Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep 7 year old DS home from camp

60 replies

IrishMama2015 · 12/07/2022 21:45

Hi all, I'm looking for advise please. DS,7, has always been a good kind boy but in the last year there is lots of fibbing when he thinks he will be in trouble and it's really really becoming a flash point. He gets punished when he does something wrong so I can see why he lies on one hand but I cannot bear lying and I don't trust him at all now.

He has been at a camp the last 2 days. Finished camp yesterday and I found his full water bottle in his bag, when I queried it he told me 10 different random tales until he finally admitted he didn't like the bottle as it has 'baby' designs in it and told the camp coordinator that he didn't have any water and they had to go trying to find a cup to fill all day long for him. It's a sports camp. I then got email last night reminding me water was essential. I had strong words and warned him about lying again.

Today the water was fine but after me giving him the Spanish enquisition he admitted that he was jealous of the other kids having treats in their lunches (which the camp had asked us not to give) and so went around to all his group begging them and badgering them to share their treats pretending he didn't have a lunch even though some were getting annoyed with him and shouting at him to leave them alone.First he said it was one kid then two then all the group. Then he only did it today and finally admitted yesterday too. One of the moms sent me a text tonight basically gently asking me to stop him begging for her sons lunch.

I am so so cross at my DS and humiliated that these people now think we don't feed or water him . And I just threw out his entire lunch box of sandwiches and fruit and crackers and a flapjack.

AIBU if I keep him home from camp tomorrow to teach him a lesson?

OP posts:
Isaidno22 · 13/07/2022 00:13

I think you are being too strict here. Kids can be so cruel so I understand him not wanting to use the babyish water bottle. He had water provided so was not at risk of dehydration and a quick word with the camp staff to say it was in his bag, with his lunch, when you dropped him the next day, was all that was needed to restore any reputation damage. If it was that much of an issue, they'd have called you to ask you to drop it off.

I'd be upset at the 'friend' who moaned to their parent about your child wanting to share the treats (they were told not to bring) and the parent who felt the need to contact you about it. I would have just replied to the parent about how kind their child was to share their illegal treats and that you'd sent him with some on Day 2 to share. I'd really hope my child would share their food with someone who said they didn't have a lunch (regardless of if it was true or not). If everyone else had treats, again, he is just trying to fit in but if he was actually hungry, he'd have eaten his packed lunch. Also, I'd question why did the camp staff did not sort him out a lunch?

Go with what PP have said about praising the positive. You want them to be able to talk to you and not fear you. Make sure they know that lying isn't the right thing to do but he is only 7 and does not have an adults mind. Camp is, as someone else said, for social development and fun. He shouldn't be worrying about a punishment as it will spoil his camp. Pack a few illegal treats for him to share with his friends on Day 2.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 13/07/2022 00:01

So not sure if it’s the ‘in’ thing to do parenting wise but when I was a kid I would get punished for whatever transgression… then double that for lying about it. As a kid you learn pretty quick to fess up to whatever you did wrong in the first place and not get caught out later.

Heartofglass12345 · 13/07/2022 00:00

You sound like hard work. He is going to lie to you more and more as he gets older as he's going to be too scared to tell the truth. He's only 7 why constantly feel the need to punish, it sounds so controlling and harsh!

Threetulips · 12/07/2022 23:57

I would get the staff onboard. I would ask them to message you if there are any issues and explain how he’s been. Don’t hide behind the lies. The more the adult stuck together to less chance he has of getting away with the lies.

My Dad lied at school a few times and we arranged for the teacher to text me and we would speak to him together so he knew we all knew.

Worth considering.

Anothermother3 · 12/07/2022 23:51

You clearly have good intentions from your last response. Maybe spend some time figuring out why you find his behaviour so triggering and how to address that for yourself so your response can be more measured. We all have things that trigger us and children often bring those to the fore. Always worth apologising for your part in things and always worry validating his thoughts and feelings even if the behaviour isn’t what you’d hope for. ‘The whole brain child’ and ‘the explosive child’ are 2 books that give good perspectives although the second one might be less relevant for him as it’s hard to get a sense of how he is generally.

womaninatightspot · 12/07/2022 23:43

I'm glad that you're going to try things differently. It is frustrating when you try and follow the rules and other parents don't though. My kids went to a camp yesterday which requested healthy lunch and snacks. There was a vending machine which loads had brought money to and some children had brought massive bags of haribo to share. They went to the same place today and I gave them all cash for the machine so they fit in and can share sweets with the kids who gave to them yesterday.

It's not ideal but not a hill I'm prepared to die on. They do a lot of exercise on these days so I'm assuming it balances out the sugar.

loldawg · 12/07/2022 23:36

Quite frankly the issues your son is having are created by you, and completely your fault.

in your own words: “I admit I am v strict and expect a lot from him, and myself and everyone, which can be hard to live up to.”

People that stay stuff like that actually don’t tend to expect much from themselves, if they did they wouldn’t make feel entitled to make the people around them miserable by holding them to an arbitrary ‘standard’ that they don’t keep themselves.

You also clearly care about the, irrelevant, opinions of other parents more than your own son.
its very telling that your son didn’t feel like he could tell you he didn’t like his water bottle or what the other kids were having in their lunch boxes - he probably feared your narcissistic rage. That probably drives the lies too.

Address your behaviour and stop emotionally and psychologically abusing your son.

IrishMama2015 · 12/07/2022 23:29

Thank you everyone for your help and advise.

I have definitely handled this incorrectly. I will apologise in the morning and I will give a different water bottle and give him a small treat in his lunch and send him to camp. He loves it and all his friends are there.

I clearly need to change my approach to this part of parenting and work on my reactions to situations and be more understanding.

I have been so afraid of not correcting bad behavior/ encouraging bad behaviour that my parenting has deviated totally from what I what I want him to have and what he deserves.

He is extremely loved so I need to remind him of that tomorrow.

OP posts:
Thesearmsofmine · 12/07/2022 23:16

Poor kid, he sounds scared of you and being punished. He is only 7 and he had a telling off from you, his dad and then sent to bed without a story and you want to keep him home from camp? Way overboard and it’s more about you then him.
Instead of so much focus on punishment, show him where being open and honest gets him.

Duttercup · 12/07/2022 23:11

I wrote a longer reply but I just think this is a really sad thread.

A 7 year old sent to bed alone being told he isn't trusted because he got himself all in a muddle over being embarrassed about his water bottle?

I'd rather raise a snowflake if this is the alternative.

CloudSunLeavesCoud · 12/07/2022 23:06

Did you give him a different water bottle today? One that he is more happy with? I think yabu, i have a DC the same age. I wouldn’t have told him off for the water thing I’d just have asked him to tell me straight away next time so that I could sort it earlier and given him a hug as sounds like he was desperate to fit in. Now the food. In the morning talk to him about what he wants in his lunchbox. Id give him some options and choices that I’m comfortable with and that I know he likes. If he literally only wants sweets/treats that you don’t feel
comfortable with, how about a compromise that you will bring the treat at pick up and he can eat it then if he’s been good and not hassled the other kids for their food? Try to compromise somehow. Talk to staff at drop off and pick up and see how he’s done with water and food. If you can get him to talk to you after camp tomorrow I’d ask if he has friends there and if he likes it and how he feels at camp. Try to understand what’s going on with him.

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 12/07/2022 23:04

You seem very quick to punish, rather than connect and understand. Being very strict does nothing other than to put a bridge betwixt your child and you. It's not laudable parenting to have a child that complies out of fear, and has probably started lying out of fear.
You allow him to be himself, so he probably annoys the other kids due to his (unrecognised) inauthenticity.
He's 7. Make the changes now before you totally cruah his personality via your expectations, demands and authoritarian ways.

IrishMama2015 · 12/07/2022 22:49

'Though you probably badgered him so much about who he asked and when, he can’t remember himself. It may well have been just one or two others.'

@DillyDilly yes I think you are right about badgering too much as I kept trying to get to the bottom of the whole truth

OP posts:
DillyDilly · 12/07/2022 22:48

What exactly did other parent say - maybe her child mentioned that yours was asking for a treat and she was just trying to tell you that it was ok to send treats and you misread the sentiment of her text.

OneEyedPenguin · 12/07/2022 22:47

I just am struggling with how to punish the lies when the truth is finally told without it seeming to him that it would have been better for him to not tell the truth. If that makes sense

Don't punish. Praise the truth. When you're asking him something that you think he might be being untruthful about reassure him that sometimes we all mess up and it's no big deal as long as we tell the truth. If we tell the truth then we can work together to find a solution and that better to own up later than never.

* I admit I am v strict and expect a lot from him, and myself and everyone, which can be hard to live up to*

Get over yourself. He a child not a small adult, he's his own person. You'll be crushing his self esteem and confidence. I'm sure you don't live up to some people expectations, it's just that they're not in a position of power over you to make you feel crap.

DillyDilly · 12/07/2022 22:46

“I admit I am v strict and expect a lot from him, and myself and everyone, which can be hard to live up to”

I think this is the cause of your DS lying. It sounds like you are far too harsh with him and he’s afraid of the constant punishments and having to always ‘be good’.

His behaviour in asking others for food is a little unusual though, so maybe keep an eye on this as there may be issues at play ? Though you probably badgered him so much about who he asked and when, he can’t remember himself. It may well have been just one or two others.

IrishMama2015 · 12/07/2022 22:43

Thank you everyone I really do appreciate all the replies, from all perspectives, and am taking them all onboard.

OP posts:
StarlingsInTheRoof · 12/07/2022 22:41

You could consider that he is lying because he is scared of you. It sounds like this time the punishment is because he embarrassed you, not that he did anything terrible. Start working out what actually stops the lying rather than how punishment must be the answer.

Tell the other parents you do feed him, remind him that the natural consequences of annoying everyone is that they won't want to play with him and get him a more grown up water bottle. You're not going to be able to stop him showing off. He is trying to work out how to interact with other kids and is probably a bit behind following lockdowns stopping that from happening at a critical age. Give yourself a chance to wind down too and see what you can enjoy together.

SnackSizeRaisin · 12/07/2022 22:40

IrishMama2015 · 12/07/2022 22:31

Thank you so much for the replies I really appreciate them.

He gets treats regularly. He gets unlimited, and I mean UNLIMITED, junk when at grandparents when they look after him one day a week and he usually gets a treat maybe 3 other days at home and we have a big movie night with treats at weekend.

It seems like he just behaves totally out of character when trying to 'show off' and fit in when away from us. I admit I am v strict and expect a lot from him, and myself and everyone, which can be hard to live up to.

I just am struggling with how to punish the lies when the truth is finally told without it seeming to him that it would have been better for him to not tell the truth. If that makes sense

In general I don't think punishment is an effective motivator. He has to want to behave well and be truthful because he feels loved and respected and trusted, and feels the same about you. Excess punishment just leads to lying and deceit and a feeling that he can never be good enough.
I'd work on building a good relationship with him, you can be strict without punishment.

IrishMama2015 · 12/07/2022 22:39

Unfortunately the lunch was all soggy and bashed around, presume from the heat today bag being thrown and moved around etc. I always give him a fresh one in the mornings. That he picks himself! He had never mentioned that others had treats or junk until tonight but even so I don't know if I would have sent some with him today if he had mentioned it.

OP posts:
OppsUpsSide · 12/07/2022 22:39

There is very little (any?) mention in all of that about your sons feelings and ALOT about yours.
He didn’t do any of those things to humiliate you - how do you even expect him to comprehend that as an idea at 7? You are very cross with him for humiliating you when he was trying, in a 7yr old way, not to feel humiliated himself (babyish water bottle).
You come across as very self-focused and immature so the fact your 7yr old isn’t behaving maturely with a sense of how their actions affect others isn’t hugely surprising. Rather than seeking out punishments for the child, try fixing yourself.

SnackSizeRaisin · 12/07/2022 22:35

I think you are being a bit harsh. Don't worry so much about what other people think and consider what is motivating your son's behaviour. Is he suffering low self esteem?
Keeping him off tomorrow would be a huge overreaction
His behaviour is silly and attention seeking but it's not malicious or nasty. Other parents will just think he's been a bit daft that's all.
Also why throw out his lunch? Surely most of it was still fine after 1 day?

IrishMama2015 · 12/07/2022 22:31

Thank you so much for the replies I really appreciate them.

He gets treats regularly. He gets unlimited, and I mean UNLIMITED, junk when at grandparents when they look after him one day a week and he usually gets a treat maybe 3 other days at home and we have a big movie night with treats at weekend.

It seems like he just behaves totally out of character when trying to 'show off' and fit in when away from us. I admit I am v strict and expect a lot from him, and myself and everyone, which can be hard to live up to.

I just am struggling with how to punish the lies when the truth is finally told without it seeming to him that it would have been better for him to not tell the truth. If that makes sense

OP posts:
LittlePumpkinPie21 · 12/07/2022 22:28

Sounds like he's wanting to fit in with his peers, support him to be on an equal footing with them.

OneEyedPenguin · 12/07/2022 22:27

I told him I can't believe his behaviour and lies and that I don't trust him anymore. That he broke his promise. My DH repeated the same more or less and we sent him to bed alone without a story which is a huge deal to him

Wtf? He's only 7 years old, no need to be so horrid towards him. Poor thing, I bet he feels absolutely hated and unloved at the moment.

Could the problem be that he doesn't feel comfortable enough with you to ask for a different water bottle of treat etc? You seem quite harsh and he sounds like he just wants to fit it.