Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone helped their child to be less uptight?

119 replies

itwasntmetho · 12/07/2022 19:43

Okay not an AIBU but I really need the help of the wise ones here.
My ds is 10, he's always been a bit of a victim, has a face on him if something is challenging, expects to be rescued.
He really isn't doing well socially atm, one of the really lovely school mums was brave enough to be honest with me that her child says my ds gets other kids into trouble, makes a big deal of small things and victimises himself if play is rough in general (paraphrasing).
This is a habit/ personality trait I've been pulling ds up on since forever and I don't think he ever believed me that his friends would vote with their feet and people wouldn't always overlook it. He's getting quite lonely now in school and I'm gutted for him. How can I help him break the habit?

OP posts:
BotCrossHuns · 13/07/2022 10:05

The series is called "What to do when...." The one about worry is a commonly recommended one, and sometimes the anger one as well.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 13/07/2022 10:05

I'm not convinced that he isn't a victim and what you're trying to do is mould him into someone they're less likely to target. That's the opposite of resilience.

It's quite uncomfortable to read another parent excusing 'rough play' as the victim being too sensitive and then implying the victim is 'deliberately' getting DCs into trouble - and you agreeing and taking that focus back to your DC.

Fwiw most schools wouldn't be happy with rough play at that age. And they won't give DCs into trouble just because someone is 'playing the victim'.

Your DS is in a rugby/rough play ie violent year group that has victim blaming DCs and parents. That's what he needs support with. And yy you can do that by trying to turn him into another bullying mini-thug or by forcing the school to address the bullying issues in that year and supporting your DC to be who he is.

BotCrossHuns · 13/07/2022 10:04

That book is part of a whole series of books that are good - they're all by different authors so some better than others. But if you look on amazon, you can see the different ones. Based on CBT techniques.

Might be good for you also to get a CBT type book for yourself, to work on seeing how you can change your mindset towards him into more unconditional love, to make sure that this really comes across to him. I can't stress enough how damaging it is for children to feel that their parents don't value who they are, faults and all. And how many parents will be sure that they do and that this comes across, when from the child's point of view, it doesn't. Really really worth looking carefully at yourself and thinking about this angle.

itwasntmetho · 13/07/2022 10:01

Wbeezer · 13/07/2022 09:41

I've got this book I could send you if you like

I need that in my life!
Thank you, can you pm me your paypal details and I'll give you some money for it? x

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 13/07/2022 09:57

It sounds like he’d enjoy quieter games and rules based play - do the school have a chess club, or offer scrabble games or similar in the library at lunch time?

If not, maybe look in to joining an extracurricular chess club or Scouts, where activities are structured and work towards an end goal.

You sound like a good Mum who doesn’t want to let her DS down, while trying to prepare him for the real world. I agree with PP’s that he shouldn’t tolerate rough play if he doesn’t like it, but he may need help working on social and emotional skills.

Ask the school if they think a SEN assessment or meeting with the EdPsych might be helpful, to rule out other things; then if nothing improves I’d look in to some counselling to help him work through his feelings. It worked wonders for my DNephew at a similar age.

Wbeezer · 13/07/2022 09:52

Pressed post too soon... Gladly put this in the post to you, its just sitting on a bookshelf waiting to be passed on (but a bit awkward to suggest that they might need it!).
It turned out that all of my kids were neuro diverse in various ways and that was why they were a bit rigid about rules and rather negative about normal social interactions. In the end I accepted that they were behind in social and emotional development and just tried to discreetly provide back up but there were some difficult times (sports days, arghh). They are all adults now and all found friend groups they could handle in the end. The oldest is still a bit of a moaner though!

Whitehorsegirl · 13/07/2022 09:46

I feel sorry for that boy.

You have just called him ''uptight'' and described him as ''someone who plays the victim'', that you have been trying to change his personality ''forever'' and you go along with what other parents tell you rather than supporting your own child...

What you should be doing is accepting him for who he is and stop trying to make him into someone he is not. I don't see anything wrong with not liking to be around kids who like to ''play rough''.

I suggest you try being a bit less critical and instead focusing on helping your kid develop his self-confidence. Maybe a new activity/sport. Have you actually asked him what he enjoys doing?

You are trying to mould this child into an alpha action man and this is not who he is. You also seem to be over-analysing every aspect of his behaviour. No wonder this kid will be anxious...

To me reading this it also sounds like you have an unhealthy attitude to parenting and the issue might not be simply with your boy. Someone has to say it.

Clatterbacks · 13/07/2022 09:44

My 9yo is autistic and he sounds very similar (aspergers). I sometimes have to label the behaviour for what it is (manipulative).

Wbeezer · 13/07/2022 09:41

I've got this book I could send you if you like

Has anyone helped their child to be less uptight?
itwasntmetho · 13/07/2022 09:41

Another thing you might want to try is parkour. It's non-competitive, you are basically using your body in line with the built environment.

Is that like floor is lava? My ds loves that. I didn't know it was a thing outside of the playground.

OP posts:
MaChienEstUnDick · 13/07/2022 09:28

I hated the 'rough-housing' stage and so did my DS. Which is totally OK, I hate that boys are supposed to like fighting and scrapping.

But between not liking that and not liking football, his playtimes were fairly miserable at primary school. We talked about it a lot though - if you don't want to do something you don't have to do it, but if all the other people you want to play with want to do the thing then it's going to be hard. What's more important? Joining in or not doing the thing you don't like? The thing I then focused on was being at peace with the decision he'd made. And helping him understand that if he joined in because he wanted to be with his friends that day, he couldn't change the rules/conventions to suit himself. It's really tough but it did ease massively at high school when lunch and break times look quite different.

Another thing you might want to try is parkour. It's non-competitive, you are basically using your body in line with the built environment. It's great for building confidence, knocks are par for the course but they just get back up and back on with it because of the way the (usually super-cool) instructors deal with it.

Siameasy · 13/07/2022 09:24

I think its about teaching him how to articulate his needs in an assertive way. They say behaviour is communication so help him articulate the feelings behind the actions.

Society currently seems to reward victims but at ground level this behaviour is massively off putting.

Tomselleckhaskindeyes · 13/07/2022 09:16

He sounds like my son OP. I was often worried about him as he was highly strung. I did some CBT with him and worked with his teachers. He's 13 and we've had a few wobbles at senior school but in the whole he has become loads more resilient. He discussed with his friends he doesn't do rough play and they avoid it with him.

InvincibleInvisibility · 13/07/2022 09:13

I think there's a huge difference between "forcing" a child to rough house and stopping a child doing passive aggressive over the top complaining when barely touched.

Once my DS stroked his cousin's back. His cousin kicked off about how he'd hurt him. We said it was just a stroke but nephew then insisted he was scratched etc etc.

The result is that my DS is starting to avoid his cousin and wont hug him in case he gets yelled at.

BotCrossHuns · 13/07/2022 09:09

The language you use about him is so critical, though, that I wonder whether he really does feel that you see the good things about him - I know you say you tell him those, but it sounds like you've got such harsh ideas about him that it might be coming across anyway. And that can make it harder for a child to change, because they feel like there is something wrong with who they naturally are. I had some traits as a child that my Mum didn't like, and was very much pushed into trying to change them - but it didn't help, or even made me feel worse about myself and more misunderstood. I had to come to the realisations myself about what I wanted to change, and what was just my personality and could be accepted. It would have helped a lot more if i felt loved unconditionally. So even the fact that you talk about him as being 'uptight' - you don't have to use such a loaded, negative word about him or his whole personality, but instead, could be focus on certain behaviours that are a bit rigid. It makes it sound a lot more changeable, and focuses on a core part of him that is still worthy, somehow, with external traits that are changeable if he wants. Words like 'pandering' and so on are also extremely pejorative, and even when you don't use them in front of him, might mean that your real feelings are showing through and he will pick up on that.

There are things he can do to change - reading books about friendships, encouraging him to role play, maybe working with a counsellor or someone external to you, so that it's not always you telling him to change, which can be so damaging to a child - you can then be 'on his side', accepting him for who he is, but supporting his efforts to work on things. If he thinks that his personality is just who he is, which of course many children do, then having a parent who doesn't accept them is so hard. It just feels like there is nowhere you can be yourself, because who you are naturally just isn't acceptable, and that is such a hard message for children (and such a hard message to let go of later in life). I was a bit of a negative child, prone to over thinking, and constantly being told to be positive, smile, be resilient, etc just made me feel like who I was was wrong. It took years to accept that I was fine and valuable regardless, and that I could then make choices in how I saw the world, how I presented things to other people etc, but that having a negative mindset originally doesn't actually make me a bad person. In fact it is much much easier to choose changes, when you feel accepted and understood.

So maybe working a bit on yourself as well, to see him differently and make sure that he knows that, so that it becomes a problem set of behaviours that you can work on together to help him keep more friends, if that's what he wants. Doesn't mean you have to accept the behaviours, but I suspect there is a lot of messages coming across to him that you don't accept him (even if that is not at all what you intend).

MarsQueen · 13/07/2022 09:03

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BlueBlueCowWondering · 13/07/2022 09:03

Interesting debate on roughhousing. I see both boys and girls being much more physical than we were in school (back in the dark ages). I don't mean fighting but there's a huge amount of hugging/ arm around shoulder/ linking arms (girls)/ pushing each other towards hedges (boys) that I notice from the pupils at local schools. All done in a friendly way but could be difficult for a child not used to positive physical contact.

workwoes123 · 13/07/2022 08:58

the phase

“parent the child you have not the one you wish you had”

this, 100%. DH and I clash on this a bit. He frets that our DS1 is too flippant, that he gives up too easily, that he has a short attention span. That our DS2 is shy, too quiet in class, too much of a perfectionist, not sociable enough. He keeps trying to ’teach’ them to be more serious / honest / resilient/ confident / outspoken etc etc - whatever he thinks would ‘help’ them. But I’m pretty sure that what they mostly hear is “you aren’t good enough the way you are: you need to be different (to make me happy)”.

That’s who they are though - that’s them. While we all want life to be easy for our children (and we can recognise that certain personality traits make for an ‘easier’ life) I draw the line at pushing them to change their basic personalities to fit in. Look around you. The world is full of people, all different. And children learn. You can certainly point out to your DS when he is being unreasonable, in a neutral way. And yes role play can help - if he’s asking for help.

I’ve got a friend whose DD, also an only, is very like your DS. She can’t cope with other people breaking the rules: she’s grown up in a very rational, reasonable and adult world where people generally follow the rules and she has always found the rough and tumble craziness of the playground and friendships with children quite difficult to manage. She’s definitely the’ good girl’ and puts huge stock in being ‘good’ in every way. She tends to hold her (child) friends to the same standards as the adults she lives with, inevitably they fall short, and she gets very judgmental with them. So yes, she finds friendships hard and she possibly always will.

my dad was a psychiatric nurse for many years. He told me once that his hardest cases to treat / help (and he had some pretty horrible ones) were adults who felt that they had not lived up their parents expectations, whether academically, socially, behaviourally, whatever. Because that message of not being good enough, of being a failure, of being a disappointment, has been drummed into them from early childhood. And that is hard to shift in later life.

itwasntmetho · 13/07/2022 08:55

I've never looked at martial arts, just asked ds if he'd like to go once when his friend was going but he said no, I might revisit that.

I know it sounds like inverted snobbery but it's quite a MC area and I'm sceptical about the number of profit making business' around here pushing extra curriculars as essentials, from baby sensory, toddler dancing, must start water babies straight after first jabs, tennis lessons, hockey lessons, rugby in winter, cricket in summer. I moved here because I used to nanny here and I knew so many frazzled kids I felt sorry for some of them.

How do middle ground people do it when a child isn't keen or wants to give up something? there must be a whole host of normal between me who lets it go and people who say no carry on. I think that could be good for him, but he won't naturally be keen.

OP posts:
Mardyface · 13/07/2022 08:53

I really disagree about training boys to roughhouse if they don't like it. If boys want to play like that then fine but it's an early lesson in consent isn't it. 1. You shouldn't have to play like that if you don't want to. 2.You shouldn't assume others want to play like that. 3.You should stop if they tell you to. 4.You shouldn't go along with the crowd if they are doing something to someone else you're not comfortable with (eg insisting on rough play).

Life lessons for boys.

Lima1 · 13/07/2022 08:48

OP I think you are totally right to try to help your son overcome some of these behaviours. Its all well and good people telling you that you need to accept your son the way he is but the reality is that the world wont accept them and he will have a much easier life if the behaviours are managed.

My nephew sounds very like your DS. His mother and GM highly value polite well mannered children and hate any type of roughhousing. He was always rewarded for being quiet and polite and taught that adults prefer that type of child. Whenever he hurt himself as a child he was mollycoddled and was taught to avoid danger. He is 16 now and is a lovely boy but he struggled with friendships as he always wanted things done correctly, hates rule breakers and never liked any contact sport (or any sport really). It definitely affected him and more so in secondary school. He would happily tell on other students and was openly shocked and critical if they did something he considered wrong.
His social skills are not great. He is ok around adults when he gets to know them but struggles to make friends and put himself out there.

I do think an ability to deal with roughhousing is a good skill for boys. Most boys roughhouse and while your son may not like it (and thats fine), he needs to learn not to overreact to it when it happens (obviously I mean genuine play fighting and not something that is designed to hurt or intimidate him under the guise of play).
Would his dad work on this with him, my kids (including my 14 year old DD) love wrestling their dad, maybe something like play arm wrestles or thumb wars to start off, just something physical to get him used to the contact.

I would also speak to the school, they are the ones that oversee most of his interactions with his peers and may have a better insight into what is going on and suggestions to help.

Good luck

itwasntmetho · 13/07/2022 08:43

Mardyface · 13/07/2022 08:26

I think I would approach this sideways. I think sometimes 'coaching' people through situations can make it worse because it's never the same situation twice and then the kids is second guessing themselves and feeling like they can't do anything in case it's wrong.

In your case I think I'd be wondering where the whiny/blamey behaviour comes from and bearing in mind what you have said (and of course it isn't much because it's just a description on a Mumsnet thread) it sounds like he needs to learn how to be more assertive about what he wants generally. He went back surfing with a cut finger because he wanted to surf. If he doesn't want to play rugby he needs not to, or if he doesn't enjoy rough play he needs to say so clearly when it happens (or take himself away). It's OK to have needs and wants but if you can't express them you do tend to resort to the sort of passive aggressive behaviour you're talking about.

Oh yeah my ds definitely needs to be more assertive and direct with it not hoping someone will guess.

That's something I could work on.

OP posts:
Iwanttenofthose · 13/07/2022 08:41

I appreciate this might not be a standalone solution, but if you're going down the route of extra curricular activities to broaden his perspective etc I would seriously consider martial arts.

My friend was horrifically bullied until he did a summer at karate camp and the bullies never came near him again. Not because they knew (they didn't) but because taking up that sport completely transformed him. He held himself differently, and had this quiet confidence about him that he'd never had before. I know it's not the same as your son's situation but I can see a parallel because martial arts are very good for instilling a sense of resilience and self discipline that could be really helpful to him. He may also be less concerned about rough play if he knows he has the skills to safely protect himself (without "fighting") should the need ever arise. Worth a free trial lesson at least to see if he takes to it?

itwasntmetho · 13/07/2022 08:40

BlueBlueCowWondering · 13/07/2022 08:16

I think there have been some really good suggestions so far in this thread. Hitting secondary school with the tools already in place to make and keep friends is so valuable.

One thing I would add is to look into parenting classes locally. My council run them in conjunction with schools. You'll get lots of information and support, but I found them just as valuable to hear from a wide variety of other parents. I've done a couple aimed at parents of teens which @itwasntmetho isn't far off.

Yeah I always find other mums have the most useful input, especially when they have been challenged.

OP posts:
Mardyface · 13/07/2022 08:26

I think I would approach this sideways. I think sometimes 'coaching' people through situations can make it worse because it's never the same situation twice and then the kids is second guessing themselves and feeling like they can't do anything in case it's wrong.

In your case I think I'd be wondering where the whiny/blamey behaviour comes from and bearing in mind what you have said (and of course it isn't much because it's just a description on a Mumsnet thread) it sounds like he needs to learn how to be more assertive about what he wants generally. He went back surfing with a cut finger because he wanted to surf. If he doesn't want to play rugby he needs not to, or if he doesn't enjoy rough play he needs to say so clearly when it happens (or take himself away). It's OK to have needs and wants but if you can't express them you do tend to resort to the sort of passive aggressive behaviour you're talking about.

Swipe left for the next trending thread