Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inlaws think my 3yr old has ASD

134 replies

TheGreatBobinsky · 12/07/2022 09:08

My inlaws keep insisting I get my DD(3) assessed for autism. They will not drop the subject despite me stating my many reasons against it. AIBU to be angry they won't leave it now.

My reasons are:

  1. She's only just turned 3 years old. Even if she was showing traits, she wouldn't be assessed this young anyway.
  2. She has met almost all of her milestones* and even surpassed many of them - her speech is brilliant, she's mostly potty trained, she knows her numbers up to 10, she has a fantastic imagination and role plays constantly, she can take turns and share, she is showing interest in playing with her peers, she has the emotional intelligence expected of a year old.
  3. She hasn't got any of the traits listed on the diagnostic criteria.
  4. Even if she did have traits, it's really unfair for them to keep saying it in front of her, especially when they are phrasing it as if there's something wrong with her which is insulting to people who are autistic.

The reasons they have given me for thinking this are:

  1. She doesn't like certain members of the family. She refuses to talk much to these people.
  2. She is very shy - she was only 6m old when lockdowns began, she's getting alot better with socialising but I don't think its surprising that she is shy.
  3. She has a limited diet - she is extremely fussy and this is a concern but this alone doesn't scream ASD to me.
  4. She's obsessed with her hands. She's not!
  5. She can't jump with two feet off the ground. *this is the one milestone she hasn't reached.
  6. She has accidents around one member of the family - who apparently tells her off if she has an accident 🙄

None of my health visitors, GPs, nursery staff (although they've only seen her at show around admittedly) or my own family - including two teachers (one of whom works in a SEN setting) think she shows any traits. I've tried being polite and shutting down this conversation but that's clearly not working.

The way things are said are implying that their is something wrong with her that needs to be fixed - she doesn't need fixing and even if she did have ASD she still wouldn't need fixing! What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
bloodyplanes · 12/07/2022 18:06

I have two dc with autism and there were most definitely very obvious signs at the ages of 2-3. However your daughter sounds absolutely fine.

Loveisnotloving · 12/07/2022 17:42

Why don't you get her assessed...if it turns out she is on the spectrum, well then you can go from there and if she turns out not to be then you can let them know and leave it.

beenanddoneit · 12/07/2022 16:58

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 12/07/2022 10:50

If that were always true DS would have been assessed years ago rather than just being referred recently at 9 and now we have a 26mth wait.

You're right...my Dil had concerns about her DC from early school days but was always assured by teachers that DC was fine..roll on a few years and DC is definitely on the spectrum ..

firef1y · 12/07/2022 16:01

MrsLargeEmbodied · 12/07/2022 10:50

profesionals know more and more about autism now and i am pretty sure it is common to have a genetic component of parents with BPD,/anxiety or at least i am sure it is relevant.

Autism in girls/women is very often misdiagnosed as things like BPD, anxiety depression.
I was previously diagnosed as having social anxiety disorder, clinical depression, mood disorder. Nope I'm actually autistic and needed to understand why I'm like I am rather than being pumped full of drugs

firef1y · 12/07/2022 15:51

It's not that easy to get an ASD assessment. There was a long waiting list before covid and its even longer now.
First there are forms you and the school/pre-school fill in. Then you get to see a paed (we saw a neuro), them there's loads more hoops to jump through before you get to the actual assessment.

It took 12 years to get my very obviously autistic son diagnosed.
But it can happen faster, due to being a preemie, with multiple issues including epilepsy and a relatively rare form of cerebral palsy and seeing a developmental paed from a couple weeks old, his older brother got the PDD-NOS (atypical autism) dx at 18 months. But he's much more at the severe end of the spectrum. 3 of my other children didn't get their dx until much older and I was 45.when I got mine.

It doesn't really sound like your child would hit the dx threshold though. Although talking early, toilet training etc are not indicators that someone is NT. I've been told I was toilet trained before 18months and was an early talking as was one of my older girls. We're still on the spectrum though. Girls do often present very differently to boys

Sweettums · 12/07/2022 15:16

She’s only a baby. It’s totally normal for kids to be fussy and shy at that age. If concerns are raised later by school/nursery you can act on them then. Many of the traits associated with ASD are entirely normal developmental stages that only become red flags if they persist beyond the “normal” period. If every kid who ticked a couple of the boxes was put on the waiting list for ASD referral “just in case” the system would implode.

Aquilegia23 · 12/07/2022 15:07

orbitalcrisis · 12/07/2022 11:00

@Aquilegia23

As an adult with ASD i can tell you that diagnosis benefits everyone, not having that understanding about yourself or from those around you can have devastating consequences to your mental well-being and gives you added protections by law. I do not know a single person that regrets getting one. But as know several who wish they had been diagnosed as children but weren't as their parents didn't want to 'label' them.

And although I don't think you meant to, your post actually advocates for nobody to get an autism diagnosis. There is no 'severity' of autism that can be medicated for, it's not an illness.

My post does not suggest that no-one should pursue an autism diagnosis. I am saying that unless there are clear, obvious signs of autism, a diagnosis isn't worth it unless for medication needs. It doesn't change the person themselves. People are individuals, with different traits of personality.

And of course there are different levels of severity of autism - that's why it's called 'a spectrum.'

As another poster said, every little quirk of personality nowadays has to be 'diagnosed' as something.

'He looks at his hands - get him diagnosed.' 'He can't concentrate - get him diagnosed.' 'He won't sit still - get him diagnosed.' 'He doesn't like loud noises - get him diagnosed.' It really is becoming irritating.

lemmein · 12/07/2022 14:50

Haven't RTWT but, I think sometimes other people pick up on differences before those closest to the child. I remember bumping into an old work mate, I hadn't seen them for about 5 years and she told me that her son had been diagnosed with ASD. I last seen him when he was about 2 and I knew then that he was probably ASD, whereas his parents didn't suspect a thing, or if they did they never mentioned it.

Fast forward to now and my GS is on the pathway to diagnosis - he's our first GC, the centre of our family, I genuinely hadn't noticed his behaviour as relating to ASD at all. However, once he started school the teachers picked up on it immediately - he's now in a specialised school for kids with ASD. On his first day there his teacher said instantly 'yes, without doubt!' when my DD asked if she thought he had ASD. I was genuinely shocked. I think maybe because he's the baby of the family we've 'overlooked' a lot of his behaviours and put them down to his own unique little quirks. Now he's 5 and when I take him to the park it's really obvious when he's interacting with other kids.

Kids with ASD don't need to be 'fixed' but some do need more support. My GS couldn't cope with mainstream - he's thriving now he's swapped schools; they don't need fixing, but their environments may need to. I've worked as a support worker with people who are on the spectrum so I have seen most behaviours associated with ASD - I still didn't spot it in my GS, so although your ILs might be talking nonsense I'd keep an open mind.

Mammajay · 12/07/2022 14:41

Read the threads, or rather show pil them (although probable better to ignore pil) about the things toddlers get scared of/ angry about. My granddaughter wouldn't touch a broken biscuit till I persuaded her they are biscuit puzzles. She is shy until she feels she knows people. Yesterday she told me how her mum cuts her apple in half.. a big no no to her. Your daughter sounds like a sweet toddler and you should trust your parental instinct on this.

Notodaynotever · 12/07/2022 14:35

Keep her away from the person who was cross with her for having an accident.

I can't believe the posters suggesting autism is on the cards. And I have a DD with autism. They must have read the in-laws list and taken it at face value.

It seems more likely she is picking up on tensions and odd treatment when she's with them.

I wouldn't want 'query autism diagnosis' on my child's notes unless I personally thought it necessary.

Thinkingblonde · 12/07/2022 14:20

My daughter was quiet, (she still is, like me), shy, didn’t speak to anyone she didn’t really know well, my brother once said ‘Can this little poppet talk? Yes, once she gets to know you.
Her 7 yr daughter is the same, hides her head behind her mums back until she’s ready to engage. Both NT.
Loud noises: A lots of kids and adults dislike loud noise, I’ve seen many a child cry at loud noise, I was one of them, loud noise and music stresses me out, it overwhelms me, to the point I cant speak.
Who is the person who shouts at her? This needs to be stopped, she sounds scared of them, hence the accidents.

parenthood1989 · 12/07/2022 14:16

I know my daughter's autistic as I am and she's a mini me. I wouldn't get her assessed. The same manual used to diagnose autism as a medical condition was used to diagnose homosexuality as a mental disorder into the 1970s.

It's changed a bit. For both autism and mental disorders. It's not the 'same manual'

queenMab99 · 12/07/2022 14:14

She is not having any significant difficulties or causing any, to anyone else but certain members of their family. I would suggest it is those people who need assessment, and perhaps therapy to make them more acceptable and less creepy and mean to small children.

127LMS · 12/07/2022 14:14

*The full quote was meant to be in bold

127LMS · 12/07/2022 14:14

She has met almost all of her milestones and even surpassed many of them - her speech is brilliant, she's mostly potty trained, she knows her numbers up to 10, she has a fantastic imagination and role plays constantly, she can take turns and share, she is showing interest in playing with her peers, she has the emotional intelligence expected of a year old.*

⬆️ This describes my autistic daughter.

I know my daughter's autistic as I am and she's a mini me. I wouldn't get her assessed. The same manual used to diagnose autism as a medical condition was used to diagnose homosexuality as a mental disorder into the 1970s. Just like I don't believe being attracted to the same sex is a mental disorder, I do not believe that having sensory, social and communication needs that are in a minority means you're a natural way is automatically impaired or disordered.

For girls like ours there are often no advantages to an autism diagnosis but there are a lot of downsides. For example, some occupations will deem you unfit to work unless proven otherwise.

2bazookas · 12/07/2022 14:11

" We've thought about your suggestion, and disagree with your view of DC. No further action will be taken and that is the end of this conversation."

Mischance · 12/07/2022 14:03

Arrange to meet with them away from your DD. Tell them you have had proper professional advice which supports your view that she is fine; and that you will get assessments needed if any traits arise.

And above all else tell them that you are not prepared to accept any further comments along these lines either with just you parents there or within earshot of your child.

I guess we must assume that their comments are intended to be helpful. But that does not mean you cannot state your position clearly.

Thehop · 12/07/2022 14:01

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 12/07/2022 10:50

If that were always true DS would have been assessed years ago rather than just being referred recently at 9 and now we have a 26mth wait.

That’s sadly not true. Private settings are very reluctant to pursue a referral as they don’t get extra funding to cover a 1:1, so have to find it themselves.

TigerRag · 12/07/2022 13:53

TheGreatBobinsky · 12/07/2022 12:16

My partner thinks that it couldn't hurt to get her assessed but realises the waiting lists are huge. He actually finds it harder to deal with her than her big sister, because she can be a little clingy and prefers to sit and read books or draw whereas our eldest is more outgoing and happier to play roughly (basically the older one has more of his personality traits whereas the younger one is more like me) and so he's been more convinced by his family. But to be honest, he usually does listen more to his family than he does to me.

How much of your youngest DDs behaviour is to do with spending so much time in lockdown over these last few years? Some sounds like it could be.

Hugasauras · 12/07/2022 13:53

She just sounds like she's a more introverted personality type and there's nothing wrong with that. Picky eating, hating hand dryers, those are just normal 3yo things, not necessarily indicative of any other condition.

I'd just tell them that no one has any concerns and to please stop mentioning it as you will be the judge of what she needs, not them. I'd find it hard to stay civil I think if they kept bringing it up after being asked not to.

Thinkingblonde · 12/07/2022 13:48

Whether she has it or not they need firmly reminding that she is your daughter, not theirs and you will decide how to deal with any health issues. I’d also tell them, not ask them, to stop being negative about her, in front of her. Advocate for her, be more forceful with them.
By the same token getting assessed can be a long and difficult process so keep that in mind and take steps if you have any doubts, she sounds fine to me but I’m no expert.
Some one up thread asked what is the point in a diagnosis. A diagnosis will get the child funding at school for extra help: such as 1 to1 teaching, aids such as transparent coloured overlays help with reading for children with Dyslexia, special pens for children with poor muscle control or strength to help them with writing, safe places for children overwhelmed or over stimulated with sensory overload.

teatowelsneedawash · 12/07/2022 12:39

I'm a professional who assessed children for autism.

Technically she is not too young to be assessed but practically she is, it's very tricky to diagnose girls at the best of times especially when that young and bright. It seems that an assessment or diagnosis would not actually benefit her as she is currently anyway.

So, whether she has autism or not is relatively immaterial at present. I would firmly tell the in-laws that you hear their concerns, you are alert to any possible issue and if anything starts to impair her functioning or well-being at a later date you will revisit the issue, but will not be seeking an assessment now. She is who she is regardless, and that you hope they can accept her for that.

Mamapep · 12/07/2022 12:33

She’s not too young to be assessed but other than that I think you’re right to be irritated by them. Mine were shy round certain family members too, that’s totally typical for that age!

Triffid1 · 12/07/2022 12:23

They are basically pissed off because she's not leaping up to cuddle all and every member of the family. Which is likely a combination of personality and post-Covid issues. ALL young children are struggling to some extent as a result of the lack of socialisation during Covid.

Your ILs are being rude and ridiculous. And even if their concerns were genuine, unless there's a genuine concern re the child being at risk, it's not on them to hound you about assessment. We have once mentioned to SIL that we think Nephew could benefit from similar assessment that DS has undergone - and even then, it came up in conversation where she was expressing concerns. We have not said anything since - it's up to her, not us.

TheGreatBobinsky · 12/07/2022 12:16

My partner thinks that it couldn't hurt to get her assessed but realises the waiting lists are huge. He actually finds it harder to deal with her than her big sister, because she can be a little clingy and prefers to sit and read books or draw whereas our eldest is more outgoing and happier to play roughly (basically the older one has more of his personality traits whereas the younger one is more like me) and so he's been more convinced by his family. But to be honest, he usually does listen more to his family than he does to me.

OP posts: