Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about the tax cutting obsession

63 replies

SnowyLamb · 12/07/2022 08:38

Among the leadership candidates?

I'm sure tax cuts will win them an election, but I really can't see how they're the answer to the current crisis. It feels really dangerous to me.

Even Margaret Thatcher increased tax during the recession, she didn't cut tax until we were through the other side.

OP posts:
NightmareSlashDelightful · 12/07/2022 09:51

Ooops autocorrect typo. Sunak.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 12/07/2022 09:50

I know what you mean, but I don't know if they'll actually do it.

Right now, they'll all playing to the peanut gallery. It's marketing and froth. The winner of this contest will be chosen by Conservative party members, who are predominantly pensioners and (relatively) economically inactive.

The channel to that audience is via the Mail and the Telegraph. The approval of these two papers is crucial. (Or seen as such by the candidates.) That's why they're all posting these bizarre videos with drone shots of Dover cliffs, Captain Tom and kind-looking nurses.

I'm no fan of Sunk — I'm habitually a Labour, Lib Dem or SNP voter personally — but he's at least in the rough ballpark of saying the right thing on this. The others are mostly punting make-believe.

Getoff · 12/07/2022 09:48

I agree. Some people, not all, are struggling. The government can't change what stuff costs. All they can do is give those people some money. Realistically, that money will have to come from other people. (The alternative of cutting government spending on something else is probably not an option. If the "something else" wasn't something we wanted to spend money on, we'd have stopped doing so already.)

If you want to do something about the cost of living crisis, you can only do that by taking more money from people who have it and giving it to those who don't. So overall you should be looking at how to increase taxes.

I say that as someone who is more of a "taxation is theft" than a "property is theft" sort of person.

DiamanteDelia · 12/07/2022 09:46

Yes, it's really worrying. It feels like every major decision that's been taken for our country (from the Brexit referendum to the present) has been motivated by the personal political ambitions of a handful of entirely self-serving politicians. No wonder we are so screwed.

roarfeckingroarr · 12/07/2022 09:45

It's a vote winner. I'll vote for whoever promises individual tax cuts as leader and will vote Conservative again if they are put into practice.

FourTeaFallOut · 12/07/2022 09:43

Yes, I agree. The Bank of England must have its head in its hands. We need to get inflation down.

WatchoRulo · 12/07/2022 09:43

SnowyLamb · 12/07/2022 08:38

Among the leadership candidates?

I'm sure tax cuts will win them an election, but I really can't see how they're the answer to the current crisis. It feels really dangerous to me.

Even Margaret Thatcher increased tax during the recession, she didn't cut tax until we were through the other side.

Taken across the entirety of her shitty reign, taxes as a proportion of GDP rose.

Thecatsatonthewalls · 12/07/2022 09:40

forinborin · 12/07/2022 08:59

On the other hand, lower taxes will attract both commercial and private capital, and 15% of £200 is better than 20% of £100.

Remember, capital is very fluid and fungible in the 21st century, and the UK is predominantly service-driven when it comes to the economy surplus. Brexit has shown how easy it is to lose massive companies (and therefore their tax revenues) pretty much overnight. It will be easy in the other direction too, should a sufficiently sweet carrot be there.

So, from my perspective, lowering tax is not necessarily a bad strategic decision in the current climate. But what I want to see is a well thought out plan with proper arguments for it, not just pure populism. So far there's none.

Tax cuts or not, the UK is no longer part of the SM and thats a huge loss.

Business doesn't only look at tax rates, which are fickle, health services, educated work force, culture, ease of movement.

Problem with cutting business taxes is that their is no obligation to invest in this country, profits can easily be taken overseas.

We need investment i.e education, health, transport and with the loss of EU Horizon programs, Science and Tech.

But the biggest and best thing we could do is rebuild our relationship with the worlds richest trading bloc, where over 40% of our trade is done, not rejoin, more Norway and Switzerland.

DomesticShortHair · 12/07/2022 09:31

There are really two types of tax cuts. One type are considered and targeted tax cuts, designed to provide stimulus and grow the economy (or limit the damage, at the very least).

The other are tax cuts which sound like they are considered and targeted to provide stimulus and grow the economy, but are actually just knee-jerk sound bites, designed to appeal to a very narrow band of MPs and the electorate who hold a party membership, purely to become Prime Minister.

LakieLady · 12/07/2022 09:22

We've seen a massive deterioration in public services after 12 years of cuts.
If they make another 20% cut in budgets, there'll be next to nothing left.

I'm more fearful for the future of people in this country than I have ever been in my life, and I'm nearly 67.

underneaththeash · 12/07/2022 09:02

Me too OP (and we pay a huge amount of tax). I'd rather they kept tax as it is and sorted out the NHS - especially the mental health provision (again, not that we need it as a family, but I can know lots of people are struggling).

It's probably time for a labour government at the next election anyway though. They just need to make sure the looney lefties are kept out of senior government.

forinborin · 12/07/2022 08:59

On the other hand, lower taxes will attract both commercial and private capital, and 15% of £200 is better than 20% of £100.

Remember, capital is very fluid and fungible in the 21st century, and the UK is predominantly service-driven when it comes to the economy surplus. Brexit has shown how easy it is to lose massive companies (and therefore their tax revenues) pretty much overnight. It will be easy in the other direction too, should a sufficiently sweet carrot be there.

So, from my perspective, lowering tax is not necessarily a bad strategic decision in the current climate. But what I want to see is a well thought out plan with proper arguments for it, not just pure populism. So far there's none.

SweatyAndGrumpy · 12/07/2022 08:53

Just my 2p but I think the answer to the current crisis is

a) We need better global trade post Brexit. To get those, I suspect a whole heap of things needs to happen; not least we need to stop looking like tits on the world stage. So many small-medium businesses have been unable to cope in the post-Brexit world and someone needs to be properly unpicking why and sorting out those hurdles to prevent us losing more (and to encourage more to start up).

b) We need better food and energy security to help buffer against global swings such as we are seeing now. Energy and food production, storage, processing capbility. This is a long game, so every government for 30+ years has just kicked the can down the road - and here we are: drowning in cans.

Tax cuts are a short term bandaid. They would help individual people cope with costs that are spiralling out of control. But someone needs to be looking at the long game. Unfortunately, I don't think anyone is: they are all looking at the current PMinister race and the GE in 2 years time instead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread