Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think there is no solution to bullying

113 replies

cofingalthetime · 12/07/2022 19:06

So my ds has been in a team for just over 2 years. He is not the best on the team, or the worst - if that matters. The coach is very competitive. DS has been miserable going to matches and training for about 6 months. He says (and I've seen and heard it) the boys give out to him all the time, if he makes a mistake they say under their breath FFS, or tell him he's standing in the wrong place, or shout at him. The coach's son was the worst culprit. So gradually DS attendance has fallen off. I offered to speak to the coach but DS said it wouldn't help, would probably make things worse - does speaking to the coach ever work?

Anyway last night was another training session, and ds didnt want to go, so I just said we should just tell them he is leaving - it was hard, cos he loves football, and I have made friends (as I thought) with some of the parents. Anyway, in the end, he made the decision to leave (with my help). So I texted the coach and said I would ring him tmw - it was getting late at this stage so I didn't want to disturb him by ringing.

Almost immediately he texts the group chat saying DS has decided to leave and best wishes to him. He also texts me that he had had a feeling for a while that DS was becoming disinterested.

I slept on it, but it really annoyed me, that yet again, this kind of thing was being swept under the carpet, and the coach was even going so far as to say ds wasnt committed enough - that was what he was hinting at.

So wrote a long text to the coach explaining how unhappy ds had been, that I had witnessed the behaviour of the boys, that I had suggested saying something to him, but ds said no way, that I felt it may not have made any difference in any case, as once it's the norm to pick on someone, it's very difficult to change that narrative. I mean 13 year old boys don't take much heed of what the adults say do they. I've seen it before - when a teacher has tried to 'help' and ended up making things worse.

Well, the coach is very angry - he wrote me a long email about how the club does not condone bullying and that he had seen or heard nothing, and that I was to describe specific incidents to him (which of course I can't, as it's that insidious, snide type of bullying that is very hard to pin down). In a word, he is clueless how to deal with it. He said that the boys were very competitive, as they should be, and challenged each other. I wanted to respond that ds is well able for banter, and is very competitive and is popular at school, with lots of friends. But I didn't. I also posted a similar message in the group chat. (I left the group then).

Only 1 mother has texted me to say how sorry she is - ironically her son is one who was nice to ds on a few occasions.

I'm just disappointed, not surprised, but I was bullied in school over 30 years ago, and honestly the attitudes and ways of dealing with it don't appear to have changed one bit. Don't we need to look at this from a different angle. THe coach was literally blaming ds for not coming forward He said "DS has never mentioned anything to me or the other coachers". Well OF COURSE he hasnt, are you an idiot.

Just wondered about others experiences - is there an answer to bullying, or are we destined to leave it up to the victim to leave, move on, heal themselves, always wondering if there is something "wrong" with them, that they got picked on.

I'm left with a nearly 14 year old who is very down on himself, thinks he is crap at football, and what team would even want him now. I'm so sad - he bloody loves football. Not fair.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hotmess19 · 15/07/2022 10:55

cofingalthetime · 13/07/2022 16:53

Really? I left the group as I didn't want any drama - and also before the coach removed me! I just wanted to tell them the real reason ds left. Not let the coach get away with smoothing it over as "cofinallthetime's ds has left as is not that into being on the team any more, or giving it the commitment it requires". I thought that was really unfair and basically a LIE.

So yeh, I told them all the real reason. I did NOT criticise the coach, just gave the facts, and said to them maybe to use it as an opportunity to talk to their boys.

And really? Is it that cumbersome to text someone from a group chat? I don't find it that difficult tbh, or time consuming.

If you didn’t want drama why do you want them to indulge you on the drama you just created?
I wouldn’t save your number on my phone, not because it’s cumbersome but because I wouldn’t want your number on my phone now that I wasn’t going to see you again.
what you did is the group chat version of a vague Facebook post like “at A&E” and when people ask what’s up you go “PM me hun”

RedHelenB · 13/07/2022 18:09

Aquilegia23 · 12/07/2022 19:20

He says (and I've seen and heard it) the boys give out to him all the time, if he makes a mistake they say under their breath FFS, or tell him he's standing in the wrong place, or shout at him

To be honest, I don't think this qualifies as bullying. Football is very competitive, and it's natural for team members to comment if they think a player is wrong. Saying 'ffs' isn't bullying.

I appreciate that you are disappointed that your son left the team, but that was his own choice. The coach didn't ask him to leave.

This. Happens in my son's team nut he's friends with them all.
I'd look for another club tbh, are his school friends in football teams?

Caiti19 · 13/07/2022 17:06

He's passionate about football, and will hopefully land on his feet and flourish with a team that doesn't take itself quite so seriously. Fingers crossed for you OP!

cofingalthetime · 13/07/2022 16:59

Greengagesnfennel · 13/07/2022 16:55

Maybe your son can find a better team. My son was rubbish at football and some of his team were really good. (Eg the coaches son). The coach always praised my son and the weaker ones when they did something good, or had had a (relatively) good game. Ds tended to win the 'most improved player prize' at end of season 🤣. It was a competitive league too. He got subbed more than some of the others but that was fair. Not all clubs are the same. If your ds enjoys football I think it's worth trying somewhere else.

Thanks yeah I'm looking around @Greengagesnfennel

Coming from a family of all girls, and all non-sporty, I think I was very naieve about football teams lol! And ds had a lovely team in the last place we lived in. Lol at 'most improved player'!!! DS is never going to be a professional football player, although he would love to be! but the likelihood is none of the other boys will be either. I guess the coach is living out his own dream of being a coach of a major team - bit sad really.

OP posts:
Greengagesnfennel · 13/07/2022 16:55

Maybe your son can find a better team. My son was rubbish at football and some of his team were really good. (Eg the coaches son). The coach always praised my son and the weaker ones when they did something good, or had had a (relatively) good game. Ds tended to win the 'most improved player prize' at end of season 🤣. It was a competitive league too. He got subbed more than some of the others but that was fair. Not all clubs are the same. If your ds enjoys football I think it's worth trying somewhere else.

cofingalthetime · 13/07/2022 16:53

hotmess19 · 13/07/2022 12:57

tbh I wouldn’t have replied to your text if you’d put it in a group chat and then left. It’s attention seeking and will always leave you hurt that people didn’t follow up with you, when following up means saving your number on my phone and then back on WhatsApp and all that.
And if we’d been friends up until then I’d be put off you’d done it like that.

Really? I left the group as I didn't want any drama - and also before the coach removed me! I just wanted to tell them the real reason ds left. Not let the coach get away with smoothing it over as "cofinallthetime's ds has left as is not that into being on the team any more, or giving it the commitment it requires". I thought that was really unfair and basically a LIE.

So yeh, I told them all the real reason. I did NOT criticise the coach, just gave the facts, and said to them maybe to use it as an opportunity to talk to their boys.

And really? Is it that cumbersome to text someone from a group chat? I don't find it that difficult tbh, or time consuming.

OP posts:
TheTerfTavern · 13/07/2022 16:53

Siameasy · 12/07/2022 20:30

Somehow, and I know it’s not easy, we have to teach our kids to point out shitty behaviour the first time it happens.
A kind of “what’s your problem”.
Even adults are pretty bad at this. Many of us never really learn how to do it, particularly women.
We have to let our kids be aggressive to bullies and not constantly expect them to turn the other cheek.
My DD told me a boy hit her, I said what are you waiting for go and hit him back so she did.

THIS

Unfortunately this is what I’ve had to teach my introverted gentle ( non sporty) sons - do it back harder now matter what it is.

A teacher complained to me once when he hit somebody back. Luckily it was in front of my son so I was able to express very clearly that I would never tell off my children for standing up for themselves even if it meant retaliating. Since then they have more confidence in playground issues - he was being bullied by a child in the year below so is very obvious target.

Anyway, OP, to be honest, it feels like you would have been better if you had spoken to the coach about it first. What can he do once you’ve left the club? You need to give people a chance to resolve issues and that’s why it’s not just children that need a zero tolerance policy. If I’d been there when the coach roared at him, I would absolutely have expressed my displeasure although I worked have been very calm about it.

o hope he find a nicer groups soon.

cofingalthetime · 13/07/2022 16:49

Inkyblue123 · 13/07/2022 13:43

you need to
move on and also be an example to your son. He needs to find a hobby that he enjoys. Sometimes things just don’t work out and you cannot influence anyone else’s behaviour, only your own. You sound more disappointed than he does, maybe you also need to find “ your tribe”. Let it go .

I AM letting it go lol!!! He has a hobby he loves - football? Why should he have to give it up and let the bullies continue to enjoy their football? @Inkyblue123

OP posts:
cofingalthetime · 13/07/2022 16:46

Caiti19 · 13/07/2022 16:41

"He did a trial for about 3 months before he was allowed onto the team - and the coach said he didn't know if would allow him on."

This team sounds really competitive - a 3 month trial? Have you scoured the area for a football team that is more for fun?

There are so many threads on Mumsnet about boys and harsh treatment on competitive teams. Our local team streams the kids from abut age 10/11 onto 3 different teams - they all train together and play games against other A/B/C teams from other areas (though they are never referred to as A/B/C) so that teams are fairly matched and every child gets to play games. This business of there being room for 14 kids and only the best are selected to be part of that 14 is really strange to me. If that were the case where I live, my son might not ever get a game. And football is his happy place - as is the case with so many boys!

Right - yeah DS was so excited though - it was really built up into this big achievement. He was so proud. But yeah it obviously backfired. I guess I'm naieve. Am looking for another team for him, and he is asking his friends at school too so fingers crossed :)

OP posts:
cofingalthetime · 13/07/2022 16:44

maskersanonymous · 13/07/2022 13:03

I don't understand why you didn't bring the bullying issue to the attention of the coach and work with them to tackle it while it was happening. If it had been brought to their attention and they failed to deal with it or dealt with it badly, then that was the time to leave and write the email.

Ok. Let's examine this.

Imagine for a moment a mother approaches you, with her son, or even the boy on his own (if you has the courage to "snitch" on the coach's own son).

She says her son is being picked on. She tries to give example but it's difficult to pin down as it is all 'low-level' stuff.

You say he is sworn at by other team members when he misses a shot - coach's response "well they are very competitive, its all part of the banter, your son is too sensitive"

You say he is always picked last and groaning sounds are made from the team he ends up with in training sessions - the coach says "well someone has to be the last to be picked, your son is too sensitive, he needs to toughen up"

And so on.

Given the response I've had from the coach, these are the kind of answers he would have given. Also, he would now have his back up, ESPECIALLY if I had dared say his son was the ringleader.

I think my ds was right - reporting it to the coach would have made it worse, and definitely not improved anything. Believe me.

OP posts:
Caiti19 · 13/07/2022 16:41

"He did a trial for about 3 months before he was allowed onto the team - and the coach said he didn't know if would allow him on."

This team sounds really competitive - a 3 month trial? Have you scoured the area for a football team that is more for fun?

There are so many threads on Mumsnet about boys and harsh treatment on competitive teams. Our local team streams the kids from abut age 10/11 onto 3 different teams - they all train together and play games against other A/B/C teams from other areas (though they are never referred to as A/B/C) so that teams are fairly matched and every child gets to play games. This business of there being room for 14 kids and only the best are selected to be part of that 14 is really strange to me. If that were the case where I live, my son might not ever get a game. And football is his happy place - as is the case with so many boys!

cofingalthetime · 13/07/2022 16:38

And I didn't imply any criticism of the coach in the group chat - on the contrary, I admitted / stated that ds did not WANT to report it, so yes the coach can legitimately say he did not know. He made assumptions - that ds was "disinterested in being part of the team". If he had even asked DS was he ok, he might have been enlightened as to what was going on.

I stand by my decision to tell the group. Why should it always be hushed up and not spoken about.

I would love to know if your kids have ever had to endure this kind of bullying.

OP posts:
loldawg · 13/07/2022 16:38

Thereisnolight · 13/07/2022 16:33

It’s not two kids though, it was all of them.

Most people are all mouth, usually if you clatter one the rest back down

cofingalthetime · 13/07/2022 16:35

fUNNYfACE36 · 13/07/2022 11:59

You are being very unfair to post about this publicly in group chat if you haven't previously raised it. If you don't feel you can raise it with the coach them the club will have acwelfare officer for this purpose.
The coach probably had no clue yhat your son had any problem.when you go you are focused on your boy. The coach has a lot more to think about!
I think it us appalling you publicly implied criticism on the coach who is good enough to give up his time to facilitate the boys having this opportunity , without having previously given any indication anything is wrong.what do you for for the club? Shame on you

Have one of your kids ever been bullied @fUNNYfACE36 ?

Have you ever reported bullying and seen the absolute shambles that can happen to make it even worse?

I was perfectly entitled to tell the group the real reason DS was leaving. After the coach put up something totally untrue, and smoothed everything out so everyone could say Byeee

And of course he knew - he was there and saw and heard what I saw. He either wilfully ignored it as "banter" and "competitive spirit" or he is deaf and blind.

Ah so I should be "grateful". And he's too busy as a coach? WTF. He's not the coach for manchester united lol. This is his job - to run a team, and I would think a major part is to ensure every boy is happy?

OP posts:
Thereisnolight · 13/07/2022 16:33

It’s not two kids though, it was all of them.

loldawg · 13/07/2022 16:32

Thereisnolight · 13/07/2022 16:30

Go for the biggest one and give them a bif, sometimes youngsters, especially boys, have to get a bit of civility with their fists

Arr, that do remind me it do of the time I threw our Billy into the pond because he was afeard of the water. He drowned but it was better than having a lily-livered lad about the farm.

And then there was the time one lad got a knife, then the other got a semiautomatic, then their mates got a hydrogen bomb, then everyone got long-range missiles…oh wait…

I think you’re overstating the impact of a straightener between two kids but go off

cofingalthetime · 13/07/2022 16:30

serenghetti2011 · 13/07/2022 11:17

I’ve commented on this on another post and the amount of people who say ‘it’s not bullying’ well I’m sorry if one child, or a group of kids pick on one child to make them feel bad, upset, singled out etc then that is bullying. Just because child a wouldn’t feel upset by it doesn’t mean it’s not bullying!! No one should be made to feel less than or anything else negative by someone else. It should be managed far better and it isn’t now nor was it when I was bullied as a kid till teens leaving school.

That’s why kids don’t speak up, because teachers say oh it’s nothing, or that wouldn’t upset me or you’re being too sensitive etc I heard it all! I got into trouble for retaliating - verbally but by then I was so worn down and fed up with it I didn’t care anymore. I’d then get bullied more it’s a vicious cycle. Your sons coach sounds like a tool op, he’s handled that so badly. If someone said that to me I would be sorting it out and so apologetic that they felt they couldn’t speak up to me. Maybe he’ll keep a closer eye on the team as they’ll find someone else to pick on now your son isn’t there which is sad. I just hate bullying, it made my life an absolute misery at school and my confidence and self esteem were non existent by the time I left. I hate to think of kids going through that now, and that schools, clubs still don’t deal with it properly or see it! It was quite obvious what was happening to me, the teachers all knew my mum was on to the school regularly nothing was done!.

@serenghetti2011 I could have written this post. It really is so infuriating and sad that things have not moved on. There is a mountain of research on it, and still it's usually minimised, dismissed, and nothing done.

It's really triggering for me. I remember the sense of utter powerlessness.

OP posts:
Thereisnolight · 13/07/2022 16:30

Go for the biggest one and give them a bif, sometimes youngsters, especially boys, have to get a bit of civility with their fists

Arr, that do remind me it do of the time I threw our Billy into the pond because he was afeard of the water. He drowned but it was better than having a lily-livered lad about the farm.

And then there was the time one lad got a knife, then the other got a semiautomatic, then their mates got a hydrogen bomb, then everyone got long-range missiles…oh wait…

MarshaBradyo · 13/07/2022 16:23

BookShop · 13/07/2022 10:12

I am sick of hearing the excuse that this low level insidious stuff isn't bullying. A girl at my DDs school took her life. The school know it is a problem. They have recently had their Ofsted downgraded from Outstanding to Requires Improvement. The response from the Headteacher was appalling to say the least. Lots of slippery shoulder activity and blaming everyone else rather than accept it and put in place a plan to rectify.

My DD frequently hears her name being spoken and whispered about and when she looks over the bullies say 'We love you Bookshop's DD'. When mentioned to the teacher all we get back is 'I only heard them say we love you'. Absolutely fuming that this crap isn't stamped out more assertively.

I would definitely take this further.

That’s so difficult for your dd

Is there a way to address it?

Feels really hard to fix

loldawg · 13/07/2022 16:19

Anonymouseposter · 13/07/2022 16:15

Ioldawg I'm not sure exactly what you're expecting kids to do.
If the group were against him I doubt that telling them to fuck off in the first place would have improved the situation. Aren't they just likely to have laughed at him.
If a child is singled out at school how can they stand up to a group?
I do agree that building self confidence and helping them to see the people picking on them as being wrong rather than internalising the bullying helps but there are circumstances where getting into confrontation doesn't help at all.
What would you suggest a kid does if a large number of the peer group are picking on them?

Go for the biggest one and give them a bif, sometimes youngsters, especially boys, have to get a bit of civility with their fists.

Anonymouseposter · 13/07/2022 16:15

Ioldawg I'm not sure exactly what you're expecting kids to do.
If the group were against him I doubt that telling them to fuck off in the first place would have improved the situation. Aren't they just likely to have laughed at him.
If a child is singled out at school how can they stand up to a group?
I do agree that building self confidence and helping them to see the people picking on them as being wrong rather than internalising the bullying helps but there are circumstances where getting into confrontation doesn't help at all.
What would you suggest a kid does if a large number of the peer group are picking on them?

loldawg · 13/07/2022 14:56

I’m not the problem here. You teaching them to back down from confrontation Is.

wingardium8 · 13/07/2022 14:42

You’re well out of it with this team. Walk away and find another team for DS with the right ethos for him.

im involved a bit in junior football and that sort of behaviour would be noticed and not tolerated in my club. All run by parent volunteers so I don’t know if there are policies or safeguarding leads as such, but it’s known for being friendly and inclusive.

The ‘competitive’ clubs, where the kids are having a go at the opposition, their own players, the referee, are also well known. Without exception, they have argumentative coaches who are never happy with the decisions and give their players a really hard time.

Plenty of the nice clubs around. You won’t change this one so cut your losses and give them no head space.

Really sorry your DS had to go through that though. Soul destroying x

Inkyblue123 · 13/07/2022 13:43

you need to
move on and also be an example to your son. He needs to find a hobby that he enjoys. Sometimes things just don’t work out and you cannot influence anyone else’s behaviour, only your own. You sound more disappointed than he does, maybe you also need to find “ your tribe”. Let it go .

maskersanonymous · 13/07/2022 13:03

I don't understand why you didn't bring the bullying issue to the attention of the coach and work with them to tackle it while it was happening. If it had been brought to their attention and they failed to deal with it or dealt with it badly, then that was the time to leave and write the email.