Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about the tax cutting obsession

63 replies

SnowyLamb · 12/07/2022 08:38

Among the leadership candidates?

I'm sure tax cuts will win them an election, but I really can't see how they're the answer to the current crisis. It feels really dangerous to me.

Even Margaret Thatcher increased tax during the recession, she didn't cut tax until we were through the other side.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 12/07/2022 12:30

vermicello · 12/07/2022 12:10

Why? Most tax is just wasted (look how much was spent on Track and Trace and how much of our taxes are wasted on vanity projects by politicians). Better to reduce spending and waste and let people decide for themselves how they spend their money. Something like 50% of the population doesn't pay any tax which means the pressure is on the remaining 50% to pay it all. Totally unfair.

This is a libertarian stance, and is thankfully in the stark minority.

SleeplessInEngland · 12/07/2022 12:28

It's something they'll talk about but meet a brickwall of reality when they come into power.

And if they do follow through on it then great - the average british voter hates public services being cut a lot more than paying taxes.

SnowyLamb · 12/07/2022 12:23

JemimaPuddleducksWaddle · 12/07/2022 12:20

Some people, not all, are struggling.

Lots are and it is now hitting groups that it doesn't usually.

Yes, but giving people more to spend via tax cuts will fuel inflation and male the price rises even worse. So individuals will be no better off and there'll be less money for services.

OP posts:
JemimaPuddleducksWaddle · 12/07/2022 12:20

Some people, not all, are struggling.

Lots are and it is now hitting groups that it doesn't usually.

Rummikub · 12/07/2022 12:16

Rainbunny · 12/07/2022 10:59

We pay a lot in taxes and I don't enjoy how much they've gone up but I worry deeply that the real aim behind cutting taxes now is to give whichever hardcore Tory PM and Chancellor in the job, an excuse to cut finding to the NHS and. enact reforms that further opens up the NHS to private business interests etc... They'll do it under the cover of "being fiscally responsible."

Yes I think this too.

and I also suspect tax cuts only means corporate tax.

whenwillthemadnessend · 12/07/2022 12:14

@vermicello

But surely if that's the case those 50 % are either unemployed (low presently)
On low wages (high presently)
Or part time for what ever reason. Caring duties etc. (Saving govt money)
Or disabled etc
Why would you want them to pay more tax.

roarfeckingroarr · 12/07/2022 12:12

@DoNotWorryBeHappy no, it doesn't worry me. I truly believe we are taxed far too much already and more disposable income is good for the economy.

vermicello · 12/07/2022 12:10

Why? Most tax is just wasted (look how much was spent on Track and Trace and how much of our taxes are wasted on vanity projects by politicians). Better to reduce spending and waste and let people decide for themselves how they spend their money. Something like 50% of the population doesn't pay any tax which means the pressure is on the remaining 50% to pay it all. Totally unfair.

DoNotWorryBeHappy · 12/07/2022 12:09

It would be great if it did boost the economy ... Win-win indeed... But a decade of Conservative austerity and low taxes hasn't really managed that so far. Taxes pay for adult social care for the elderly to get care outside of hospital, freeing up a hospital bed, allowing another patient into A and E, freeing an ambulance to get to their next life or death call... This kind of knock on effect does need some kind of funding from our taxes right now - perhaps when that is sorted, tax cuts could be considered. When they are offered in the current situation in which so many are suffering from underfunded public services, it seems like callous timing. And populist. Maybe they'll offer us a pony as well!

roarfeckingroarr · 12/07/2022 12:06

SBAM · 12/07/2022 09:58

On a local level it drives me mad. The local election leaflets are all about how our council tax is the lowest of the nearby boroughs - yes but we’ve also got potholes a caving club could make use of, they’re trying to knock down the local library, the play parks are all looking very tired. I recognise my financial privilege, but I’d be ok if they increased tax if it meant living conditions were improved.

Wandsworth?

Now Labour are in our low council tax is likely to go 😩

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/07/2022 12:00

DoNotWorryBeHappy · 12/07/2022 11:59

Doesn't it worry you that reduced taxes will have a detrimental impact on public services? Many of us might think it wouldn't affect us, maybe that's true, until a child needs special needs provision or we suffer an agonising wait for an ambulance or A and E. Doesn't a civilised and compassionate society need to raise and allocate sufficient taxes? The knock on effects will surely touch us all in some way.

Not if the knock on effect is to improve the economy.

DoNotWorryBeHappy · 12/07/2022 11:59

roarfeckingroarr · 12/07/2022 09:45

It's a vote winner. I'll vote for whoever promises individual tax cuts as leader and will vote Conservative again if they are put into practice.

Doesn't it worry you that reduced taxes will have a detrimental impact on public services? Many of us might think it wouldn't affect us, maybe that's true, until a child needs special needs provision or we suffer an agonising wait for an ambulance or A and E. Doesn't a civilised and compassionate society need to raise and allocate sufficient taxes? The knock on effects will surely touch us all in some way.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/07/2022 11:52

Well, decreasing income tax a little will not necessarily create a big gap in teh budget it if has the impact of improving the economy generally (more spending and investment) as the increased revenue will come from other places. One way to improve the economy is to invest rather than to cut back.

I thought this diagram explanation was interesting: ifs.org.uk/taxlab/key-questions/where-does-government-get-its-money
Income tax is only about 25% of the country's income. Decreasing that a little if you bolster the other ones doesn't do any harm to the bottom line. Plus better economy, more people working/ earning more, more income tax.

Blossomtoes · 12/07/2022 11:43

I wish you could be PM @alphapie.

whenwillthemadnessend · 12/07/2022 11:33

Tbh. I'd rather more targeted spending and investment in the important things. Green energy. General Education, new targeted apprenticeships in skilled trade and nursing social care
Free degrees for doctors nurses and other medical staff, ambulance drivers
Increases in Police numbers

Than a tax cut

Don't forget tho the govt are taking in a huge amount of revenue from the rise in petrol prices. I bet that can afford a small cut. However as I said I'd rather that money was invested

whenwillthemadnessend · 12/07/2022 11:18

British politics NEVER looks at the long game. If you want that you need to move to Sweden Norway etc

Summerwhereareyou · 12/07/2022 11:16

Tax won't sort out the NHS! It needs a proper business people to overhaul it. Root out bad cultures.

alphapie · 12/07/2022 11:12

YANBU, we need higher taxes (that are well spent) instead of lower ones.

But the tories rely on being 'popular' to win, they can't rely on their policies, or their professionalism, they have to rely on lying to people and giving them what they want (whilst also dragging others for what they perceive is the same thing)

I think a lot of public services atm need a full review, and decisions to be made (positive or negative) and plans put in place, I am fed up with this half arsed effort to 'improve' the NHS, they either need to decide to cut what people are eligible for or pump the money needed into the service, at the moment they are doing neither and we, the public and the NHS staff are suffering for it.

We need a full review of our justice system, again, either pump the money needed into our crumbling prison service, or reassess what counts as a custodial sentence and put more funding into external support for those arrested for less extreme crimes.

At the moment no one is doing anything to properly address the bigger issues in this country, and I do think it's because deep down they all know it would take higher taxes to sort things out, and that wouldn't win them elections.

SushiShopSearch · 12/07/2022 11:03

I would support higher earners (us included) paying more tax.

Rainbunny · 12/07/2022 10:59

We pay a lot in taxes and I don't enjoy how much they've gone up but I worry deeply that the real aim behind cutting taxes now is to give whichever hardcore Tory PM and Chancellor in the job, an excuse to cut finding to the NHS and. enact reforms that further opens up the NHS to private business interests etc... They'll do it under the cover of "being fiscally responsible."

TheLeadbetterLife · 12/07/2022 10:53

They're Tories, what do you expect? Tax cuts are all they have left now to win votes.

Blossomtoes · 12/07/2022 10:49

Empty promises. None of the have said or even thought about how they’d pay for these fabled tax cuts. They’re saying whatever they think will get them into Downing Street which they then won’t be able to deliver. I can’t take them seriously.

balalake · 12/07/2022 10:46

Income tax cuts don't include a significant part of the population and don't reduce the inflation rate. Cutting energy costs will help almost everyone.

Dreamstate · 12/07/2022 10:28

Good lets cut tax and work on sorting out all the ways our money is already being wasted. NHS being the biggest example of how money is wasted. You could take Elon's entire wealth and not even all that money will fix it.

First thing we all do in households is look at our budget are we spending money efficiently or are we wasting it so same should apply to how are our taxes are spent.

SBAM · 12/07/2022 09:58

On a local level it drives me mad. The local election leaflets are all about how our council tax is the lowest of the nearby boroughs - yes but we’ve also got potholes a caving club could make use of, they’re trying to knock down the local library, the play parks are all looking very tired. I recognise my financial privilege, but I’d be ok if they increased tax if it meant living conditions were improved.