinking during the school day.

Knittingnanny2 · 13/07/2022 09:50

@parenthood1989 yes

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 13/07/2022 09:49

Most school allow juice in there pack lunches so send her with a packed lunch and juice at least she will have a drink then

BlackeyedSusan · 13/07/2022 09:47

pogostickplastique · 12/07/2022 23:36

I have a genuine question as I see this same issue pop up on various forums frequently.

How do children end up drinking squash in the first place? Surely if they had never had it they wouldn't know any different? Guidance when I had my children was water only for teeth purposes probably and I was always aware they'd need water in school so mine had never been given squash to know it was an option.
Mine have now been offered squash at various events and refuse and ask for water. Exception is DS2 will ask for an applied juice as a treat after having a slurp of nanny's one day I'm the garden.

Because they spat water out from whenever you were supposed to introduce it. Would not drink cow milk later. (Makes them have tummy ache) Would only have formula in a bottle at the correct temperature.

At some point you have to find something they will drink. We got it down to very very weak squash but never to pure water. Even now won't really drink water (Y11)

parenthood1989 · 13/07/2022 09:41

Knittingnanny2 · 13/07/2022 09:11

@TimeToGoUpAGear I agree in principle with telling not hiding, but if needs must....

There is no 'needs must' here. The law is on OPDD side.

CometCupidDonnerBlitzen · 13/07/2022 09:32

@Zilla1 My daughter wouldn't drink water at all but it was literally the only thing on offer to her at school. So her water bottle would come home full and untouched and she wouldn't drink the water on the table at lunchtime either. So she would be going from 8:00 to gone 3:00 every day without a drink. She wouldn't then get home and gulp down a drink. it would still be a struggle to get her to have anything at all. But at least she would sip at squash if we persisted. This is what people aren't realising I think. A child who doesn't drink because of SEN doesn't suddenly start downing fluids at 3pm everyday. The issue is deeper. So naturally over time this causes issues because they are ending up dehydrated.
When I was at school no water bottles were on offer throughout the day either. However when I got my packed lunch out my mum would have sent me a carton of ribena (which no one seemed to care about back in the 90s). So at least I'd had a drink half way through my day. The kids we're talking about here are having nothing because of the rigid school policies and lack of understanding regarding their SEN.

Swipe left for the next trending thread