Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you a Conservative Party Member who you like to see in the final two and who would you vote for?

483 replies

BreadInCaptivity · 12/07/2022 19:57

As the title says.

We will have a new PM and the decision on who it is will ultimately reside with CP members.

I would rather this wasn't a political thread in the sense of Conservative/Labour/LidDem/Green etc.

I'm simply very interested to understand the direction of travel here for party members and would ask that people posting respect that and don't pounce on party members who post.

For reference I'm not a party member, but my uncle is and in his constituency he's saying it's a run off between Sunak, Mordant and Badenoch in terms of local support.

OP posts:
Catherston79 · 14/07/2022 18:38

I know Liz Truss. She is highly experienced, having been toxic and panicky across a number of Whitehall departments. Who could forget her Dr Zhivago turn in Moscow, her speech on cheese or prison dogs trained to bark at drones. Good with data but doesn’t do people, organisations or culture at all. The toxicity kills trust and drives awful (survival) behaviour in those around her but it’s the panicky over-reactions dressed up as ‘grip’ that would really trouble me were she PM. Experience isn’t everything.

Conservative party member, not currently feeling like a Conservative voter however.

MarshaBradyo · 14/07/2022 18:34

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 18:21

Others may feel he was a central option? Which is fine we won’t all agree on issues

I don't know about central. I don't trust what any of them say. But I have seen him chairinf committees etc that show he is a rational person who seems to consideer evidence and outcomes before making choices. It's a low bar but at this point that is all I ask.

I probably would have liked him more without the reach for lockdown, maybe his party would have too. I don’t want that to be a quick solution again

Although he’s already had a go at it before so maybe that was an issue too

liliainterfrutices · 14/07/2022 18:29

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 18:07

Johnson appealed to the public more with his persona. It's was also his biggest downfall but whatever negatives you say about him his charisma was appealing.

Only if you are deaf and blind and lacking rational function. Or the ability to use google to check his track record.

Quite.
I've never got the appeal of Johnson. He just comes over as a very immature, cocky year 12 boy who thinks he's a lot cleverer than he is.
I've never once heard him say anything witty. He seems to make people laugh with his unbrushed hair and humphing and hawing.

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 18:29

Sorry for typing!

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 18:21

Others may feel he was a central option? Which is fine we won’t all agree on issues

I don't know about central. I don't trust what any of them say. But I have seen him chairinf committees etc that show he is a rational person who seems to consideer evidence and outcomes before making choices. It's a low bar but at this point that is all I ask.

MarsQueen · 14/07/2022 18:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MarshaBradyo · 14/07/2022 18:10

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 18:03

The CP made the right call at the time as they got an 80 seat majority, Hunt may not have - but who knows

This is the problem. The right call is choosing the option that has the besz outcomes for the country, not the best outcomes for Conservative candidates/ MPs who want to get/ keep those jobs.

I don’t think Hunt would have been better for the country, I’m glad he’s now out too

He was too prone to wanting lockdown and that was damaging.

Others may feel he was a central option? Which is fine we won’t all agree on issues

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 18:10

MiniPiccolo · 14/07/2022 08:12

Just to point out, anyone but Rishi and we would have a general election. Conservatives (and women who care about women's rights) may wish to take heed of that. A no confidence vote may not be triggered against Kemi but it absolutely will against all others. The Queen likes Rishi. She could refuse a general election.

The Queen refusea general election which Parliamemt has decided to hold? Delusional.

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 18:07

Johnson appealed to the public more with his persona. It's was also his biggest downfall but whatever negatives you say about him his charisma was appealing.

Only if you are deaf and blind and lacking rational function. Or the ability to use google to check his track record.

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 18:06

honkeytonkwoman38 · 14/07/2022 07:13

Liz Truss has just slagged off her old school. For what reason. She's 46. It's my daughters school now and outstanding! So is she saying her own government inspections are a waste of time? Apparently her dad was lovely and a socialist.

I think that is disingenuous: the school may have been very different and not outstanding several decades ago. Education was especially appalling in the 90s and it seems that may have been when she was at school?

But a proper response to this from her or anybody else would be to massively increase funding so that class sizes are under 20, as in private schools.

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 18:03

The CP made the right call at the time as they got an 80 seat majority, Hunt may not have - but who knows

This is the problem. The right call is choosing the option that has the besz outcomes for the country, not the best outcomes for Conservative candidates/ MPs who want to get/ keep those jobs.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 14/07/2022 17:53

Fillet I know what you mean. It's still all about Brexit, primarily. They want someone who believes in it. Despite all her posturing, and despite the fact the he sort of likes her, FIL still refers to LT as 'erstwhile remainer Liz Truss'.

I think the truth is, they don't care about the wider electorate. Not right now, anyway. They don't feel the need to. Whoever gets in will be sitting on a 70-something majority and no need to call a GE for 2.5 years.

But I will caveat my remark by reminding everyone that FIL is just one berk man, and his comments should be taken with a liberal (!) pinch of salt.

Fillet · 14/07/2022 17:45

FIL (party member) reckons the powers-that-be would prefer to keep Tugendhat off the telly just in case he creates a Nick Clegg moment

Interesting. The Tory party want to avoid the nightmare scenario that the only halfway compassionate, relatively normal and somewhat plausible candidate might succeed.

I don't get it. The Tory Party are clueless about the electorate. The Ultra Right are putting plenty of people off voting Tory. They must only read the DM comments.

While (almost) all DM readers are likely to be Tories, not all Tories are DM readers and do NOT hold hard Right views.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 14/07/2022 17:29

FIL (party member) reckons the powers-that-be would prefer to keep Tugendhat off the telly just in case he creates a Nick Clegg moment; the bulk of the membership (not to mention the parliamentary party) won't want him to win.

BreadInCaptivity · 14/07/2022 17:00

stuckdownahole · 14/07/2022 15:44

There are TV debates, starting tomorrow (Friday) which could influence the outcome.

First question is whether there will be four or five on the platform - will Tugendhat pull out? He would have expected to pick up most of Jeremy Hunt's supporters and increase from 37 votes from MPs to around 50. Instead, he is down to 32 which must be discouraging. Is there really any point him carrying on?

I'm not a Tory party member (or a Tory) but if I was, I would be watching these debates. It is not a done deal that Sunak and Mordaunt will be the final two. Kemi Badenoch is very bright and outspoken and has nothing to lose so could outperform everyone at the debates. Liz Truss has support from the right wing of the Tory party so will be trying to cast herself as the true believer in conservative values against high-tax Rishi and woke Penny. If those two go on the attack, they could land some punches.

I agree and aside from the debates there will be a lot of horse trading going on behind the scenes.

Between them, Suella, Liz and Kemi had far more votes in this round than Penny and Tom combined.

My guess is there will be a lot of pressure on Kemi and Liz to join forces - and that would please Rishi's supporters also.

Irrespective of any deal struck between Liz/Kemi, MP's themselves might stop the split by transferring support from one to the other to keep a right wing candidate in the final two.

Results:

Rishi Sunak: 101 (+13)
Penny Mordaunt: 83 (+16)
Liz Truss: 64 (+14)
Kemi Badenoch: 49 (+9)
Tom Tugendhat: 32 (-5)
ELIMINATED
Suella Braverman: 27 (-5)

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 14/07/2022 15:46

Apparently the final two won't be announced until Wednesday. Try to contain your excitement.

stuckdownahole · 14/07/2022 15:44

There are TV debates, starting tomorrow (Friday) which could influence the outcome.

First question is whether there will be four or five on the platform - will Tugendhat pull out? He would have expected to pick up most of Jeremy Hunt's supporters and increase from 37 votes from MPs to around 50. Instead, he is down to 32 which must be discouraging. Is there really any point him carrying on?

I'm not a Tory party member (or a Tory) but if I was, I would be watching these debates. It is not a done deal that Sunak and Mordaunt will be the final two. Kemi Badenoch is very bright and outspoken and has nothing to lose so could outperform everyone at the debates. Liz Truss has support from the right wing of the Tory party so will be trying to cast herself as the true believer in conservative values against high-tax Rishi and woke Penny. If those two go on the attack, they could land some punches.

WatchoRulo · 14/07/2022 15:41

I’m not a registered Tory voter.
No-one is

NightmareSlashDelightful · 14/07/2022 15:23

The bulk of Braverman's backing will swing behind Badenoch, I would have thought. They're ideologically in the same ballpark. Although I can see Mordaunt picking up a handful.

The steam seems to be dissipating from Tugendhat's momentum too. (Down five votes since yesterday.) I wonder where his support will go?

Truss isn't where she needs to be either. Not surprising really, her speech this morning was decidedly limp.

Fillet · 14/07/2022 15:20

Yep. Thank God for that.

liliainterfrutices · 14/07/2022 15:10

Braverman out, thank God.

Fillet · 14/07/2022 13:38

Look at what the Tory party is serving up, on top of the disaster of Brexit, 200,000 Covid deaths, a tanking economy, a cost of living crisis that they seem to think st nothing to do with them, and heading for a winter of hunger and poverty for millions: a bunch of D-listers who haven't got anything like the political chops, compassion or experience to make a dint in any of it.

And a despicable AG who is blithely suggesting that we 'leave the ECHR.'

What an absolute shit show.

Aintnosupermum · 14/07/2022 12:59

I’m not a registered Tory voter.

Hell no to Sunak. Fraud occurred, was identified and ignored and it was a Lord, not the Treasury minister, who raised the issue. Working in financial services, should such fraud occur in my workplace there would be serious consequences. Sunak did nothing. His conflicts of interest are a major integrity issue for me. How can you be chancellor and have a greencard? His campaign is being funded how exactly? My understanding is that his in laws are not British. I think there are huge question marks regarding his integrity and the influence his wife’s family have been able to buy from having their SIL at such a top level of British politics.

I heard Penny speak, nope. Truss, nope. Tugboat is mediocre but I don’t think he has enough experience. Ben Wallace is probably the best of the bunch and he isn’t an option, which is insane. I still want Ruth Davidson and we as a society should look at ourselves and change so good people like her don’t leave politics. What she accomplished in Scotland was nothing short of spectacular.

liliainterfrutices · 14/07/2022 12:56

I'm always bemused when people say that we have to accept the result and pull together to make it work. How does that work? It's not as if by saying that I don't hate Leavers [and I don't] I'll be able to make one jot of difference to the ways in which small businesses, farmers, fishermen, academics etc etc have all been shafted.

liliainterfrutices · 14/07/2022 12:54

But one of Brexit's defining features is that it won't 'be done' for decades. The unravelling of our ties and defining our new relationship will go on and on, as we are seeing, and as it does the question of how we want to relate to Europe is going to be endlessly debated. Johnson never got Brexit done - it's one of his big lies. He is trying to tear up the deal and all the future leaders are saying they can't stand by the deal that they all supported in 2019. It's an utter shitshow.

Swipe left for the next trending thread