Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ehcp review tips!

32 replies

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 13:14

I am attending a review meeting for my child's formal ehcp review this week..

I'm still new to all of this, and this is the first review since it was first issued a year ago.

Any tips on things to look out for? Things to request? What is really important to have in there?

My child is 5, and an Ed psych will be present with the school Senco.

Thanks in advance!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
oddoneoutalways · 13/07/2022 11:07

I know it was yesterday but my tips for anyone reading (I've done several annual reviews now for my child, and work in the field separately):

Make sure you have any reports etc beforehand as required and through the EHCP with a fine toothed comb. Every outcome, section I and F. Is each point and provision relevant, needed and currently being met? Does it need to go further? Have the needs changed, if so how will they be met in future?. Have the outcomes been achieved, do they need updating or changing? Do you need a personal budget or direct payment provision (if so the provision must be detailed in section F)? Is the funding adequate? Make notes. Ask school to clarify in writing prior to the meeting any queries you have about if things that should be happening, are. If they're not, why not and how will they be going forwards?

NO WOOLLY WORDING. No 'may benefit from' etc. They're useless and unenforceable. You need 'must have', 'at all times' it needs to be specific, quantifiable and with no room for interpretation. If your child needs a full time 1:1 at all times, it must say exactly that.

At the meeting, if you can, take someone along to take notes for you and request minutes afterwards. Make sure you see a draft of the changes before it goes to the LA and check that you're happy with it and what was agreed is done. If not, go back and challenge.

LargeLegoHaul · 13/07/2022 10:30

elliejjtiny · 13/07/2022 10:09

I was planning on naming the mainstream catchment secondary school where his 2 older brothers currently attend, The LA won't try and name somewhere else will they?

Having said that, we live in a slightly weird area where our catchment primary school isn't our nearest school. We managed to get DS1 into the nearest school in 2010 the last year it was undersubscribed, just before a new build estate popped up between us and the school. Then the younger ones all got in on the sibling rule. Last year the LA tried to name the catchment school on DC4's EHCP despite him having been settled and happy there for 4 years and with 2 of his brothers there too Confused. We managed to persuade them not to but they still insisted on asking the catchment school if they could meet DC4's needs. Who then phoned the head of the current school and told him DC4 would be leaving. The poor headteacher thought he'd done something wrong. It was all sorted out in the end and I told the senco that if we were considering moving any of the dc it would be to a specialist school and if she heard anything about the dc moving to a different mainstream school she should ignore it.

The LA may try to name the nearest suitable secondary, so if the catchment secondary isn’t the nearest the LA may try to name another MS if it’s closer and they think it can meet needs. However, you can challenge this, although they may force you to appeal. If the LA agree to name a school that isn’t the nearest they may try to name it as parental preference and refuse transport, but again you can challenge this and SENTAS can help with a transport appeal.

partygate · 13/07/2022 10:21

Agree with the above - it must be written in concrete language, ie will receive etc. They try to write in woolly language as it is not enforceable (as in you cannot sue them for breach of the EHCP plan).

Be careful as well about any suggestion the school does all the work, ie will train teachers in speech and language therapy or physio and that will be provided once a week etc. No teacher in a mainstream school has time to provide that 1:1 level of care. If the child needs it, it must be outsourced (ie by a special 1:1 or someone coming to school to provide physio etc)

The plan will have the most minimal support possible so I’m afraid most plans will need to be challenged.

elliejjtiny · 13/07/2022 10:09

LargeLegoHaul · 12/07/2022 14:56

A vague and woolly EHCP isn’t worth the paper it is written on. DC may not get the support and you can’t enforce it. The wording needs challenging, although it may take an appeal. What are the reports like? Provision in EHCPs is taken from the reports, so if the reports are vague and woolly the EHCP will be too.

@elliejjtiny IPSEA have a model letter that can be used to complain when the AR isn’t held on time. You can also threaten Judicial Review too. It will help secondary transition if the EHCP is up to date beforehand. Otherwise you get problems like @BiscoffSundae’s, where because provision isn’t specified and quantified in F an inappropriate school is named and DC won’t get the provision needed.

I was planning on naming the mainstream catchment secondary school where his 2 older brothers currently attend, The LA won't try and name somewhere else will they?

Having said that, we live in a slightly weird area where our catchment primary school isn't our nearest school. We managed to get DS1 into the nearest school in 2010 the last year it was undersubscribed, just before a new build estate popped up between us and the school. Then the younger ones all got in on the sibling rule. Last year the LA tried to name the catchment school on DC4's EHCP despite him having been settled and happy there for 4 years and with 2 of his brothers there too Confused. We managed to persuade them not to but they still insisted on asking the catchment school if they could meet DC4's needs. Who then phoned the head of the current school and told him DC4 would be leaving. The poor headteacher thought he'd done something wrong. It was all sorted out in the end and I told the senco that if we were considering moving any of the dc it would be to a specialist school and if she heard anything about the dc moving to a different mainstream school she should ignore it.

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 18:35

SunshineLollipopsRainbow · 12/07/2022 18:21

I've recently attended a first year EHCP review for a child in my class.
We found that the initial ehcp (which he came to me with) was very vague with a lot of inaccuracies and discrepancies but the first year review was a great opportunity to really make it specific and personalised to the needs of the child which is what I did (class teacher) alongside our SENCO and parents.
Hope that helps

That's reassuring to know.

It always feels like a bit of a battle to get what these children need.

All they need is to make the playing field level with their peers, but it seems like they're always someone trying to block support or take it away, usually because of money.

I just want a positive meeting where my child's needs are put first!

OP posts:
SunshineLollipopsRainbow · 12/07/2022 18:21

I've recently attended a first year EHCP review for a child in my class.
We found that the initial ehcp (which he came to me with) was very vague with a lot of inaccuracies and discrepancies but the first year review was a great opportunity to really make it specific and personalised to the needs of the child which is what I did (class teacher) alongside our SENCO and parents.
Hope that helps

LargeLegoHaul · 12/07/2022 17:11

Unfortunately, if the reports are vague and woolly section F will be too. You need new reports. You could either ask the LA to reassess or following the AR appeal and seek independent reports. If any of the reports are recent you could ask the LA to go back to the report writers to make them detailed, specific and quantified, but that won’t work if the reports are all from the EHCNA.

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 16:20

@LargeLegoHaul

A vague and woolly EHCP isn’t worth the paper it is written on. DC may not get the support and you can’t enforce it. The wording needs challenging, although it may take an appeal. What are the reports like? Provision in EHCPs is taken from the reports, so if the reports are vague and woolly the EHCP will be too.


The reports are quite similar.

I think in eyfs it was fine because of the environment they are in and they tend to get a high level of support anyway, but I think it needs to be much more specific for ks1.

OP posts:
LargeLegoHaul · 12/07/2022 14:58

@elliejjtiny the other thing to consider if the EHCP needs amending prior to considering secondary transition is how long appeals are taking. To give you an idea, appeals lodged now are looking at Jan/Feb hearing dates.

LargeLegoHaul · 12/07/2022 14:56

A vague and woolly EHCP isn’t worth the paper it is written on. DC may not get the support and you can’t enforce it. The wording needs challenging, although it may take an appeal. What are the reports like? Provision in EHCPs is taken from the reports, so if the reports are vague and woolly the EHCP will be too.

@elliejjtiny IPSEA have a model letter that can be used to complain when the AR isn’t held on time. You can also threaten Judicial Review too. It will help secondary transition if the EHCP is up to date beforehand. Otherwise you get problems like @BiscoffSundae’s, where because provision isn’t specified and quantified in F an inappropriate school is named and DC won’t get the provision needed.

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 14:47

@elliejjtiny

Oh bless you.

I'm sure it will be fine, unless there's anything you think needs adding/changing ready for the new school year it will be fine to hang on until after summer.

OP posts:
elliejjtiny · 12/07/2022 14:44

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 13:47

I think as long as the plan is working for them and it has all the action and provision they need, a delayed review won't do any harm.

If the plan is outdated and not providing what they need anymore, then I would be pushing for the review asap.

Thankyou. It's fine at the moment but it will need changing when he moves to secondary school (currently year 4). Deputy SENCO has resigned and won't be replaced until September so the senco is now doing all the special needs work, safeguarding and being deputy head. I don't want to add to her stress by making a fuss if it won't make much difference to DS, even if it's a legal requirement. Mind you, a short spell free of paperwork in prison for not getting DS's ehcp done in time might be a welcome release for her Grin. Sometimes when DS won't sleep again, prison sounds like an attractive alternative Wink.

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 14:41

Thank you

I believe they will mostly need 1:1 support for talking them through certain lesson in simpler terms and then working through any activities/worksheets with them.

I know they won't be able to sit and take in a lesson then do subsequent activities alone.
They will just sit there.
Their learning and cognitive abilities are progressing, but slowly.
They can write and recognise their name, count to 20 and understand one more/less, basic addition and subtraction, and read some basic words using phonics sounds. They can recall a story and tell what happened. But it's all very simple early years level. For year one there's obviously a big gap between what's expected and where they are at.

They also need a high level of support with toileting (still using nappies, although not incontinent they rely on nappies due to asd/sensory related difficulties).

School has assured me mainstream is appropriate and they can meet need, and I do believe they are in the best place, it's just really getting it down on paper so it's clear to everyone involved.

Some stories on here and elsewhere online has made me realise how important a clear ehcp is.

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 12/07/2022 14:28

Think about all the help your child needs and what a 1 to 1 woukd be used for, do they need to be with them all day (including breaks) or are there times and lessons when they can manage? What actual help will the 1 to 1 be needed for and why? Progress reports from the last year, Ed psych report, other expert reports and your own observations from home will help you here. Does theb1 to 1 need to have specific skills (eg sign language, expertise in speech and language therapy)

Don't be afraid to challenge them. If they say no to something then ask them how they have reached that conclusion and what evidence they have.

Make copious notes - or take someone with you who can. You may not get answers while you are there - it will depend on who attends. So things may have to go to the LA for decisions.

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 13:56

@starfishmummy

You need to challenge these woolly phrases like "will benefit from".


How likely am I to get this changed to be more specific? Is there a certain criteria a child needs to meet to get this kind of support?

OP posts:
jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 13:55

OneInEight · 12/07/2022 13:51

Go prepared. What works. What doesn't. What would you like amended if anything.

Having said this unless it was a transition point we found the LEA were most reluctant to change anything.

Also we found that although the professionals and LA were invited to the review they often did not turn up. So if you want them there you might have to do some chasing up yourself. Otherwise ends up being a chat between you and school (can be beneficial but does not always mean any changes recommended will be taken up the LEA)

Because it's a move from early years to ks1 I'm hoping for some significant changes to reflect the different learning environment etc.

OP posts:
jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 13:54

@starfishmummy thank you i will have a look

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 12/07/2022 13:51

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 13:36

One thing that worries me is how vague the wording is currently.

"Opportunities for..."

"Would benefit from..."

When referring to 1:1 and group work.

I know they will not be able to access the curriculum without a high level of 1:1 and small group support in class.

The main thing I want from this meeting is reassurance that 1:1 and small group interventions will be regular and adequate. Especially for English/maths/phonics.

You need to challenge these woolly phrases like "will benefit from".

They need to state that shebhas a 1 to 1 for x hours a day and what they will actually do. And what they expect the outcomes to be.

If you do Facebook, theres a private group called SEND and EHCP Advice and Support that may be useful.

OneInEight · 12/07/2022 13:51

Go prepared. What works. What doesn't. What would you like amended if anything.

Having said this unless it was a transition point we found the LEA were most reluctant to change anything.

Also we found that although the professionals and LA were invited to the review they often did not turn up. So if you want them there you might have to do some chasing up yourself. Otherwise ends up being a chat between you and school (can be beneficial but does not always mean any changes recommended will be taken up the LEA)

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 13:47

elliejjtiny · 12/07/2022 13:45

Following. DS's first review is now 2 months overdue. I've chased it up twice but I'm wondering if it actually makes a difference to him whether the review is done on time or not.

I think as long as the plan is working for them and it has all the action and provision they need, a delayed review won't do any harm.

If the plan is outdated and not providing what they need anymore, then I would be pushing for the review asap.

OP posts:
elliejjtiny · 12/07/2022 13:45

Following. DS's first review is now 2 months overdue. I've chased it up twice but I'm wondering if it actually makes a difference to him whether the review is done on time or not.

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 13:36

One thing that worries me is how vague the wording is currently.

"Opportunities for..."

"Would benefit from..."

When referring to 1:1 and group work.

I know they will not be able to access the curriculum without a high level of 1:1 and small group support in class.

The main thing I want from this meeting is reassurance that 1:1 and small group interventions will be regular and adequate. Especially for English/maths/phonics.

OP posts:
BiscoffSundae · 12/07/2022 13:32

jimminycrickett · 12/07/2022 13:25

My daughter has a 30 hour 1:1 but because it’s not written in her ehcp they want to remove it in September despite the fact she still needs it,
today it took half an hour and 3 members of staff to get her into school how can they say it’s not needed; basically If it’s not in the ehcp they don’t need to do it


@BiscoffSundae why on Earth do they want to remove it?!

Because she is going to secondary school in September they have put her in a mainstream despite me applying for sen schools and the mainstream have said they can’t meet her needs but the LA can override this and still name them which they have despite the fact she has a 1:1 all day at school in year 6 which her senco told me is uncommon and she’s one of their most complex children

wonderstuff · 12/07/2022 13:29

you should get paperwork ahead of the meeting. They should review targets, note progress against them and set new ones for the next year. Part of that process should be reviewing support in place and whether it should be changed going forward.
You’ve done the difficult bit in getting the EHCP, reviews should be positive and focused on best support for the child. Great that her EP will be there, in my school we’d also try to have teacher and/or TA who works with the child day to day.

Jagley · 12/07/2022 13:27

It's always nerve wracking. I would say go through paperwork in the run up, highlight things YOU want changed/don't agree with, speak to school about what they're asking for. In the meeting don't be afraid to speak up or challenge what the ed psych/senco etc.... are saying, you know your child. Take notes in the meeting of what is being changed etc... and then use this to check those changes have been made when the paperwork comes back. Don't be afraid to ring the LA/your caseworker about it all. Good luck!