Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think there is no solution to bullying

113 replies

cofingalthetime · 12/07/2022 19:06

So my ds has been in a team for just over 2 years. He is not the best on the team, or the worst - if that matters. The coach is very competitive. DS has been miserable going to matches and training for about 6 months. He says (and I've seen and heard it) the boys give out to him all the time, if he makes a mistake they say under their breath FFS, or tell him he's standing in the wrong place, or shout at him. The coach's son was the worst culprit. So gradually DS attendance has fallen off. I offered to speak to the coach but DS said it wouldn't help, would probably make things worse - does speaking to the coach ever work?

Anyway last night was another training session, and ds didnt want to go, so I just said we should just tell them he is leaving - it was hard, cos he loves football, and I have made friends (as I thought) with some of the parents. Anyway, in the end, he made the decision to leave (with my help). So I texted the coach and said I would ring him tmw - it was getting late at this stage so I didn't want to disturb him by ringing.

Almost immediately he texts the group chat saying DS has decided to leave and best wishes to him. He also texts me that he had had a feeling for a while that DS was becoming disinterested.

I slept on it, but it really annoyed me, that yet again, this kind of thing was being swept under the carpet, and the coach was even going so far as to say ds wasnt committed enough - that was what he was hinting at.

So wrote a long text to the coach explaining how unhappy ds had been, that I had witnessed the behaviour of the boys, that I had suggested saying something to him, but ds said no way, that I felt it may not have made any difference in any case, as once it's the norm to pick on someone, it's very difficult to change that narrative. I mean 13 year old boys don't take much heed of what the adults say do they. I've seen it before - when a teacher has tried to 'help' and ended up making things worse.

Well, the coach is very angry - he wrote me a long email about how the club does not condone bullying and that he had seen or heard nothing, and that I was to describe specific incidents to him (which of course I can't, as it's that insidious, snide type of bullying that is very hard to pin down). In a word, he is clueless how to deal with it. He said that the boys were very competitive, as they should be, and challenged each other. I wanted to respond that ds is well able for banter, and is very competitive and is popular at school, with lots of friends. But I didn't. I also posted a similar message in the group chat. (I left the group then).

Only 1 mother has texted me to say how sorry she is - ironically her son is one who was nice to ds on a few occasions.

I'm just disappointed, not surprised, but I was bullied in school over 30 years ago, and honestly the attitudes and ways of dealing with it don't appear to have changed one bit. Don't we need to look at this from a different angle. THe coach was literally blaming ds for not coming forward He said "DS has never mentioned anything to me or the other coachers". Well OF COURSE he hasnt, are you an idiot.

Just wondered about others experiences - is there an answer to bullying, or are we destined to leave it up to the victim to leave, move on, heal themselves, always wondering if there is something "wrong" with them, that they got picked on.

I'm left with a nearly 14 year old who is very down on himself, thinks he is crap at football, and what team would even want him now. I'm so sad - he bloody loves football. Not fair.

OP posts:
Eatingchips · 13/07/2022 07:59

@cofingalthetime I agree that bullying has no solution. I have experienced extreme bullying myself and it has no solution.

I think the only solution is get out as quick as you can because it destroys your self esteem otherwise and then you can focus on building resilience. Don’t let him feel like a victim, build him up as the type of person who saw something was wrong and took action. Use this as a means to teach your son to walk away from toxic people and toxic situation, there is a lot of this about in life.

I’m sorry this happened but it does, it is common and you have did a great proactive thing about it. Turn the narrative for you son to recognise that.

Birdwitted · 13/07/2022 07:50

Hi OP. Sorry this has happened to your son. My experience of sports clubs is that this is pretty common. Basically they are often pretty cliquey and one person who is not "in" with the rest will be blamed for mistakes even if it's not their fault at all. To be honest, if it was a well run team with a different coach they wouldn't do this in the first place as it would be noticed, and it would be unacceptable. I have coached a lot myself and I would always see this sort of thing and stamp on it straight away. You have to call it out - "why are you not passing to them, they are free, they were the best option, you need to improve your decision making". Rules like literally no comments on the pitch/court of a negative nature, just praise and helpful instructions.

The coach sounds clueless and the boys horrid - I hope your son hasn't had his love of the sport ruined and is able to find a nicer team in the future.

CassandrasCastle · 13/07/2022 07:18

Okdoke

TheSoundOfLunch · 13/07/2022 00:56

Aquilegia23 · 12/07/2022 19:20

He says (and I've seen and heard it) the boys give out to him all the time, if he makes a mistake they say under their breath FFS, or tell him he's standing in the wrong place, or shout at him

To be honest, I don't think this qualifies as bullying. Football is very competitive, and it's natural for team members to comment if they think a player is wrong. Saying 'ffs' isn't bullying.

I appreciate that you are disappointed that your son left the team, but that was his own choice. The coach didn't ask him to leave.

Yes it’s bullying. Behaviour intended to cause distress is exactly bullying.

Disappointing but unsurprising to see adults defending this appalling excuse for sportsmanship.

Bunty55 · 13/07/2022 00:42

My grandson plays for a team and we attend some of the matches. The coaches are parents and the referees are as well.
One team had this awful guy who shouted at the boys and marched about like a lunatic. When our team missed a goal or was fouled he shouted and cheered and clapped. At first we were all laughing at him but quickly realised he was deadly serious and disruptive. He was pulled for his behaviour by the coaches and some of the parents, and he argued and threatened people all in front of young boys who were disturbed and upset.
It got out of hand. The match stopped and he continued to argue with several of the coaches and the ref. One dad walked over to him and poured a bottle of water over his head, told him to calm down.
It worked, but the guy kicked off and made a complaint and now that dad is not allowed to attend the matches played against that particular team.
Point is - some people are just not qualified or capable of dealing with a situation like this, or with bullying that they know is going on, so they defend themselves by denying what they know is true and become aggressive as a defence mechanism
Allowing it to continue by doing nothing is unfair but most people do not want to get involved and even if they have seen your son being treated unfairly are unlikely to say anything which is awful.

I think you need to find another team and quickly before his confidence is destroyed. You also need to talk about what has happened and make it clear it is not his fault, and that the person who had the power to deal with it was unable to because he either chose to ignore or should not have been in charge of children

Coyoacan · 13/07/2022 00:22

Apart from the cruelty, the really stupid thing is that a team that works as a team will be much better than that lot.

My dd was in a tiny alternative school run by parents and was terribly bullied by the other children. When we complained we were told by the adults that they were trying to understand her but it was the bullies they should have look at. We took her out and she is thriving at her new school while I'm sure her bullies have found a new target.

loldawg · 12/07/2022 23:56

This isn’t going to be a popular opinion but In my experience a lot of bullied kids have, usually middle class. parents who are afraid to nut up and teach their kids that it’s ok to stand up for themselves. In the case of OP’s son this could have been nipped in the bud if he told the kids giving it big ‘uns to fuck off.

While the middle classes think it’s socially desirable to be a door mat their kids will get bullied.

Snowballtorch · 12/07/2022 23:24

Our son left his football team last year aged 13 due to exactly the experiences within his team. It is bullying, despite what some previous posters have said, and it shouldn't be justified. It is insidious though and very difficult to call out and deal with, so the coaches and other parents would rather ignore it and the more you raise it, the more you are labelled as the the problem.

I think the older the football teams get, the more competitive it becomes, as those who only play for fun tend to drop out along the way. The coaches are usually parent volunteers and rarely equipped to deal with such behaviour and it is often complicated by their own child's involvement. Our coach always said he would deal with it if he saw it, but he was always rather conveniently looking the other way.

We had to encourage our son to leave in the end. He didn't really want to stop playing, but it was a battle to get him to go each week and we could see it was really affecting his self confidence. He is much happier since he left and has since taken up other friendlier sports.

TheSoundOfLunch · 12/07/2022 23:10

Oh that is so sad you your son and for you. And the coach sound like an arsehole.

Yes there is a solution to bullying. Finland has virtually stamped it out. They run programmes from early primary and it has been so successful that they no longer run them in high school because there is no need.

I do think though that in places like England and America which are very focused on money being king and kicking people when they’re down, that positive change os a long way off.

I mean when you have daily newspapers making very vindictive and personal attacks, it doesn’t bode well for the nation as a whole.

Fuck the coach, fuck the nasty little boys, keep being you and keep encouraging your son.

It sure is a shame though. I mean only about one millionth of kids will go on to a career in elite sports so all this angst over performance is laughable. And research tells us that most kids don’t want it, they want to play.

MiniPiccolo · 12/07/2022 23:09

I'm so sorry for your son OP.

Can I ask though, you say he is down for banter etc though, is there a reason he didn't just respond with "shut up knobhead" or similar, "what's your problem?" or called the lads out every time they muttered or commented?

If he's not stood up for himself, it's just been left to fester and got worse by the sound of it.

It also sounds like he just wasn't the right fit for the team though, for whatever reason. It's a lads equivalent of a clique. Teenagers are brutal.

VincaBlue · 12/07/2022 23:05

It's good that one mum has contacted you. I suppose as you only told them today you might hear from more of them

VincaBlue · 12/07/2022 23:01

Any after school clubs?

RaisingAgent · 12/07/2022 23:01

I understand the feeling of disappointment for you personally too, as well as your concern for your son having been bullied. It sounds like as a single parent in a new town you felt you were connecting well with the other parents and had found a sense of belonging with this network. It must feel harsh to realise that the other parents' loyalty is with the group and maintaining the status quo. Hopefully as you move forwards you can find different connections with people who share more similar values to you.

VincaBlue · 12/07/2022 23:01

Are there any football summer camps or would it be the same bunch?

VincaBlue · 12/07/2022 22:59

PS. Glad your son is OK at school. Are there any other footie opportunities he could get involved in or is it just the one? It's a shame they weren't more welcoming to a newcomer

VincaBlue · 12/07/2022 22:57

Both really. Dd1 who was treated unkindly at primary is nearly 18 now. Her secondary school (a comp) is probably slightly rougher than her primary was, but I've been really impressed at the non bullying culture that's been encouraged at the school and others have said the same. Teachers didn't really consider it their problem when I was at school.

cofingalthetime · 12/07/2022 22:50

VincaBlue · 12/07/2022 22:41

I think a lot of schools are better at dealing with bullying than they used to be. Not all of them of course. We did have a teacher who was new to the profession who brushed it off like your coach. The experienced teachers have tended to be better at dealing with it at my children's schools. I suppose football coaches wouldn't have the same sort of training as experienced teachers. It sounds like your son gets on ok at school where they are more experienced at dealing with this sort of thing. At least it's given the coach, parents and kids food for thought even if they won't admit to it. The coach and parents will probably be more vigilant in future if the boys find a replacement scapegoat

I'm happy to hear that @VincaBlue are you talking about secondary or primary?

DS hasnt experienced any bullying in school thank god, but I notice they are ultra quick to respond if you do report anything - once a boy started picking on him, and kept tripping him up, and I emailed the form teacher as he hurt himself quite badly the last time. DS told me the boy was moved to a different class immediately. And ds had to give a "report" to a 'special teacher' who came round to his class and pulled him out for a few mins. And the teacher didnt try and argue with him, just wrote down exactly what ds said and didnt make any comment or judgement on the situation. Just said 'thank you for explaining what happened'. So yeah, maybe responding asap is part of the solution.

OP posts:
VincaBlue · 12/07/2022 22:41

I think a lot of schools are better at dealing with bullying than they used to be. Not all of them of course. We did have a teacher who was new to the profession who brushed it off like your coach. The experienced teachers have tended to be better at dealing with it at my children's schools. I suppose football coaches wouldn't have the same sort of training as experienced teachers. It sounds like your son gets on ok at school where they are more experienced at dealing with this sort of thing. At least it's given the coach, parents and kids food for thought even if they won't admit to it. The coach and parents will probably be more vigilant in future if the boys find a replacement scapegoat

cofingalthetime · 12/07/2022 22:34

Thereisnolight · 12/07/2022 22:20

Sorry to hear your updates.

The whole culture of the team sounds unpleasant. The funny thing is, I can see why some parents would not see the bullying - as it is more something that is ingrained in the culture itself rather than anything about your DS or a particularly unpleasant boy. They as a group probably genuinely would not understand that they are doing anything wrong. It’s just “ the way we do things here”. Toughen up or move on. And yes, they’ll scapegoat someone else when your DS leaves.

You’re right, this comes from the top down aka the coach in this case. And he probably attracts a particular type of parent/son to the team. Others, including you and your DS will move on. These sorts of coaches are a menace as they actively encourage this sort of culture - but many boys/men love it and don’t see anything wrong with it at all. It’s calling being a man, innit? (Or, like, being a man, yah?)

yeah this is the nub of it I think. Which is why I think ds instincts were right - no point in saying or doing anything.

I'm trying not to think about all the conversations that will be had - or whispered at the side of the pitch at the next match, about how DS just wasnt up to it, and "sure the boys are competitive" and "ah she was just being dramatic, we have a great team here, sure the boys love it don't they". Am wondering even now were they talking behind my back all along as some of them have been together since their kids were small, so obviously very strong bonds. You'd think with them all coming from stable happy families, they wouldnt mind welcoming a new kid, just emigrated from a different country, single parent (me). Though now that I think of it, a few weeks ago I got a puncture on the way up to the training. I texted the group and not one parent replied, or offered to come down and help me. They were all up at the club. I had to wait 2 hours for the AA to come and obviously ds missed training ( he was relieved now that I think about it!). But yeh, just another example of me not being in the "in-crowd". All the kids had 2 parents in a stable relationship except me. Couldnt help noticing that.

I do worry about the kind of sons we are raising.

OP posts:
Thereisnolight · 12/07/2022 22:20

Sorry to hear your updates.

The whole culture of the team sounds unpleasant. The funny thing is, I can see why some parents would not see the bullying - as it is more something that is ingrained in the culture itself rather than anything about your DS or a particularly unpleasant boy. They as a group probably genuinely would not understand that they are doing anything wrong. It’s just “ the way we do things here”. Toughen up or move on. And yes, they’ll scapegoat someone else when your DS leaves.

You’re right, this comes from the top down aka the coach in this case. And he probably attracts a particular type of parent/son to the team. Others, including you and your DS will move on. These sorts of coaches are a menace as they actively encourage this sort of culture - but many boys/men love it and don’t see anything wrong with it at all. It’s calling being a man, innit? (Or, like, being a man, yah?)

cofingalthetime · 12/07/2022 22:18

Clymene · 12/07/2022 21:21

Please, please escalate it. There will be another scapegoat now. A team with that dynamic need to find someone to play that role. Your son isn't there any longer so there's a vacancy.

I bet all the other kids who aren't the star players are shitting themselves. And so are their parents.

I can understand your reluctance to pursue it - it's not going to benefit your DS and why should you protect these other kids (who probably also joined in).

But unless parents raise the issue, no one is going to realise there's an issue.

I don't think I can put myself through any more. Plus the coach will come right back at me, they will cover their arses, and nothing will happen. I think change can only happen when the will is there and it just doesnt seem to be. I get your point though. Maybe if you all helped me draft something....?? I get too emotional and end up shooting myself in the foot. And losing the argument!!!!

OP posts:
whowhatwerewhy · 12/07/2022 22:01

Sorry your son felt he had to leave the team . If he wants to still be involved in football has he coincided becoming a referee? He would be part of the sport , become a good roll model for the players and help eliminate bullying on the pitch.

paisley256 · 12/07/2022 21:25

The parents won't message you as they'll be scared it will come back on them and their son will be dropped from matches.

My son played in 2 teams. The first one the coaches son was star player and full of himself. There were so many issues the parents were unhappy with and they'd all go on about how pissed off they were. I spoke up and not one of them had my back, not one. We left and moved on but that experience really opened my eyes.

I'm sorry your son had this experience and you too. It's awful to witness your child being ignored, bullied and blamed.

Clymene · 12/07/2022 21:21

Please, please escalate it. There will be another scapegoat now. A team with that dynamic need to find someone to play that role. Your son isn't there any longer so there's a vacancy.

I bet all the other kids who aren't the star players are shitting themselves. And so are their parents.

I can understand your reluctance to pursue it - it's not going to benefit your DS and why should you protect these other kids (who probably also joined in).

But unless parents raise the issue, no one is going to realise there's an issue.

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 12/07/2022 21:13

Ugh this made me feel really uncomfortable op, your poor son.
I always say to my dd you don't have to do the whole be kind thing - you don't have to be best friends with everyone and it is ok to not like everyone you meet but you must never be unkind. Obviously their sons have never been on the receiving end of this vile behaviour.
He will find his tribe either on or off the pitch xx