Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inlaws think my 3yr old has ASD

134 replies

TheGreatBobinsky · 12/07/2022 09:08

My inlaws keep insisting I get my DD(3) assessed for autism. They will not drop the subject despite me stating my many reasons against it. AIBU to be angry they won't leave it now.

My reasons are:

  1. She's only just turned 3 years old. Even if she was showing traits, she wouldn't be assessed this young anyway.
  2. She has met almost all of her milestones* and even surpassed many of them - her speech is brilliant, she's mostly potty trained, she knows her numbers up to 10, she has a fantastic imagination and role plays constantly, she can take turns and share, she is showing interest in playing with her peers, she has the emotional intelligence expected of a year old.
  3. She hasn't got any of the traits listed on the diagnostic criteria.
  4. Even if she did have traits, it's really unfair for them to keep saying it in front of her, especially when they are phrasing it as if there's something wrong with her which is insulting to people who are autistic.

The reasons they have given me for thinking this are:

  1. She doesn't like certain members of the family. She refuses to talk much to these people.
  2. She is very shy - she was only 6m old when lockdowns began, she's getting alot better with socialising but I don't think its surprising that she is shy.
  3. She has a limited diet - she is extremely fussy and this is a concern but this alone doesn't scream ASD to me.
  4. She's obsessed with her hands. She's not!
  5. She can't jump with two feet off the ground. *this is the one milestone she hasn't reached.
  6. She has accidents around one member of the family - who apparently tells her off if she has an accident 🙄

None of my health visitors, GPs, nursery staff (although they've only seen her at show around admittedly) or my own family - including two teachers (one of whom works in a SEN setting) think she shows any traits. I've tried being polite and shutting down this conversation but that's clearly not working.

The way things are said are implying that their is something wrong with her that needs to be fixed - she doesn't need fixing and even if she did have ASD she still wouldn't need fixing! What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SpidersAreShitheads · 15/07/2022 03:43

I don't have time for a long reply right now, and you've had lots of great answers. I've only skimmed the thread so apologies if I've missed this, but have you done the MCHAT test on your DC?

It's a specific autism test designed for toddlers which quantifies the likelihood of autism. It might be useful for you to do so you can tell your inlaws that she's been assessed and is low risk (assuming that's how it comes out). As others have said it's entirely possible to be diagnosed at age 3, and there's a very strong link with better outcomes with an early diagnosis. I have two autistic DC and I'm autistic myself.

Here's the MCHAT test to administer mchatscreen.com

Threenorns · 15/07/2022 03:06

I would not be so quick to shut them down. It is a mistake to think that she cannot be assessed at 3 years old. My youngest daughter was assessed at 4, and she did not show many of the characteristic traits that people think are "typical" of autism.

One trait my daughter is very well known for is her absolute charm. When the doctor assessed her, she said "this is easily the most charming child I have met in 17 years of practice." Then she looked at me sideways and said "you know that's not normal, right?"

She was tested, then the test results were sent to a second specialist, then she was tested again with an occupational therapist.

The results were conclusive. She is autistic, even though she dazzles people with her wit and brilliance, and socializes like there's no tomorrow.

As long as she is in a tightly controlled environment, she glitters and shines like she's on the red carpet at the oscars. However, put her in a normal situation and after about a half an hour, the people she's talking to start to look at her sideways and then make excuses to leave. They know something's wrong, but they cannot figure it out. It's because she cannot maintain the train of the conversation. Her responses begin to diverge more and more widely. Eventually, she will be exhausted and she'll go climb under a table or behind a clothing rack, or lock herself in the bathroom.

The idea that there is a defining set of characteristics is wrong, wrong, wrong! Like the saying goes, if you meet somebody with cystic fibrosis, then you know about cystic fibrosis. If you meet an autistic person, then you've met an autistic person.

If there is at all a history of autism in your family, or if the father was over 40, then really do keep at least half an eye on her. This really is one condition you want to get a hold of as fast as possible.

Max was speaking at 9 months. She had over a dozen words, including door ("dowah"), finger (doe-doe), toe (feet doe-doe, which sounded like "peep doe-doe"), buh! ("Bird" but really meant "something flying overhead"), water (badow), out, up, yes, no, mama, Dada, keekah ("kitty-cat"), and "goggie" (dog). By 13 months, she had stopped speaking and was not even saying mama anymore. The reason for this is because she realized nobody except her family could understand what she was saying and that she didn't sound proper, so she shut down out of frustration. It took eight rounds of speech therapy to get her going again.

She is brilliantly quick to pick up on physical things. For example, she watched a bunch of guys being taught how to do hockey slides while ice skating. After about 5 minutes, she did a perfect hockey slide. In karate, she saw someone do a spin kick, so she did a spin kick.

But even though she is very friendly and very charming, she has one friend. Friends never come to visit her, and she very rarely visits friends unless the parents ask her. She's been to exactly one birthday party in her life that wasn't her own or a family member's.

In school, she got 90 on her midterm marks for math, then promptly stopped doing anything at all. She failed the year.

She took 5 years of French immersion and tested out advanced enough that she was exempted from taking French high school credits. So I thought it would be a good idea to have her take french, as it should be an easy, relaxing credit for her. she did not turn in any work and failed.

It sounds like an awful thing to say, but I often wish that she was more profoundly disordered because at least then outsiders would see there's something wrong and stop telling her she's just a lazy gadabout.

But then I think of my oldest daughter, who is also autistic. I was told 35 years ago that girls don't get autism unless it is the classic headbanging variety. My poor oldest daughter was left to twist in the wind, being bounced from one wrong diagnosis to the other. She is virtually housebound now, virtually unable to navigate socially, even when it would be in the best interest of my granddaughter.

Who also shows the same signs of autism in that she's very brilliant and charming for her age.

Morph22010 · 14/07/2022 19:19

Aquilegia23 · 12/07/2022 10:18

I have a grandson who hated loud noises when he was young. We think he is autistic but he doesn't have a diagnosis. He would be just the same happy, intelligent boy with or without one. I don't see the point in diagnosing unless there are severe needs that medication would reduce.

Whether your in-laws are right or not, it's none of their business. I would tell them you might look into it when your daughter is older, and then change the subject.

There’s no medication for autism anyway

StationaryMagpie · 14/07/2022 18:46

its not uncommon for women with Autism/ADHD to be misdiagnosed with BPD, so it may be that your dr is entirely wrong about you not having ASD.

That being said, your In-laws need to butt out, and if they can't shut up and respect your desire to wait and see, then i'd stop spending time with them.

Cornishbelle · 14/07/2022 18:13

I think itsa pil problem. Mine love to constantly compare in a negative way. Best bet tune it out but pull them up if mentioned in front of your child

TheGreatBobinsky · 14/07/2022 18:06

@Snaketime oh I'm not writing off as a possibility, I think maybe my first post came across as quite defensive but I do know that meeting her milestones etc. Doesn't mean that she hasn't got ASD, just that the things my in laws state don't mean that she does. I think I'm more upset that they seem so anxious for a diagnosis, they don't understand the process for a referral either - one of them thinks if they ring and speak to the doctor she'll be able to somehow jump the list 🙄 despite other children needing an assessment far more urgently. The way it's spoken about by them is that a diagnosis will somehow 'fix her' but as I have told them even if they are correct she will still be the same lovely little girl, a diagnosis wouldn't change a single thing and I wouldn't want it too. Obviously if she does show more traits as she gets older and is struggling then I will take the appropriate steps to get her any support she needs, but for now she is perfectly happy and so are we (her parents) and so right now nothing needs to be done.

OP posts:
Snaketime · 14/07/2022 18:06

I should add that doesn't mean you in laws are right and as I said it isn't necessarily ASD. I only said what I said because the earliest sign with my DD was that she couldn't jump with 2 feet off the floor, the big problem was that she struggled at school and because she struggled and couldn't do things her peers could she believed she was stupid. Even though her school was absolutely amazing with her I watched my beautiful confident girl loose all her confidence in herself and become despondent at school, hiding in the toilets to get out of lessons, it is only just starting to get better since she has had her DCD diagnosis and understands herself a little better. I still remember the conversation I had with her at the start of all the assessments where I told her that there was something going on with her that is making things more difficult for her, that me and the doctors were going to sort that out and for her not to worry, but it does mean she has to work harder than her peers to achieve things that she IS capable off, her response "So I'm not stupid then?" It completely broke my heart.

All I meant was don't completely ignore the idea just because the majority of reasons your in laws have given are complete bs.

USTeacher · 14/07/2022 18:00

I'm so glad you see your little one and her needs! So many of us want to use labels, not to understand and help children, but to bludgeon them into "right thinking people" of whatever type makes us most comfortable.

Snaketime · 14/07/2022 17:48

I havent RTFT and I have put YABU. I agree it doesn't sound like she has ASD, and there isn't a lot you can do at her age, but my DD met all her milestones and most of them early. Her speech was perfect by the age of 18 months, walking before she was 1 etc but couldn't jump with 2 feet off the floor by the time she was 3 (that was my first sign), this just like your DD was the first milestone she didn't hit. She has since been diagnosed with Developmental coordination disorder ( DCD also know as dyspraxia) she also qualified for an ASD assessment (still awaiting the results) and is still waiting for an ADHD assessment. So don't just blow off their concerns, tell them you are listening to them, but there isn't a lot you can do yet as she is still too young, you will keep monitoring her for now and see what happens when she starts school.
They won't refer for most things until the child is 6, but please don't just write everything off as age, my DF did that with my DD and just wouldn't listen to me, everytime I raised my concerns it was "its just her age" "she is the youngest in her year" etc.

TheGreatBobinsky · 14/07/2022 17:44

@USTeacher thank you for your reply, what an incredibly sad situation for those poor boys 😢 I truly hope they are doing OK now, it sounds like they had a really difficult time. It's a good thing those children have at least one person advocating for them! They all sound like lovely children.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 14/07/2022 17:36

I think handryers is a ridiculous example for them to be using anyway, handryer noise is awful, I hate it as an adult, its such a high pitch.

hangrylady · 14/07/2022 17:30

TheGreatBobinsky · 12/07/2022 09:38

If she does start to show signs of struggling as she gets older then I will absolutely look into an assessment but currently she just seems like any other just turned 3 year old. Although the PP who mentioned loud noises may have a point, she really hates hand dryers and fans and won't be in the room with them, but my nieces were the same at a similar age and grew out of it so again all I could do is wait and see.

It's extremely common for young kids to hate hand dryers, my son is nearly 10 and still isn't keen. He also finds fireworks and loud music uncomfortable but he's a completely NT child.

USTeacher · 14/07/2022 17:20

Hi, I know it's very late to the discussion, but I made an account just to say how reasonable you're being! My parents and my in-laws are just like yours, basically insisting that every grandchild with traits they don't like has a disorder or needs immediate intervention.

My son--going into third grade and actually had a brain malformation as an infant. All grands were in denial, insisted that he was fine and would grow out of his delays, weakness, and health concerns. Intensive PT and OT, plus baby neuroplasticity, and he's in thriving in school, learning the trumpet, and playing soccer.

However, he's quirky. He has an extremely limited diet but is adding a food each month or so, gets overstimulated at Disney or live performances, has a temper, and after lockdown, had to see a counselor for a while due to social anxiety. Now my parents insist that he's autistic because he doesn't enjoy time with them, hates talking on the phone, and dislikes being hugged, kissed, or photographed very often.

My parents have diagnosed my nephew with Oppositional Defiance Disorder and a few other things because he insists on wearing feminine clothing, sometimes in public, which they know they shouldn't admit to disliking.

My in laws- They think my son is perfect, but are convinced that his cousin is autistic because she's afraid of hand dryers and doesn't like to run around constantly and get dirty. Also, she is fascinated by insects and will watch them for a long time and try to help them, instead of playing on the monkey bars and "getting exercise."

Two other cousins have been written off as being autistic by the in-laws because they never bonded with my SIL (step-mom) after a contentious divorce when they were very young.

She was polite and highly disciplined with them, including them in family hikes, biking, travel, etc., but never attempted to engage in their interests. They liked video games and TV, weren't academically gifted, wrestled and ran around until told to stop, etc., which both parents allowed in the past and their dad still allowed when he met SIL. She also forbade all junk food and desserts, making no effort to bridge between the two households. With their mom and her boyfriends, they are only junk and had no boundaries, and with stepmom and Dad they weren't even allowed to tell me about their favorite show when asked, because there was no gaming or TV talk allowed.

They did do extensive family counseling, plus individual counseling for the boys, both of whom were diagnosed with depression, but the parents needed counseling even more. For example, years in, SIL still laughed over accidentally making a bike trip so arduous, the boys were crying with exhaustion halfway through. She could've called for a relative to get them, but no. They'd done the ride in exchange for ice cream and they needed to push through just like she did in triathlons.

Zero empathy from either parent, pretty much ever, when talking about the boys, and I'm thinking that behind the veil of kind tones of voice and polite words, that iciness never abated. If anyone is autistic or narcissistic, it's sadly likely to be the three parents in their lives, not the children.

Now the boys are both out after turning sixteen, one kicked out for dangerous marijuana smoking (smoldering ash in trash cans isn't funny, and I get that) and the other run away, but the family blames it on neurodivergence instead of bad family dynamics all around. Nobody has tried to find the runaway or establish contact with either boy, even after three years including a pandemic. They're completely different with parenting their daughters together of course.

Anyway, this novel shoes how comfortable and easy it is, especially for grandparents, to diagnose children and escape all responsibility for appreciating their personalities and interests. It's probably a big thing now because simply demanding that children should be seen and not heard is no longer done.

Thinkingblonde · 13/07/2022 09:14

Thatsveryniceofyou · 13/07/2022 08:43

@TheGreatBobinsky are your in-laws the same as mine? They're obsessed my DS is autistic. We spoke to his teacher (they have no concerns at all), paid privately for an assessment but my in laws still think he is autistic and as we paid for an assessment it's not accurate as they will apparently report what the parents want them too. They tell everyone we have failed our Son. I honestly think they just don't know how to be around him as he is a quiet boy and his cousins that side are very loud cheeky children - my son just isn't like that (he is quite shy and takes a while to warm up to others. My in laws were also worried because he doesn't like hand dryers (but then ignore that he likes hair dryers, fireworks etc and other loud noises) my mother in law was the worst and at one party as my Son was joining is she goes oh look at him clap his hands when the other children do. My hubby did go low contact with his family after this as he felt their attitude was not healthy around our son.

Keep an eye on your daughter and please shelter her from the comments. I think you are trying to so that and it's the best you can do don't make her feel like she is different or wrong in how she is

My daughter had to pay for her son to be assessed for Dyslexia, he needed the assessment to get funding to get him the help he needs at school. The board responsible for the funding only accept diagnosis’s from the one my daughter used. His school contributed to the fee.
So that blows your in laws theory that they only say what the parents want to hear right out of the water.

Thatsveryniceofyou · 13/07/2022 08:43

@TheGreatBobinsky are your in-laws the same as mine? They're obsessed my DS is autistic. We spoke to his teacher (they have no concerns at all), paid privately for an assessment but my in laws still think he is autistic and as we paid for an assessment it's not accurate as they will apparently report what the parents want them too. They tell everyone we have failed our Son. I honestly think they just don't know how to be around him as he is a quiet boy and his cousins that side are very loud cheeky children - my son just isn't like that (he is quite shy and takes a while to warm up to others. My in laws were also worried because he doesn't like hand dryers (but then ignore that he likes hair dryers, fireworks etc and other loud noises) my mother in law was the worst and at one party as my Son was joining is she goes oh look at him clap his hands when the other children do. My hubby did go low contact with his family after this as he felt their attitude was not healthy around our son.

Keep an eye on your daughter and please shelter her from the comments. I think you are trying to so that and it's the best you can do don't make her feel like she is different or wrong in how she is

Morph22010 · 13/07/2022 08:07

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 12/07/2022 10:02

I think my 3.5 year old is the exact same he's not obsessed with his hands is the only one he doesn't have. But he's very selective of who he'll speak to and can't be arsed with a load of people- to the point of rudeness. Obviously an area we need to work on. But when he's in the mood/comfortable he'd talk the ear of you. Anyway as you say a diagnosis won't "fix" anything they think isn't right- it'll just provide you with additional information or support so what's the point if you're not worried and don't need support?

Agree with the post except the bit about a diagnosis bringing extra support. I was quite surprised when my Ds was diagnosed that we just got diagnosis from paediatrician and sent on our way with a few leaflets. The support is a whole completly different fight

Crumbleburntbits · 13/07/2022 01:12

Are your in laws qualified health or educational professionals with experience in diagnosing SEND including autism? If not, you need to tell them to stop or they won’t see their granddaughter.

It sounds like your daughter is an excellent judge of character and she’s intelligent enough to have picked up that your in laws are loudmouthed idiots!

Rainbowdrops2021 · 13/07/2022 00:41

As the (very proud) mum of an autistic 4 year old boy I honestly can’t get my head around this. My ds never hit any of his milestones; he had no eye contact, no pointing, no playing, no speech. He had 8 hearing tests because we thought he might be deaf. I honestly can not believe that your in laws are suggesting that because your dd is a bit of a fussy eater and a bit shy she’s autistic. I actually find their behaviour a bit insulting actually like it minimises the real struggle some autistic people and carers face. Your dd sounds like a typical 3 year old to me and you should tell your in-laws where to go.

Notodaynotever · 12/07/2022 23:05

She could be highly sensitive. Worth looking up.

Your in-laws... Deserve a highly insensitive diagnosis.

Silverbirch2 · 12/07/2022 23:04

I'd keep an eye on her, others often see what those closest describe as quirks. Needing personal space at 3, the shy and not talking to certain people as well as the hands comment and the reaching some milestones early could all be markets. You absolutely can get assessed now and in your position I would, if she is the early you know and can support the easier for her.

cottagegardenflower · 12/07/2022 22:57

You tell them never to mention this again in yours or DDs presence. If they do they'll see neither of you.

It's disgraceful. She shows no signs from your or their list and stigmatising her is unacceptable. I'd be furious

Daisycrown · 12/07/2022 22:49

Sorry accidentally pressed yabu but you definitely are not being unreasonable!

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 12/07/2022 22:49

Just bear these comments in mind and see what nursery says.

If your in laws' comments bother you just say that you'll bear them in mind and change the subject.

Benjispruce4 · 12/07/2022 22:46

Why are your in laws so family with your child’s milestones? How do they know what she can and can’t do in so much detail?

Benjispruce4 · 12/07/2022 22:46

Lots of little chn are fearful of hand dryer noise.