Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend and her husband’s financial arrangement

88 replies

Salvia89 · 11/07/2022 22:10

Hi all,

I was chatting to my friend (Let’s call her Emma) the other day.. she and her husband have a 1.5 year old DC and she’s been back at work for 6 months after mat leave.

She mentioned in passing that it’s soul destroying working and only getting about £200 at the end of the month after paying nursery fees and I said “well you need to think of it as a joint expense.. I.e you’re only really paying half.. or actually even less if you think of it proportionally from your salaries”. She’s probably on a salary of mid 20s and husband is on about 80k I guess.

She said “well no, as I pay for nursery out of my wage. Tom (not real name) pays for everything else like mortgage, meals out etc, so it’s fine”. I said “hmm… ok” then the conversation moved on.

Later I remembered a time when we were chatting towards the end of her Mat leave where she said she’d blown her months cash on a lunch that we had out. The only money that she was getting on mat leave was her crappy mat pay which for the end I think was next to nothing!

He on the other hand was going out for fancy dinners with his mates.

I mentioned that it seemed a little very unfair and she said that he’s give her some extra money if asked so it was fine.

she doesn’t seem worried by the situation and seems quite happy..

Do you all agree that this is massively unfair?! Surely as a married couple with kids you pool your resources.. especially when there’s such a disparity in salaries.

Anyway.. my AIBU. Should I bring it up again and advise her to seek a fairer agreement?

YABU - they both seem happy so let them get on with it
YANBU - it’s worth bringing it up again and suggesting a fairer split.

OP posts:
DarkCharlotte · 12/07/2022 01:38

Hmm. I have relatives who are married with kids and do not share finances, things like holidays or really big expenses they will sort out between them for the family, but personal things are their own. The wife there has just had cosmetic surgery, she couldn't afford it so loaned from her husband, she will pay it back. It works for them.

If she asked for money, he would give it to her, so I don't see it as an issue. If she new a lunch with you was going to blow her £200, why didn't she ask him for some money towards it?

It's hard to say if he is abusive, that l depends on how he reacts to being asked for further money. Personally, I wouldn't really need to ask, if I said I was going out for lunch mine would offer to give me money towards it.

I wouldn't want joint finances with anyone personally. If any bills need to be paid jointly then I would transfer my % into the bank account of my partner, or he would pay his % into my account. I don't really see the need for a joint account.

Also, having singular accounts means that if someone has a moment and spends a bit recklessly, at least it's just their part of the money they've blown!

He pays for things for her and the family, and probably is building up good savings for their future and children... but I do think maybe he should just pay her a % of the childcare into her account also if she is really struggling.

Biker47 · 12/07/2022 01:25

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/07/2022 22:14

Yep, you are her mate, and she is being financially abused. Take her out to lunch, tell her what the norm is (you don’t need to make it the purpose of the lunch, but I think you should say - I’ve been wanting to raise this as your arrangement is unusual, and it may not be the best thing for uou), and then just say it’s normal for a couple to have joint finances and pay into a pot that covers everything on a percentage basis)

And that's not normal for me. All people have different ways of doing it.

Ponderingwindow · 12/07/2022 01:21

Your friend is being abused. Staying silent is not ok.

I know some women in this position don’t think they are being abused, but there are also women doing all the housework and child care, women who are constantly belittled, and women who are coerced into marital sex who don’t think they are being abused either. Denial or intense socialization doesn’t change reality.

caringcarer · 12/07/2022 01:14

You have raised the issue twice and established Emma is quite happy with arrangement. To keep bringing it up risks your friendship. You are overstepping the mark to bring it up a third time.

RustyShackleford3 · 12/07/2022 01:09

If she seems happy then I would stay out of it. You've already mentioned it, that's enough.

It is very difficult to say what is fair in someone else's marriage because you don't have all the information. You're guessing their salaries and you could be wildly wrong, plus there could be all sorts of other factors at play - one or both of them could have other sources of income, a lump sum of inheritance money, a mountain of debt etc. You just don't know from the outside.

Lanareyrey · 12/07/2022 01:03

Why are you concerned about other peoples financial situations? Only on Mumsnet will be seen that you should “pool your resources together”. Never understood that to be honest.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 12/07/2022 00:56

Well to be fair his take home pay would be about 55k to her 17k of both work full time if he is paying everything other then the childcare which is probably a huge amount of his income, has he always paid everything so she was used to having full wage to herself before child, and anyone spending 200 on 1 meal is crazy

EmeraldShamrock1 · 12/07/2022 00:48

It is a short term expense for her.

Lots of couples work their finances out like this, £50 a week after bills are paid, nursery, mortgage is pretty normal in the early days of cohabiting.

My Dsis always paid nursery, her DC is in school now and her husband has continued as he is.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/07/2022 00:44

If she mentions it again you could say your opinion that you think it’s odd he has more ‘spending’ money.
It very much depends on what she’s funding. Has she got access to his money for clothes, activities, haircuts etc. If he’s in latest styles and she can only afford charity shop and diy cuts then it’s clearly not right.
She’s married so ultimately if she did split then she’d be entitled to share of his assets and pension.
When child’s free nursery hours kick in she’ll have more spare cash. She could still claim child benefit I think to give her more spends (and him repay via tax)

Vikinga · 12/07/2022 00:38

She shouldn't be crimping whilst he's splashing out!

Namenic · 12/07/2022 00:32

I think it is a bit concerning that they don’t have the same fun money. I guess I might gently ask her how she is finding things, mention cost of living etc. If she doesn’t say that much, I wouldn’t probe more. But if she says that she’s always skint, I guess I might suggest that her DH transfers her some money to equalise - as from this thread, it seems to be the more usual thing.

smileandsing · 11/07/2022 23:45

You only know what you know about their finances. For all you know your friend could be rubbish with money which is why they don't have a shared 'pot'. Or maybe her DH is financially abusing her. Perhaps they have huge debts. You don't know what their bills are, or their incomes after tax are (remember someone earning £80k doesn't take home four times what a £20k earner does).

I don't subscribe to the idea that bills should be split proportionately but spending money should be equal. There are far too many variables in every relationship for a one size fits all approach.

In short, just stay out of it unless she is asking for your advice

elbo7 · 11/07/2022 23:25

On the face of it, it doesn't seem fair that her personal 'allowance' has reduced massively and his has stayed the same. If it was me and my close friend I'd be blunt and tell her if I didn't think it was fair, but I know she would take it coming from me. It depends on your friendship I think, if you can talk about things like that to her. It is very hard to talk about money with friends.

Dh and I are in a similar situation with massively different wages, he (by choice, as he works in finance) sorts out the finances every month so that we have equal 'fun' money. No joint account, but he gives me money each month to reimburse my family spends and to make it equal, and we have a joint credit card. We had a very grown up conversation about it when we thought about trying for a baby, and, most importantly, we are both happy with the arrangement.

Plogeggio · 11/07/2022 23:24

Agree with others, sounds a very outdated and unfair setup, but not actually abusive and probably on the whole none of your business. I know a few women who seem to live happily with this kind of financial arrangement, even though it's not something I'd ever stand for. Maybe you could gently ask if she thinks it's unfair that he has more disposable income than her, and just listen to her response and gauge whether she is genuinely okay with the whole thing. If she is I think you need to butt out, but if she says she thinks it's unfair then you could support her and let her know that's a perfectly valid way to feel.

RaspberryRippleTipple · 11/07/2022 23:16

It’s probably unfair, although you don’t know all of the figures and proportions to be sure.

It’s not an unusual set up, even though it is flawed.

YABU to interfere though. Expressing your opinion once is fine, but don’t keep mentioning it, and don’t push her to change it if she doesn’t feel the need. Especially as it is ‘socialising money’ that she doesn’t have lots of, it might come across that you just want her to be able to afford fancy lunches with you more often.

I’ve got a similar financial arrangement. It is a bit crap, and I’m not ecstatic about it, but I wouldn’t want my friends to comment on it or start passing judgement on my parter / relationship. Addressing such inequalities in relationships isn’t easy, she might have decided this isn’t the battle she wants to pick.

Salvia89 · 11/07/2022 23:15

I think the issue lies in that her finances have taken a massive hit since having DC whereas his haven’t. Obviously I don’t know the ins and out of their financial arrangements but before DC she never complained about not being able to afford a coffee etc. i wouldn’t bat an eyelid if their joint income is low, but it’s really not!

Since she’s been on mat leave she’s had to live on a pittance whereas his life is financially more or less the same.

OP posts:
925XX · 11/07/2022 23:11

Not nice to post your friends private business on here plus it is non of your business!

DockOTheBay · 11/07/2022 23:08

dworky · 11/07/2022 23:00

He is financially abusing her & neglecting to pay for his own child's care. She needs to fully understand that.

So if he paid half the childcare but then expected her to pay the same amount towards bills and food, that would be ok?

OnTheBoardwalk · 11/07/2022 23:06

I can't see anything wrong with him paying bills and your friend paying childcare as I don’t know the split

the issue is him having disposable income every month but your friend doesn’t. That’s what need to be discussed and agreed

pastaandpesto · 11/07/2022 23:06

I absolutely agree with you, but voted YABU because on balance I don't think the situation is bad enough to justify uninvited interference. It's not a situation I would ever want for myself. I particularly dislike the fact she pays for the nursery fees - it further entrenches the idea that the child is primarily her responsibility.

baxtersm · 11/07/2022 23:05

My husband and I have a joint account where my salary and his go into. He earns a lot more than me but it's never been an issue. All our DDs, mortgage, childcare etc come out of the same account and we both have a debit card and spend what we want! 200 a month goes into a savings account in my name and same in his but apart from that everything is shared! I would absolutely hate to have to ask him for money for treats.. if anything I'm the one giving out to him when I check the app that he's bought another pair of silly running shoes or something daft for the kids!

arethereanyleftatall · 11/07/2022 23:04

dworky · 11/07/2022 23:00

He is financially abusing her & neglecting to pay for his own child's care. She needs to fully understand that.

Eh?
How on Earth do you know that?!?

The op said he was paying all the bills, mortgage etc. he may well be paying far far more of the joint costs than she is!

dworky · 11/07/2022 23:00

He is financially abusing her & neglecting to pay for his own child's care. She needs to fully understand that.

MrszClaus · 11/07/2022 22:59

Do you think paying for a mortgage and bills on a nice house (so all council / energy / cars / food?!) plus meals out and holidays might be proportionate to their wage disparity if she is paying for childcare?

arethereanyleftatall · 11/07/2022 22:55

I guess this could have been my situation with my ex and I wasn't remotely financially abused. Nothing of the sort. We just couldn't be arsed to sort a joint account, so he paid most of the bills and I paid smaller ones. If I needed any money I said 'can you transfer x' and he said 'yes'. Nothing to hate about that. The 'soul destroying' bit just refers to the nursery draining a salary. If one of my friends suggested the thought to bring it up, simply because they managed their finances a different way, I'd find them very odd indeed. She says she's happy so leave it.