Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inlaws think my 3yr old has ASD

134 replies

TheGreatBobinsky · 12/07/2022 09:08

My inlaws keep insisting I get my DD(3) assessed for autism. They will not drop the subject despite me stating my many reasons against it. AIBU to be angry they won't leave it now.

My reasons are:

  1. She's only just turned 3 years old. Even if she was showing traits, she wouldn't be assessed this young anyway.
  2. She has met almost all of her milestones* and even surpassed many of them - her speech is brilliant, she's mostly potty trained, she knows her numbers up to 10, she has a fantastic imagination and role plays constantly, she can take turns and share, she is showing interest in playing with her peers, she has the emotional intelligence expected of a year old.
  3. She hasn't got any of the traits listed on the diagnostic criteria.
  4. Even if she did have traits, it's really unfair for them to keep saying it in front of her, especially when they are phrasing it as if there's something wrong with her which is insulting to people who are autistic.

The reasons they have given me for thinking this are:

  1. She doesn't like certain members of the family. She refuses to talk much to these people.
  2. She is very shy - she was only 6m old when lockdowns began, she's getting alot better with socialising but I don't think its surprising that she is shy.
  3. She has a limited diet - she is extremely fussy and this is a concern but this alone doesn't scream ASD to me.
  4. She's obsessed with her hands. She's not!
  5. She can't jump with two feet off the ground. *this is the one milestone she hasn't reached.
  6. She has accidents around one member of the family - who apparently tells her off if she has an accident 🙄

None of my health visitors, GPs, nursery staff (although they've only seen her at show around admittedly) or my own family - including two teachers (one of whom works in a SEN setting) think she shows any traits. I've tried being polite and shutting down this conversation but that's clearly not working.

The way things are said are implying that their is something wrong with her that needs to be fixed - she doesn't need fixing and even if she did have ASD she still wouldn't need fixing! What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
Justkidding55 · 12/07/2022 12:04

I’d tell them that if agree to be tested for anxiety, munschuesens by-proxy, and OCD then you will take her to get assessed for autism..

seriously though this must be so frustrating. Even if she got a diagnosis there wouldn’t necessarily be any need or value in it at this stage anyway. What does your partner think about it?

toooldtocarewhoknows · 12/07/2022 11:49

UnbeatenMum · 12/07/2022 09:23

I have an 11yo with autism. She met all her milestones, was way ahead with speech and there weren't a huge number of signs at 3 (restricted diet, didn't like loud noises, would make eye contact then look away instantly, hand flapping when excited). No behavioural issues or difficulties at school until age 9-10, which is when we started pursuing a diagnosis. It sounds like there are some similarities to your daughter but we didn't really think autism until it seemed life she was having difficulties rather than just being a bit quirky IYSWIM. In your situation I would probably do the same and just wait and see how school goes and how her social skills develop etc. In laws should respect this even if they do turn out to be right.

I have a young adult daughter and completely agree with this. It often doesn't start becoming an issue until later on.

If it is, it is. Best just to read up about female presentation of autism and be aware. Nothing more.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 12/07/2022 11:25

why are your inlaws so knowledgeable? <<or think they are>>
they should learn some tact by the sound of things op

  • let them know you will ask nursery

FictionalCharacter · 12/07/2022 11:24

MatildaTheCat · 12/07/2022 09:13

I’d stop being polite for a start.

‘Thanks, we’ve heard you and considered what you are saying. Right now everyone is really happy with her development so let’s drop the subject?’

Exactly this. The most important thing is that as you say She hasn't got any of the traits listed on the diagnostic criteria. And the GP and HV aren’t seeing any signs.

Sounds like they’ve become obsessed with this. It’s their way of rationalising why she doesn’t like some members of the family - they’ve decided it’s her not them!

PinguIglu · 12/07/2022 11:24

The person she has accidents around should be kept well away from your DD. She is scared of them.

Cyclebabble · 12/07/2022 11:20

Generally speaking you as the mother are best placed to know your child. I had plenty of "advice" from the in-laws and suggestions that my son was uncoordinated and a slow learner. he has now just qualified as a Doctor.

Sometimes DGPs can get frustrated when a child is shy, does not see a lot of them and therefore (understandably) is not wholly comfortable in their presence. In my case, rather than seeing this as an issue they could address (by spending more time with DGCs, there was clearly a problem with the child!

I would just (politely) rebuff. Annoying though I agree.

BorsetshireBanality · 12/07/2022 11:19

Maybe your child is a good judge of character at a young age, and that’s why she avoids talking to a particular person (is it the same person who makes a big deal about accidents?)

Keep to the back of your mind a possible ASD issue but above all enjoy being with your daughter and helping with her development.

I hate the kind of people who pick up on a perceived issue but hound you about getting diagnosis, treatment and made a huge deal about it, using it as a stick to beat you with. They should stop with mentioning it in front her and criticising “accidents”.

For what it’s worth, my cousin’s son was diagnosed as autistic at 4 (non verbal and pointing to things). His parents tried not to make it an “issue”, while getting him appropriate help. He’s happy and doing as well as he can and everyone is happy for him!

FloorWipes · 12/07/2022 11:17

ASD seems to get misdiagnosed as BPD and anxiety a lot in women. Maybe you have ASD and therefore your DDs traits seem typical to you because of that.

BogRollBOGOF · 12/07/2022 11:16

It's when there's a whole cluster of traits and they persist long beyond developmental trends and when you think back, there always has been traits that you'd get any success out of professionals in investigating/ diagnosing. In a child that young they'd been looking at persistant development delays before paying attention.

Whether she is or isn't, you're happy and the professionals are happy too so it's rude for the ILs to keep going on about it and at this stage you'd be unlikely to get far out of a referral anyway.

It's my NT child that loathes loud noise such as hand driers and the electric shower noise. My sensory, autistic child cares more about pitch than volume (I've had an earful about the windows being open and the incessant bird song this morning...)

greenbirdsong · 12/07/2022 11:04

CuppaTeaAndSammich · 12/07/2022 10:23

Everyone is just so quick to diagnose a child with a disorder these days without acknowledging that every child is different in their own way.... irritating

This ^

greenbirdsong · 12/07/2022 11:00

TheGreatBobinsky · 12/07/2022 09:38

If she does start to show signs of struggling as she gets older then I will absolutely look into an assessment but currently she just seems like any other just turned 3 year old. Although the PP who mentioned loud noises may have a point, she really hates hand dryers and fans and won't be in the room with them, but my nieces were the same at a similar age and grew out of it so again all I could do is wait and see.

I don't see anything here for concern. And I have an autistic nephew so have some experience with asd children.

At 3 my son also hated hand dryers. He would go nuts and screamed and cried. 6 months later and he thinks they're funny. He grew out of it.

Some kids are fussy with food, some are shy. Doesn't mean they have asd.

If you have no concerns and neither do any HV's, nursery etc then just ignore your inlaws.

Honestly I don't see anything there to be concerned about.

orbitalcrisis · 12/07/2022 11:00

@Aquilegia23

As an adult with ASD i can tell you that diagnosis benefits everyone, not having that understanding about yourself or from those around you can have devastating consequences to your mental well-being and gives you added protections by law. I do not know a single person that regrets getting one. But as know several who wish they had been diagnosed as children but weren't as their parents didn't want to 'label' them.

And although I don't think you meant to, your post actually advocates for nobody to get an autism diagnosis. There is no 'severity' of autism that can be medicated for, it's not an illness.

MercurialMonday · 12/07/2022 10:57

I see nothing that suggests the OP won't be keeping a close eye on her DD going forward and re-assessing the situation all the time.

She just needs the grandparents to stop brining it up all the time .

OP just have to tell them to stop and try and stop all the comparisons - though that can be hard as my IL also compared our older two - and made no allowance that middle child was two years younger than eldest - that's partly as second child is grandson and they weren't as keen - we've stepped in every times and sometime been very blunt. At least the kids are aware this is a GP issue and nothing to do with them.

butterflydress · 12/07/2022 10:51

Aquilegia23 · 12/07/2022 10:18

I have a grandson who hated loud noises when he was young. We think he is autistic but he doesn't have a diagnosis. He would be just the same happy, intelligent boy with or without one. I don't see the point in diagnosing unless there are severe needs that medication would reduce.

Whether your in-laws are right or not, it's none of their business. I would tell them you might look into it when your daughter is older, and then change the subject.

I wish you were my mother in law! My son was the same with loud noises but ex mother in law was like OP's and kept banging on about trying to get a diagnosis.. I said the same that he'll be the same amazing child with or without one and he doesn't need any medication!

MrsLargeEmbodied · 12/07/2022 10:51

nursery staff should know more about autism now than they did even 5 years ago

MrsLargeEmbodied · 12/07/2022 10:50

profesionals know more and more about autism now and i am pretty sure it is common to have a genetic component of parents with BPD,/anxiety or at least i am sure it is relevant.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 12/07/2022 10:50

Staryflight445 · 12/07/2022 10:28

Does she go to nursery op? she should definitely go for her 15 hours if not.
Staff would pick up on anything really quickly.

If that were always true DS would have been assessed years ago rather than just being referred recently at 9 and now we have a 26mth wait.

MaChienEstUnDick · 12/07/2022 10:49

Girls do mask and they do it from an incredibly early age. There are a couple of things in there that would suggest to me that you keep a watchful eye on her - but honest to god, doesn't every involved and loving parent keep a watchful eye on their kid's development!

In my area you wouldn't get an assessment. I think the pp suggestion of giving it a term then checking in with nursery is excellent because they will see such a wide range of DCs.

As for your in-laws... I think your attitude to autism is perfect. It isn't something to be fixed. I don't think they share that attitude though which means that they're really not being kind to their grandchild. Time to get the mummy tiger out and just shut that shit down ' We have heard your concerns, and don't want to discuss it further.' Every time. Until 'we have repeatedly told you we don't want to discuss this further, if you persist on bringing this up when we see you we are going to severely limit our time with you.'

You cannot let your DC spend time with people who think she is broken and needs fixing - and I speak as the parent of a DC with autism who struggles terribly in life.

TheGreatBobinsky · 12/07/2022 10:47

toomuchlaundry · 12/07/2022 10:39

Is there anyone else in the family who is autistic? Are there other grandchildren they are comparing her to?

You can tell them you have noted their concerns, but if they continue to go on (especially in her presence) I would be limiting contact (especially with the person who doesn’t treat her kindly when she has an accident)

I have BPD, chronic depression and anxiety so that presents with a lot of the same traits as autism, but I've never been assessed for that and when I asked my GP was told that it's likely just the BPD.

There are other grandchildren, including my elder DD that they are comparing her too but I just think my 3 year old has a quiter personality than her sister and cousins.

OP posts:
PinguIglu · 12/07/2022 10:47

And re: limited diet, try not to worry about that. One of my DC (who isn’t autistic) barely ate anything as a toddler. We saw a paediatrician once who told me that his son only ate sausages for years and not to pay any attention to it 😁

Another DC still has a very limited beige diet (as I did as a child). She is definitely not autistic and has no SEN. It’s just how she is.

I give her multivitamins, offer a range of food and nice fruit and let her get on with it. If she chooses to eat weetabix while we eat dinner, no big deal. I experienced enough cajoling/forcing as a child to know it makes no difference ( apart from adding on stress and guilt). In my late teens my preferences changed and I eat everything now. It’s no big deal.

As it happens, my autistic child doesn’t have issues around food - she eats most things!

user850301848172 · 12/07/2022 10:41

@TheGreatBobinsky

I think with the group of behaviours you've listed there I would be keeping a very close eye, asking nursery to observe and contacting the health visitor.

Individually the behaviours are ok but when you group them together like your list, you have more than a few traits of autism.

My dd is the same age and does everything your dd does (and a few more) and is being assessed for autism. My daughter can blend in because she copies other children. She's also creative but when I was watching her creativeness, it was repetitive and most of it was something she had seen on tv or heard us or her older sibling say to her so limited creativity.

Your in laws won't be saying this just to annoy you. Early intervention is the best thing for kids.

My son was much older when he was diagnosed and I wished someone, anyone would have listened to my concerns instead of him struggling through nursery and school before he was finally diagnosed and given the correct support.

PinguIglu · 12/07/2022 10:41

I am autistic and have an autistic child. That list does not raise concerns about a 3 year old.

They sound like a nightmare and definitely not good people for your DD to be around, or for you. Can you stop or limit contact with these people?

ComDummings · 12/07/2022 10:41

Your in-laws are pricks. Don’t be polite. “It’s none of your business fuck off.” Many children have some traits that could be seen as being part of ASD but a) it’s a spectrum so it varies and b) NT toddlers can grow out of these behaviours.

toomuchlaundry · 12/07/2022 10:39

Is there anyone else in the family who is autistic? Are there other grandchildren they are comparing her to?

You can tell them you have noted their concerns, but if they continue to go on (especially in her presence) I would be limiting contact (especially with the person who doesn’t treat her kindly when she has an accident)

MrsLargeEmbodied · 12/07/2022 10:38

just keep an open mind and ask the nursery their opinion once she has been there for a term.