Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Interested to know if this financial set up is fair

66 replies

Cagedcheddar · 12/07/2022 20:03

Will start this by saying DH is lovely, no backstory of control or abuse. Speaking to offer couples, our financial set up is different so interested to know if there's a better way of doing it or if how we are doing it is fine.

Have been together for 20 years. At first, we earnt the same and put same amount into shared account for rent and bills, leaving rest for whatever we wanted. Since having kids, my DH earnings have increased and now he is a high earner. My earnings have decreased - mat leave, than PT work. This was my choice but I did/do 90% school runs etc, most chores. Earnings ranged from £500-£1100 a month so earning a lot less.

I stopped adding to shared account years ago and instead pay for all kids classes (eg swimming) etc, their phones (teens), my phone, occasional big spends like a weekend away for us all, car insurance, car servicing etc. The rest i spend how I want - usually try and save a bit, drinks with friends, occasional clothes.

My DH adds to shared account and pays 100% mortgage (relatively small), bills, plus most of big things like holidays. I use this shared account for groceries and any family purchases like days out, kids clothes. For really big things eg car, we both took money from savings to pay.

I feel like I have a good deal. However... Despite paying considerably more into household finances then me, still has much a lot more "spare" He saves some, but the rest buys himself whatever he wants. His/our life is pretty frugal (camping hols, lots of 2nd hand etc) but he will happily buy whatever he wants eg new camera. I feel this money would be better spent on eg reducing mortgage/saving for kids future but it's not "mine" so I can't dictate where it goes.

I have increased my hours (work 0.8 FTE) now kids are older but will never reach his earning potential even if FT and spend my day "off" mainly doing chores.

Is this a fair set up? Is there a better way of splitting finances or am I a massive freeloader?!

OP posts:
cptartapp · 13/07/2022 11:41

DH earns six times what I do. We each pay proportionate % wise into a joint account by direct debit for absolutely everything joint, so he puts in six times more than I do, and the remainder of our monies is for us to spend or save as we wish.
No need to run anything by anyone then.

Herecomestreble1 · 13/07/2022 11:33

Hugasauras · 12/07/2022 22:35

I have to say I never understand the 'he pays for mortgage, utilities, I pay for food, kids stuff' setups. We have a joint account that all joint expenses come out of. We both pay for everything as we both contribute to the JA and anything that is for the family comes out of that: house stuff, childcare, cars, clothes for kids, etc. We don't keep score of who pays what or who is due X or Y. At times we have each been the higher earner and it doesn't change anything.

Exactly the same with DH and I! Any other way just seems to cause headaches.

OooErr · 13/07/2022 11:26

Isonthecase · 13/07/2022 10:06

I think this sort of thing works well if you both have similar spending habits and any spare goes in to family big spends (holidays, DIY) but otherwise can lead to inequality. We have the same issue after years of a situation where we couldn't really contribute evenly every month (variable overtime, working away for months at a time) and it's really tricky to unravel.

I'm thinking the answer might literally be all wages in to one account and then fun money comes out for each of you to your own account but that doesn't account for things like one of you being the one who buys most things for the kids. It's also a lot of paperwork 😅

It's not just spending habits, but the value of a PT parent that they should be on board with. OP said it was 'her choice'. What does that mean?
She wanted it and the DH said 'yes'? He was ambivalent either way?

If she was on minimum wage it might seem like the obvious decision. But otherwise 2 people earning an 'average' wage take home more than one high earner. If everything is done 100% FAIRLY w.r.t topping up PT parent's pension, equal spending etc it might actually be more expensive.

SaggyBlinders · 13/07/2022 10:11

Doesn't sound fair to me. You're doing all the skivvy work, have less disposable spending money and don't seem to have any say in planning savings for the future.

Should be one pot after 20 years together.

Isonthecase · 13/07/2022 10:06

I think this sort of thing works well if you both have similar spending habits and any spare goes in to family big spends (holidays, DIY) but otherwise can lead to inequality. We have the same issue after years of a situation where we couldn't really contribute evenly every month (variable overtime, working away for months at a time) and it's really tricky to unravel.

I'm thinking the answer might literally be all wages in to one account and then fun money comes out for each of you to your own account but that doesn't account for things like one of you being the one who buys most things for the kids. It's also a lot of paperwork 😅

Tessasanderson · 13/07/2022 10:03

You are a 50/50 partnership in everything else, why should your finances be any different.

Pay the bills, agree to save and split the rest 50/50. Or just leave it in the account and make joint decisions on how the surplus is spent.

Any relationship where a man gets to dictate any surplus after bills is wrong imo. Yes sir, no sir

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 13/07/2022 10:02

You should have joint savings and equal spending money.

But you also need to respect what he wants. Just because you think it would be better to overpay the mortgage, and that's the sensible choice, doesn't mean to get to dictate how he spends his own spending money (as long as you have access to a similar amount). I would not put up with my DH telling me how I must spend my money. It would be something we discussed and agreed on together.

HippoLover · 13/07/2022 10:02

I don’t see a problem with his cameras. Men need hobbies and trying to shut them down will only breed resentment. After all it’s not like he’s stopping you from finding a hobby and buying things for with family money is he? If not then you are perhaps just resentful that he’s spending money on himself rather than providing it all for you and the kids. That’s a bad attitude for a wife to have, people are allowed their hobbies even if they are costly - so long as your not living likenpaupers.

HippoLover · 13/07/2022 09:58

@MRex

Its quite possible for one partner to have higher earning potential as a result of greater intelligence and for there to be nothing the other can do to match it. It’s not nice to say it but obviously it can be the truth.

Teachertotutor · 13/07/2022 09:57

We treat all our money as shared. We pay all our bills/food/petrol etc from a joint account, give ourselves the same amount of money each for our own socialising/clothes etc and then save the rest. I feel this is 100% fair. At times he has been the higher earner, at other times I have.

HippoLover · 13/07/2022 09:56

It’s fair even though this forum will tell you it’s not which I suspect is why you commented here.
If you want to keep some money seperate and also work and have your own money then this does sound fair. It might be different if you were fully committed to being a SAHP or housewife but that is not the case.

You choose to stay at home with the kids and work pt despite people here making it sound like you’ve sacrificed unwillingly. That’s fine but you also want to go back to work.

Thisnis why two working parents is complicated, especially when the wife both wants to keep her own money but also feel that she is being provided for adequately. It’s better to either be all in on being at home or both work equally, everything else is a complication.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 13/07/2022 09:51

Family costs should come from the main account so get the kids clubs, and all movile phones and car costs swapped to the joint account.

ApolloandDaphne · 13/07/2022 09:45

That is pretty much how we have always done things but I can also access DH's main account (it is a joint account) or use credits cards (these are paid off every month) for anything else I fancy buying. Would either of these be any option for you? Does he accept he has more than you and does he give you money for larger purchases you might want if you ask?

devonianBiatch · 13/07/2022 09:40

What about your pension op? His will be sky high and yours will be a pittance!

iabr · 13/07/2022 09:32

Of course it's not fair OP. You are a family. He is your husband. His money is your money. Most people would just pool everything. Why should you live like a second class citizen in your own home, just because he earns more (which you have largely facilitated)?

MRex · 13/07/2022 09:15

will never reach his earning potential even if FT and spend my day "off" mainly doing chores
Whatever works for you both as a family is broadly fine, I would think it's better to share more evenly, and especially to save more for retirement, but it's your call. Your view of your own working potential or intellectual capability is very poor though, fix that. Why are you spending a day on chores and deciding you don't have the capability to earn? Women are not in general intellectually inferior to their husbands and it's an awful example to your children to behave as though you are. Get a cleaner, get out there and achieve something.

Wombat27A · 13/07/2022 08:56

The issue here isn't how it's set up, it's the lax control of the spare cash.

I was once accused of being a "Child of Thatcher" on here for saying we run our finances like a business. But we do and we are far, far better off for it as it's all fairly stragegic, combined with the luck that investing always requires. Despite me having a very flaky job history, which is being very kind to myself!

If he is a high earner, why are you still behaving like you're still scraping by as a family? Fair enough to carry on being frugal but it's sounding very one-sided and with little provision for future needs.

You need some strategy, allowing for life being short, etc. Maybe a financial planner consultation could help, would take the "is it fair?" out of it and make it "is it reasonable?" and "is it the best use of funds?" and crucially, "are we both protected against financial shocks, eg, illness, job redundancy, etc or marriage breakdown?"

It sounds like his savings are a mystery to you...

Oblomov22 · 13/07/2022 08:56

Loads on this thread have a joint account. This is very unusual on mn. We've only ever had a joint account too. You know this isn't good OP, but you don't need mahoosive changes, just a couple of minor tweaks.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 13/07/2022 08:37

Also I think when you're a family you make the major financial decisions together. Like how much you should be saving, what you invest in if anything, how much you live for now vs the future etc. I'm more of a spend it now on experiences person and my husband would save more and retire earlier so we compromise, eg have more holidays than he wants but less than I want. Because we are a family and planning for a future together. It wouldn't feel like a family to me if he made the decision because it was 'his' money...especially if he had made his money on the back of me giving up mine (so he had never had to worry about taking days off when kids were sick, or taking them to appointments, or dropping his hours to do nursery pick ups or drop offs, or had to refuse to travel because there was no one to look after them etc)

romdowa · 13/07/2022 08:37

To me there is only 2 fair ways to do it.

  1. Where you both earn the same and then spilt it 50/ 50 or
  2. All the money goes into the pot and is family money.
Number 2 is how we do it as I couldn't earn as much as dp.
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 13/07/2022 08:33

I work 0.8 but look after young primary age kids on most of my day off...my husband earns almost double what I do when take into account bonus. However he works away a bit and can only do this if I don't, which does limit my career a bit as the next level up for me is expected to do more entertaining in the evening and a bit more travel etc

We both have roughly equal spending money and put the rest into a joint account and everything else comes from there. If either of us need to make any significant individual purchases or overspend on stuff then we take it from the joint account, however this only really works because we have a very similar attitude to money and neither of us are into anything flash or expensive brands or shopping sprees etc so we generally trust each other to be sensible.

Diddlypiddly · 13/07/2022 08:31

Does he have a pension? Do you? What's the split like in the pensions between the two of you?

I'm asking because your set-up is such that you've given up being an equal earner to him to do the child rearing etc, so therefore you're always going to be on the backfoot with how much you can save for your pension. You're never going to catch him up in this regard. Unless of course he's putting equal amounts into a pension for you and for him.

OooErr · 13/07/2022 08:22

OP your problem isn’t that YOU have no money to spend on yourself. You want him to spend on something ‘sensible’ , like reducing the mortgage, or ‘save for the kids’.

What’s wrong with him enjoying life? It’s short, and gone all too quickly.

Fair enough for you to say he should give you some of the money instead of having oodles more money. Unfair of you to dictate what should be done with it.

DottyDotAgain · 13/07/2022 08:14

So I'm going against the grain here and would say it's fair if you both think it's fair.

Dp and I have been together for 30 years, 2 x kids and over the years she has earned considerably more than me for the first few years and then it switched and I've earned considerably more for the last 20 years or so. She left work/returned part-time to look after the boys and I found a career from somewhere!

We have never had a joint current account. I pay the mortgage and all the bills except the water and TV - she pays those so she's got some bills just in her name. She pays for the weekly food shop with her part-time income. We don't have any joint savings accounts either.

I have money left over each month that I put into savings for house/holidays and she does the same. We decide where we want to go on holiday/what needs doing with the house and generally I'll pay the majority and she contributes.

Over the years this has worked really well - we each have money left over at the end of the month and will either save or spend it on what we want. I definitely fritter more on coffee/going out with friends and she will buy more books!

It just works for us - we've discussed having a joint account a few times over the years and have decided that it would probably cause more friction, so why change things when this works so well?

So, if you're not happy then find another way, but if it works, it works.

Munchyseeds2 · 13/07/2022 08:07

Can never get my head around 'he pays, I pay!
We are a team
He earns more than me, everything goes into a joint account, everything comes out of same account.
If we want something we buy it (joint credit card)
We do both have the same (sensible) attitude to spending tho

Swipe left for the next trending thread